Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / BalancingDeathsBooks

Go To

Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
What does this mean for the pantheon: the true culprit behind Homura\'s fall was actually Darth Vader (perhaps in an attempt to PetTheDog involving kinds words to someone in a situation like his own gone HORRIBLY wrong) with Lucifer trying to falsely claim credit for it all, which shall be exposed by Batman. She never used the item given to her, taking matters into her own hands after believing (correctly) that the Incubators are still a threat to Madoka.
to:
The comparison makes LOTS of sense given that both had someone they cherished and wanted to protect through any means nessecary and a manipulative bastard that\\\'s the root cause of everything wrong that needed to be dealt with. Vader failed, Homura succeeded. I can just see the monologue before Homura\\\'s decision.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
Looks like we\'re going to have to rewrite the stuff regarding Homura AGAIN. Based on some very compelling evidence from Rebellion such as the flower conversation, being a master of the JerkAssFacade, hints all throughout the series that she sincerely cares about ALL the other girls despite her cold act, her feeling terrible about what she had to do, this is starting to look like a ZeroApprovalGambit, one that will most likely blow up in Homura\'s face....horribly.
to:
* Vader\\\'s words in her head, upon discovering that Kyubey found the truth and what he was planning to do, Homura realized she had no other choice but to do something drastic. \\\"I will protect her. All of you, yes even you Sayaka deserve to be happy. For what I have to do, I\\\'m....so....sorry. Forgive me for I won\\\'t be able to do so myself.\\\"
Changed line(s) 6 from:
to:
What does this mean for the pantheon: the true culprit behind Homura\\\'s fall was actually Darth Vader (perhaps in an attempt to PetTheDog involving kinds words to someone in a situation like his own gone HORRIBLY wrong) with Lucifer trying to falsely claim credit for it all, which shall be exposed by Batman. She never used the item given to her, taking matters into her own hands after believing (correctly) that the Incubators are still a threat to Madoka.

Looks like we\\\'re going to have to rewrite the stuff regarding Homura AGAIN. Based on some very compelling evidence from Rebellion such as the flower conversation, being a master of the JerkAssFacade, hints all throughout the series that she sincerely cares about ALL the other girls despite her cold act, her feeling terrible about what she had to do, this is starting to look like a ZeroApprovalGambit, one that will most likely blow up in Homura\\\'s face....horribly.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
What does this mean for the pantheon: the true culprit behind Homura\'s fall was actually Darth Vader (perhaps in an attempt to PetTheDog gone HORRIBLY wrong) with Lucifer trying to falsely claim credit for it all, which shall be exposed by Batman. She never used the item given to her, taking matters into her own hands after believing (correctly) that the Incubators are still a threat to Madoka.
to:
What does this mean for the pantheon: the true culprit behind Homura\\\'s fall was actually Darth Vader (perhaps in an attempt to PetTheDog involving kinds words to someone in a situation like his own gone HORRIBLY wrong) with Lucifer trying to falsely claim credit for it all, which shall be exposed by Batman. She never used the item given to her, taking matters into her own hands after believing (correctly) that the Incubators are still a threat to Madoka.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I think I managed to get exactly what I wanted in terms of metting out karma, thanks to some interview notes I read a while back. Seems Urobuchi has personally discredited the Lucifer analogy, saying that Darth Vader is a more accurate comparison. He says stuff about comparing PMMM to StarWars (meaning we\'re in the Empire Strikes Back portion of the story with Season 2 being Return of the Jedi).
to:
I think I managed to get exactly what I wanted in terms of metting out karma, thanks to some interview notes I read a while back. Seems Urobuchi has personally discredited the Lucifer analogy, saying that Darth Vader is a more accurate comparison. He says stuff about comparing PMMM to StarWars (meaning we\\\'re in the Empire Strikes Back portion of the story with Season 2 being Return of the Jedi). Note: Empire Strikes back analogies are based off my own notes after reading the commentary.
Top