Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / TheSpartanWay

Go To

[002] jatay3 Current Version
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
2. However, hoplite battles seldom generated enough casualties in actual combat to threaten the Spartan predominance. Furthermore no Greek state before the Macedonian empire possessed a strong enough exploitation arm to make up for that.
to:
2. However, hoplite battles seldom generated enough casualties in actual combat to threaten the Spartan predominance. Furthermore no Greek state before the Macedonian empire possessed a strong enough exploitation arm to make up for that in the rare event of a Spartan retreat.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
3. Therefore, \'\'so long as\'\' Sparta\'s policy remained restricted to the maintenence of hegemony over the Peleponece then having a body of severely trained hoplites that can be usually trusted to win a head-to-head clash, and almost always trusted to maintain good enough order to prevent a hot pursuit in the rare instances of a retreat is very useful. Spartiates could not prevent raiding or partisan warfare. What they could do is always be a present threat. And so long as they were always there, Sparta was there.
to:
3. Therefore, \\\'\\\'so long as\\\'\\\' Sparta\\\'s policy remained restricted to the maintenence of hegemony over the Peleponece then having a body of severely trained hoplites that can be usually trusted to win a head-to-head clash, and almost always trusted to maintain good enough order to prevent a hot pursuit in the rare instances of a retreat is very useful. Spartiates could not prevent raiding or partisan warfare. What they could do is always be a present threat. And so long as they were always there, Sparta was there. The reluctance of Sparta to risk Spartiates in battle becomes understandable. It may have short term disadvantages but it also has considerable advantages.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
1. The weakness of TheSpartanWay was that it automatically created two centers of gravity: A) The small number of Spartiates which, given sufficient casualties would leave insufficient numbers to train recruits, and B)Helotage, which was an economical system which could actually be destroyed in a successful campaign simply by driving off or lureing off all the Helots(unlike Athens and Thebes which could only suffer moderate crop damage).
to:
1. The weakness of TheSpartanWay was that it automatically created two centers of gravity: A) The small number of Spartiates which, given sufficient casualties would leave insufficient numbers to train recruits, and B)Helotage, which was an economical system which could actually be destroyed in a successful campaign simply by driving off or lureing off all the Helots(unlike Athens and Thebes which could only suffer moderate crop damage, so long as the farmers came back to their farms).
Top