[002]
Cthulboohoo
Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Even the Beatles presence is pretty ambiguous - Eight years is a pretty good long time for a rock band. Yes, they produced a lot of material in a short time, but compared to Buddy Holly or the Sex Pistols, they were around for an eternity.
to:
Even the Beatles presence is pretty ambiguous - Eight years is a pretty good long time for a rock band. Yes, they produced a lot of material in a short time, but they have more albums than most rock bands and stayed together longer than the average rock band.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
I\'m tempted to remove both, but I wanted to see if anyone had an argument for their inclusion before I did.
to:
Similarly, Elliot Smith and the Red House Painters had careers spanning at around a decade. Bon Scott and the Smiths made half a decade. I don\\\'t think the purpose of this is to have just a collection of people who died young. For instance, in the twenty-seven club, Brian Jones put out fifteen albums in seven years before he died. Compared with Robert Johnson, who recorded two albums with about twenty five tracks, that\\\'s a freaking eternity.
The music section here is already extremely cluttered. If you put out a dozen albums over eight years, when most bands fold after three or four albums and half the time, you are scarcely short lived in the music industry.
I\\\'m tempted to remove them, but I wanted to see if anyone had an argument for their inclusion before I did.
The music section here is already extremely cluttered. If you put out a dozen albums over eight years, when most bands fold after three or four albums and half the time, you are scarcely short lived in the music industry.
I\\\'m tempted to remove them, but I wanted to see if anyone had an argument for their inclusion before I did.
