[003]
LordGro
Current Version
Changed line(s) 25 from:
n
As for Magnificent Bastard, it’s a YMMV trope and we don’t collect YMMV tropes for real-life persons and events. That’s a rule.
to:
As for MagnificentBastard, it’s a YMMV trope and we don’t collect YMMV tropes on pages for real-life persons and events. That’s a rule. [Edited for greater clarity.]
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
@Turtler: First, what Xzenu already said: I didn\'t accuse you of being a vandal or spoke of vandalism when I removed those examples. This thread started after an editor called @/nightmares had obviously vandalized the page (see the history), but I removed these tropes here for different reasons. And as far as I can see, no one else has accused you of being a vandal either. You got that wrong. No need to take offence.
to:
@Turtler: First, what Xzenu already said: I didn\\\'t accuse you of being a vandal or spoke of vandalism when I removed those examples. This thread started after an editor called @/{{nightmares}} had obviously vandalized the page (see the history), but I removed these tropes here for different reasons. And as far as I can see, no one else has accused you of being a vandal either. You got that wrong. No need to take offence.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
Note furthermore that it’s acknowledged that “depiction”, “storytelling” and “work” is a bit broader than only “fiction”. We don’t exclude NonFictionLiterature. What we DO exclude is classifying and categorizing real life in trope terms. TheQuran is a work, the hadith are works, biographies of Mohammed are works, Mohammed in HistoricalFiction is works, scientific literature on Mohammed is works. TheProphetMohammed is not.
to:
Note furthermore that it’s acknowledged that “depiction”, “storytelling” and “work” is a bit broader than only “fiction”. We don’t exclude NonFictionLiterature. What we DO exclude is classifying and categorizing real life in trope terms. TheQuran is a work, the hadith are works, biographies of Mohammed are works, Mohammed in HistoricalFiction is works, scientific literature on Mohammed is works. TheProphetMuhammad is not.
