Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / YouHaveToHaveJews

Go To

[001] Jordan Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Jeez, what\'s with the attitude? I was trying to be more conciliatory. I was kind of set off criticizing this trope again because of Alrune\'s posting, and I do understand now that your perspective on it isn\'t the same as hers.
to:
Jeez, I was trying to be more conciliatory. I was kind of set off criticizing this trope again because of Alrune\\\'s posting, and I do understand now that your perspective on it isn\\\'t the same as hers.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
A series set in a New York City law firm that didn\'t have a Jewish character in it would just be that. It\'s not an aversion You might have gotten the impression that I object to any work that doesn\'t have a Jewish character, but that\'s not my perspective. Generally (see, not an absolute statement), I don\'t think the presence or absence of a Jewish character in an American tv show is noteworthy either way.
to:
A series set in a New York City law firm that didn\\\'t have a Jewish character in it would just be that. It\\\'s not an aversion You might have gotten the impression that I object to any work that doesn\\\'t have a Jewish character, but that\\\'s not my perspective. Generally (see, not an absolute statement), I don\\\'t think the presence or absence of a Jewish character in an American tv show is noteworthy either way. \\\"So it\\\'s your opinion that that observation applies to the entire USA, not just CA.\\\" Well, not the \\\'\\\'entire\\\'\\\' USA (i.e. every area of every state), but at the very least, it\\\'s not unusual in more states than those too.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
\
to:
To avoid being accused of making an absolute statement, I\\\'ll say that I haven\\\'t seen every American tv show. [[SincerityMode If there are American tv shows you consider notable examples or aversions, I\\\'d be interested in hearing them]]. And it would probably help too to know of British examples where you feel this is striking.

Edit- edited to sound less hostile



Top