Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / NoYay

Go To

[006] BritBllt Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \'\'reaction\'\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \
to:
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \\\'\\\'reaction\\\'\\\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \\\"fan reaction\\\" from \\\"one fan\\\'s reaction\\\" is an ordeal.

Still, it\\\'s possible - TheScrappy, CompleteMonster and other subjectives have pretty much the same obstacles, but they work, so there\\\'s no reason this page can\\\'t too. I think we\\\'ll just need to slam the natter hammer down hard and keep only the examples that really have this reaction from the fandom at large, or seem intended as such (so, for instance, Frodo and Sam are going right out the window - no in-universe innuendo, no real reason for the reaction except, as you said, SlashIsEw, and a large part of the fandom\\\'s all for it).

You\\\'re right, though, all-out AtrociousCouples that got together and got this reaction from other characters may be a different trope altogether. I\\\'ll see about YTTKW\\\'ing it later tonight (and moving some of the shakier NoYay examples over here for discussion).
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \'\'reaction\'\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \
to:
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \\\'\\\'reaction\\\'\\\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \\\"fan reaction\\\" from \\\"one fan\\\'s reaction\\\" is an ordeal.

Still, it\\\'s possible - TheScrappy, CompleteMonster and other subjectives have pretty much the same obstacles, but they work, so there\\\'s no reason this page can\\\'t too. I think we\\\'ll just need to slam the natter hammer down hard and keep only the examples that really have this reaction from the fandom at large, or seem intended as such (so, for instance, Frodo and Sam are going right out the window - no in-universe innuendo, no real reason for the reaction except, as you said, SlashIsEw, and a large part of the fandom\\\'s all for it).

You\\\'re right, though, all-out AtrociousCouples that got together and got this reaction from other characters may be a different trope altogether. I\\\'ll see about YTTKW\\\'ing it later tongiht (and moving some of the shakier NoYay examples over here for discussion).
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \'\'reaction\'\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \
to:
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \\\'\\\'reaction\\\'\\\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \\\"fan reaction\\\" from \\\"one fan\\\'s reaction\\\" is an ordeal.

Still, it\\\'s possible - TheScrappy, CompleteMonster and other subjectives have pretty much the same obstacles, but they work, so there\\\'s no reason this page can\\\'t too. I think we\\\'ll just need to slam the natter hammer down hard and keep only the examples that really have this reaction from the fandom at large, or seem intended as such (so, for instance, Frodo and Sam are going right out the window - no in-universe innuendo, no real reason for the reaction except, as you said, SlashIsEw, and a large part of the fandom\\\'s all for it).

You\\\'re right, though, all-out AtrociousCouples that got together and got this reaction from other characters may be a different trope altogether. I\\\'ll see about YTTKW\\\'ing it later (and moving some of the shakier NoYay examples over here for discussion).
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \'\'reaction\'\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \
to:
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \\\'\\\'reaction\\\'\\\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \\\"fan reaction\\\" from \\\"one fan\\\'s reaction\\\" is an ordeal.

Still, it\\\'s possible - TheScrappy, CompleteMonster and other subjectives have pretty much the same obstacles, but they work, so there\\\'s no reason this page can\\\'t too. I think we\\\'ll just need to slam the natter hammer down hard and keep only the examples that really have this reaction from the fandom at large, or seem intended as such (so, for instance, Frodo and Sam are going right out the window - no in-universe innuendo, no real reason for the reaction except, as you said, SlashIsEw, and a large part of the fandom\\\'s all for it).

You\\\'re right, though, all-out AtrociousCouples that got together and got this reaction may be a different trope altogether. I\\\'ll see about YTTKW\\\'ing it later (and moving some of the shakier NoYay examples over here for discussion).
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \'\'reaction\'\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but seperating \
to:
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \\\'\\\'reaction\\\'\\\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but separating \\\"fan reaction\\\" from \\\"one fan\\\'s reaction\\\" is an ordeal.

Still, it\\\'s possible - TheScrappy, CompleteMonster and other subjectives have pretty much the same obstacles, but they work, so there\\\'s no reason this page can\\\'t too. I think we\\\'ll just need to slam the natter hammer down hard and keep only the examples that really have this reaction from the fandom (so, for instance, Frodo and Sam are going right out the window - no in-universe innuendo, no real reason for the reaction except, as you said, SlashIsEw, and a large part of the fandom\\\'s all for it).

You\\\'re right, though, all-out AtrociousCouples that got together and got this reaction may be a different trope altogether. I\\\'ll see about YTTKW\\\'ing it later (and moving some of the shakier NoYay examples over here for discussion).
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \'\'reaction\'\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but seperating \
to:
This page is trickier, because whereas HoYay, FoeYay and IncestYay address different kinds of relationships and the mere presence of subtext, NoYay addresses the fan \\\'\\\'reaction\\\'\\\' to the subtext that falls under one of the other categories. This is one of those tropes that does exist, but seperating \\\"fan reaction\\\" from \\\"one fan\\\'s reaction\\\" is an ordeal.

Still, it\\\'s possible - TheScrappy, CompleteMonster and other subjectives have pretty much the same obstacles, but they work, so there\\\'s no reason this page can\\\'t too. I think we\\\'ll just need to slam the natter hammer down hard and keep only the examples that really have this reaction from the fandom (so, for instance, Frodo and Sam are going right out the window - no in-universe innuendo, no real reason for the reaction except, as you said, SlashIsEw, and a large part of the fandom\\\'s all for it).

You\\\'re right, though, all-out AtrociousCouples that got together and got this reaction may be a different trope altogether. I\\\'ll see about YTTKW\\\'ing it later (and moving some of the shakier NoYay examples over here for discussion).
Top