[005]
nargles77
Current Version
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
* Another troper summed the scene up well on the \
to:
* Another troper summed the scene up well on the \\\"Just Bugs Me\\\" HBP page. Very [[RuleofCool Rule of Cool]] for the filmmakers to add even more depth to an already emotional scene.
** \\\"When the rest of the Death Eaters arrive, Harry realizes Dumbledore is screwed if he doesn\\\'t do something (even though pretty much anything he might try would likely be insufficient to save Dumbledore and would get Harry killed as well, but he is known for having more guts than brains) so he takes out his wand, prepares to attack... and then Snape stops him. He tells him to shut up and goes upstairs. Now, Harry might have his doubts about Snape, but when the guy who you think is a Death Eater has a chance to take you out by surprise and instead warns you to keep quiet and doesn\\\'t even mention you to the Death Eater group upstairs, you start thinking maybe you were wrong about him, maybe he has a plan to save Dumbledore, and maybe, just maybe, you really should just shut up and stay quiet for once. Of course, then Snape kills Dumbledore.\\\"
** \\\"When the rest of the Death Eaters arrive, Harry realizes Dumbledore is screwed if he doesn\\\'t do something (even though pretty much anything he might try would likely be insufficient to save Dumbledore and would get Harry killed as well, but he is known for having more guts than brains) so he takes out his wand, prepares to attack... and then Snape stops him. He tells him to shut up and goes upstairs. Now, Harry might have his doubts about Snape, but when the guy who you think is a Death Eater has a chance to take you out by surprise and instead warns you to keep quiet and doesn\\\'t even mention you to the Death Eater group upstairs, you start thinking maybe you were wrong about him, maybe he has a plan to save Dumbledore, and maybe, just maybe, you really should just shut up and stay quiet for once. Of course, then Snape kills Dumbledore.\\\"
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
* Another troper summed the scene up well on the \
to:
* Another troper summed the scene up well on the \\\"Just Bugs Me\\\" HBP page. Very RuleofCool for the filmmakers to add even more depth to an already emotional scene.
** \\\"When the rest of the Death Eaters arrive, Harry realizes Dumbledore is screwed if he doesn\\\'t do something (even though pretty much anything he might try would likely be insufficient to save Dumbledore and would get Harry killed as well, but he is known for having more guts than brains) so he takes out his wand, prepares to attack... and then Snape stops him. He tells him to shut up and goes upstairs. Now, Harry might have his doubts about Snape, but when the guy who you think is a Death Eater has a chance to take you out by surprise and instead warns you to keep quiet and doesn\\\'t even mention you to the Death Eater group upstairs, you start thinking maybe you were wrong about him, maybe he has a plan to save Dumbledore, and maybe, just maybe, you really should just shut up and stay quiet for once. Of course, then Snape kills Dumbledore.\\\"
** \\\"When the rest of the Death Eaters arrive, Harry realizes Dumbledore is screwed if he doesn\\\'t do something (even though pretty much anything he might try would likely be insufficient to save Dumbledore and would get Harry killed as well, but he is known for having more guts than brains) so he takes out his wand, prepares to attack... and then Snape stops him. He tells him to shut up and goes upstairs. Now, Harry might have his doubts about Snape, but when the guy who you think is a Death Eater has a chance to take you out by surprise and instead warns you to keep quiet and doesn\\\'t even mention you to the Death Eater group upstairs, you start thinking maybe you were wrong about him, maybe he has a plan to save Dumbledore, and maybe, just maybe, you really should just shut up and stay quiet for once. Of course, then Snape kills Dumbledore.\\\"
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
* Another troper summed the scene up well on the \
to:
* Another troper summed the scene up well on the \\\"Just Bugs Me\\\" HBP page.
** \\\"When the rest of the Death Eaters arrive, Harry realizes Dumbledore is screwed if he doesn\\\'t do something (even though pretty much anything he might try would likely be insufficient to save Dumbledore and would get Harry killed as well, but he is known for having more guts than brains) so he takes out his wand, prepares to attack... and then Snape stops him. He tells him to shut up and goes upstairs. Now, Harry might have his doubts about Snape, but when the guy who you think is a Death Eater has a chance to take you out by surprise and instead warns you to keep quiet and doesn\\\'t even mention you to the Death Eater group upstairs, you start thinking maybe you were wrong about him, maybe he has a plan to save Dumbledore, and maybe, just maybe, you really should just shut up and stay quiet for once. Of course, then Snape kills Dumbledore.\\\"
** \\\"When the rest of the Death Eaters arrive, Harry realizes Dumbledore is screwed if he doesn\\\'t do something (even though pretty much anything he might try would likely be insufficient to save Dumbledore and would get Harry killed as well, but he is known for having more guts than brains) so he takes out his wand, prepares to attack... and then Snape stops him. He tells him to shut up and goes upstairs. Now, Harry might have his doubts about Snape, but when the guy who you think is a Death Eater has a chance to take you out by surprise and instead warns you to keep quiet and doesn\\\'t even mention you to the Death Eater group upstairs, you start thinking maybe you were wrong about him, maybe he has a plan to save Dumbledore, and maybe, just maybe, you really should just shut up and stay quiet for once. Of course, then Snape kills Dumbledore.\\\"
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It\'s a wink to the book fans who already know Snape is working on Dumbledore\'s orders. And it makes things all the worse for Harry. He has to let Snape handle the situation, especially since Snape is a member of the Order. After Dumbledore dies, Harry feels twice as betrayed because he let Snape into the tower without warning Dumbledore.
to:
It\\\'s a wink to the book fans who already know Snape is working on Dumbledore\\\'s orders. And it makes things all the worse for Harry. He has to let Snape handle the situation, especially since Snape is a member of the Order. After Dumbledore dies, Harry feels twice as betrayed because he let Snape into the tower without warning Dumbledore.
* Another troper summed the scene up well on the \\\"Just Bugs Me\\\" HBP page. (I couldn\\\'t find it earlier or I would have included it then).
** \\\"When the rest of the Death Eaters arrive, Harry realizes Dumbledore is screwed if he doesn\\\'t do something (even though pretty much anything he might try would likely be insufficient to save Dumbledore and would get Harry killed as well, but he is known for having more guts than brains) so he takes out his wand, prepares to attack... and then Snape stops him. He tells him to shut up and goes upstairs. Now, Harry might have his doubts about Snape, but when the guy who you think is a Death Eater has a chance to take you out by surprise and instead warns you to keep quiet and doesn\\\'t even mention you to the Death Eater group upstairs, you start thinking maybe you were wrong about him, maybe he has a plan to save Dumbledore, and maybe, just maybe, you really should just shut up and stay quiet for once. Of course, then Snape kills Dumbledore.\\\"
* Another troper summed the scene up well on the \\\"Just Bugs Me\\\" HBP page. (I couldn\\\'t find it earlier or I would have included it then).
** \\\"When the rest of the Death Eaters arrive, Harry realizes Dumbledore is screwed if he doesn\\\'t do something (even though pretty much anything he might try would likely be insufficient to save Dumbledore and would get Harry killed as well, but he is known for having more guts than brains) so he takes out his wand, prepares to attack... and then Snape stops him. He tells him to shut up and goes upstairs. Now, Harry might have his doubts about Snape, but when the guy who you think is a Death Eater has a chance to take you out by surprise and instead warns you to keep quiet and doesn\\\'t even mention you to the Death Eater group upstairs, you start thinking maybe you were wrong about him, maybe he has a plan to save Dumbledore, and maybe, just maybe, you really should just shut up and stay quiet for once. Of course, then Snape kills Dumbledore.\\\"
