Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / RWBY

Go To

[003] Wyldchyld Current Version

10th May '20 at 06:46:31 AM

Changed line(s) 3 from:

n

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13639868050A17401700&page=2618#comment-65449

to:

[=https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13639868050A17401700&page=2618#comment-65449=]

Changed line(s) 11 from:

n

** There\'s a subset of fans who support Ironwood in Volume 7, claiming that he was the only leader in Remnant who actually had a logical plan to combat Salem, even if that logical plan got derailed to the point where Ironwood decides to [[spoiler:sacrifice Mantle\'s non-evacuated populace to save Atlas itself and the Relic of Creation]]. That RWBY obscuring some major truths to Ironwood despite their compaints about being lied to in previous Volumes and their plan as a whole being only ever elaborated on to be \

to:

** There\\\'s a subset of fans who support Ironwood in Volume 7, claiming that he was the only leader in Remnant who actually had a logical plan to combat Salem, even if that logical plan got derailed to the point where Ironwood decides to [[spoiler:sacrifice Mantle\\\'s non-evacuated populace to save Atlas itself and the Relic of Creation]]. That RWBY obscuring some major truths to Ironwood despite their compaints about being lied to in previous Volumes and their plan as a whole being only ever elaborated on to be \\\"We\\\'ll fight and win\\\" didn\\\'t help.
*** \\\'\\\'\\\'We\\\'re all familiar with the fandom\\\'s debate over who\\\'s right and wrong between Ironwood and Team RWBY, with a lot of people coming down on one side or the other, or thinking both sides have a point, or thinking both sides are equally bad. However, I haven\\\'t seen people who support Ironwood\\\'s side of the argument do so because of this trope. This trope is supposed to be about the villains being more popular than the heroes. So, is this trope in play?\\\'\\\'\\\'
** There is another subset of fans who have, for one reason or another, become upset with the main cast and want Salem to conquer the world.
*** \\\'\\\'\\\'This is Administrivia/ZeroContextExample as written, especially as it just comes across as \\\'fandom contains people with different opinions\\\'. If the trope\\\'s in play for this scenario, it needs rewriting.\\\'\\\'\\\'

[002] Wyldchyld

10th May '20 at 06:46:15 AM

Changed line(s) 1 from:

n

I\'d like to ask some questions about the following entries:

to:

I\\\'d like to ask some questions about the following entries. I\\\'ve also asked the same question on the RWBY forum thread, here:

Changed line(s) 2 from:

to:

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13639868050A17401700&page=2618#comment-65449

Changed line(s) 9 from:

n

** There\'s a subset of fans who support Ironwood in Volume 7, claiming that he was the only leader in Remnant who actually had a logical plan to combat Salem, even if that logical plan got derailed to the point where Ironwood decides to [[spoiler:sacrifice Mantle\'s non-evacuated populace to save Atlas itself and the Relic of Creation]]. That RWBY obscuring some major truths to Ironwood despite their compaints about being lied to in previous Volumes and their plan as a whole being only ever elaborated on to be \

to:

** There\\\'s a subset of fans who support Ironwood in Volume 7, claiming that he was the only leader in Remnant who actually had a logical plan to combat Salem, even if that logical plan got derailed to the point where Ironwood decides to [[spoiler:sacrifice Mantle\\\'s non-evacuated populace to save Atlas itself and the Relic of Creation]]. That RWBY obscuring some major truths to Ironwood despite their compaints about being lied to in previous Volumes and their plan as a whole being only ever elaborated on to be \\\"We\\\'ll fight and win\\\" didn\\\'t help.
*** \\\'\\\'\\\'We\\\'re all familiar with the fandom\\\'s debate over who\\\'s right and wrong between Ironwood and Team RWBY, with a lot of people coming down on one side or the other, or thinking both sides have a point, or thinking both sides are equally bad. However, I haven\\\'t seen people who support Ironwood\\\'s side of the argument do so because of this trope. This trope is supposed to be about the villains being more popular than the heroes. So, is this trope in play?\\\'\\\'\\\'
** There is another subset of fans who have, for one reason or another, become upset with the main cast and want Salem to conquer the world.
*** \\\'\\\'\\\'This is Administrivia/ZeroContextExample as written, especially as it just comes across as \\\'fandom contains people with different opinions\\\'. If the trope\\\'s in play for this scenario, it needs rewriting.\\\'\\\'\\\'

[001] Wyldchyld

10th May '20 at 06:44:56 AM

Changed line(s) 9 from:

n

** There\'s a subset of fans who support Ironwood in Volume 7, claiming that he was the only leader in Remnant who actually had a logical plan to combat Salem, even if that logical plan got derailed to the point where Ironwood decides to [[spoiler:sacrifice Mantle\'s non-evacuated populace to save Atlas itself and the Relic of Creation]]. That RWBY obscuring some major truths to Ironwood despite their compaints about being lied to in previous Volumes and their plan as a whole being only ever elaborated on to be \

to:

** There\\\'s a subset of fans who support Ironwood in Volume 7, claiming that he was the only leader in Remnant who actually had a logical plan to combat Salem, even if that logical plan got derailed to the point where Ironwood decides to [[spoiler:sacrifice Mantle\\\'s non-evacuated populace to save Atlas itself and the Relic of Creation]]. That RWBY obscuring some major truths to Ironwood despite their compaints about being lied to in previous Volumes and their plan as a whole being only ever elaborated on to be \\\"We\\\'ll fight and win\\\" didn\\\'t help.
*** \\\'\\\'\\\'We\\\'re all familiar with the fandom\\\'s debate over who\\\'s right and wrong between Ironwood and Team RWBY, with a lot of people coming down on one side or the other, or thinking both sides have a point, or thinking both sides are equally bad. However, I haven\\\'t seen people who support Ironwood\\\'s side of the argument do so because of this trope. This trope is supposed to be about the villains being more popular than the heroes. So, is this trope in play?\\\'\\\'\\\'
** There is another subset of fans who have, for one reason or another, become upset with the main cast and want Salem to conquer the world.
*** \\\'\\\'\\\'This is Administrivia/ZeroContextExample as written, especially as it just comes across as \\\'fandom contains people with different opinions\\\'. If the trope\\\'s in play for this scenario, it needs rewriting.\\\'\\\'\\\'

Top