[002]
jonnyf
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The end of the recap of S1E8 differs slightly in action and tone from the Netflix version.
The recap ends>> Back to the present, Julián laments what he caused and Amelia tries to console him, but he rages about it, the Ministry and tells Amelia that there\'s no chance of them getting together ever. As he closes the door to his room rather forcefully, Amelia gets the photograph out and gazes on it: it shows Julián, herself and a young baby girl, smiling. A crying Amelia rips the photo off.
On Netflix S1E8 (last episode of the season):
The car accident scene ends with Julian(paramedic) holding his wife Maite, at 1h08m. Cuts to Alonso asking Amelia about giving Julian a concoction (sleeping aid?).
[ Not in this version: Julian laments ... Amelia consoles, rage, getting together .. he closes the door forcefully. ] Alelia closes the door quietly at 1h08:34 saying she is going to lay down. She sits silently. Alonzo tells a sleeping Julian that he changed his (Alonzo\'s) wife\'s destiny. Pans down to show Julian\'s eyes open, listening, he then closes his eyes. The last shot is the same as the recap
>Amelia gets the photograph out and gazes on it: it shows Julián, herself and a young baby girl, smiling. A crying Amelia rips the photo off.
Julian\'s voice over \
The recap ends>> Back to the present, Julián laments what he caused and Amelia tries to console him, but he rages about it, the Ministry and tells Amelia that there\'s no chance of them getting together ever. As he closes the door to his room rather forcefully, Amelia gets the photograph out and gazes on it: it shows Julián, herself and a young baby girl, smiling. A crying Amelia rips the photo off.
On Netflix S1E8 (last episode of the season):
The car accident scene ends with Julian(paramedic) holding his wife Maite, at 1h08m. Cuts to Alonso asking Amelia about giving Julian a concoction (sleeping aid?).
[ Not in this version: Julian laments ... Amelia consoles, rage, getting together .. he closes the door forcefully. ] Alelia closes the door quietly at 1h08:34 saying she is going to lay down. She sits silently. Alonzo tells a sleeping Julian that he changed his (Alonzo\'s) wife\'s destiny. Pans down to show Julian\'s eyes open, listening, he then closes his eyes. The last shot is the same as the recap
>Amelia gets the photograph out and gazes on it: it shows Julián, herself and a young baby girl, smiling. A crying Amelia rips the photo off.
Julian\'s voice over \
to:
The netflix version removes the conflict between Julian and Amelia in the final minutes. she gives him something to sleep, she closes the doors quietly. No arguing or discussion of what happened with his late wife.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Because there was a consensus that the reaction to V5 was completely different to the reaction to V4, to the point where some of the fanbase has even said that they've changed their minds about V4 given how bad they feel V5 is -- and that doesn't mean they've gone from disliking to liking V4, it means they feel the issues they had with V4 have been contextualised, either clearing up some issues they had and/or giving the volume a perspective that makes them group V1-V4 as being different to V5 in terms issues.
to:
Because there was a consensus that the reaction to V5 was completely different to the reaction to V4, to the point where some of the fanbase has even said that they\'ve changed their minds about V4 given how bad they feel V5 is -- and that doesn\'t mean they\'ve gone from disliking to liking V4, it means they feel the issues they had with V4 have been contextualised, either clearing up some issues they had and/or giving the volume a perspective that makes them group V1-V4 as being different to V5 in terms issues.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
That said, if you feel there's merit in adding Volume 4 to the SeasonalRot trope, start a discussion on it. The original entry didn't forget V4, it deliberately excluded it, so I discussion would be needed to re-evaluate V4. I'd suggest starting a new discussion thread, however, as this one's long and further down the page so more easily missed.
to:
That said, if you feel there\'s merit in adding Volume 4 to the SeasonalRot trope, start a discussion on it. The original entry didn\'t forget V4, it deliberately excluded it, so a discussion would be needed to re-evaluate V4. I\'d suggest starting a new discussion thread, however, as this one\'s long and further down the page so more easily missed.
