[005]
Apocrypha
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn't. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of ''Star Wars'', and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being
to:
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn\'t. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of \'\'Star Wars\'\', and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being \"abusive\" fall more under the realm of RonTheDeathEater, because she was \'\'doing her job\'\' by tazing Finn. He was on a Resistance ship, had already worked in a Resistance mission, was regarded as a Resistance hero, and up until the FO followed them out of lightspeed, used \"we\" in regards to the Resistance\'s next move. Even if he hadn\'t officially joined, he was still an ally and was trying to sneak away--the conclusion for anyone would be obvious.
Similarly, others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from Poe. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]], and point out that if we saw things from HER eyes and knew about the plan, Poe would seem the villain. Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Similarly, others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from Poe. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]], and point out that if we saw things from HER eyes and knew about the plan, Poe would seem the villain. Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn't. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of ''Star Wars'', and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being
to:
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn\'t. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of \'\'Star Wars\'\', and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being \"abusive\" fall more under the realm of RonTheDeathEater, because she was \'\'doing her job\'\' by tazing Finn. He was on a Resistance ship, had already worked in a Resistance mission, was regarded as a Resistance hero, and up until the FO followed them out of lightspeed, used \"we\" in regards to the Resistance\'s next move. Even if he hadn\'t officially joined, he was still an ally and was trying to sneak away--the conclusion for anyone would be obvious.
Similarly, others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from Poe. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]], and point out that if we saw things from HER eyes and knew about the plan, Poe would seem the villain. Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Similarly, others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from Poe. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]], and point out that if we saw things from HER eyes and knew about the plan, Poe would seem the villain. Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn't. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of ''Star Wars'', and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being
to:
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn\'t. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of \'\'Star Wars\'\', and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being \"abusive\" fall more under the realm of RonTheDeathEater, because she was \'\'doing her job\'\' by tazing Finn. He was on a Resistance ship, had already worked in a Resistance mission, was regarded as a Resistance hero, and up until the FO followed them out of lightspeed, used \"we\" in regards to the Resistance\'s next move. Even if he hadn\'t officially joined, he was still an ally and was trying to sneak away--the conclusion for anyone would be obvious.
Similarly, others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from him. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]], and point out that if we saw things from HER eyes and knew about the plan, Poe would seem the villain. Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Similarly, others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from him. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]], and point out that if we saw things from HER eyes and knew about the plan, Poe would seem the villain. Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn't. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of ''Star Wars'' theme and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being
to:
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn\'t. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of \'\'Star Wars\'\', and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being \"abusive\" fall more under the realm of RonTheDeathEater, because she was \'\'doing her job\'\' by tazing Finn. He was on a Resistance ship, had already worked in a Resistance mission, was regarded as a Resistance hero, and up until the FO followed them out of lightspeed, used \"we\" in regards to the Resistance\'s next move. Even if he hadn\'t officially joined, he was still an ally and was trying to sneak away--the conclusion for anyone would be obvious.
Yes, and others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from him. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]]. Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Yes, and others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from him. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]]. Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn't. Additionally, people who think Rose's behavior is
to:
While Rose and Holdo are talked about negatively, they also have their fans and defenders; TheScrappy doesn\'t. Rose has people who think she preaches a good message that falls in line with the theme of \'\'Star Wars\'\' theme and like that she saved Finn from dying. The comments about her being \"abusive\" fall more under the realm of RonTheDeathEater, because she was \'\'doing her job\'\' by tazing Finn. He was on a Resistance ship, had already worked in a Resistance mission, was regarded as a Resistance hero, and up until the FO followed them out of lightspeed, used \"we\" in regards to the Resistance\'s next move. Even if he hadn\'t officially joined, he was still an ally and was trying to sneak away--the conclusion for anyone would be obvious.
Yes, and others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from him. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]]. Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
Yes, and others consider Holdo to be in the right to withhold information from him. He\'d gotten all her bombers killed, proven himself to disrespect authority, and went behind her back the first chance he got (before ever confronting her about a plan). Basically, people\'s reaction on her depends on who they blame more for PoorCommunicationKills (when personally I think they\'re both equally at fault). There are also those who like the narrative twist of her [[UnreliableNarrator seeming villainous because we\'re looking at her through Poe\'s eyes]]. Lots of negativity around her, but also lots of positivity.
