Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / LoudnessWar

Go To

[005] BLOODPOUCH Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
A. It ignores the fact that portable digital music players do not have the power to play uncompressed music at a high volume. Doing so will either cause clipping or destroy the battery life, and most people can\'t be bothered to spend $20 on an amp.
to:
A. It ignores the fact that portable digital music players do not have the power to play uncompressed music at a high volume. Doing so will either cause clipping or destroy the battery life, and most people can\\\'t be bothered to spend $20 on an amp. Like the article says, \\\"all recording medium have an absolute limit when it comes to amplitude\\\".
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
B. It assumes that having lots of compression is an inherently bad thing. It can\'t be common because people like the fuller, more \
to:
B. It assumes that having lots of compression is an inherently bad thing. It can\\\'t be common because people like the fuller, more \\\"forward\\\" sound, or that consumers favour noise cancelling over sound quality when listening to music in public, or that they have shitty MP3 players. No, they\\\'re uncultured simpletons who have this horrible music forced on them by \\\"stupid executives\\\". In fact, the \\\"Amusing Casualties\\\" section refers to uncompressed sound as \\\"correct\\\".

C. There\\\'s only a single sentence explaining \\\'\\\'why\\\'\\\' overcompression in music exists, and it\\\'s pretty much one giant TakeThat.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
B. It assumes that having lots of compression is an inherently bad thing. It can\'t be common because people like the fuller, more \
to:
B. It assumes that having lots of compression is an inherently bad thing. It can\\\'t be common because people like the fuller, more \\\"forward\\\" sound, or that consumers favour noise cancelling over sound quality when listening to music in public, or that they have shitty MP3 players. No, they\\\'re uncultured simpletons who have this horrible music forced on them by \\\"stupid executives\\\".

C. There\\\'s only a single sentence explaining \\\'\\\'why\\\'\\\' overcompression in music exists, and it\\\'s pretty much one giant TakeThat.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
B. It assumes that having lots of compression is an inherently bad thing. It can\'t be common because people like the fuller, more \
to:
B. It assumes that having lots of compression is an inherently bad thing. It can\\\'t be common because people like the fuller, more \\\"forward\\\" sound, or that consumers favour cancelling noise over sound quality when listening to music in public, or that they have shitty MP3 players. No, they\\\'re uncultured simpletons who have this horrible music forced on them by \\\"stupid executives\\\".

C. There\\\'s only a single sentence explaining \\\'\\\'why\\\'\\\' overcompression in music exists, and it\\\'s pretty much one giant TakeThat.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
So the message is that anyone who \'\'likes\'\' this unsubtle, compressed style is a fool who knows nothing about music? Because with the exception of a token \
to:
This article has several flaws:

A. It ignores the fact that portable digital music players do not have the power to play uncompressed music at a high volume. Doing so will either cause clipping or destroy the battery life, and most people can\\\'t be bothered to spend $20 on an amp.

B. It assumes that having lots of compression is an inherently bad thing. It can\\\'t be common because people like the fuller, more \\\"foward\\\" sound or that they have shitty MP3 players. No, they\\\'re uncultured simpletons who have this horrible music forced on them by \\\"stupid executives\\\".

C. There\\\'s only a single sentence explaining \\\'\\\'why\\\'\\\' overcompression in music exists, and it\\\'s pretty much one giant TakeThat.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
So the message is that anyone who \'\'likes\'\' this unsubtle, compressed style is a fool who knows nothing about music?
to:
So the message is that anyone who \\\'\\\'likes\\\'\\\' this unsubtle, compressed style is a fool who knows nothing about music? Because with the exception of a token \\\"well, some people actually do like this\\\", the entire article is dedicated to bashing compression and the artists who use it.

Also, I love how the explanation for why compression is used is basically \\\"because people are \\\'\\\'stupid\\\'\\\'! >:(\\\"
Top