Discussion History Main / SelfInsertFic

Go To

[003] BURGINABC Current Version

Changed line(s) 1 from:

As I've said multiple times before, {{Averted}} tropes are not listed unless there is a very good reason for the trope's absence to be surprising, which there is not in this case.

to:

As I\'ve said multiple times before, {{Averted}} tropes are not listed unless there is a very good reason for the trope\'s absence to be surprising, which there is not in this case.

Changed line(s) 10 from:

That wasn't an exhaustive list, but the point is, there need to be special circumstances surrounding an Aversion before it's worth mentioning, and that's not the case here.

to:

That wasn\'t an exhaustive list, but the point is, there need to be special circumstances surrounding an Aversion before it\'s worth mentioning, and that\'s not the case here.

Changed line(s) 12 from:

ArsonMurderAndJaywalking simply shouldn't be listed on this page.

to:

ArsonMurderAndJaywalking simply shouldn\'t be listed on this page.

Changed line(s) 14 from:

Yes, it is an

to:

Yes, it is an \"averted variant\" but so is \'\'every single trope that doesn\'t appear in the movie.\'\' If it were proper to list aversions without a special reason, then we would need to list \'\'every single trope on the site\'\'.

The scene at Bunnyburrow\'s train station is an aversion of TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt since it doesn\'t involve the destruction of the world, but obviously we\'re not going to list that. And listing the scene with Judy accusing Nick as an aversion of ArsonMurderAndJaywalking because the crimes are of equal severity, is equally silly. The trope doesn\'t apply, and there\'s no reason for this to be interesting.

Is this finally getting through to you? Because I can\'t think of an any more detailed way to explain this.

[002] BURGINABC

22nd Oct '17 at 09:45:08 PM

Changed line(s) 1 from:

As I've said multiple times before, {{Averted}} tropes are not listed unless there is a very good reason for the trope's absence to be surprising, which there is not in this case.

to:

As I\'ve said multiple times before, {{Averted}} tropes are not listed unless there is a very good reason for the trope\'s absence to be surprising, which there is not in this case.

Changed line(s) 10 from:

That wasn't an exhaustive list, but the point is, there need to be special circumstances surrounding an Aversion before it's worth mentioning, and that's not the case here.

to:

That wasn\'t an exhaustive list, but the point is, there need to be special circumstances surrounding an Aversion before it\'s worth mentioning, and that\'s not the case here.

Changed line(s) 12 from:

ArsonMurderAndJaywalking simply shouldn't be listed on this page.

to:

ArsonMurderAndJaywalking simply shouldn\'t be listed on this page.

Yes, it is an \"averted variant\" but so is \'\'every single trope that doesn\'t appear in the movie.\'\' If it were proper to list aversions without a special reason, then we would need to list \'\'every single trope on the site\'\'.

The scene at Bunnyburrow\'s train station is an aversion of TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt since it doesn\'t involve the destruction of the world, but obviously we\'re not going to list that. And saying that the scene with Judy accusing Nick is an aversion of ArsonMurderAndJaywalking because the crimes are of equal severity, is equally silly. The trope doesn\'t apply, and there\'s no reason for this to be interesting.

Is this finally getting through to you? Because I can\'t think of an any more detailed way to explain this.

[001] BURGINABC

22nd Oct '17 at 09:15:58 PM

Changed line(s) 1 from:

As I've said multiple times before, {{Averted}} tropes are not listed unless there is a very good reason for the trope's absence to be surprising, which there is not in this case. ArsonMurderAndJaywalking simply shouldn't be listed on this page.

to:

As I\'ve said multiple times before, {{Averted}} tropes are not listed unless there is a very good reason for the trope\'s absence to be surprising, which there is not in this case.

Reasons an AvertedTrope might be listed include:

* It is an OmnipresentTrope. (e.g. NobodyPoops)
* It is such a standard part of a genre, that seeing a work in that genre without the trope is surprising (e.g. HeroicBuild in a superhero story)
* The trope is absent in an adaptation or reboot of a story where that trope was prominent.
* An entry in a StrictlyFormula series deviates from the formula by averting the trope.

That wasn\'t an exhaustive list, but the point is, there need to be special circumstances surrounding an Aversion before it\'s worth mentioning, and that\'s not the case here.

ArsonMurderAndJaywalking simply shouldn\'t be listed on this page.

Top