Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / HeroicMime

Go To

[001] TrueShadow1 Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Well for me, Meliodas most definitely knows Elizabeth is Liz's reincarnation. And that Liz is also someone else's reincarnation. And that someone else is someone else's reincarnation. All the way until the original Elizabeth.
to:
Well for me, Meliodas most definitely knows Elizabeth is Liz\'s reincarnation. And that Liz is also someone else\'s reincarnation. And that someone else is someone else\'s reincarnation. All the way until the original Elizabeth.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
The most glaring hint is when Mel said something about Elizabeth converting an entire army of demon 3000 years ago. Neither Liz or Elizabeth could be alive at that point, so it must be the original goddess apostle. And since Mel associated her with Ellie, he must know there's some reincarnation thingie going on.
to:
The most glaring hint is when Mel said something about Elizabeth converting an entire army of demon 3000 years ago. Neither Liz or Elizabeth could be alive at that point, so it must be the original goddess apostle. And since Mel associated her with Ellie, he must know there\'s some reincarnation thingie going on.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
The only argument against Mel knowing is
to:
The only argument against Mel knowing is \"Nakaba hasn\'t confirmed it outright\", which requires ignoring dozens of hints he threw around.

It\'s simple application of OccamsRazor. \"Mel knows\" is the simpler and more plausible answer than \"Mel doesn\'t know and is in denial and just projecting Liz into Elizabeth\".

Anyway, regarding DawnVelocity\'s comment on how \"his reason doesn\'t matter\", yes it does. It provides more context to the situation, which is never a bad thing.

Addition:

I don\'t rember the exact chapter, but didn\'t Mel release Liz when she was an enemy spy when they first met? That, too, implies Mel knows Liz is special.
Top