Tropes Media Browse Indexes Forums Videos Ask The Tropers Trope Finder Media Finder Trope Launch Pad Tech Wishlist Reviews Tools
Cut List New Edits Edit Reasons Launches Images List Crowner Activity Un-typed Pages Recent Page Type Changes Changelog
Tips
Creating New Redirects Cross Wicking Tips for Editing Text Formatting Rules Glossary Edit Reasons Handling Spoilers Word Cruft Administrivia FAQ
Tropes HQ
About Us Contact Us Advertise DMCA Notice Privacy Policy Report Bug
Go Ad-Free Changelog
  • Show Spoilers
  • Night Vision
  • Sticky Header
  • Highlight Links
 

Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / TheSevenDeadlySins

Go To
[004] DawnVelocity Current Version
3rd Aug '16 at 09:19:01 PM
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
You seem so very sure of yourself. What's important to note is that we have no physical ''instance'' of reincarnation. As far as we know, nothing happened to make Meliodas think baby Elizabeth was Liz. Maybe if there were a flash of light, or Liz's ghost hovering over the baby? I might buy it. But we go from Liz dying to Meliodas holding a baby and declaring it his woman. Oh sure, the proof is there--sixteen years later! But with no actual visible instance of reincarnation, Meliodas has no more way of knowing immediately after the fact what he may or may not believe, than we do.
to:
You want the unknowns? Here\'s a good one. What\'s important to note is that we have no physical \'\'instance\'\' of reincarnation. As far as we know, nothing happened to make Meliodas think baby Elizabeth was Liz. Maybe if there were a flash of light, or Liz\'s ghost hovering over the baby? I might buy it. But we go from Liz dying to Meliodas holding a baby and declaring it his woman. Oh sure, the proof is there--sixteen years later! But with no actual visible instance of reincarnation, Meliodas has no more way of knowing immediately after the fact what he may or may not believe, than we do.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
At any rate, this discussion is over your edit. Even disregarding whether he knew or not, that edit was pointless and only served to make Meliodas look less like a pedophile over his pedophilic actions. It doesn't matter who he was protective over or why. He decided an infant girl was his woman. Please leave the entry as is, it doesn't need any defending or devil's-advocating or mediating.
to:
At any rate, this discussion is over your edit. Even disregarding whether he knew or not, that edit was pointless and only served to make Meliodas look less like a pedophile over his pedophilic actions. It doesn\'t matter who he was protective over or why. He decided an infant girl was his woman. Please leave the entry as is, it doesn\'t need any defending or devil\'s-advocating or mediating.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Let me correct you on ShowDontTell: Nakaba has utterly failed in it. We have been ''told'' Meliodas and Elizabeth are close and romance material, but we have seen nothing of a relationship grow between them beyond Meliodas molesting her and Elizabeth being entirely too grateful for his help. We are ''told'' Elizabeth is the reincarnation of Liz, but we have not been presented a visible instance of it. We are ''told'' Elizabeth is like Liz, but have been shown that Liz was a different personality altogether and only physical looks are consistent between them. That is not showing. That is telling.
to:
Let me correct you on ShowDontTell: Nakaba has utterly failed in it. We have been \'\'told\'\' Meliodas and Elizabeth are close and romance material, but we have seen nothing of a relationship grow between them beyond Meliodas molesting her and Elizabeth being entirely too grateful for his help. We are \'\'told\'\' Elizabeth is the reincarnation of Liz, but we have not been presented a visible instance of it. We are \'\'told\'\' Elizabeth is like Liz, but have been shown that Liz was a different personality altogether and only physical looks are consistent between them. That is not showing. That is telling.
[003] DawnVelocity
3rd Aug '16 at 09:17:33 PM
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
You seem so very sure of yourself. What's important to note is that we have no physical ''instance'' of reincarnation. As far as we know, nothing happened to make Meliodas think baby Elizabeth was Liz. Maybe if there were a flash of light, or Liz's ghost hovering over the baby? I might buy it. But we go from Liz dying to Meliodas holding a baby and declaring it his woman. Oh sure, the proof is there--sixteen years later! But with no actual visible instance of reincarnation, Meliodas has no more way of knowing immediately after the fact what he may or may not believe, than we do.
to:
You seem so very sure of yourself. What\'s important to note is that we have no physical \'\'instance\'\' of reincarnation. As far as we know, nothing happened to make Meliodas think baby Elizabeth was Liz. Maybe if there were a flash of light, or Liz\'s ghost hovering over the baby? I might buy it. But we go from Liz dying to Meliodas holding a baby and declaring it his woman. Oh sure, the proof is there--sixteen years later! But with no actual visible instance of reincarnation, Meliodas has no more way of knowing immediately after the fact what he may or may not believe, than we do.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
At any rate, this discussion is over your edit. Even disregarding whether he knew or not, that edit was pointless and only served to make Meliodas look less like a pedophile over his pedophilic actions. It doesn't matter who he was protective over or why. He decided an infant girl was his woman. Please leave the entry as is, it doesn't need any defending or devil's-advocating or mediating.
to:
At any rate, this discussion is over your edit. Even disregarding whether he knew or not, that edit was pointless and only served to make Meliodas look less like a pedophile over his pedophilic actions. It doesn\'t matter who he was protective over or why. He decided an infant girl was his woman. Please leave the entry as is, it doesn\'t need any defending or devil\'s-advocating or mediating.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Let me correct you on ShowDontTell: Nakaba has utterly failed in it. We have been ''told'' Meliodas and Elizabeth are close and romance material, but we have seen nothing of a relationship grow between them beyond Meliodas molesting her and Elizabeth being entirely too grateful for his help. We are ''told'' Elizabeth is the reincarnation of Liz, but we have not been presented a visible instance of it. We are ''told'' Elizabeth is like Liz, but have been shown that Liz was a different personality altogether and only physical looks are consistent between them. That is not showing. That is telling.
to:
Let me correct you on ShowDontTell: Nakaba has utterly failed in it. We have been \'\'told\'\' Meliodas and Elizabeth are close and romance material, but we have seen nothing of a relationship grow between them beyond Meliodas molesting her and Elizabeth being entirely too grateful for his help. We are \'\'told\'\' Elizabeth is the reincarnation of Liz, but we have not been presented a visible instance of it. We are \'\'told\'\' Elizabeth is like Liz, but have been shown that Liz was a different personality altogether and only physical looks are consistent between them. That is not showing. That is telling.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
As discussion is not leading us to an agreement, please consider this discussion brought to a halt unless someone else decides to comment on it, and until they do, please do not re-add the entry, as that would be in violation of your own act of bringing it here.
to:
As discussion is not leading us to an agreement, please consider this discussion brought to a halt unless someone else decides to comment on it, and until they do, please do not re-add the entry.
[002] DawnVelocity
3rd Aug '16 at 09:17:04 PM
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
You seem so very sure of yourself. What's important to note is that we have no physical ''instance'' of reincarnation. As far as we know, nothing happened to make Meliodas think baby Elizabeth was Liz. Maybe if there were a flash of light, or Liz's ghost hovering over the baby? I might buy it. But we go from Liz dying to Meliodas holding a baby and declaring it his woman. Oh sure, the proof is there--sixteen years later! But with no actual visible instance of reincarnation, Meliodas has no more way of knowing what he may or may not believe than we do.
to:
You seem so very sure of yourself. What\'s important to note is that we have no physical \'\'instance\'\' of reincarnation. As far as we know, nothing happened to make Meliodas think baby Elizabeth was Liz. Maybe if there were a flash of light, or Liz\'s ghost hovering over the baby? I might buy it. But we go from Liz dying to Meliodas holding a baby and declaring it his woman. Oh sure, the proof is there--sixteen years later! But with no actual visible instance of reincarnation, Meliodas has no more way of knowing immediately after the fact what he may or may not believe, than we do.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
At any rate, this discussion is over your edit. Even disregarding whether he knew or not, that edit was pointless and only served to make Meliodas look less like a pedophile over his pedophilic actions. It doesn't matter who he was protective over or not. He decided an infant girl was his woman. Please leave the entry as is, it doesn't need any defending or devil's-advocating or mediating.
to:
At any rate, this discussion is over your edit. Even disregarding whether he knew or not, that edit was pointless and only served to make Meliodas look less like a pedophile over his pedophilic actions. It doesn\'t matter who he was protective over or why. He decided an infant girl was his woman. Please leave the entry as is, it doesn\'t need any defending or devil\'s-advocating or mediating.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
Let me correct you on ShowDontTell: Nakaba has utterly failed in it. We have been ''told'' Meliodas and Elizabeth are close and romance material, but we have seen nothing of a relationship grow between them beyond Meliodas molesting her and Elizabeth being entirely too grateful for his help. We are ''told'' Elizabeth is the reincarnation of Liz, but we have not been presented a visible instance of it. We are ''told'' Elizabeth is like Liz, but have been shown that Liz was a different personality altogether and only physical looks are consistent between them. That is not showing. That is telling.
to:
Let me correct you on ShowDontTell: Nakaba has utterly failed in it. We have been \'\'told\'\' Meliodas and Elizabeth are close and romance material, but we have seen nothing of a relationship grow between them beyond Meliodas molesting her and Elizabeth being entirely too grateful for his help. We are \'\'told\'\' Elizabeth is the reincarnation of Liz, but we have not been presented a visible instance of it. We are \'\'told\'\' Elizabeth is like Liz, but have been shown that Liz was a different personality altogether and only physical looks are consistent between them. That is not showing. That is telling.
[001] DawnVelocity
3rd Aug '16 at 09:15:56 PM
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
You seem so very sure of yourself. What's important to note is that we have no physical ''instance'' of reincarnation. As far as we know, nothing happened to make Meliodas think baby Elizabeth was Liz. Maybe if there were a flash of light, or Liz's ghost hovering over the baby? I might buy it. But we go from Liz dying to Meliodas holding a baby and declaring it his woman. Oh sure, the proof is there--sixteen years later! But with no actual visible instance of reincarnation, Meliodas has no more way of knowing what he may or may not believe than we do.
to:
You seem so very sure of yourself. What\'s important to note is that we have no physical \'\'instance\'\' of reincarnation. As far as we know, nothing happened to make Meliodas think baby Elizabeth was Liz. Maybe if there were a flash of light, or Liz\'s ghost hovering over the baby? I might buy it. But we go from Liz dying to Meliodas holding a baby and declaring it his woman. Oh sure, the proof is there--sixteen years later! But with no actual visible instance of reincarnation, Meliodas has no more way of knowing what he may or may not believe than we do.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
At any rate, this discussion is over your edit. Even disregarding whether he knew or not, that edit was pointless and only served to make Meliodas look less like a pedophile over his pedophilic actions. It doesn't matter who he was protective over or not. He decided an infant girl was his woman. Please leave the entry as is, it doesn't need any defending or devil's-advocating or mediatign.
to:
At any rate, this discussion is over your edit. Even disregarding whether he knew or not, that edit was pointless and only served to make Meliodas look less like a pedophile over his pedophilic actions. It doesn\'t matter who he was protective over or not. He decided an infant girl was his woman. Please leave the entry as is, it doesn\'t need any defending or devil\'s-advocating or mediating.

Let me correct you on ShowDontTell: Nakaba has utterly failed in it. We have been \'\'told\'\' Meliodas and Elizabeth are close and romance material, but we have seen nothing of a relationship grow between them beyond Meliodas molesting her and Elizabeth being entirely too grateful for his help. We are \'\'told\'\' Elizabeth is the reincarnation of Liz, but we have not been presented a visible instance of it. We are \'\'told\'\' Elizabeth is like Liz, but have been shown that Liz was a different personality altogether and only physical looks are consistent between them. That is not showing. That is telling.

As discussion is not leading us to an agreement, please consider this discussion brought to a halt unless someone else decides to comment on it, and until they do, please do not re-add the entry, as that would be in violation of your own act of bringing it here.

Important Links

Ask The Tropers Trope Finder Media Finder Trope Launch Pad Tech Wishlist Reviews Go Ad Free!
Crucial Browsing
Resources
Top