Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / RWBY

Go To

[002] Wyldchyld Current Version
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
** The fan theory about Qrow being Ruby's real father has sparked controversy to a near FandomBerserkButton level. Those who support it think that it would be an amazing plot twist, add depth to the relationship between them and point out the many reasons why that would be likely (from Qrow taking Ruby under his wing to their various similarities). Fans against it however, are much more outspoken, pointing out that it would be traumatizing for Ruby to have her family lying to her about her father, that it would nullify the FamilyOfChoice point made by their sweet uncle-niece relationship that has no blood relation and that those in favor are favoring the fact that it would make Qrow/Summer canon over how this would affect their family. There's also an undertones of a ShipToShipCombat between those who ship Qrow/Summer and those who ship Qrow and Summer with other characters.
to:
** The fan theory about Qrow being Ruby\'s real father has sparked controversy to a near FandomBerserkButton level. Those who support it think that it would be an amazing plot twist, add depth to the relationship between them and point out the many reasons why that would be likely (from Qrow taking Ruby under his wing to their various similarities). Fans against it however, are much more outspoken, pointing out that it would be traumatizing for Ruby to have her family lying to her about her father, that it would nullify the FamilyOfChoice point made by their sweet uncle-niece relationship that has no blood relation and that those in favor are favoring the fact that it would make Qrow/Summer canon over how this would affect their family. There\'s also an undertones of a ShipToShipCombat between those who ship Qrow/Summer and those who ship Qrow and Summer with other characters.
Changed line(s) 4 from:
n
I've never seen this subject break the fandom base. I have - only once - seen an insane blow-up over this subject, a while back, and it was driven by shipping wars. But it was in a very shipping-oriented forum, was definitely not representative of the fandom at large, and would be a ShipToShipCombat example at best, and not BrokenBase.
to:
I\'ve never seen this subject break the fandom base. I have - only once - seen an insane blow-up over this subject, a while back, and it was driven by shipping wars. But it was in a very shipping-oriented forum, was definitely not representative of the fandom at large, and would be a ShipToShipCombat example at best, and not BrokenBase.
Changed line(s) 6 from:
n
Has anyone else seen enough evidence of this for the example to stay under BrokenBase? Most of the time I see this subject again it either gets a 'oh, this old chestnut' response, a half-hearted or calm discussion on the pros and cons... and that's about it.
to:
Has anyone else seen enough evidence of this for the example to stay under BrokenBase? Most of the time I see this subject again it either gets an \'oh, this old chestnut\' response, a half-hearted or calm discussion on the pros and cons... and that\'s about it.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
** The fan theory about Qrow being Ruby's real father has sparked controversy to a near FandomBerserkButton level. Those who support it think that it would be an amazing plot twist, add depth to the relationship between them and point out the many reasons why that would be likely (from Qrow taking Ruby under his wing to their various similarities). Fans against it however, are much more outspoken, pointing out that it would be traumatizing for Ruby to have her family lying to her about her father, that it would nullify the FamilyOfChoice point made by their sweet uncle-niece relationship that has no blood relation and that those in favor are favoring the fact that it would make Qrow/Summer canon over how this would affect their family. There's also an undertones of a ShipToShipCombat between those who ship Qrow/Summer and those who ship Qrow and Summer with other characters.
to:
** The fan theory about Qrow being Ruby\'s real father has sparked controversy to a near FandomBerserkButton level. Those who support it think that it would be an amazing plot twist, add depth to the relationship between them and point out the many reasons why that would be likely (from Qrow taking Ruby under his wing to their various similarities). Fans against it however, are much more outspoken, pointing out that it would be traumatizing for Ruby to have her family lying to her about her father, that it would nullify the FamilyOfChoice point made by their sweet uncle-niece relationship that has no blood relation and that those in favor are favoring the fact that it would make Qrow/Summer canon over how this would affect their family. There\'s also an undertones of a ShipToShipCombat between those who ship Qrow/Summer and those who ship Qrow and Summer with other characters.
Changed line(s) 4 from:
n
I've never seen this subject break the fandom base. I have - only once - seen an insane blow-up over this subject, a while back, and it was driven by shipping wars. But it was in a very shipping-oriented forum, was definitely not representative of the fandom at large, and would be a ShipToShipCombat example at best, and not BrokenBase.
to:
I\'ve never seen this subject break the fandom base. I have - only once - seen an insane blow-up over this subject, a while back, and it was driven by shipping wars. But it was in a very shipping-oriented forum, was definitely not representative of the fandom at large, and would be a ShipToShipCombat example at best, and not BrokenBase.
Changed line(s) 6 from:
n
Has anyone else seen enough evidence of this for the example to stay under BrokenBase?
to:
Has anyone else seen enough evidence of this for the example to stay under BrokenBase? Most of the time I see this subject again it either gets a \'oh, this old chestnut\' response, a half-hearted or calm discussion on the pros and cons... and that\'s about it.
Top