Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / BeautyEqualsGoodness

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I see someone's interested in adding the Steering Committee as an example of Complete Monster...
to:
I see someone\'s interested in adding the Steering Committee as an example of Complete Monster...
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Honestly, I've thought about it before, and I don't think they qualify for a few reasons:
to:
Honestly, I\'ve thought about it before, and I don\'t think they qualify for a few reasons:
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
* Firstly, it's an organization. The CM trope is usually reserved for individuals due to the issue of collectives not having moral autonomy--it's why The Party from ''1984'' aren't examples of CMs.
* Secondly, there's an argument to be made for them genuinely believing that their versions of Hope and views on talent are what's best for the world. Self-interested as they are, I don't think they went this far with protecting Hope's Peak Academy's shady history just for a power-grab.
* Thirdly, I don't quite think they meet the heinousness standard. Certainly, erasing Hajime's personality after misleading him, whitewashing various crimes occurring in the school, and treating the students more like experiments than people is bad, but they haven't gone to Junko's (and even Monaca's) levels of depravity. The latter two aren't CMs because of their Freudian Excuses and sympathetic qualities (Junko does genuinely love her sister and Matsuda, Monaca has a horrific past and seems to have some affection for Nagito and Junko), so if they don't cut it, I have a hard time seeing the Committee cutting it.
to:
* Firstly, it\'s an organization. The CM trope is usually reserved for individuals due to the issue of collectives not having moral autonomy--it\'s why The Party from \'\'1984\'\' aren\'t examples of CMs.
* Secondly, there\'s an argument to be made for them genuinely believing that their versions of Hope and views on talent are what\'s best for the world. Self-interested as they are, I don\'t think they went this far with protecting Hope\'s Peak Academy\'s shady history just for a power-grab.
* Thirdly, I don\'t quite think they meet the heinousness standard. Certainly, erasing Hajime\'s personality after misleading him, whitewashing various crimes occurring in the school, and treating the students more like experiments than people are bad, but they haven\'t gone to Junko\'s (and even Monaca\'s) levels of depravity. The latter two aren\'t CMs because of their Freudian Excuses and sympathetic qualities (Junko does genuinely love her sister and Matsuda, Monaca has a horrific past and seems to have some affection for Nagito and Junko), so if they don\'t cut it, I have a hard time seeing the Committee cutting it.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
That should elaborate my position on this topic. Feel free to disagree, as I'd like to see some conversation about this.
to:
That should elaborate my position on this topic. Feel free to disagree, as I\'d like to see some conversation about this.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I see someone's interested in adding the Steering Committee as an example of Complete Monster...
to:
I see someone\'s interested in adding the Steering Committee as an example of Complete Monster...
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Honestly, I've thought about it before, and I don't think they qualify for a few reasons:
to:
Honestly, I\'ve thought about it before, and I don\'t think they qualify for a few reasons:
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
* Firstly, it's an organization. The CM trope is usually reserved for individuals due to the issue of collectives not having moral autonomy--it's why The Party from ''1984'' aren't examples of CMs.
* Secondly, there can be an argument made for them genuinely believing that their versions of Hope and views on talent are what's best for the world. Self-interested as they are, I don't think they went this far with protecting Hope's Peak Academy's shady history just for a power-grab.
* Thirdly, I don't quite think they meet the heinousness standard. Certainly, erasing Hajime's personality after misleading him, whitewashing various crimes occurring in the school, and treating the students more like experiments than people is bad, but they haven't gone to Junko's (and even Monaca's) levels of depravity. The latter two aren't CMs because of their Freudian Excuses and sympathetic qualities (Junko does genuinely love her sister and Matsuda, Monaca has a horrific past and seems to have some affection for Nagito and Junko), so if they don't cut it, I have a hard time seeing the Committee cutting it.
to:
* Firstly, it\'s an organization. The CM trope is usually reserved for individuals due to the issue of collectives not having moral autonomy--it\'s why The Party from \'\'1984\'\' aren\'t examples of CMs.
* Secondly, there\'s an argument to be made for them genuinely believing that their versions of Hope and views on talent are what\'s best for the world. Self-interested as they are, I don\'t think they went this far with protecting Hope\'s Peak Academy\'s shady history just for a power-grab.
* Thirdly, I don\'t quite think they meet the heinousness standard. Certainly, erasing Hajime\'s personality after misleading him, whitewashing various crimes occurring in the school, and treating the students more like experiments than people is bad, but they haven\'t gone to Junko\'s (and even Monaca\'s) levels of depravity. The latter two aren\'t CMs because of their Freudian Excuses and sympathetic qualities (Junko does genuinely love her sister and Matsuda, Monaca has a horrific past and seems to have some affection for Nagito and Junko), so if they don\'t cut it, I have a hard time seeing the Committee cutting it.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
That should elaborate my position on this topic. Feel free to disagree, as I'd like to see some conversation about this.
to:
That should elaborate my position on this topic. Feel free to disagree, as I\'d like to see some conversation about this.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I see someone's interested in adding the Steering Committee as an example of Complete Monster...
to:
I see someone\'s interested in adding the Steering Committee as an example of Complete Monster...
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Honestly, I've thought about it before, and I don't think they qualify for a few reasons:
to:
Honestly, I\'ve thought about it before, and I don\'t think they qualify for a few reasons:
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
* Firstly, it's an organization. The CM trope is usually reserved for individuals due to the issue of collectives not having moral autonomy--it's why The Party from ''1984'' aren't examples of CM.
* Secondly, there can be an argument made for them genuinely believing that their versions of Hope and views on talent are what's best for the world. Self-interested as they are, I don't think they went this far with protecting Hope's Peak Academy's shady history just for a power-grab.
* Thirdly, I don't quite think they meet the heinousness standard. Certainly, erasing Hajime's personality after misleading him, whitewashing various crimes occurring in the school, and treating the students more like experiments than people is bad, but they haven't gone to Junko's (and even Monaca's) levels of depravity. The latter two aren't CMs because of their Freudian Excuses and sympathetic qualities (Junko does genuinely love her sister and Matsuda, Monaca has a horrific past and seems to have some affection for Nagito and Junko), so if they don't cut it, I have a hard time seeing the Committee cutting it.
to:
* Firstly, it\'s an organization. The CM trope is usually reserved for individuals due to the issue of collectives not having moral autonomy--it\'s why The Party from \'\'1984\'\' aren\'t examples of CMs.
* Secondly, there can be an argument made for them genuinely believing that their versions of Hope and views on talent are what\'s best for the world. Self-interested as they are, I don\'t think they went this far with protecting Hope\'s Peak Academy\'s shady history just for a power-grab.
* Thirdly, I don\'t quite think they meet the heinousness standard. Certainly, erasing Hajime\'s personality after misleading him, whitewashing various crimes occurring in the school, and treating the students more like experiments than people is bad, but they haven\'t gone to Junko\'s (and even Monaca\'s) levels of depravity. The latter two aren\'t CMs because of their Freudian Excuses and sympathetic qualities (Junko does genuinely love her sister and Matsuda, Monaca has a horrific past and seems to have some affection for Nagito and Junko), so if they don\'t cut it, I have a hard time seeing the Committee cutting it.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
That should elaborate my position on this topic. Feel free to disagree, as I'd like to see some conversation about this.
to:
That should elaborate my position on this topic. Feel free to disagree, as I\'d like to see some conversation about this.
Top