[002]
Wyldchyld
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Initially removed because they were ZeroContextExamples and overtroping (relevant tropes related to the subject were already on the page). They've been readded without an edit reason and are still ZeroContextExamples, so I've brought them to the discussion page.
to:
Initially removed because they were ZeroContextExamples and overtroping (relevant tropes related to the subject were already on the page). They\'ve been readded without an edit reason and are still ZeroContextExamples, so I\'ve brought them to the discussion page.
Changed line(s) 4 from:
n
* Tomboy: Kubo considers her to be one due to her brash
to:
* Tomboy: Kubo considers her to be one due to her brash \"one-of-the-guys\" personality
* TomboyWithAGirlyStreak: She always wears dresses and acts girly around her schoolmates in the human world.
Orihime:
* GirlyGirl: Her bubbly, sweet, cheerful personality
Issue:
Rukia and Orihime already have the TomboyAndGirlyGirl entry under both their sections. It\'s a subversion because Rukia initially seems to be a tomboy but is a girly girl and Orihime looks like a girl girl but has some very tomboy interests. I can see how TomboyWithAGirlyStreak can be added to help clarify the subversion in the other trope, and Orihime already has the GirlyGirlWithATomboyStreak in her entry, but it needs context.
These three tropes cover everything. There\'s no need for separate {{Tomboy}} or GirlyGirl tropes. That\'s just overtroping. I\'m suggesting the following rewrite of the three relevant tropes:
Rukia:
* TomboyWithAGirlyStreak: Rukia was raised in one of the most violent regions of Soul Society. She is quick-tempered, physically violent and shouts a lot. However, she\'s into cartoon artwork and cute and fluffy animals (especially bunnies), favours wearing dresses when given the choice, and loves romance stories. Renji states on one occasion that she has an inner grace that shines through even her roughest behaviour.
* TomboyAndGirlyGirl: Rukia and Orihime have had a close friendship ever since Rukia first empowered Ichigo. The tomboy appears to be Rukia, with her rough-tempered, physically violent personality and soldier lifestyle. The girly girl appears to be Orihime, with her gentle, protective and peaceful personality and aversion to violence. However, when given the choice, Rukia favours loose dresses, reading romance novels and adores cartoon artwork and bunnies while Orihime is quietly a black-belt martial artist who is into sci-fi and robots, and shares her boys\' comics with her male friends.
Orihime:
* GirlyGirlWithATomboyStreak: Orihime is a well-mannered girl who usually wears flowing skirts and wears her hair long in memory of her brother. She nearly always retains her friendly, bubbly spirit and weird sense of humour, and prefers people to get along. Her abilities are personality based, focussed on protecting and healing rather than physical violence. However, she\'s interested in sci-fi and robots, she reads boys\' comics (and lends them out to boys\'), and she is a black-belt martial artist (the anime changes this to yellow-belt).
* TomboyAndGirlyGirl: Rukia and Orihime have had a close friendship ever since Rukia first empowered Ichigo. The tomboy appears to be Rukia, with her rough-tempered, physically violent personality and soldier lifestyle. The girly girl appears to be Orihime, with her gentle, protective and peaceful personality and aversion to violence. However, when given the choice, Rukia favours loose dresses, reading romance novels and adores cartoon artwork and bunnies while Orihime is quietly a black-belt martial artist who is into sci-fi and robots, and shares her boys\' comics with her male friends.
* TomboyWithAGirlyStreak: She always wears dresses and acts girly around her schoolmates in the human world.
Orihime:
* GirlyGirl: Her bubbly, sweet, cheerful personality
Issue:
Rukia and Orihime already have the TomboyAndGirlyGirl entry under both their sections. It\'s a subversion because Rukia initially seems to be a tomboy but is a girly girl and Orihime looks like a girl girl but has some very tomboy interests. I can see how TomboyWithAGirlyStreak can be added to help clarify the subversion in the other trope, and Orihime already has the GirlyGirlWithATomboyStreak in her entry, but it needs context.
These three tropes cover everything. There\'s no need for separate {{Tomboy}} or GirlyGirl tropes. That\'s just overtroping. I\'m suggesting the following rewrite of the three relevant tropes:
Rukia:
* TomboyWithAGirlyStreak: Rukia was raised in one of the most violent regions of Soul Society. She is quick-tempered, physically violent and shouts a lot. However, she\'s into cartoon artwork and cute and fluffy animals (especially bunnies), favours wearing dresses when given the choice, and loves romance stories. Renji states on one occasion that she has an inner grace that shines through even her roughest behaviour.
* TomboyAndGirlyGirl: Rukia and Orihime have had a close friendship ever since Rukia first empowered Ichigo. The tomboy appears to be Rukia, with her rough-tempered, physically violent personality and soldier lifestyle. The girly girl appears to be Orihime, with her gentle, protective and peaceful personality and aversion to violence. However, when given the choice, Rukia favours loose dresses, reading romance novels and adores cartoon artwork and bunnies while Orihime is quietly a black-belt martial artist who is into sci-fi and robots, and shares her boys\' comics with her male friends.
Orihime:
* GirlyGirlWithATomboyStreak: Orihime is a well-mannered girl who usually wears flowing skirts and wears her hair long in memory of her brother. She nearly always retains her friendly, bubbly spirit and weird sense of humour, and prefers people to get along. Her abilities are personality based, focussed on protecting and healing rather than physical violence. However, she\'s interested in sci-fi and robots, she reads boys\' comics (and lends them out to boys\'), and she is a black-belt martial artist (the anime changes this to yellow-belt).
* TomboyAndGirlyGirl: Rukia and Orihime have had a close friendship ever since Rukia first empowered Ichigo. The tomboy appears to be Rukia, with her rough-tempered, physically violent personality and soldier lifestyle. The girly girl appears to be Orihime, with her gentle, protective and peaceful personality and aversion to violence. However, when given the choice, Rukia favours loose dresses, reading romance novels and adores cartoon artwork and bunnies while Orihime is quietly a black-belt martial artist who is into sci-fi and robots, and shares her boys\' comics with her male friends.
