Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs Opinionated Guide to Avatar: The Last Airbender
Korval2011-06-17 20:09:14

Go To


Avatar: The Last Airbender. What is there to say, really?

A lot, apparently, since I'm going to walk through each episode of the entire 61 episode run. But first, some background.

Avatar: The Last Airbender was a cartoon show that ran for 3 years, from 2005 to 2007. It has become quite popular, particularly among its periphery demographic. It is often praised for having well-written characters, a story arc, good episode-to-episode continuity, and a well-developed world. It's also one of those shows you see on just about every TV Tropes page; it has a large fandom on this site.

It also had a recent film adaptation that was... universally reviled. But we're not talking about that horseshit now.

Each liveblog page will, in general, discuss a particular episode. Two parters will be handled depending on what kind of two-parter it is. If the two parter is really two episodes that chronologically flow from one to the next (ie: one starts immediately after the other, with a Sequel Hook), then I will review them as two episodes. However, if it's really just a single story told in multiple parts, then I will review it as one.

I also intend for this blog to be more analytical than humorous. I'll throw jokes in where I can, but mostly I'm here to point out what works and what doesn't. Because of that, there will be times when talking about something that happened in an episode at length would bog the actual liveblog down too much. In these cases, I will generally extract that section out of the flow of the text and put it in its own section after the episode synopsis. If you're not interested in such analysis, feel free to skip it whenever you see these sections.

Also, I will occasionally have an entire post devoted to some particular aspect of the series up to that point. These are for things that deserve a detailed calling out on, but don't fit into the season introductions. Usually, this is something that covers events from multiple previous episodes. These too are skippable, though you may be missing some interesting analysis.

For those who have not seen this series, there will be some light spoilers for later episodes. I'll minimize them somewhat, in case you're following along for the first time at home. And I won't reveal the most important ones, unless they have been heavily foreshadowed or are otherwise obvious. If I need to analyze a scene in context of something later, I'll generally only present as much as you need to know at that time to understand what I'm saying.

Also, please read the title. This is the opinionated guide to Avatar. You don't have to agree with anything I say here. You should find that most of these opinions do at least have some evidential support, even if you disagree with the conclusion. I welcome discussion where it happens, so if you agree or disagree, feel free to point it out in the comments section.

Lastly, particularly in the early episodes, you may get the impression that I hate this show. I don't. It's a good show, with quality writing and production values. It's well worth your time, and I even own the last two seasons on DVD (NetFlix lets me watch season 1 whenever I want). But that doesn't mean that I will let crap past, and it's hard to argue that the show started on its best foot. If the show does something wrong, I'm going to call it out.

Book 1: Water

It begins...

The show's seasons are called "books." For some reason. I don't get it either; books do not prominently figure prominently within the show's overall theme or general milieu. Indeed, one main character is completely illiterate. In any case, season one is called Book 1: Water.

Normally, for the introduction to a season, I will do a look back at what transpired and a look forward, with some detailed analysis. My goal in such sections is to make some particular point about the show that you may not have thought about.

But, since there is no prior season as of yet, instead, I will go over the general concepts behind this world. That way, I don't have to clog up the episodes themselves with such minutiae.

The world of Avatar: The Last Airbender consists of several cultures, most of them drawn from Asian influences. In this world, there are elemental manipulators known as "benders:" Airbenders, Firebenders, Waterbenders, and Earthbenders. Bending, to varying degrees, relies on movements based on real-world martial arts. So when a firebender throws a karate-like punch, a fireball emerges from his fist.

There are a number of large nations that have arisen around bending forms. The Earth Kingdom occupies the largest landmass in the world. There are two Water Tribes, one in the North Pole and one in the South Pole. The Air Nomads occupied 4 hidden air temples in the north, south, east, and west (four winds. Get it?) of the Earth Kingdom's landmass. And the Fire Nation is on a large island to the west of the Earth Kingdom.

Each nation has a loose basis in some real-world culture. The Earth Kingdom bears a striking resemblance to Imperial China. The Water Tribes are Inuits as they live on the ice. The Air Nomads seem very typically Buddhist monk-ish. And the Fire Nation is some kind of hybrid between Imperial Japan and China with some Indian (India-Indian) influences thrown in.

The nations are also color coded. The Water Tribes wear blue, the Earth Kingdom wears greens, the Fire Nation wears reds, and the Air Nomads wear tans and browns. This extends to just about everyone's dress in these nations; rare is the person who dresses out of color for their nation.

The titular Avatar is a perpetually reincarnated being. He/She is the only individual capable of bending all four elements (or even just more than one), and he/she is charged with defending the world and maintaining the "balance". Exactly what that means is never really explained, but it generally means that each nation stays where it is and doesn't invade another. Or something.

Comments

Korval Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 7th 2011 at 10:19:35 PM
I'll be back on Friday with the Season 3 intro.
Emperordaein Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 7th 2011 at 10:58:57 PM
''—> A soldier on my own, I don't know the way
I'm riding up the heights of shame
I'm waiting for the call, the hand on the chest
I'm ready for the fight, and fate''

Woodkid: Iron *

I have to say, this was an amazing season finale. The action, plot, themes and overall impact on the story are some of the best in any piece of Western Animation.

And I have never watched it again after the first time.

Why? It's.....It's a quirk I have. There are things I admit are very, VERY good, but I don't like watching them. I don't like watching this because it is soul crushingly depressing. Actually, from those emotions I realised that this finale is basically the end of Empire Strikes Back. Hell, the Book 1 finale was A New Hope.

Cut to the rest of the Gaang back at their house. Toph uses her Toph-Vision to see that nobody's home. Then she says someone's at the door; an old friend. When the Gaang opens it, they see... Iroh! Wait; how did he know where they were? I know how he knew they were in Ba Sing Se, but how did he know how to find the Gaang's house?

"Oh thank god it's you! I busted into five houses before this one!"

Seriously, why did they surrender just to keep this fop alive? Let Azula roast his ass; serves him right for being an idiot, and maybe someone not made of fail can run the Earth Kingdom afterwards.

Hey, they aren't going to let someone be killed due to apathy. A life is a life. And if I can (Barely) endure half an Act of trying to put a useless doormat on a throne, only for him to fuck everything up, I can endure them trying to save the Earth King.

But the writers didn't do that. Why? Because there wasn't time. This episode is so full of stuff that there simply wasn't any time to write it that way. Maybe if they hadn't screwed around with those time-wasting episodes earlier in the season, they could have done the finale as a proper two-parter rather than a 1.5-parter.

Since Legend Of Korra is having a tighter episode count, I bet they will be much more inclined to not fall into that trap.

JusticeMan Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 8th 2011 at 11:42:33 AM
1. Why do you keep using (improperly I might add) Diablos Ex machina. All the things that happen are direct outputs of character actions, its can only be an Ex Machina if it just came out of nowhere.

2.It was a very personal moment. Imagine a jew being trapped with a Nazi. Would you expect, calm, cool statement of the facts, or a full freak attack, which is more realistic?

3. And letting him die would be immensely out of character. ._.

4.The point of the speech was that the Dai-Li as secret police only respected Power. Azula, as the. Most powerful one, was who they listened to. They really don't give a shit, they run the city any way.

5.I liked the reference to the season 2 Octopus technique a good instance of a power upgrade, I'd also like to note that if she's immobilized she can't bend

6. Okay, HOW can you go on a long praise stating that Azula's defeat of the Avatar was anything but a Diablos Ex Machina and, the, one paragraph later say the exact opposite! What the hell!

All in all, awesome review, very Linkaresque. I'll be seeing you. ;)
ManwiththePlan Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 8th 2011 at 11:33:06 AM
Wow, you actually praised the writing of Avatar?

In all seriousness, I agreed with alot of the positive AND negative criticisms you gave for this finale. This is how the liveblog should be done more often: less nitpicking over the unrealistic story, all the character's behaviour or Komedy! and more REALLY looking at things for what you percieve them as.
98.213.219.116 Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 8th 2011 at 6:10:19 PM
It was a pretty good finale, but there's no excuse for the Dai Li to still be in power, and Long Feng's lobotomy was unbearable. Why is he giving Azula control of the Dai Li again? Oh, right. To facillitate the plot. Of course, that man has spent the entire Ba Sing Se Arc doing whatever is needed to move the story along, regardless of what he logically stands to lose or gain. I might not have had as big a problem with Feng being out-manuevered if he hadn't had the ambiance of someone crafty and intelligent. The way his voice-actor spoke, I got the impression that he was a veteran schemer. If a fantasy-loving college kid can spot the risks in giving an enemy authority over the Dai Li, then Long Feng should have been able to do the same. Given how crucial the Dai Li were to Azula's plan, Long Feng's idiot balling really marred the finale for me.

On a sidenote, a poster named The Narrator over at Television Without Pity had this to ask about the Gaang after they escaped from the conquered Ba Sing Se. Why didn't they get in contact with the millitary forces guarding the wall and tell them that the city has been taken over by Fire Nation agents?
PataHikari Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 9th 2011 at 1:48:56 AM
Cutting out some of the filler episodes from earlier could have allowed them to improve the final arc of this season.

I R KORVAL!! CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT? WORLDBUILDING! MAKE KORVAL ANGRY! KORVAL SMASH!!!!
ManwiththePlan Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 9th 2011 at 8:36:37 AM
Long Feng's problem was that he got focused on doublecrossing Azula when the time came to it rather than focusing on the Dai Li possibly doublecrossing him. He was overconfident in their loyalty to him but when they turned on him, he saw that he had no real power anymore. Azula told it to him straight and he surrendered. Personally, I thought it was well handled. Yeah, Long Feng could've showed a bit more resistance in the end but he's been scheming, manipulating, wielding power, and fighting people with words his whole life. When confronted with Azula, she, as he put it, "beat him at his own game."
98.213.219.116 Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 9th 2011 at 9:34:29 AM
But why would Long Feng give Azula the opportunity to take control of the Dai Li? His need for Azula and her companions is simple and limited. They are to stalemate or capture the Avatar and his friends. Long Feng himself can take care of coordinating the Dai Li's movements. And though it might be reasonable to suggest that Long Feng underestimated Azula, Long Feng 1)knows that Azula had the intelligence and boldness to plot a takeover of Ba Sing Se and should thus be considered just as dangerous as any adult and 2)Long Feng has undoubtably had previous experience fighting political battles, both before and during his rise to power. He's obtained, and kept, the position of head of the Dai Li despite the attempts other power-hungry individuals would have wanted to replace him. He should be too smart to jeopardize his hold over the Dai Li by handing authority over them to anyone. Even if Azula's authority was only intended to be temporary, she doesn't do anything with the Dai Li that Long Feng can't do himself. It's not like the man hasn't fought directly before. Truthfully, Azula should have simply tried to kill Long Feng and anyone else who challenged her for command, and even then Azula would be taking the risk that someone ambitious enough and smart enough among the Dai Li would instigate a coup against her.
ManwiththePlan Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 10th 2011 at 8:57:39 AM
1) No, he did NOT know that Azula had the intelligence and boldness to plot a takeover; she was acting when she was first brought in front of him and probably led him to believe that the whole thing would be his plan. He gave her temporary control of the Dai Li BEFORE knowing how "terrifying and inspirational" she was. He never knew Azula personally until now, she was just the Fire Nation princess to him. 2) Long Feng doing it all himself would mean attempting a prison break, which would cause a commotion and put him in a more suspicious position when the coup was attempted. Long Feng's all about handling things quietly. He wanted to stay in prison while Azula and her friends directed the Dai Li in overthrowing the Earth Kingdom.

Oh and Azula killing Long Feng wouldn't have the same effect as her Hannibal Lecture, and why would she attempt to take out anyone who challenged her. She's way to sure of her ability to control people to do that: she never had that sort of paranoia until after Mai and Ty Lee betrayed her.
98.213.219.116 Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 10th 2011 at 2:37:53 PM
  • Yes, Long Feng knew she could plot a takeover of Ba Sing Se, since that was why Azula was in the city to begin with.
  • There's no reason for Azula to be giving orders to the Dai Li, period. It doesn't matter if Long Feng thinks of Azula as brainless thug; if the Dai Li's loyalty is based on greed, power-lust or fear then they can be corrupted. Long Feng has every reason not to give Azula a chance to win the Dai Li over.
  • Long Feng is being guarded by Dai Li. They can easily slip him out of his cell. Besides, by the time Dai Li agents are arresting generals and the Earth King and taking down our heroes, there's no more reason for Long Feng to worry about being suspicious. He doesn't have any more reason to be docile.
  • I suggested that Azula kill Long Feng since taking control of the Dai Li by force is the only realistic way to have them on her side. Long Feng isn't going to hand them over; the Dai Li are a powerful weapon and are also the most important part of the coup since they are the only ones with the power to run the city.
ManwiththePlan Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 13th 2011 at 7:39:25 PM
  • Did he know how capable she was of actually pulling it off, though?
  • Long Feng was not told that "the Dai Li's loyalty was based on greed, power-lust, or fear", he was told by the Dai Li that they were "loyal to HIM." He didn't consider Azula moving in on his territory until it started happening.
  • It would depend on if Long Feng would want that.
  • Unfortunately (for you at least), the writers weren't going for "realistic". Azula won the Dai Li over by being Azula. Call her a Villain Sue for it if you must, but that's how it is.
98.213.219.116 Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 13th 2011 at 8:16:37 PM
  • Long Feng didn't know if Azula was truly as competent as she thought she was, but he certainly wasn't going to act on the assumption that Azula was in over her head. That would be taking a needless chance.
  • Long Feng should have some idea of why the people in his employ work for him without needing to be spoon-fed the answers. He's no mind-reader, obviously, but he ought to at least know if there was the possibility that someone could give the Dai Li a more attractive alternative to working for him.
  • If Long Feng is does not want to get involved personally, why doesn't he delegate control of the coup to some trusted subordinates? He certainly doesn't need to put Azula in charge.
ManwiththePlan Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 16th 2011 at 7:10:00 PM
But the fact is, Long Feng did not do any of the things you think he should have done. He just wasn't as good at what he was doing as you thought he was or wanted him to be. You don't have to like or understand this part of the episode but Azula beating Long Feng at his own game is what happened and what needed to happen. End of story.
JtheDrafter Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 26th 2011 at 8:13:10 AM
And the only reason that Long Feng behaved like this was so that Azula could succeed. Even though Long Feng has no reason to act the way he does.
ManwiththePlan Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 30th 2011 at 3:12:38 PM
Maybe being arrested the first time threw him off his game and he got hold of the Idiot Ball?
ideae Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 18th 2013 at 8:36:39 PM
Azula was just being a luckier Zhao when she shot lightning at Aang. Zhao knew no restraint, and didn't seem like the guy who would stand around and wait to get his ass kicked. Azula was just better at it because the writers had to show her as being powerful enough to be a viable threat. That's why Long Feng gave up instantly.
HyperAlbion Since: Dec, 1969
Jul 18th 2013 at 1:07:02 PM
>She doesn't ask that he form a new kind of government

Kyoshi didn't believe there was anything wrong with this kind of government. Her job as the Avatar was generally to keep things the same as they've always been.

Aang was a progressive avatar, but generally all the Avatars before him did the job of ensuring that the borders between the nations stayed the same for the most part and that their governments also remained the same traditional forms of government that they'd always been. That's the Avatar's job.

The Dai Li were not created to be the king's private army or police force. They were meant to be an independent organization that ensured that the traditional form of government and social structure always stayed intact, because Earth Kingdom people don't like change very much and the Avatar's job was never really to create new forms of government as much as it was to make sure the traditional forms stayed in place. The Dai Li were for all intents and purposes an independent organization that served as advisers to the King. They stopped any rebellion that might change the government or social structure of Ba Sing Se, but were also there to make sure that Earth King ran the government correctly according to how Earth Kingdom culture and tradition said an Earth King should behave.
OnoreBakaSama Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 18th 2013 at 2:40:59 PM
Wait; how did [Iroh] know where they were? I know how he knew they were in Ba Sing Se, but how did he know how to find the Gaang's house?

Remember those leaflets Aang dropped, which Zuko caught one of? You'd have to know how to read Chinese to get it, but Aang's address is written on the flier.
Bourne~Endeavor Since: Dec, 1969
Aug 8th 2015 at 12:38:11 AM
"Such a person would kneel down, earthbend her out of that seat, and then perform that kill-move he used on Jet while she's flying through the air."

And upon doing so, Azula would notice his attempted assault given he's directly in front of her, dodge it and strike him dead with lightning.

Long Feng is a schemer. He knows any opposite towards Azula means either his political or literal demise. Therefore, he chooses the more advantageous path of servitude.

Honestly, do you even pay attention to the nuisances or does that get in the way of your rants?
Top