Follow TV Tropes

Following

Context YMMV / TotalDramaCodysRedemption

Go To

1* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Gwen continued hatred to Cody despite Cody doing nothing to warrant has cause fans to theories she also got back in time, and remembers how he acted in seasons after the first. [[spoiler:This has been debunked, as its been revealed that her reason is actually very petty.]]
2* BaseBreakingCharacter: Cody is either adorable and lovable as a protagonist, or drags the story down with it by removing a majority of the canon character's biggest flaws. There's rarely a middleground.
3* BrokenBase: The story as a whole to the ''Total Drama'' community as a whole. It has an outspoken and loyal fanbase, but it should be noted that quite a large number of critics have sighted it as an example of bad storytelling.
4* DesignatedHero: Readers have cited Cody as being portrayed in this light. Cody is supposed to be the hero who's trying to improve his life. It failed as Cody unnecessarily rants about the miniscule of things, has meltdowns, and is described and whiny and self-centered by his detractors. This Reddit [[https://www.reddit.com/r/Totaldrama/comments/sr82q7/semioccasional_fanfiction_review_series_no_2/ post]] goes in full depth about his flaws.
5* TheScrappy: Gwen. She's despised by fans of the story due to her terrible treatment of Cody, while detractors often sight her as one of the biggest problems with the story due to being completely out-of-character.
6* UnintentionallySympathetic: Courtney tells Cody that they can't talk to each other during the competition after Dodgebrawl. While a sad decision, it's not unreasonable as they have to focus on the competition and Cody could be targeted as well for talking to the opposite team. And even though Courtney does act high-strung around him afterwards, Cody isn't portrayed any better. He goes off on her for her decision and even humiliates her in front of everyone at one point out of pettiness. There's also the fact that he once forced eyedrops onto her despite refusing and roared at her for it.

Top