Line #53 Main/TrainingTheGiftOfMagic


1	%%
2	%% Examples here are in ALPHABETICAL ORDER. PLEASE preserve this!
3	%%
4	%% (Please also ensure that the work you add involves both a Gift AND Training to use it
5	%% correctly. Works that require just one or the other come under different tropes.)
6	%%
7	->''"Oh, you do know something of the Art. Do you have the Sight?"''
8	-->-- '''Merlin''', ''Film/{{Excalibur}}''
9
10	In some settings with functional magic (or magic-like powers), the ability to work it properly is an innate talent that not everyone possesses -- and if you haven't got it, you'll never be a high-power spell-caster. But you ''also'' need training to use this gift to full effect.
11
12	This is not the same as magic as an innate superpower, used instinctively; magic-working still requires study, and high levels of skill give a large advantage over under-trained casters. But you still need the "gift" to start with. Where magic works and is a matter of education but this trope isn't in play, anyone with enough smarts, determination, and training can be able to use magic as well as anybody else.
13
14	This trope, then, has two assumptions:
15	# One must have an inborn gift to practice magic.
16	# One must train in order to use it effectively.
17
18	The combination has various social and narrative consequences.
19
20	In some cases, it is impossible to work magic without the gift, although it may be possible to operate some enchanted items. Perhaps more often, though, someone who lacks the gift can only work magic by the use of lengthy, complex, and unreliable {{ritual\|Magic}}s, whereas the gifted can learn to cast spells quickly and reliably, making them, for example, useful in combat.
21
22	Likewise, in some cases, even a person with the gift can only work magic after learning the requisite skill or otherwise having it "unlocked" in some way. In others, the gifted can produce magical effects, perhaps when under stress or through intense concentration, but can't ''control'' them properly. The latter situation usually makes gifted but untrained individuals [[PowerIncontinence highly dangerous to themselves and others]]; magic-workers may consider locating and training the gifted to be an important social duty. If too many untrained gifted individuals have done too much accidental damage, they--and sometimes other magic workers--may be the target for semi-justified {{Witch Hunt}}s. More trivially, the ungifted may be at once jealous of the gifted and puzzled about why they spend so much time in laboratories and classrooms, not understanding the importance of training.
23
24	The gift itself may be defined as the ability to perceive magical forces (so un-gifted spell-casters are in effect working blind), the ability to channel [[BackgroundMagicField magical energies from the environment]] into spells (so un-gifted workers probably need a different source of energy), or the personal favor of some gods or spirits whose help is needed to make magic work. Or it may just [[BecauseDestinySaysSo be left vague]].
25
26	Related to the Inherent Gift option described in FunctionalMagic, but that also encompasses magic as a "superpower" that requires no training. WizardingSchool may be one source of training, and perhaps the only one. See also OurMagesAreDifferent, which describes various ways of training or channeling magic, any of which may be required to enable someone with the gift to work effectively or safely, and MageSpecies, which covers situations where magical power (usually specifically "witchcraft") is a hereditary gift, to the point of defining a separate human species, but these "witches" may or may not need some degree of training. Compare TheSparkOfGenius, for settings in which super-advanced science and engineering are a form of ''de facto'' magic for which [[MadScientist certain individuals]] have an inherent talent.
27
28	----
29	!!Examples
30
31	[[foldercontrol]]
32
33	[[folder:Anime and Manga]]
34	* In ''Manga/TheAncientMagusBride'', Elias [[SuperHumanTrafficking buys]] Chise in the first place to teach her magic. He says it's a common last resort since magically-talented children are rare in the modern era.
35	* Magic involves both some kind of gift and training in ''Literature/TheFamiliarOfZero'', though the details are vague. The protagonist, Louise, is notoriously bad at casting magic, so much so that she's been nicknamed "Zero" by her classmates (and the fact that she is able to summon a familiar is seen as a miracle), but it's unclear if ranks on the FantasticMeasurementSystem are in-born or achieved through training.[[note]]It turns out that her problem is complex. Magic in this setting is based on elemental powers -- [[DishingOutDirt Earth]], [[BlowYouAway Air]], [[MakingASplash Water]] and [[PlayingWithFire Fire]]. Most individuals can only control one element, or at least are ''much'' better with one element than with the others. Louise is inheritor to the long-lost ElementNumberFive, [[ThePowerOfTheVoid Void]], and as a result, she can't use ''any'' other form of magic -- implying an obvious problem in acquiring the necessary training.[[/note]]
36	* In the ''Franchise/LyricalNanoha'' franchise, only those who have a Linker Core, a magic organ that not everyone is born with, can have magic, and even then, mages are born with different levels of magic potential. However, to reach the higher mage ranks, you still need to train a lot to use your magical reserves effectively and [[FormulaicMagic master the formulas needed to perform the spells at a drop of a hat]]. Nanoha, the main character and a mage so powerful that {{Artificial\|Human}} {{Super Soldier}}s question if she's actually human, reached her level because she was born with a high magic potential and [[TalentedButTrained constantly studied and trained herself every moment of her life]].
37	* "Ninjutsu" in ''Manga/{{Naruto}}'' is available only to those who have the inherent gift of manipulating [[LifeEnergy chakra]], and unavailable to those without the gift like Rock Lee. Some ninja have more chakra to manipulate than others and with intensive training, they can learn to use their chakra more efficiently. Sakura is noted to be WeakButSkilled, with a smaller chakra pool that she uses more efficiently than the UnskilledButStrong title character, at least until he trains with Jiraiya and [[TookALevelInBadass takes several levels in badass]].
38	* ''Literature/OfFireAndStars'': In order to learn [[PowerIncontinence control]] over their gift, mages need training. Dennaleia, whose control has been dangerously nonexistent, enters training in the sequel for this.
39	* ''Franchise/OnePiece'': Potentially all living beings can use ''Haki'', a supernatural power based on ambition, although training is also necessary (and many people perhaps ''think'' that Haki is a rare gift). However, very few can use a rare type of Haki called "King's Disposition", which lets you subdue weak-willed people through force of will. It is described as a gift ("no amount of training will give you that Haki if you just don't happen to have it"), and only a handful of people ([[OddlyCommonRarity at least,]] [[HadToBeSharp overall]]) have it. And like the other Haki types, it has to be trained.
40	[[/folder]]
41
42	[[folder:Comic Books]]
43	* Creator/DCComics
44	** While the metaphysics of the Creator/DCComics universe is often confused, it seems that some characters (such as ComicBook/{{Zatanna}}) are "Homo Magi", members of a subspecies of humanity with the ability to work magic quickly and easily, while others (such as [[ComicBook/{{Hellblazer}} John Constantine]]) have to work through rituals and hard study.
45	** Many members of the ''ComicBook/LegionOfSuperHeroes'' come from worlds whose denizens have the same powers they do. Chameleon Boy, for example, is a Durlan with the natural ability to shapeshift. However, because of the intense training and breadth of experiences they undergo as Legionnaires (combat, rescue, exploration of strange phenomena, helping with scientific experiments, investigation and more), members tend to become far more adept at the application of their abilities than other examples of their species, growing stronger by constantly working to overcome their limits. To use Chameleon Boy again, the average Durlan is a recluse who never leaves their home planet, while he's personally gone out into the galaxy and learned about all kinds of different creatures with amazing abilities he can utilize in their forms. Some like Saturn Girl or Cosmic Boy also start out as above-average examples of their kind and only get better with experience.
46	* [[Characters/XMenMutants Mutants]] in the Franchise/MarvelUniverse are sometimes described in similar terms, although their powers are explicitly ''not'' magical; these powers usually kick in at adolescence, and it's sometimes said that mutants need training to prevent them harming themselves and others. However, in practice, many mutants seem to get their powers to work pretty well without much or any training, with at worst twinges of megalomania or outbursts of PowerIncontinence.
47	[[/folder]]
48
49	[[folder:Fan Works]]
50	* ''Fanfic/ChildOfTheStorm'':
51	** The ability to sense and wield magic is an inborn gift, though it's implied that with the right {{Magitek}}, you ''can'' manipulate it, as it's also the fifth fundamental force of the universe. In fact, that's how a lot of Asgardian technology works (and, for that matter, the Ring of the Green Lantern and [[spoiler: Pandora's Box]]) - in essence, they function as a much more sophisticated form of ritual.
52	*** Aside from that, it takes training for a magical gift to go anywhere beyond PowerIncontinence: in the case of Wandless Magic in particular, even a naturally strong gift can fade away into nothing if it is resolutely ignored. On the other hand, the genetic potential remains, it can be inherited, and it can wake up again if given a suitable outside stimulus. Likewise, while raw power is dictated partly by birth, it's also dependant on training.
53	** X-Gene mutations in general are inborn, and so are power levels, though it's implied that Harry would have been blissfully unaware of his own vast psionic powers if they hadn't been forced out of dormancy. Some need more training than others, particularly PsychicPowers - which, not coincidentally, are repeatedly noted to partially overlap with magic.
54	** Chaos Magic also seems to run in families (or at least, it does once it's ''in'' a family), as Hermione demonstrates. Wanda hints that it's not impossible to use otherwise, implying that a lot of more ordinary magic is much closer to chaos than its practitioners would like to admit. However, it's a pretty rare and unique form of magic that needs special education because it's dangerous, and because MagicAIsMagicA absolutely does not apply.
55	* ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12672455/1/Dedicated-Hearts-made-Fullmetal Dedicated Hearts made Fullmetal]]'' has this slowly happen as [[Franchise/FullmetalAlchemist the Elric Brothers]] help teach [[Anime/AttackOnTitan the Humans of The Walls]] about the art of [[AlchemyIsMagic Alchemy]] as a means to help better their society [[GivingRadioToTheRomans along with updating their scientific capabilities and technological understanding]], with Hange Zoe and Armin Artlet becoming the first two Alchemists of the Scouts. [[VillainTakesAnInterest After realizing the danger that this development poses]], Reiner convinces Bertholdt that they need to capture at least one of the Elrics and take them back to their homeland in order to extract the knowledge of Alchemy for the sake of [[spoiler:Marley]].
56	-->'''Reiner''': Unlike [[OneWingedAngel our Titan powers]] their abilities can be taught and spread.
57	[[/folder]]
58
59	[[folder:Films -- Animation]]
60	* In ''WesternAnimation/{{Onward}}'', Ian discovers he has magical ability [[Dangerous16thBirthday on his 16th birthday]], but he has no clue how to use it. Fortunately, his brother Barley is an avid fan of a D&D-like game that's based on a time when magic was more common, giving him the knowledge he needs to train Ian into a proper mage.
61	[[/folder]]
62
63	[[folder:Films -- Live-Action]]
64	* In ''Film/{{Excalibur}}'', when Merlin assesses Morgana as a possible magic-worker, he tests her knowledge of "the Art" -- training in magic-related lore -- and then attempts to determine if she has "the Sight" -- innate magical sensitivity.
65	* In the ''Franchise/StarWars'' franchise, not everyone is "strong in the Force"; a BadassNormal like Han Solo could meditate on hokey ancient religions all he liked, but it would be no match for a good blaster at his side. Without training, most Force-sensitives can use their powers only unconsciously, rendering them lucky in ways subtle enough to only be identified through statistical analysis of gambling patterns, or enhancing their reflexes in ways that render them not much different from a BadassNormal. ''With'' training, they can do all the flashy quasi-magical Jedi tricks we see in the films, novels, video games, etc.
66	* ''{{Film/Mythica}}'': The highly experienced Wizard Gojun Pye wants to train Marek, and she wants his help, but events keep on getting in the way.
67	[[/folder]]
68
69	[[folder:Literature]]
70	* Magic in ''Literature/AnOutcastInAnotherWorld'' requires not only an innate spark of potential to utilize, but takes years of rigorous study to use effectively. [[spoiler:Unless you’re an Archmage.]]
71	* ''Literature/TheBlackMagicianTrilogy'': Magical power is an innate gift, but mages need to be taught how to use it for anything more sophisticated than [[KamehameHadoken brute-force strikes]], like telepathy or HealingHands. Sonea becomes the first non-aristocrat in Imardin's WizardingSchool because her magical gift is great enough to threaten a SuperpowerMeltdown if left untrained.
72	* ''Literature/TheBrokenEarthTrilogy'': Orogeny is a trait that one must be born with, and is usually but not always genetic. The Fulcrum believes orogeny is inherently dangerous and [[MutantDraftBoard actively conscripts orogenes]] in order to control their powers, in all senses of the word. In an inversion of how it's usually portrayed, orogenes are naturally capable of massive, dramatic displays of power -- what the Fulcrum teaches is ''subtlety''.
73	* ''Literature/CircleOfMagic'': Mages have a law whereby, if a mage discovers anybody with untrained magic (usually children, but the occasional adult does pop up), the mage is required to become their teacher, or find someone better for the job -- the reason being that magic can be quite dangerous to people if they don't learn to control it.
74	* ''Literature/{{Darkover}}'': There's a saying that "an untrained telepath is a danger to themselves and everyone around them". Thus at least basic training is considered a must for anyone who manifests actual PsychicPowers. A properly-trained psychic, aided by a [[AmplifierArtifact matrix crystal]], can perform feats of what is MagicByAnyOtherName.
75	* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': This trope is at least implied in several places in the series.
76	** In the earliest books, wizards (and presumably witches) are said to be able to see "octarine", the eighth color of the spectrum, the "color of magic", because of special octagonal structures in their eyes as well as rods and cones. This isn't mentioned much in later books, but it still seems in those that magic is some sort of innate gift.
77	** It also seems that people with ''strong'' magical gifts, such as Eskarina Smith, can be dangerous to everyone around them if not properly trained. Even partly-trained but powerful casters can be dangerous to themselves; for example, "borrowing" an animal's mind can lead to a witch becoming lost in the animal's senses. Unseen University has a gymnasium lined with magic-proof materials where students are required to practice.
78	** The one big attempt we see by untrained and ungifted characters to work significant magic, in ''Literature/GuardsGuards'', involves lengthy rituals and external sources of power. It sort of works, very spectacularly, but does not end at all well. (The first edition ''TabletopGame/DiscworldRolePlayingGame'' compares it to driving a car with no lessons, while blindfolded -- if you ''do'' manage to achieve anything, your problems have only started.)
79	** The interplay between training and gift is emphasised in the short story "The Sea and Little Fishes", where someone says that recurring series character Granny Weatherwax has a "natural talent" and her friend Nanny Ogg replies that no, she works bloody hard at it. It’s sometimes hinted that Nanny herself may have a stronger gift, but can't be bothered with training it much — though Granny ''is'' very definitely gifted in her own right, as are many members of the Weatherwax family. (Granny’s sister Lily was a powerful fairy godmother who ruled Genua as the ManBehindTheMan for decades, and Galder Weatherwax — a distant cousin — was Archchancellor of Unseen University back in the KlingonPromotion days.) Granny's hard work certainly more than makes up any deficit in her gift compared to Nanny’s.
80	* ''Literature/{{Dragonvarld}}'': Draconas trains Marcus over several months to use his magic, which would end up killing him otherwise, sending him off home afterward.
81	* ''Literature/TheDresdenFiles'': Ordinary humans are limited to being able to make a circle (which just requires a drop of blood and an effort of Will) and work a ritual, which Dresden describes as "a cosmic vending machine" -- perform ritual, insert sacrifice, get result, because the power comes from the being you're invoking. You need to have magical potential to work proper spells, but how hard you train ultimately affects what you can use your magic for, it being explicitly stated that even a relatively minor talent, properly trained and [[StrongerWithAge given time]] can "grow teeth." Harry starts out as UnskilledButStrong - he's one of the top 50 strongest mages in the world in his mid-twenties, despite the fact that practitioners hit their magical prime at around 100 years old. However, he's not overly subtle, lacks control and stamina, and often wastes power as a result in the earlier books. Over the course of the books, he learns a lot about using far more precision and focus (especially after he takes [[spoiler: Molly]] as his apprentice, meaning that he gets a much better understanding of the basics after re-examining them as an adult). This is made most apparent in ''Literature/SkinGame'' when he encounters another mage who he says has a similar level of raw power, but because she's only ever practiced fire magic and [[CripplingOverspecialization neglected everything else, she's ultimately the weaker of the two]]. At the end, even though he's tired and carrying a number of broken bones, while she's relatively fresh and backed up by [[spoiler: Lasciel]], with extensive knowledge of most of his offensive and defensive skills, he still beats her comfortably, even while trying to talk her down. As he says afterwards, sickened, "that wasn't a fight. It was murder."
82	* Human magic may work this way in Creator/UrsulaKLeGuin's Literature/{{Earthsea}}. Ged is first taken as a trainee by a witch when he shows a remarkable ability to cast simple spells after hearing them once, then recruited for (extensive) training at a WizardingSchool after showing greater but still limited power. It's possible that anyone could achieve ''something'' if they knew the right [[LanguageOfMagic true names]], but most people would probably be dangerously clumsy at best.
83	* In ''Literature/TheFiresStone'', Chandra has done most of her studying on her own, and the BigBad tempts her with the knowledge he can share with her to increase her natural abilities.
84	* In the ''Literature/HarryPotter'' series, you're either a witch/wizard or a "muggle." Witches and wizards can only perform minor and largely uncontrolled magic without training and the assistance of a wand, but a muggle can study all they like, they'll ''never'' be able to do it. "Muggleborn" wizards exist, so the gift isn't always inherited directly from your parents, but WordOfGod is that they must all have ''[[RecessiveSuperGenes some]]'' wizard ancestors.\
85	(There is a ''possible'' middle ground in the form of "squibs" like Argus Filch — the children of wizards who don't have magical powers. Most of them can at least ''sense'' magic, even if they can't ''use'' it. Filch tried to use a lesson series to use some magic but he never developed any abilities and it's highly implied those lessons were a scam.)
86	* Usually played straight in the works of Creator/MercedesLackey.
87	** In the Literature/HeraldsOfValdemar series, True Magic and [=MindMagic=] (PsychicPowers) are both inborn abilities. Untrained Gifts suffer from PowerIncontinence; an untrained {{telepath\|y}}, for example, could drive herself mad through HearingVoices and needs to learn a PsychicBlockDefense to stay sane. Gifts tend to [[PubertySuperpower activate at puberty]]. Gifted persons with the potential to be Heralds attract the attention of the [[BondCreatures Companions]], who Choose likely youngsters and carry them off to the capital to be trained. Others get training with Healers, Bards, independent magic schools, or even foreign mages like the Tayledras.\
88	The strength of Gifts varies wildly, with Mage gifts in particular being divided into tiers[[note]]Divided after the fact. Not every culture or school of magic agrees on the tiers. It's a categorization, not a level system.[[/note]] by the strongest source of magical energy they can access without backlash. Each power source offers upwards of an order of magnitude more energy than the last, yet it's oft-noted that a WeakButSkilled caster can still defeat somebody at a higher tier that does nothing but clumsily throws their weight around.
89	** Magic in the same Literature/ElementalMasters series appears to follow this pattern. Marina specifically points out in ''Literature/TheGatesOfSleep'' that while she may have the potential to be an Elemental Master, she doesn't have the training to claim that title.
90	** In her Literature/TalesOfTheFiveHundredKingdoms, magic is the ability to manipulate the [[BackgroundMagicField Tradition]], and it doesn't appear to be an innate ability. What is needed is more the right set of traditional circumstances, a savvy tutor, and a good stock of magic already at hand to learn on. Some characters receive the blessing of the Fae, which makes the magic visible and helps a lot, but it doesn't seem to be strictly necessary.
91	* In Creator/CassandraClare's ''Literature/TheMortalInstruments'' and its prequel series ''Literature/TheInfernalDevices'', Warlocks and Shadowhunters are an example of this. Warlocks are the HalfHumanHybrid offspring of demons and possess an innate ability to wield magic. But they can only do so in the most crude ways without training in magical languages, writing, and spells. Likewise, the Shadowhunters have angelic blood that gives them the potential to scribe [[GeometricMagic magical runes]] from the language of Heaven. However, this is akin to learning calligraphy, as the runes are often very complex. They also have to be drawn with focused intent using an implement called a ''stele'' (analogous to a wand) in order to work. Most Shadowhunters only know a fraction of the runes originally given to them by the [[CelestialParagonsAndArchangels Angel Raziel]].
92	* In ''Literature/MyNextLifeAsAVillainessAllRoutesLeadToDoom'', the magical power a magic-user has is more or less determined when their powers first manifest at about four or five; any training only gives improvements ''at best''. Training, however, improves the user's control over their magic. This is important to people like Keith whose magic is both [[MarionetteMaster very powerful and very difficult to control]]; PowerIncontinence is part of his DarkAndTroubledPast.
93	* In ''Literature/TheIrregularAtMagicHighSchool'', magic requires not just the right bloodline, but high-level understanding of physics and technological aids, which magician schools also teach. Untrained magicians tend to overheat the Magic Calculation Areas in their brain, crippling themselves forever (the Juumonji bloodline has particular problems with this, which is why training is mandatory for them), or they use magic before their bodies have developed enough to handle it, which has adverse effects on the child's growth.
94	** In the ''Maidens of Cygnus'' spinoff, a character plays [[FictionalSport magic tennis]] mainly to train herself. The idea is that it teaches her to conjure multiple shields quickly and intuitively, and keep track of a competitor's moves the same way she might have to someday in real combat.
95	* In Creator/SergeyLukyanenko's ''Literature/NightWatchSeries'', the [[DifferentlyPoweredIndividual Others]] are born with the potential to do magic (except for humans turned by vampires and werewolves). However, in order to become a full-fledged Other, one must first be discovered by an Other (usually by AuraVision) and then initiated (an unspoken rule states that, if an uninitiated Other has been found by a Light or Dark Other, then an Other from the opposing side must not attempt to "poach" him or her; generally, an Other will attempt to subtly manipulate the uninitiated into a certain state of mind before their first trip into the Twilight). At the moment of initiation, the new Other's alignment (Light or Dark) is determined by their current emotional state. ''Using'' magic requires spells, which an untrained Other would not know. Both the Night and the Day Watches have school facilities in their headquarters, where the newly-initiated Others are educated in the history of the Others, rudimentary magic skills, and the need to maintain TheMasquerade. Those who subsequently join their Watch can be trained further in magic, although true mastery requires centuries. (It helps that the Others are, effectively, TheAgeless.)
96	* In Lynn Flewelling's Literature/{{Nightrunner}} series, most of the [[OurElvesAreDifferent Aurënfaie]] and many humans with 'faie ancestors exhibit some Inherent Gift. It is usually very minor unless they work to develop proficiency with it. The Third Orëska of Skala actively seeks children with magical potential and recruits them as apprentice wizards.
97	* ''Literature/TheQueenOfIeflaria'': In order to safely use magic, people must be trained, as otherwise they [[PowerIncontinence can't control it]].
98	* ''Literature/SchooledInMagic'': You need to be magically gifted to use most forms of magic. Using it well and safely however requires training, which [[WizardingSchool schools like Whitehall provide]] (some rich magicians get tutors).
99	* In ''Literature/SkinHunger'', there seem to be different ways to work magic. Sadima is born with the ability to communicate with animals, while Hahp just learns to do magic. It is left unclear whether Hahp had some magic talent to begin with.
100	* In ''Literature/{{Slayers}}'', the magical gift comes in [[FantasticMeasurementSystem two measurable parts]]: "bucket capacity" (how many "spell points" you can use with one spell) and "pool capacity" (how many "spell points" you can have in total). High levels of either attribute are an in-born gift, but if you have those, you also need to study and learn magical lore. Gourry Gabriev, for example, has magical gifts but lacks the intelligence and memory to learn magical skill. Furthermore, only pool capacity can be increased through training and practice; bucket capacity is something determined at birth, so the only ways to increase it are by magical "cheating" (e.g. wearing extremely rare and specialized power-boosting talismans, or undergoing the [[FusionDance chimera process]] with magical creatures like Brau Demons).
101	* In Tanya Huff's ''[[Literature/SmokeAndShadows Smoke]]'' series, protagonist Tony Foster demonstrates the potential to wield magic in the first book, but does not become truly proficient at it until [[WeirdnessMagnet repeated supernatural problems]] compel him to seriously apply himself to study and practice.
102	* ''Literature/SwordOfTruth'': People who have the gift need training for them to use magic (this requires touching their "Han", or life force). The gifted are trained in the Palace of the Prophets. When sorceresses, this is fairly easy. However, if they're wizards this can take ''centuries''. As a result, the Palace is under a spell that stops people aging while they're there so they don't simply die of old age before this is possible. Wizards used to be trained in the Wizards' Keep, but the old wizards have died out except for Zedd by the time of the series (he's too busy to train anyone as well).
103	* ''Literature/ThirdTimeLuckyAndOtherStoriesOfTheMostPowerfulWizardInTheWorld'': In "And Who Is Joah?" Magdelene can tell Joah has vast magical power, like her, but without any training she'll be hugely dangerous. So she takes Joah as her apprentice, something Magdelene would never do usually.
104	* ''Literature/{{Uprooted}}'': Only those born with the gift of magic (like Agnieszka) can cast spells. There are a lot of spells out there to learn, and casting them gets easier with practice. It's still possible to use your gift in small ways without spells, even if you don't know that you ''have'' a gift, but you're not going to get very far. Hence the king's law that everyone with the gift must be trained.
105	* In Creator/RobertJordan's ''Literature/TheWheelOfTime'', approximately one percent of people have the ability to touch the True Source and draw on the One Power, but they'll never do it unless they learn [[MeditationPowerUp the proper form of meditation]]; then they have to learn the precise ways of arranging the Power into [[GeometricMagic weaves]] to create a specific desired effect. This attribute is partly genetic, partly spiritual, which basically means it crops up more often among families, but the main characters are more capable than most BecauseDestinySaysSo. Of those who can channel, about one percent have what is called the "spark", and will eventually channel whether they try or not, often killing themselves in the process. A handful of those survive by putting an instinctive 'block' on their channelling, which makes it harder for them to learn how to do it correctly when they get official training.
106	[[/folder]]
107
108	[[folder:Live-Action TV]]
109	* After her SuperpoweredEvilSide's RoaringRampageOfRevenge at the end of Season 6, ''Series/{{Buffy the Vampire Slayer}}'''s Willow Rosenberg undergoes magical training in England. This is a slightly odd example, in that she had already reached a pretty advanced stage of development as a witch, but it's implied that she relied too much on raw power, with almost no discipline, and Season 6 certainly saw the development of a very [[AddictiveMagic unhealthy approach to her power]]. Her post-England attitude to magic is noticeably more Zen, or at least more focused and less wild, than it had ever been up to this point. Characters in the series such as Giles who possess sufficient education but no apparent gift can work magic but must perform complex rituals and are a lot more tentative about it.
110	* In ''Series/{{Charmed\|1998}}'', witches are born with their abilities, and plenty of people are shown as being unable to use magic. And while you're born with your specific gift (other than the ability to cast spells and scry, each of the witches has their own skill -- telekinesis, empathy, etc.), you have to learn to use your abilities and hone your skills. Powers can also be "bound" (repressed) or transferred from one character to another. Characters can also power up over time with abilities changing to more powerful forms.
111	* ''Series/MotherlandFortSalem'': Magic is a largely hereditary and inherent ability. However, it requires training to be used properly. In the US, that's a military issue, with witches conscripted and trained at Fort Salem.
112	* The Ocampa on ''Series/StarTrekVoyager'' have absolutely enormous potential for PsychicPowers, with the possibility of even becoming EnergyBeings and AscendingToAHigherPlaneOfExistence. However, this is something that the vast majority of them will never achieve, as it usually requires a great deal of training (or something pushing them into SuperMode) to get them to this point. The SufficientlyAdvancedAlien Suspiria has made it her mission to train a small group of Ocampa to reach their full potential and join her in AnotherDimension. It also doesn't help that the Ocampa have an average lifespan of only 9 years, limiting their training time.
113	* In ''Series/WandaVision,'' it appears that witch-magic is an inborn gift that must be trained to work at all dramatically; [[spoiler:Agatha]] apparently has a lot of inborn power, but first had to be trained by her mother’s coven, and then surpassed them through self-teaching from books of ThingsManWasNotMeantToKnow. She deduces that Wanda, on the other hand, was born with a small gift that would have faded through lack of training, but then had it unlocked and amplified by exposure to an [[ArtifactOfDoom Infinity Stone]], eventually making her a quite terrifyingly UnskilledButStrong being [[spoiler:— the legendary “Scarlet Witch”]]. [[spoiler:Agatha]] seems to be simultaneously awestruck, jealous, and nervous of Wanda’s ability to defy the trope, but has [[PowerParasite her own response to this]].
114	[[/folder]]
115
116	[[folder:Tabletop Games]]
117	* In ''TabletopGame/ArsMagica'', full-power magicians have to possess "The Gift", although some other people can work slightly less impressive forms of magic. The Gift must be "unlocked" to be useful, but even before that, characters who possess it tend to be perceived as creepy and dubious by other humans and animals, often causing them to be [[WitchHunt persecuted]] by their neighbors.
118	* In ''TabletopGame/TheDarkEye'', one has to have both magical talent and a long, involved education to become a full mage. A person who wasn't trained, or whose talent was weaker, is a "quarter-mage" or "magic-dilettant": they have a limited number of spells they can cast as a supernatural ability, but they can't learn other spells and have a smaller spell point pool. Half-mages are in between (depending on a character's culture and profession, they may have had more or less magical education). Only some humans are capable of magic, but all [[OurElvesAreDifferent elves]] are, and every half-elf is at least a quarter-mage.
119	* The Sorcerer character class in ''TabletopGame/DungeonsAndDragons''. In contrast to wizards, sorcerers have an Inherent Gift for magic. However, like all other character classes, they have to accumulate experience points and gain levels in order to expand their spells known and how powerful the spells they can cast are. On the other hand, how much level advancement represents "training" [[SlidingScaleOfGameplayAndStoryIntegration really depends how one views the nature of the game world]]. There are also prestige classes that they can pursue in order to gain more specialized abilities.
120	* ''TabletopGame/{{Pathfinder}}'' (which derives from ''D&D'' as described above) features the Arcanist class, which is described as a person with the sorcerous gift who learns to channel and control it by wizard-like studies. While not meant to be more powerful than sorcerers or wizards (for balance reasons), by default they can be described as more magically adept than sorcerers, in that instead of the bloodline changes sorcerers develop arcanists get various tricks related to spells and magic.
121	* ''TabletopGame/{{GURPS}}'': This kind of distinction is represented in the basic magic system by the "Magery" character advantage (also known as "Magical Aptitude"). In some settings, only characters with Magery can cast spells; in others, in areas of "high mana", anyone can do so, but levels of Magery give a bonus.
122	* ''TabletopGame/Warhammer40000'': The powers possessed by "psykers" aren't called "magic", but they might as well be. Psykers are randomly born, but they have a very strong tendency to get possessed by demons if not found and trained by the Imperium, a process that takes years and is extremely detrimental to the psyker's mental health (and since being a psyker involves hearing voices pretty much all the time, they aren’t generally all that sane to begin with).\
123	One version of the Emperor’s backstory (which may or may not still be canon) had him being the combined reincarnation of all of Earth's shamans (ancient psykers) after they committed mass ritual suicide. When his powers awakened, he also inherited the sum total of their memories, and with it their lifetimes of training. Thus he had the good fortune of inheriting both the gift ''and'' the knowledge needed to actually control it.
124	* In ''TabletopGame/MageTheAwakening'', anyone has the potential to "Awaken" to a Supernal Path and begin to develop their powers in various "Arcana" of magic through a PointBuildSystem. However, each Path is associated with specific Arcana and a mage is limited in how far they can progress in other Arcana without outside help; for example, an Acanthus can master [[WindsOfDestinyChange Fate]] and {{Time\|Master}} on their own, but needs a tutor to progress beyond the basics in Matter.'
125	* ''TabletopGame/{{Shadowrun}}'' magic users work this way. Around .1% of the Earth's population are born "Awakened" and able to perceive magic at all, which in gameplay terms means having a Magic stat higher than 0. Within the Awakened population, there are also varying talents that decide how you can use your magic. Gameplay-wise, your talent determines what you can use your Magic stat to actually do, by limiting which magically active skills you can learn. One's talent is also limited by birth; full-blown magicians (who can learn any magic-related skill) are extremely rare setting-wise and a tiny percentage of the overall Awakened population. Finally, there is how much raw power you have, which is decided by your Magic stat, your known spells and rituals/[[MagicEnhancement Power Points (for adepts)]], and your skill rating(s) in your magical skills. This final part can be changed over time by improving characters with [[ExperiencePoints Karma]] and money, representing training your gift. A sorcerer (a magic user who can only cast spells, not perform rituals, summon spirits or enchant items) with a high Magic stat, training in spellcasting, and knowing the right combat spells can and will ruin the day of a full-blown mage who is less trained, but will never be able to match the latter's flexibility.
126	[[/folder]]
127
128	[[folder:VideoGames]]
129	* In ''VideoGame/{{Destiny}}'' and ''VideoGame/Destiny2'', being a Lightbearer requires one to be risen from the dead by a [[RobotBuddy Ghost]] that believes they displayed the right qualities to deserve empowerment (commonly parsed as "devotion, bravery, sacrifice, death"). Once that's done, however, one's facility with the Light depends wholly on their willingness to exercise it and push their boundaries -- while some characters are said to be naturally strong in the Light, nothing stops anyone else from attaining the same level with enough experience. Even Ikora Rey, one of the strongest Guardians in history, began her career only marginally more capable (at best) than average. As she explains to a self-described "low power Guardian":
130	--> [...] the possibility of your Light is unlimited. I mean this very seriously. A novice go player has the exact same power to place stones as a 9-dan master. The only difference between them lies in their knowledge and ability to choose [...] the only difference in "power" between you and me lies in what we have learned and practiced.
131	* In the [[Franchise/DragonAge Dragon Age series]] everyone (except dwarves) is connected to [[BackgroundMagicField the]] [[DreamLand Fade]], a magical realm that exists alongside the normal world. Mages are those who are born with unusually strong connections that allow them to draw power from it by shaping [[WillOTheWisp wisps]] into spells. While potential is at least partially genetic, it is impossible to say who will or will not be a mage at birth as the power usually begins to manifest at [[PubertySuperpower the onset of puberty]]. When discovered, a mage is required to join [[MutantDraftBoard the Circle of Magi]] immediately and permanently to receive training in using their powers. Those who fail to receive training as soon as possible risk stunted magical potential, [[PowerIncontinence dangerous accidents]], and DemonicPossession.
132	* In the ''VideoGame/MassEffect'' series, those individuals exposed to [[MinovskyPhysics element zero]] in the womb and not born with defects become biotics. [[GreenSkinnedSpaceBabe Asari]] are the only race, all of whom are biotic, due to the high concentration of eezo on their homeworld [[spoiler:and genetic engineering]]. All biotics except asari need to have implants in order to generate and manipulate mass effect fields strong enough for practical applications. However, their control is extremely basic and unfocused until they undergo appropriate training. It takes many years for a biotic to achieve his or her peak.
133	* ''Videogame/LeagueOfLegends'':
134	** Ezreal was born with the potential to be a powerful mage, but he wanted to be an explorer too much to waste time in magic lessons. His gift went untapped for many years, but eventually his explorations turned up an artifact that would channel his power for him. In his old lore, he 'paid' for the artifact by letting it summon him into League matches -- in his new lore, the cost is not yet known.
135	** Syndra had an immense gift, to the extent that her teacher locked most of it away and trained what he considered to be a safe level. She realized he had limited her power and made her displeasure known. Violently.
136	** This formerly applied to Twisted Fate, who wanted to be a mage but had no gift; he bought one through a Zaunian experiment and paid for it by handing over his best friend Graves. In the "Burning Tides" retcon, however, TF always had the gift and his 'betrayal' of Graves was over a different matter (and partially Graves' own fault).
137	* In ''VideoGame/LunarTheSilverStar'', whether someone is capable of casting magic is determined by taking a visit to Black Rose Street in the huge city of Meribia, where what potential you might have is unlocked; in-game, protagonist Alex has a propensity for flame and healing magic unlocked, and {{muggle}} Ramus doesn't have a lick of magic within him. Newly-unlocked mages can then travel to the floating Magic City of Vane to study and train their skills. Note that this aspect of Black Rose Street isn't used in the later 32-bit remake, as Alex's skillset changed up to downplay his magical prowess.
138	[[/folder]]
139
140	[[folder:Web Comics]]
141	* In ''Webcomic/GirlGenius'', "the Spark" is a rare, largely hereditary personal attribute that grants access to mad science that frequently verges on the magical. "Sparks" primarily possess a capacity for insane levels of hyperfocus on technical tasks, and can function without training -- but obviously, a good technical education helps; an excellent example being a baker with the Spark, whose proficiency is almost entirely limited to the production of pies with varying effects. They also need to learn to channel their own abilities ''relatively'' safely, and some are lynched by the non-Spark general populace when their abilities manifest uncontrollably for the first time.
142	* ''Webcomic/StandStillStaySilent'': Only a select number of individuals are able to use magic at all, and the differences in power between the three mages introduced in the story come from the amount of training and practical experience that they've each had.
143	* In ''WebComic/YokokasQuest'', spells involving a MagicalIncantation require the caster to be able to speak the words in the correct elemental language, and characters have an "edge" element that they should be naturally good at using. Yin teaches Yokoka a [[BoringButPractical spell]] to [[NightVisionGoggles see in the dark]], and Yfa fails to learn it due to [[LanguageBarrier not knowing the language for that spell]]. Inky also fails to teach Yokoka any Light magic, despite Light being her edge element, as [[LanguageBarrier she can't comprehend Light language]].
144	[[/folder]]
145
146	[[folder:Web Original]]
147	* The purpose of Brakket Magical Academy in ''Literature/VoidDomain''. One must not only have the ability to use magic, but they must also learn how to use that magic.
148	* {{Telepathy}} is an innate ability of a small percentage of humans (and possibly other species) in ''Literature/PayMeBug'', but telepaths must receive special training during their early adolescent years or their power could break their minds.
149	[[/folder]]
150
151	[[folder:Western Animation]]
152	* ''WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender'': This is how "bending" works. One is born as either a "bender" or "non-bender". Without training, Katara's "waterbending" is little more than a parlor trick; you could move more water just by splashing with your hands. ''With'' training, she is capable of healing, manipulating, freezing, and thawing large quantities, and even (under the right circumstances) manipulating water ''in people's blood'' to make PeoplePuppets out of her enemies. It does appear to be possible for some prodigies (such as Avatar Korra of ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra'', who is seen bending three of the four elements at a very young age with little or no formal training) to be self-taught, but it is ''very'' rare. One exception to the inborn aspect of bending shows up in the third season of ''The Legend of Korra''. The Harmonic Convergence at the end of season 2 somehow grants Airbending to people all over the world (presumably to restore balance after the genocide of the Air Nomads by the Fire Nation).
153	* ''WesternAnimation/ElenaOfAvalor'': Everyone has some level of amount of raw magic potential, but this can be changed through powerful spells and other magical processes.
154	** Elena herself became a powerful magic user from the 41 years she was inside the Amulet of Avalor. This allowed her to unlock the magical properties of the royal Scepter of Light as well as being able to see spirits, but the downside is that it's CastFromHitPoints; The first time she used it to the full extent [[AsleepForDays she passed out for two days]]. She did lose this weakness once she became fully magical, however.
155	** We also learn that magic potential is genetic, although inheritors don't always pursue learning magic. For example, Rafa de Alva never pursued magic like her father because it was outlawed during Shuriki's reign over Avalor and she had no interest in it, but her son Mateo taught himself magic when he discovered his grandfather's cache of magical items. Additionally, Rafa is shown to be able to use magic if she wanted to.
156	** Magic can be given if granted by another sorcerer, [[EvilSorcerer malvago]], or exposure to magic crystals -- similar to Elena with the amulet, Elena and [[spoiler:Esteban]] gain more magical powers from falling into the Crystal Forge, but require training to perfect them.
157	* ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'': All unicorns can use active magic, but this takes training to truly perfect. All unicorns can use basic telekinesis, but for more specialized and powerful magic they need to spend a long time in a specialized school or being tutored by a more experienced magician, practicing spells, and poring over textbooks. Even so, not all unicorns are equal -- some are innately much more powerful than others and can cast much stronger spells, while others simply don't have any inborn talent and won't be able to change this no matter how much they study.
158	[[/folder]]

Context Main / TrainingTheGiftOfMagic