Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheSuicideSquad

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Team A featured a whole team of OneSceneWonder's as SacrificialLamb's making them much more memorable than FlatCharacter Slipknot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorWorship: After getting this from Marvel fans, DC fans have embraced Creator/JamesGunn for his stellar job redeeming the Suicide Squad's mainstream reputation thanks to his hilariously dark and poignant work both as the film's writer and director. Notably, he seemed to get this from Creator/WarnerBros themselves too, as, despite the film's AcclaimedFlop status, not only did they greenlight [[Series/{{Peacemaker}} a spinoff streaming series]] which received similar acclaim, but they eventually put Gunn in charge of ''all of DC Films'', with him spearheading a full DCEU reboot and directing the first film in the new universe, ''Superman Legacy'', to widespread anticipation from fans.

to:

* CreatorWorship: After getting this from Marvel fans, DC fans have embraced Creator/JamesGunn for his stellar job redeeming the Suicide Squad's mainstream reputation thanks to his hilariously dark and poignant work both as the film's writer and director. Notably, he seemed to get this from Creator/WarnerBros themselves too, as, despite the film's AcclaimedFlop status, not only did they greenlight [[Series/{{Peacemaker}} [[Series/Peacemaker2022 a spinoff streaming series]] which received similar acclaim, but they eventually put Gunn in charge of ''all of DC Films'', with him spearheading a full DCEU reboot and directing the first film in the new universe, ''Superman Legacy'', to widespread anticipation from fans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CharacterRerailment: After being portrayes as just another superteam of antiheroes since the New 52, this movie finally brings back many elements of the Ostrander run of the Squad: [[CListFodder Obscure supervillains]], [[AnyoneCanDie high risk of death]], [[BlackComedy very dark humour]], the team being involved in politics, Rick Flag as the OnlySaneMan... Needless to say this was universally praised.

to:

* CharacterRerailment: After being portrayes portrayed as just another superteam of antiheroes since the New 52, this movie finally brings back many elements of the Ostrander run of the Squad: [[CListFodder Obscure supervillains]], [[AnyoneCanDie high risk of death]], [[BlackComedy very dark humour]], the team being involved in politics, Rick Flag as the OnlySaneMan... Needless to say this was universally praised.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorWorship: After getting this from Marvel fans, DC fans have embraced Creator/JamesGunn for his stellar job redeeming the Suicide Squad's mainstream reputation thanks to his hilariously dark and poignant work both as the film's writer and director.

to:

* CreatorWorship: After getting this from Marvel fans, DC fans have embraced Creator/JamesGunn for his stellar job redeeming the Suicide Squad's mainstream reputation thanks to his hilariously dark and poignant work both as the film's writer and director. Notably, he seemed to get this from Creator/WarnerBros themselves too, as, despite the film's AcclaimedFlop status, not only did they greenlight [[Series/{{Peacemaker}} a spinoff streaming series]] which received similar acclaim, but they eventually put Gunn in charge of ''all of DC Films'', with him spearheading a full DCEU reboot and directing the first film in the new universe, ''Superman Legacy'', to widespread anticipation from fans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sebastian the rat shows he's friendly by waving a paw at people. Owners of pet rats won't be surprised by this, as rats sometimes do raise a paw (although they don't wave it) as a greeting gesture.

to:

** Sebastian the rat shows he's friendly by waving a paw at people. Owners of pet rats won't be surprised by this, as rats sometimes do raise a paw (although they don't wave it) as a greeting gesture. He also chatters his teeth (bruxing) to express happiness at the end, another distinctive show of rat body language.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DiagnosedByTheAudience: Ratcatcher II has many traits of people with autism and can easily be seen by the audience as on the spectrum. Amongst other things:
** To start with, her fascination and love for rats is clearly what people with autism call a ''special interest''. [[note]]Liking something--it can be anything, but usally something "most people" would not really like--almost to the point of obsession, and having the need to talk about it a lot to other people who do not share the interest, and sometimes aren't even interested in having such detailed discussions about it at all[[/note]]
** There's also the fact that she so strongly believes that people totally misjudge rats and are wrong to believe them to be [[YouDirtyRat vile creatures]]. She seems genuinely hurt by this. People with autism often feel strongly for "the underdog" and can be prome to call out they are judged/treated unfairly.
** She's naive. Bloodsport at one point even calls her a "little idiot".
** HorribleJudgeOfCharacter: She completely misses that King Shark, during the first half of the movie before they become friends, would gladly eat her (or her teammates), and when he almost does, she initally stands up for King Shark against her fellow team mates who saw it happen--until her rat Sebastian communicates to her that King Shark in fact did try to eat her.
** Her subsequent interaction with King Shark where she asks to become his friends, is weirdly transactional. Most people would not ask someone to be a friend as a condition for not being murdered by them.
** LiteralMinded: When Bloodsport and Peacemaker drop the expression ''"eat dicks"'' during a discussion, she genuinely wonders why people would put penises all over the beach, missing that it's a figure of speech.
** She's referred to as being in her early twenties [[note]]The movie is set in 2021 and Peacemaker refers to her as a millenial, so she must be at least 22 years old[[/note]], but looks way younger and acts like a teenager. People on the spectrum are also often OlderThanTheyLook.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CharacterRerailment: After being portrayes as just another superteam of antiheroes since the New 52, this movie finally brings back many elements of the Ostrander run of the Squad: [[CListFodder Obscure supervillains]], [[AnyoneCanDie high risk of death]], [[BlackComedy very dark humour]], the team being involved in politics, Rick Flag as the OnlySaneMan... Needless to say this was universally praised.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SurprisinglyImprovedSequel: The film is considered to be a ''massive'' improvement from ''Film/SuicideSquad2016'' in every aspect. To contrast, while the first film had a 26% critic score and a [[CriticalDissonance 59% audience score]] on Rotten Tomatoes, indicating mixed-to-negative reviews, this film has received widespread critical acclaim from both sides, with far more positive 90% and 82% scores from critics and audiences respectively.

to:

* SurprisinglyImprovedSequel: The film is considered to be a ''massive'' improvement from ''Film/SuicideSquad2016'' in every aspect. To contrast, while the first film had a 26% critic score and a [[CriticalDissonance 59% audience score]] on Rotten Tomatoes, indicating mixed-to-negative reviews, this film has received widespread critical acclaim from both sides, with far more positive 90% and 82% scores from critics and audiences respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misplaced, moving to the correct tab

Added DiffLines:

* IKnewIt:
** When Creator/SylvesterStallone was revealed to be joining the cast, a lot of fans guessed that he would be voicing King Shark.
** When Creator/PeteDavidson's character was revealed to be Blackguard, an obscure villain even by the film's standards with a much less creative costume than the rest of the cast, many fans correctly predicted that [[spoiler:he'd be the first character to die]]. Many guesses that in the sheer basis that Davidson felt so wildly out of place in the cast, not to mention the fact that he was barely in the advertising.
** Due to the bloating of the cast, many fans guessed [[spoiler:most of the team would die early on to set up the stakes. They also correctly guessed that most of the bigger names would survive.]]
** After the final trailer came out, a common theory was that [[spoiler:Polka Dot Man's line "I'm a superhero!" would turn out to be his last words.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* EvilIsSexy:
** Bloodsport, a violent killer with very few morals, is played by the immensely handsome and charming Creator/IdrisElba.
** Sure, Captain Boomerang’s looks are played down, but not enough to disguise that Creator/JaiCourtney is one {{hunk}}y dude.
** Javelin's flowing hair and form fitting costume makes him apply as well. And as the film notes, the accent helps.
** Peacemaker is portrayed by the handsome John Cena, who gets to show off his muscular physique with a rather tight shirt, and has an entire scene where he stands in his underwear.
** Silvio Luna is a rather hot dictator, and his introduction to Harley is clearly banking on her liking his state of undress. She does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguation of Evil Is Sexy

Added: 567

Changed: 13

Removed: 564

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* QuestionableCasting:
** The cast was very well received, but many were confused by Pete Davidson's involvement, given he's regarded by most as more of a stand-up comedian than a good actor, and his usual slacker type characters don’t fit into this kind of story at all. [[spoiler:Though the fact that his character is the first to die gives the impression that his presence was intentionally jarring]].
** Michael Rooker as Savant was also considered a baffling choice for fans of the character, since the comic character is young and very conventionally attractive.



* WTHCastingAgency:
** The cast was very well received, but many were confused by Pete Davidson's involvement, given he's regarded by most as more of a stand-up comedian than a good actor, and his usual slacker type characters don’t fit into this kind of story at all. [[spoiler:Though the fact that his character is the first to die gives the impression that his presence was intentionally jarring]].
** Michael Rooker as Savant was also considered a baffling choice for fans of the character, since the comic character is young and very conventionally attractive.



** Pete Davidson’s Blackguard costume looks extremely generic and boring in contrast with everyone else’s more colorful and creative outfits. The fact that Davidson himself [[WTHCastingAgency sticks out poorly amongst the other actors]] means that his costume sticking out poorly amongst the others just makes him look especially distracting and out of place.

to:

** Pete Davidson’s Blackguard costume looks extremely generic and boring in contrast with everyone else’s more colorful and creative outfits. The fact that Davidson himself [[WTHCastingAgency [[QuestionableCasting sticks out poorly amongst the other actors]] means that his costume sticking out poorly amongst the others just makes him look especially distracting and out of place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut, as discussed on the Narm Cleanup thread. Please consult that thread first if wish to readd any of these entries back again.


* {{Narm}}:
** The landing at the beach starts out dramatically, but some of the deaths are so stupid, it makes it hard to watch: Mongal trying, and failing to bring down the Helicopter, Savant randomly freaking out and swimming out to sea, with Waller caring a lot more than she should have[[note]] especially since they were all supposed to die, anyway [[/note]]. Her saying, "Dammit" makes no sense, since he was part of the team that was not meant to survive.
** Bloodsport's fight with his daughter starts out sad... then devolves into them lobbing f-bombs at each other. Especially since Storm Reid is screaming as high as possible while Idris Elba starts teasing it. Also when he calls her out for getting caught stealing something as stupid as a TV-Watch her response is: [[LameComeback "It does other things too!"]]
** Harley's escape is cool. Her meeting up with the team right as they were planning to rescue her is hilarious. But then, Gunn feels the need to drag the scene out with Flagg looking and sounding as embarrassed as possible, while Bloodsport just stands there, with only his mask on. Even cringier still, is that he started the mission with his entire suit EXCEPT for the mask.
** Flagg's death is tragic... but the inside shot showing his pierced heart comes out of nowhere. Almost like Gunn felt the need to emphasize that he was dead, in case people weren't sure.
** The final battle with Starro has the squad facing a bunch of mindless drones. Since they are already dead, the Squad have no reason to feel bad about killing them, but they're so weak, that even six of them can't hold down Bloodsport. They don't try to attack, beyond clumsily grabbing people, and because of the Starfishes around their faces, they can't bite. They're like the definition of crippled zombies.
** The fight against Staro himself has its moments. Bloodsport being an expert marksman who can split a bullet, fires at Starro... and hits everywhere except the [[AttackItsWeakPoint giant Eye]].
** Polka-Dot Man's death is kind of stupid. Not the death itself, but the execution. After wounding Starro with his powers, he gleefully declares himself a superhero... then turns his attention away from the giant, now very angry Starfish to say it to Bloodsport. He's promptly SquashedFlat. It doesn't help that no-one in the squad even tried to warn him.
** For all of Starro's power, he is taken out... by rats. Yes, Harley pierced his eye with the Javelin, but even before that, the rats were causing him pain. For something allegedly so powerful, it's a pretty pathetic way to go out.

Top