Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheBradyBunch

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: In "The Possible Dream," Marcia gets to meet Desi Arnaz Jr. because Alice is a friend of [[Creator/LucilleBall his mother's]] housekeeper. It's too bad that more wasn't made of this connection, and the Bradys never got to meet Lucille Ball, since the series is in some ways a SpiritualAdaptation of her film ''Film/YoursMineAndOurs''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The fact that in the never-produced Season 6, Creator/SherwoodSchwartz planned to kill off Mike due to Robert Reed's HostilityOnTheSet, and later planned to do the same in ''The Bradys'' only to be stopped again by the show's cancellation. As it turned out, in 1992, Robert Reed was the first of the main cast members to die.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Carol is commonly depicted as a widow, however it's never actually clarified what happened to her first husband. She was intended to be a divorcee, but the networks didn't agree on that, so her past marriage was kept ambiguous.

to:

** Carol is commonly depicted as a widow, however it's never actually clarified what happened to her first husband. She was intended to be a divorcee, but the networks didn't agree on that, so her past marriage was kept ambiguous. Although the fact that her daughters' surname is changed to "Brady" seems to imply that Mike legally adopted them, and therefore that their birth father is dead.



** In Season 1's "The Undergraduate," when Marcia is advising Greg on the qualities women look for in a man, she claims he should be "sort of innocent, like Creator/DustinHoffman''. Since TheNewTens have seen Hoffmann accused by multiple women of sexual harassment and assault over the course of his long career, hearing him described as "innocent" rings all too ironic.

to:

** In Season 1's "The Undergraduate," when Marcia is advising Greg on the qualities women look for in a man, she claims he should be "sort of innocent, like Creator/DustinHoffman''. Since TheNewTens have seen Hoffmann Hoffman accused by multiple women of sexual harassment and assault over the course of his long career, hearing him described as "innocent" rings all too ironic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Season 1's "The Undergraduate," when Marcia is advising Greg on the qualities women look for in a man, she claims he should be "sort of innocent, like Creator/DustinHoffman''. Since TheNewTens have seen Hoffmann accused by multiple women of sexual harassment and assault over the course of his long career, hearing him described as "innocent" rings all too ironic.

to:

* ** In Season 1's "The Undergraduate," when Marcia is advising Greg on the qualities women look for in a man, she claims he should be "sort of innocent, like Creator/DustinHoffman''. Since TheNewTens have seen Hoffmann accused by multiple women of sexual harassment and assault over the course of his long career, hearing him described as "innocent" rings all too ironic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Season 1's "The Undergraduate," when Marcia is advising Greg on the qualities women look for in a man, she claims he should be "sort of innocent, like Creator/DustinHoffman''. Since the #MeToo movement has seen Hoffmann accused by multiple women of sexual harassment and assault over the course of his long career, hearing him described as "innocent" rings all too ironic.

to:

* In Season 1's "The Undergraduate," when Marcia is advising Greg on the qualities women look for in a man, she claims he should be "sort of innocent, like Creator/DustinHoffman''. Since the #MeToo movement has TheNewTens have seen Hoffmann accused by multiple women of sexual harassment and assault over the course of his long career, hearing him described as "innocent" rings all too ironic.



* TastesLikeDiabetes: The show is ''very'' saccharine, even by family sitcom standards.

to:

* TastesLikeDiabetes: SweetnessAversion: The show is ''very'' saccharine, even by family sitcom standards.



** Middle child Jan has to wait to get married because Marcia's still single, ''and'' needs her parents' approval despite being a grown woman.

to:

** Middle In "The Brady Girls Get Married," middle child Jan has to wait to get married because Marcia's still single, ''and'' needs her parents' approval despite being a grown woman.



** Also from "A Fistful of Reasons": Cindy is being bullied because of her lisp. When Peter stands up for her, the bully gives him a black eye. Today, bullying and violence are taken ''much'' more seriously in schools, and many of them have zero-tolerance policies. The bully would be at the very least be suspended.

to:

** Also from "A Fistful of Reasons": Cindy is being bullied because of her lisp. When Peter stands up for her, the bully gives him a black eye. Today, bullying and violence are taken ''much'' more seriously in schools, and many of them have zero-tolerance policies. The bully would be at the very least be suspended. The conflict is also resolved by Peter finally punching the bully. Most modern family shows that deal with bullying usually find some way to solve the problem without violence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The oldest daughter's name is spelled "Marcia” not "Marsha". Marsh-uh is also not the correct pronunciation of this Spanish name - it is Mar-see-uh.

to:

** The oldest daughter's name is spelled "Marcia” not "Marsha". Marsh-uh Although "Marsh-uh" is also not the correct pronunciation of this Spanish name - it's "Mar-see-uh" – it is Mar-see-uh.the common American pronunciation among non-Spanish-speakers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In Season 1's "The Undergraduate," when Marcia is advising Greg on the qualities women look for in a man, she claims he should be "sort of innocent, like Creator/DustinHoffman''. Since the #MeToo movement has seen Hoffmann accused by multiple women of sexual harassment and assault over the course of his long career, hearing him described as "innocent" rings all too ironic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is not an example if the line didn't actually get into the show.


* CriticalResearchFailure:
** In his retrospective about ''The Brady Bunch'', Lloyd Schwartz recalled a dispute he had with Robert Reed over a line in the script for "Jan, the Only Child" where Mike walks into the kitchen, sees Carol and Alice cooking strawberry preserves for the Charity Hoedown, takes a whiff and remarks, "This smells like strawberry heaven!" Reed contended that, per various encyclopedia articles, strawberries don't have scents and got into a huge argument with the writers. After several days of fighting and not wanting production delays over a minor point in the script, the writers conceded and changed Reed's line to "This looks like strawberry heaven." (Although the line Reed would go on to use would be "I do believe I've died and gone to strawberry heaven." Strawberries, do in fact, have a very chemically complex scent. The Schwartzes (both Sherwood and Lloyd) and Barry Williams (in his own autobiography) note that disputes such as the above were commonplace, and Lloyd further added that in Reed's previous series, ''Series/{{The Defenders|1961}}'' (where he played an a young attorney), this was also a regular occurrence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While trying to meet up with a girl who works as a park mascot "The Cincinnati Kids", Greg approaches the wrong employee and hears an exaggeratedly gravelly voice from under the costume ask "Does this ''sound'' like a 'Marge' to you?" Actually, [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons yeah; it kinda does]].

to:

** While trying to meet up with a girl who works as a park mascot in "The Cincinnati Kids", Greg approaches the wrong employee and hears an exaggeratedly gravelly voice from under the costume ask "Does this ''sound'' like a 'Marge' to you?" Actually, [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons yeah; it kinda does]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While trying to meet up with a girl who works as a park mascot "The Cincinnati Kids", Greg approaches the wrong employee and hears an exaggeratedly gravelly voice from under the costume ask "Does this ''sound'' like a 'Marge' to you?" Actually, [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons yeah; it does]].

to:

** While trying to meet up with a girl who works as a park mascot "The Cincinnati Kids", Greg approaches the wrong employee and hears an exaggeratedly gravelly voice from under the costume ask "Does this ''sound'' like a 'Marge' to you?" Actually, [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons yeah; it kinda does]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While trying to meet up with a girl who works as a park mascot "The Cincinnati Kids" has Greg approach the wrong employee and hears an exaggeratedly gravelly voice from under the costume ask "Does this ''sound'' like a 'Marge' to you?" Actually, [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons yeah; it does]].

to:

** While trying to meet up with a girl who works as a park mascot "The Cincinnati Kids" has Kids", Greg approach approaches the wrong employee and hears an exaggeratedly gravelly voice from under the costume ask "Does this ''sound'' like a 'Marge' to you?" Actually, [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons yeah; it does]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While trying to meet up with a girl who works as a park mascot "The Cincinnati Kids" has Greg approach the wrong employee and hears an exaggeratedly gravelly voice from under the costume ask "Does this ''sound'' like a 'Marge' to you?" Actually, [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons yeah; it does]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FunnyAneurysmMoment:

to:

* FunnyAneurysmMoment:HarsherInHindsight:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Robbie Rist, the original CousinOliver, would later go on to voice Chouji Akimichi in the English dub of ''Manga/{{Naruto}}''.

to:

** Robbie Rist, the original CousinOliver, would later go on to have a successful career as a voice actor, including voicing Chouji Akimichi in the English dub of ''Manga/{{Naruto}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also from "A Fistful of Reasons": Cindy is being bullied because of her lisp. When Peter stands up for her, the bully gives him a black eye. Today, bullying and violence are taken ''much'' more seriously in schools, and many of them have zero-tolerance policies. Today, the bully would be suspended.

to:

** Also from "A Fistful of Reasons": Cindy is being bullied because of her lisp. When Peter stands up for her, the bully gives him a black eye. Today, bullying and violence are taken ''much'' more seriously in schools, and many of them have zero-tolerance policies. Today, the The bully would be at the very least be suspended.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also from "A Fistful of Reasons": Cindy is being bullied because of her lisp. When Peter stands up for her, the bully gives him a black eye. Today, bullying and violence are taken ''much'' more seriously in schools, and many of them have zero-tolerance policies. Today, the bully would be suspended.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UnintentionalPeriodPiece: The show screams "early [[TheSeventies '70s]]" harder than just about any other product of its era. The show even captured a picture of how mainstream American society was moving at that time; from the early episodes where Carol had a bouffant, the girls wore skirts and dresses, the boys and Mike all had short hair to the later episodes where Carol relaxed on the haircare product, Mike and the boys let their hair grow out to their temples or shoulders, and the girls were seen in more slacks and jeans. This was a series that also depicted a married couple sleeping together (and with no additional children being conceived, likely a reference to the increased availability of birth control) and of a blended family where both parents have been married before. [[note]]''The Goldbergs'' in 1954 depicted Molly and Jake in bed in an episode, but it wasn't a OncePerEpisode aspect like ''The Brady Bunch''.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In his retrospective about ''The Brady Bunch'', Lloyd Schwartz recalled a dispute he had with Robert Reed over a line in the script for "Jan, the Only Child" where Mike walks into the kitchen, sees Carol and Alice cooking strawberry preserves for the Charity Hoedown, takes a whiff and remarks, "This smells like strawberry heaven!" Reed contended that, per various encyclopedia articles, strawberries don't have scents and got into a huge argument with the writers. After several days of fighting and not wanting production delays over a minor point in the script, the writers conceded and changed Reed's line to "This looks like strawberry heaven." Strawberries, do in fact, have a very chemically complex scent. The Schwartzes (both Sherwood and Lloyd) and Barry Williams (in his own autobiography) note that disputes such as the above were commonplace, and Lloyd further added that in Reed's previous series, ''Series/{{The Defenders|1961}}'' (where he played an a young attorney), this was also a regular occurrence.

to:

** In his retrospective about ''The Brady Bunch'', Lloyd Schwartz recalled a dispute he had with Robert Reed over a line in the script for "Jan, the Only Child" where Mike walks into the kitchen, sees Carol and Alice cooking strawberry preserves for the Charity Hoedown, takes a whiff and remarks, "This smells like strawberry heaven!" Reed contended that, per various encyclopedia articles, strawberries don't have scents and got into a huge argument with the writers. After several days of fighting and not wanting production delays over a minor point in the script, the writers conceded and changed Reed's line to "This looks like strawberry heaven." (Although the line Reed would go on to use would be "I do believe I've died and gone to strawberry heaven." Strawberries, do in fact, have a very chemically complex scent. The Schwartzes (both Sherwood and Lloyd) and Barry Williams (in his own autobiography) note that disputes such as the above were commonplace, and Lloyd further added that in Reed's previous series, ''Series/{{The Defenders|1961}}'' (where he played an a young attorney), this was also a regular occurrence.


** In Season 3's "My Sister Benedict Arnold," Marcia (who at this point is in eighth grade) announces she's been asked out by a high school sophomore, Warren Mullaney (who is Greg's age). Carol -- with Alice smiling and nodding her approval as she remarks that "next, it will be college guys!" -- gives her permission to go on the date. The thought of Warren coming on to Marcia -- who possibly hadn't even turned 14 yet -- never crosses their minds, but today, the Brady parents would put a stop to the date ... and perhaps Mike would even tell Warren (and not-so-nicely at that) [[PapaWolf to stay the eff away from his family ... or else]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The oldest daughter's name is spelled "Marcia," not "Marsha."

to:

** The oldest daughter's name is spelled "Marcia," "Marcia” not "Marsha.""Marsha". Marsh-uh is also not the correct pronunciation of this Spanish name - it is Mar-see-uh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Cousin Oliver is often unfairly thought of as a horribly annoying character who directly led to the show's cancellation. In fact, he was really just a symptom of the overall decline the show was already in, with the writers clearly having no interest in actually doing anything with him once he was introduced.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 294

Changed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CommonKnowledge: Carol is commonly depicted as a widow, however it's never actually clarified what happened to her first husband. She was intended to be a divorcee, but the networks didn't agree on that, so her past marriage was kept ambiguous.

to:

* CommonKnowledge: CommonKnowledge:
**
Carol is commonly depicted as a widow, however it's never actually clarified what happened to her first husband. She was intended to be a divorcee, but the networks didn't agree on that, so her past marriage was kept ambiguous.ambiguous.
** The oldest daughter's name is spelled "Marcia," not "Marsha."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DoNotDoThisCoolThing: In "Will the Real Jan Brady Please Stand Up?" Mike and Carol lecture Jan about the folly of artificially changing her appearance by wearing a wig. The episode happens to fall right in the middle of a several-episode stretch in which Carol's signature "hair of gold" is dyed several shades darker.

Added: 268

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceColoringAdaptation: As the movies deliberately exaggerated the most memetic parts of the original series (like Jan's MiddleChildSyndrome and Marcia hurting her nose), their depictions of the characters tend to be the ones most remembered by modern audiences.



* ContestedSequel: While ''A Very Brady Sequel'' has by and large been VindicatedByHistory, whether it remains overshadowed by the first movie or is a SurprisinglyImprovedSequel is open for debate. In particular, arguments tend to crop up about whether the downplaying of Jan's CharacterExaggeration between the two was better or worse for her character.

to:

* ContestedSequel: While ''A Very Brady Sequel'' has by and large been VindicatedByHistory, whether it remains overshadowed by the first movie or is a SurprisinglyImprovedSequel is open for debate. In particular, arguments tend to crop up about whether the downplaying of Jan's CharacterExaggeration between the two was better or worse for her character.portrayal.

Added: 1664

Changed: 243

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContestedSequel: While ''A Very Brady Sequel'' has by and large been VindicatedByHistory, whether it remains overshadowed by the first movie or is a SurprisinglyImprovedSequel is open for debate. In particular, arguments tend to crop up about whether the downplaying of Jan's CharacterExaggeration between the two was better or worse for her character.



* CultClassic: Both the first and second films qualify in slightly different ways. Neither did well critically, but the first ended up a bonafide hit at the box office due to good word of mouth and is now often touted as one of the comedic high marks of UsefulNotes/TheNineties. The second didn't do nearly as well financially but has since been VindicatedByHistory for taking the humor of its predecessor in a more irreverent direction without losing its sharpness, and is today generally seen as a worthy or even SurprisinglyImprovedSequel. [[{{Sequelitis}} The third movie wasn't nearly as lucky]].



* HollywoodHomely: Jan and occasionally Peter.

to:

* HollywoodHomely: CharacterExaggeration causes the other characters to talk about Jan as though she were hideous despite her being perfectly fine-looking. This is all PlayedForLaughs and occasionally Peter.serves to further emphasize Jan's MiddleChildSyndrome opposite the stunning Marcia.


Added DiffLines:

* UncannyValley: The Bradys' wholesome seventies sitcom stylings are deliberately played up to make them seem rather strange and even slightly unsettling when compared to the world around them. In particular, Mike, Carol, and the older Brady children all speak in calm, measured tones of voice that no actual person ever would at all times.
* VindicatedByHistory: ''A Very Brady Sequel'' was less warmly received than the first film when it was released, but has since gained recognition as a solid movie in its own right. The shift away from the first movie's emphasis on juxtaposing the Bradys with the culture of UsefulNotes/TheNineties has even caused some to declare it to be a SurprisinglyImprovedSequel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MemeticMutation: When Creator/{{Netflix}} added ''A Very Brady Sequel'' in 2015, younger viewers got a kick out of the scene where Jan came up with her fake boyfriend George Glass, and 19 years after its original release, the scene became a huge Tumblr meme, centered on Marcia's "That's funny, I've never heard of a George Glass at ''our'' '''sküle'''", and her "Sure, Jan" becoming a popular reaction gif to express doubt at a statement.

to:

* MemeticMutation: When Creator/{{Netflix}} added ''A Very Brady Sequel'' in 2015, younger viewers got a kick out of the scene where Jan came up with her fake boyfriend George Glass, and 19 years after its original release, the scene it became a huge Tumblr meme, centered on Marcia's "That's funny, I've never heard of a George Glass at ''our'' '''sküle'''", and her "Sure, Jan" becoming a popular reaction gif to express doubt at a statement.

Changed: 838

Removed: 266

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The first film shows the family [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rKeqPEGMvM going to a Sears department store and singing "Sunshine Day"]]. At the time of the film's release (1995), Sears could be reasonably said to be one of the biggest department store chains in North America. Two decades later, the company went bankrupt in the face of mounting online pressure and competition from other retail chains. Ironically, the sequence (which appears to have been shot as a way to modernize the family after the MisterSandmanSequence introducing them to TheNineties) comes off as just as dated, albeit even more hilarious in retrospect.

to:

** The first film shows the family [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rKeqPEGMvM going to a Sears department store and singing "Sunshine Day"]]. At the time of the film's release (1995), Sears could be reasonably said to be one of the biggest department store chains in North America. Two decades later, the company went bankrupt in the face of mounting online pressure and competition from other retail chains. Ironically, While the sequence (which appears joke at the time was that the Bradys getting all excited about going to have been shot a large lower-end department store is a prime example of IncrediblyLameFun (though at least a bit more modern than their obsession with TheSeventies), these days, with Sears itself as a way to modernize relic of the family after the MisterSandmanSequence introducing past, it just makes them to TheNineties) comes off as just as look more dated, albeit even more hilarious in retrospect.and unintentionally makes the joke funnier.



* MemeticMutation:
** Somehow, 19 years after release, the scene when Jan came up with her fake boyfriend George Glass became a meme on Tumblr in 2015.
-->''I've never heard of a George Glass at ''our'' sküle.''
** "Sure, Jan." is used as a reaction gif to express doubt at a statement.

to:

* MemeticMutation:
** Somehow, 19 years after release,
MemeticMutation: When Creator/{{Netflix}} added ''A Very Brady Sequel'' in 2015, younger viewers got a kick out of the scene when where Jan came up with her fake boyfriend George Glass Glass, and 19 years after its original release, the scene became a meme on huge Tumblr in 2015.
-->''I've
meme, centered on Marcia's "That's funny, I've never heard of a George Glass at ''our'' sküle.''
**
'''sküle'''", and her "Sure, Jan." is used as Jan" becoming a popular reaction gif to express doubt at a statement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Sequelitis}}: ''A Very Brady Sequel'' wasn't as successful at the box office as the first movie, and was criticized for being a bit raunchier and relying too much on a stale plotline. (Ironically, it is better remembered ''today'' because it is the source of the "sküle" and "Sure, Jan" memes.) ''The Brady Bunch in the White House'' is unanimously considered less funny than the earlier movies.

to:

* {{Sequelitis}}: ''A Very Brady Sequel'' wasn't as successful at the box office as the first movie, office, and was criticized for being a bit raunchier and relying too much on more contrived than the first movie, though others felt it was a stale plotline.SurprisinglyImprovedSequel. (Ironically, it is better remembered ''today'' because it is the source of the "sküle" and "Sure, Jan" memes.) ''The Brady Bunch in the White House'' is unanimously considered less funny than the earlier movies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Sequelitis}}: ''A Very Brady Sequel'' wasn't as successful at the box office as the first movie, and was criticized for being a bit raunchier and relying too much on a stale plotline. ''The Brady Bunch in the White House'' is unanimously considered less funny than the earlier movies.

to:

* {{Sequelitis}}: ''A Very Brady Sequel'' wasn't as successful at the box office as the first movie, and was criticized for being a bit raunchier and relying too much on a stale plotline. (Ironically, it is better remembered ''today'' because it is the source of the "sküle" and "Sure, Jan" memes.) ''The Brady Bunch in the White House'' is unanimously considered less funny than the earlier movies.

Top