Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Inferno1988

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Marvel created ''Inferno'' just [[MurderTheHypotenuse to get rid of Pryor]] because StatusQuoIsGod makes it sacred that Grey and Cyclops exclusively belong together. Decades later, Marvel decides to imply that [[EpilepticTrees both Grey and Cyclops are casting aside monogamy and are embracing]] {{Polyamory}}.

to:

** Marvel created ''Inferno'' just [[MurderTheHypotenuse to get rid of Pryor]] because StatusQuoIsGod makes it sacred that Jean Grey and Cyclops exclusively belong together. Decades later, Marvel decides to imply that [[EpilepticTrees both Grey Jean and Cyclops are casting aside monogamy and are embracing]] {{Polyamory}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: Pryor got retconned as being a clone of Grey (one of the most popular X-Men) to turn Pryor [[ExpendableClone worthless and to kill her off]]. Years later Marvel brought in [[ComicBook/{{X23}} Laura Kinney (X-23)]], a ''female'' clone of Wolverine (the most popular of all the X-Men), and she has been [[ClonesArePeopleToo thriving as a supporting X-Men character]] and even made a character in [[Film/{{Logan}} a movie]].

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: Madelyne Pryor got retconned as being a clone of Jean Grey (one of the most popular X-Men) to turn Pryor [[ExpendableClone worthless and to kill her off]]. Years later Marvel brought in [[ComicBook/{{X23}} Laura Kinney (X-23)]], a ''female'' clone of Wolverine (the most popular of all the X-Men), and she has been [[ClonesArePeopleToo thriving as a supporting X-Men character]] and even made a character in [[Film/{{Logan}} a movie]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* EvilIsSexy: Madelyne as compared to Jean.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es), General clarification on works content


%%* EvilIsSexy: Madelyne as compared to Jean.

to:

%%* * EvilIsSexy: Madelyne as compared to Jean.



* SpiritualAdaptation: ''[[Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'''s season-5 finale episode, [[Recap/BuffyTheVampireSlayerS5E22TheGift "The Gift"]], is suspiciously similar in plot to Marvel's ''Inferno'', but subverts and inverts Marvel's storyline by (temporarily, of course) killing Buffy instead of Dawn Summers, who in several details is nearly an {{Expy}} of Madelyne Pryor. (The episode's title is also the same as an X-Men story in which Pryor is a main character.)

to:

* SpiritualAdaptation: ''[[Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'''s ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'''s season-5 finale episode, [[Recap/BuffyTheVampireSlayerS5E22TheGift "The Gift"]], is suspiciously similar in plot to Marvel's ''Inferno'', but subverts and inverts Marvel's storyline by (temporarily, of course) killing Buffy instead of Dawn Summers, who in several details is nearly an {{Expy}} of Madelyne Pryor. (The The episode's title is also the same as an [[ComicBook/AsgardianWars X-Men story and Alpha Flight story]] in which Pryor is a main character.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A [[Film/TheIsland 2005 film]], whose [[Creator/ScarlettJohansson lead actress]] would later be starring in the [[Franchise/MarvelCinematicUniverse MCU films]], is about clones being manufactured to be killed to provide organs for the people from whom they were cloned, with all the clones being the heroes and innocent victims, and most of the "normal" human characters being various levels of [[HumansAreBastards monsters, bastards, or indifferent]]. Briefly included in the film is a pregnant woman who is murdered after giving birth, and the baby then handed to a joyful woman from whom the birth mother was cloned.

to:

** A [[Film/TheIsland [[Film/TheIsland2005 2005 film]], whose [[Creator/ScarlettJohansson lead actress]] would later be starring in the [[Franchise/MarvelCinematicUniverse MCU films]], is about clones being manufactured to be killed to provide organs for the people from whom they were cloned, with all the clones being the heroes and innocent victims, and most of the "normal" human characters being various levels of [[HumansAreBastards monsters, bastards, or indifferent]]. Briefly included in the film is a pregnant woman who is murdered after giving birth, and the baby then handed to a joyful woman from whom the birth mother was cloned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Numerous mutant children ''besides'' the babies abducted by the demons are depicted in the orphanage secretly run by Mister Sinister, are rescued after the event, and were never seen again.

to:

** Numerous mutant children ''besides'' the babies abducted by the demons are depicted in the orphanage secretly run by Mister Sinister, are rescued by the X-Men from another gang of mutant kidnappers after the event, and then were never seen again.again unlike the babies.

Added: 494

Changed: 300

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: The demon [[TheChessmaster chessmaster]] N'Astirh is introduced, and killed, in this story arc. Given that he's just another magic-user, fans who think Belasco, the sorcerer who turned Illyana into Magik in the first place, should have returned for this instead consider his introduction to be this.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter:
**
The demon [[TheChessmaster chessmaster]] N'Astirh is introduced, and killed, in this story arc. Given that he's just another magic-user, fans who think Belasco, the sorcerer who turned Illyana into Magik in the first place, should have returned for this instead consider his introduction to be this.this.
** Numerous mutant children ''besides'' the babies abducted by the demons are depicted in the orphanage secretly run by Mister Sinister, are rescued after the event, and were never seen again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadExportForYou: The 2015 trade paperback contains numerous excerpts of the events' subplots and leadups in other comics and includes all of the issues of ''X-Terminators'' and relevant issues of ''New Mutants'', but cuts off its ''X-Factor'' reprints '''two issues'' before the actual confrontation between the X-Men and Madeleyne, meaning the story isn't actually complete!

to:

* BadExportForYou: The 2015 trade paperback contains numerous excerpts of the events' subplots and leadups in other comics and includes all of the issues of ''X-Terminators'' and relevant issues of ''New Mutants'', but cuts off its ''X-Factor'' reprints '''two issues'' issues''' before the actual confrontation between the X-Men and Madeleyne, meaning the story isn't actually complete!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadExportForYou: The 2015 trade paperback contains numerous excerpts of the events' subplots and leadups in other comics and includes all of the issues of ''X-Terminators'' and relevant issues of ''New Mutants'', but cuts off its ''X-Factor'' reprints '''two issues'' before the actual confrontation between the X-Men and Madeleyne, meaning the story isn't actually complete!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Decades later, many folks only remember ''Inferno'' for Pryor's outfit, [[ComicBook/XMenGrandDesign barely remembering or acknowledging]] anything else about ''Inferno'', including that [[DemotedToExtra Illyana and the New Mutants]] even had anything to do with it.

to:

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Decades later, many folks only remember ''Inferno'' for Pryor's outfit, barely remembering [[ComicBook/XMenGrandDesign barely remembering or acknowledging]] anything else about ''Inferno'', including that [[DemotedToExtra Illyana and the New Mutants]] even had anything to do with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Decades later, many folks only remember ''Inferno'' for Pryor's outfit, barely remembering or acknowledging anything else about ''Inferno'', including that Illyana and the New Mutants even had anything to do with it.

to:

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Decades later, many folks only remember ''Inferno'' for Pryor's outfit, [[ComicBook/XMenGrandDesign barely remembering or acknowledging acknowledging]] anything else about ''Inferno'', including that [[DemotedToExtra Illyana and the New Mutants Mutants]] even had anything to do with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Requires Word Of God confirmation


* AuthorsSavingThrow: A lot of fans had previously complained that the retcon that the Jean in ''ComicBook/TheDarkPhoenixSaga'' was actually the Phoenix Forces negated her sacrifice at the end of the story. This storyline explains that the Phoenix Force had actually absorbed a piece of Jean's soul when she became Phoenix, thus making her Jean for all intents and purposes. Furthermore, this story has Jean reclaiming the piece of her soul borrowed by the Phoenix Force along with all of her memories from her time as Phoenix.

Changed: 2

Removed: 308

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is not YMMV.


* AllForNothing: ''Inferno'' and Pryor being killed off, in Hindsight. 1) Everyone has seen how things went between Cyclops and Jean Grey. 2) Cyclops' reputation keeps re-sinking, even though Marvel keeps on trying to re-float him. 3) Grey's parents would later end up getting slaughtered... by space aliens.



* EvilIsSexy: Madelyne as compared to Jean.

to:

* %%* EvilIsSexy: Madelyne as compared to Jean.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Idiot Plot" is now Flame Bait.


* IdiotPlot:
** ...So, nobody thought to check out Madelyne's DNA to see if it matched Jean's?
** Why didn't Sinister just use Cyclops and Jean's DNA to create the baby instead of going to such convoluted extremes? Made even worse because ''that's exactly what he does'' in the AlternateUniverse crossover, The ComicBook/AgeOfApocalypse. Though the original comics implied that there was some wild-card component to the pairing he wanted that he couldn't just copy in a lab.
** Chalk it up to being written in the 1980s before "CSI" made everyone an inexpert forensic scientist. DNA testing was advanced significantly in the 1990s, which coincides with its appearance in many crime shows. Also, it would've been kind of a jerkish thing to do to Madelyne--"Please let me draw some of your blood, I want to DNA-test you to see you aren't a clone of my late wife" would sound rather creepy even in a superhero comic. [[NoSocialSkills Reed Richards]] might just possibly do that, but it's totally in character for Cyclops ''not'' to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualAdaptation: ''[[Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'''s season-5 finale episode, "The Gift", is suspiciously similar in plot to Marvel's ''Inferno'', but subverts and inverts Marvel's storyline by (temporarily, of course) killing Buffy instead of Dawn Summers, who in several details is nearly an {{Expy}} of Madelyne Pryor. (The episode's title is also the same as an X-Men story in which Pryor is a main character.)

to:

* SpiritualAdaptation: ''[[Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'''s season-5 finale episode, [[Recap/BuffyTheVampireSlayerS5E22TheGift "The Gift", Gift"]], is suspiciously similar in plot to Marvel's ''Inferno'', but subverts and inverts Marvel's storyline by (temporarily, of course) killing Buffy instead of Dawn Summers, who in several details is nearly an {{Expy}} of Madelyne Pryor. (The episode's title is also the same as an X-Men story in which Pryor is a main character.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Decades later, most folks only remember ''Inferno'' for Pryor's outfit. Most barely remember or acknowledge anything else about ''Inferno'', including that Illyana and the New Mutants had anything to do with it.

to:

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Decades later, most many folks only remember ''Inferno'' for Pryor's outfit. Most outfit, barely remember remembering or acknowledge acknowledging anything else about ''Inferno'', including that Illyana and the New Mutants even had anything to do with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many years after resorting to this massive and hyped crossover -- which came about because Jean Grey had been brought back, and to clear the path for Cyclops and Grey's relationship and eventual marriage -- Marvel then decides that in order to attract new generations of kids to their comics, their lead characters, including Cyclops with the notable exception of [[ComicBook/FantasticFour Reed Richards and Sue Storm]], must all be unmarried and single ([[ComicBook/OneMoreDay Spider-Man being the most notorious example of this policy]]). Also, Jean Grey's increasing redundancy of storylines and character arcs lead Marvel to have her sentenced to the ''DroppedABridgeOnHim'', not returning again for more than a decade.

to:

** Many years after resorting to this massive and hyped crossover -- which came about because Jean Grey had been brought back, and to clear the path for Cyclops and Grey's relationship and eventual marriage -- Marvel then decides that in order to attract new generations of kids to their comics, their lead characters, including Cyclops characters (but with the notable exception of [[ComicBook/FantasticFour Reed Richards and Sue Storm]], Storm]]), including Cyclops, must all be unmarried and single ([[ComicBook/OneMoreDay Spider-Man being the most notorious example of this policy]]). Also, Jean Grey's increasing redundancy of storylines and character arcs lead Marvel to have her sentenced to the ''DroppedABridgeOnHim'', not returning again for more than a decade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many years after resorting to this massive and hyped crossover -- which came about because Jean Grey had been brought back, and to clear the path for Cyclops and Grey's relationship and eventual marriage -- Marvel then decides that in order to attract new generations of kids to their comics, their lead characters, including Cyclops, must all be unmarried and single ([[ComicBook/OneMoreDay Spider-Man being the most notorious example of this policy]]). Also, Jean Grey's increasing redundancy of storylines and character arcs lead Marvel to have her sentenced to the ''DroppedABridgeOnHim'', not returning again for more than a decade.

to:

** Many years after resorting to this massive and hyped crossover -- which came about because Jean Grey had been brought back, and to clear the path for Cyclops and Grey's relationship and eventual marriage -- Marvel then decides that in order to attract new generations of kids to their comics, their lead characters, including Cyclops, Cyclops with the notable exception of [[ComicBook/FantasticFour Reed Richards and Sue Storm]], must all be unmarried and single ([[ComicBook/OneMoreDay Spider-Man being the most notorious example of this policy]]). Also, Jean Grey's increasing redundancy of storylines and character arcs lead Marvel to have her sentenced to the ''DroppedABridgeOnHim'', not returning again for more than a decade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllForNothing: ''Inferno'' and Pryor being killed off, in Hindsight. 1) Everyone has seen how things went between Cyclops and Jean Grey. 2) The reputation of Cyclops keeps re-sinking, even though Marvel keeps on trying to re-float him. 3) Grey's parents would later end up getting slaughtered... by space aliens.

to:

* AllForNothing: ''Inferno'' and Pryor being killed off, in Hindsight. 1) Everyone has seen how things went between Cyclops and Jean Grey. 2) The Cyclops' reputation of Cyclops keeps re-sinking, even though Marvel keeps on trying to re-float him. 3) Grey's parents would later end up getting slaughtered... by space aliens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllForNothing: ''Inferno'' and Pryor being killed off, in Hindsight. 1) Everyone has seen how things went between Cyclops and Jean Grey. 2) The reputation of Cyclops keeps re-sinking, even though Marvel keeps on trying to re-float him. 3) Grey's parents would later end up getting slaughtered... by space aliens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A [[Film/TheIsland 2005 film]], whose [[Creator/ScarlettJohansson lead actress]] would later be starring in the [[Franchise/MarvelCinematicUniverse MCU films]], is about clones being manufactured to be killed to provide organs for the people from whom they were cloned, with all the clones being the heroes and innocent victims, and most of the "normal" human characters being various levels of [[HumansAreBastards monsters, bastards, or indifferent]]. Briefly included in the film is a pregnant woman who is killed after giving birth, and the baby then handed to the joyful woman from whom the birth mother was cloned.

to:

** A [[Film/TheIsland 2005 film]], whose [[Creator/ScarlettJohansson lead actress]] would later be starring in the [[Franchise/MarvelCinematicUniverse MCU films]], is about clones being manufactured to be killed to provide organs for the people from whom they were cloned, with all the clones being the heroes and innocent victims, and most of the "normal" human characters being various levels of [[HumansAreBastards monsters, bastards, or indifferent]]. Briefly included in the film is a pregnant woman who is killed murdered after giving birth, and the baby then handed to the a joyful woman from whom the birth mother was cloned.

Added: 1506

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NightmareFuel: Many instances, but particularly when Madelyne tries to kill her own baby.

to:

* NightmareFuel: Many instances, but particularly when NightmareFuel:
** When
Madelyne tries to kill her own baby.baby.
** The event was filled with minor moments of mass murder/maimings as the city warps into living objects of death, gouging out peoples' eyes and trapping them for eternity in postage stamps. But worse is the murderous elevators: one elevator murders a tourist family, complete with the son screaming for his daddy to save the family as they are killed behind the doors of the elevator. Even worse, was a page cut from all printings of the Inferno in collected format from ''New Mutants'' #71: right after a scene where the villainous Hellfire Club members are forced to go out to save people from the attack of the demonic objects, we see people banging on an elevator door trying to flee the building. In the page that is cut, a still at this time completely 100% evil ComicBook/EmmaFrost is in telepathic linkage with the people as they flood into the now opening elevator, as she screams at them to not go into the elevator. Cut to the screaming sounds of the dying and the elevator reaching the first floor as Emma, in telepathic contact with the civilians as they are being murdered, screams in utter and complete horror as the elevator opens up and a tidal wave of blood pours out of it, with the skulls and corpses of the dead piled up inside the elevator. Also, the key plot point is that thirteen infants were supposed to be sacrificed. Thankfully this was averted; then, later subverted, as the U.S. government raised those infants into child soldiers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorsSavingThrow: A lot of fans had previously complained that the retcon that the Jean in ''ComicBook/TheDarkPhoenixSaga'' was actually the Phoenix Forces negated her sacrifice at the end of the story. This storyline explains that the Phoenix Force had actually absorbed a piece of Jean's soul when she became Phoenix, thus making her Jean for all intents and purposes. Furthermore, this story has Jean reclaiming the piece of her soul borrowed by the Phoenix Force along with all of her memories from her time as Phoenix.
* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Decades later, most folks only remember ''Inferno'' for Pryor's outfit. Most barely remember or acknowledge anything else about ''Inferno'', including that Illyana and the New Mutants had anything to do with it.
* EvilIsSexy: Madelyne as compared to Jean.
* HarsherInHindsight: Pryor got retconned as being a clone of Grey (one of the most popular X-Men) to turn Pryor [[ExpendableClone worthless and to kill her off]]. Years later Marvel brought in [[ComicBook/{{X23}} Laura Kinney (X-23)]], a ''female'' clone of Wolverine (the most popular of all the X-Men), and she has been [[ClonesArePeopleToo thriving as a supporting X-Men character]] and even made a character in [[Film/{{Logan}} a movie]].
* HilariousInHindsight:
** Many years after resorting to this massive and hyped crossover -- which came about because Jean Grey had been brought back, and to clear the path for Cyclops and Grey's relationship and eventual marriage -- Marvel then decides that in order to attract new generations of kids to their comics, their lead characters, including Cyclops, must all be unmarried and single ([[ComicBook/OneMoreDay Spider-Man being the most notorious example of this policy]]). Also, Jean Grey's increasing redundancy of storylines and character arcs lead Marvel to have her sentenced to the ''DroppedABridgeOnHim'', not returning again for more than a decade.
** After the [[Creator/{{Disney}} Disney Corporation]] acquired Marvel in 2009, fanart was being created of Disney characters represented as Marvel characters and vice-versa. One was of [[WesternAnimation/SleepingBeauty Maleficent]] as the Goblin Queen since it seemed a perfect match. But then came the 2014 film ''Film/{{Maleficent}}'' with a revisionist characterization. The ''ComicBook/SecretWars2015'' revisit to ''Inferno'' concludes with the Goblin Queen resembling Maleficent. And calls for Madelyne to be granted an official [[ComicBook/XMenGrandDesign canon re-evaluation]] keeps persisting decades later.
** A [[Film/TheIsland 2005 film]], whose [[Creator/ScarlettJohansson lead actress]] would later be starring in the [[Franchise/MarvelCinematicUniverse MCU films]], is about clones being manufactured to be killed to provide organs for the people from whom they were cloned, with all the clones being the heroes and innocent victims, and most of the "normal" human characters being various levels of [[HumansAreBastards monsters, bastards, or indifferent]]. Briefly included in the film is a pregnant woman who is killed after giving birth, and the baby then handed to the joyful woman from whom the birth mother was cloned.
** Marvel created ''Inferno'' just [[MurderTheHypotenuse to get rid of Pryor]] because StatusQuoIsGod makes it sacred that Grey and Cyclops exclusively belong together. Decades later, Marvel decides to imply that [[EpilepticTrees both Grey and Cyclops are casting aside monogamy and are embracing]] {{Polyamory}}.
* IdiotPlot:
** ...So, nobody thought to check out Madelyne's DNA to see if it matched Jean's?
** Why didn't Sinister just use Cyclops and Jean's DNA to create the baby instead of going to such convoluted extremes? Made even worse because ''that's exactly what he does'' in the AlternateUniverse crossover, The ComicBook/AgeOfApocalypse. Though the original comics implied that there was some wild-card component to the pairing he wanted that he couldn't just copy in a lab.
** Chalk it up to being written in the 1980s before "CSI" made everyone an inexpert forensic scientist. DNA testing was advanced significantly in the 1990s, which coincides with its appearance in many crime shows. Also, it would've been kind of a jerkish thing to do to Madelyne--"Please let me draw some of your blood, I want to DNA-test you to see you aren't a clone of my late wife" would sound rather creepy even in a superhero comic. [[NoSocialSkills Reed Richards]] might just possibly do that, but it's totally in character for Cyclops ''not'' to.
* MoralEventHorizon: An attempt to kill a dozen innocent babies including your own infant son just has to count as this.
* NightmareFuel: Many instances, but particularly when Madelyne tries to kill her own baby.
* SpiritualAdaptation: ''[[Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'''s season-5 finale episode, "The Gift", is suspiciously similar in plot to Marvel's ''Inferno'', but subverts and inverts Marvel's storyline by (temporarily, of course) killing Buffy instead of Dawn Summers, who in several details is nearly an {{Expy}} of Madelyne Pryor. (The episode's title is also the same as an X-Men story in which Pryor is a main character.)
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: The demon [[TheChessmaster chessmaster]] N'Astirh is introduced, and killed, in this story arc. Given that he's just another magic-user, fans who think Belasco, the sorcerer who turned Illyana into Magik in the first place, should have returned for this instead consider his introduction to be this.
* WTHCostumingDepartment: Havok's EvilCostumeSwitch apparently involved nothing but [[https://i.pinimg.com/736x/2a/2c/ae/2a2cae4b02037d68bd77f0fe691def69.jpg taking a knife to his regular costume.]]
----

Top