Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / CharmedS2E2MoralityBites

Go To

OR

Added: 952

Changed: 288

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeartwarmingInHindsight: It's said that Piper and Leo's marriage failed because she wouldn't let him clip his wings for her. Later that season, he's BroughtDownToNormal as part of a sacrifice to save Piper's life. And while his powers are restored, he gives them up for good in Season 7. All out of love for her.

to:

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: HeartwarmingInHindsight:
**
It's said that Piper and Leo's marriage failed because she wouldn't let him clip his wings for her. Later that season, he's BroughtDownToNormal as part of a sacrifice to save Piper's life. And while his powers are restored, he gives them up for good in Season 7. All out of love for her.
** In the BadFuture, Prue is a ruthless, corrupt executive that's such a workaholic that she has no one in personal life to miss her if she died. ("Here lies Prue. She worked hard," she observed.) Once back in the present, Prue resolves to not become like her future self by making time for things other than her job. Half a season down the line, she quits working at Buckland's to protest a business deal scamming a customer, ultimately ending up as a photographer (a job she considers more fulfilling on a personal level). Though she dies sooner than she would've in the BadFuture, her funeral is very well-attended, demonstrating that lots of people miss
her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Evil Is Sexy TRS; this has become an objective, in-universe trope.


* EvilIsSexy: Well 'evil' is only informed on Prue's part, as she assumes the body of her more corrupt future self. But she spends her time in a LittleBlackDress, with beautiful blonde long hair. Piper is notably the least corrupt of the future selves, and she's the most modestly dressed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fanon}}: Fans have come up with the theory that Phoebe's ShockAndAwe power is a manifestation of the empathy power she gains in Season 6. The Season 9 comics [[IKnewIt confirm]] that she is overloading her target's brain with the negative emotions she has experienced.

to:

* {{Fanon}}: Fans have come up with the theory that Phoebe's ShockAndAwe power is a manifestation of the empathy power she gains in Season 6. The Season 9 comics [[IKnewIt confirm]] that she is overloading her creating a feedback loop from the target's brain with the negative emotions she has experienced.that is capable of overloading their brain. The technique is also given the proper name of Psychic Reflection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkhorse: Melinda, Piper and Leo's daughter in the BadFuture. Even though Seasons 5 and 6 reveal that changing the timeline resulted in two sons, fans still liked the idea of her being born anyway. This became AscendedFanon in the series finale, which shows that Piper had a daughter too. She enjoys great fan press in next generation fics and has her own subplot in the [[SequelInAnotherMedium official Season 9 comics]].

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Melinda, Piper and Leo's daughter in the BadFuture. Even though Seasons 5 and 6 reveal that changing the timeline resulted in two sons, fans still liked the idea of her being born anyway. This became AscendedFanon in the series finale, which shows that Piper had a daughter too. She enjoys great fan press in next generation fics and has too, giving her her own subplot in the [[SequelInAnotherMedium official Season 9 comics]]. sequel comics]] and a brief cameo in one of the tie-in novels. She enjoys great fan press in next generation fics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rapunzel Hair is no longer a trope.


* EvilIsSexy: Well 'evil' is only informed on Prue's part, as she assumes the body of her more corrupt future self. But she spends her time in a LittleBlackDress, with beautiful blonde RapunzelHair. Piper is notably the least corrupt of the future selves, and she's the most modestly dressed.

to:

* EvilIsSexy: Well 'evil' is only informed on Prue's part, as she assumes the body of her more corrupt future self. But she spends her time in a LittleBlackDress, with beautiful blonde RapunzelHair.long hair. Piper is notably the least corrupt of the future selves, and she's the most modestly dressed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkhorse: Melinda, Piper and Leo's daughter in the BadFuture. Even though Seasons 5 and 6 reveal that changing the timeline resulted in two sons, fans still liked the idea of her being born anyway. This became AscendedFanon in the series finale, which shows that Piper had a daughter too. She enjoys great fan press in next generation fics.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Melinda, Piper and Leo's daughter in the BadFuture. Even though Seasons 5 and 6 reveal that changing the timeline resulted in two sons, fans still liked the idea of her being born anyway. This became AscendedFanon in the series finale, which shows that Piper had a daughter too. She enjoys great fan press in next generation fics.fics and has her own subplot in the [[SequelInAnotherMedium official Season 9 comics]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Anvilicious}}: Phoebe spells out the moral that might doesn't equal right, the wrong thing done for the right reasons is still the wrong thing, and JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope can start from little actions that build up over time.


Added DiffLines:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Melinda, Piper and Leo's daughter in the BadFuture. Even though Seasons 5 and 6 reveal that changing the timeline resulted in two sons, fans still liked the idea of her being born anyway. This became AscendedFanon in the series finale, which shows that Piper had a daughter too. She enjoys great fan press in next generation fics.


Added DiffLines:

** In the future, Phoebe is exposed as a witch but Prue and Piper have still preserved their cover. This is the opposite of how "All Hell Breaks Loose" goes - where Piper and Prue are exposed to the world and Phoebe is safe in the Underworld. Once again it results in the death of a Charmed One, and this time it's not fixed with a ResetButton.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Narm}}: Brian Krause's performance as the angry future Leo is especially forced.

Added: 1425

Changed: 34

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Despite the new fashions and hairstyles, none of the Halliwells looks that older ten years into the future. Given that they're implied to have created more personal gain spells, possibly they made one to slow the aging process.



* EvilIsSexy: Well 'evil' is only informed on Prue's part, as she assumes the body of her more corrupt future self. But she spends her time in a LittleBlackDress, with beautiful blonde RapunzelHair. Piper is notably the least corrupt of the future selves, and she's the most modestly dressed.



** Everyone's shock at Phoebe's future self becoming self-centred and killing someone with her powers. In Season 6 Phoebe starts misusing her powers for personal gain - even allowing a man to be killed by demons. She even gets punished by the Elders because of it. Luckily she does grow out of it by the last season.

to:

** Everyone's shock at Phoebe's future self becoming self-centred and killing someone with her powers. In Season 6 Phoebe starts misusing her powers for personal gain - even allowing a man to be killed by demons.demons (this man also a wanted murderer). She even gets punished by the Elders because of it. Luckily she does grow out of it by the last season.



** There's a scene where Prue discovers her future self is about to lay off loads of employees. The episode is set one year after the 2008 recession, which the writers obviously couldn't have foreseen, but it retroactively makes future Prue even more corrupt; she's about to lay off a bunch of workers during a recession when she has a spell to create money.
* HeartwarmingInHindsight: It's said that Piper and Leo's marriage failed because she wouldn't let him clip his wings for her. Later that season, he's BroughtDownToNormal as part of a sacrifice to save Piper's life. And while his powers are restored, he gives them up for good in Season 7. All out of love for her.



** Phoebe is shown levitating Cal Greene into the air in her premonition. At the end of the season she's temporarily given the power to fly - and then develops it naturally in Season 3.

to:

** Phoebe is shown levitating Cal Greene into the air in her premonition. At the end of the season she's temporarily given the power to fly - and then develops it naturally in Season 3.3.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: A BadFuture in which modern day witch burnings happen, and the accused have to live underground. That's some impressive material for a whole season in its own right.

Added: 1236

Changed: 313

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenBase: Fans can be a bit divided on the episode's Aesop; one camp finds it to be straddling the CantGetAwayWithNuthin line, while others agree with Phoebe's point that "once you break the small rules, it's only a matter of time before the big ones are next."



* HarsherInHindsight: Everyone's shock at Phoebe's future self becoming self-centred and killing someone with her powers. In Season 6 Phoebe starts misusing her powers for personal gain - even allowing a man to be killed by demons. She even gets punished by the Elders because of it. Luckily she does grow out of it by the last season.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: HarsherInHindsight:
**
Everyone's shock at Phoebe's future self becoming self-centred and killing someone with her powers. In Season 6 Phoebe starts misusing her powers for personal gain - even allowing a man to be killed by demons. She even gets punished by the Elders because of it. Luckily she does grow out of it by the last season.season.
** Prue being shown in a BadFuture where she's implied to be estranged from her sisters. In Season 3 she's KilledOffForReal which it turns out is a consequence of avoiding this particular future. Piper even lampshades this in Season 5.
* HilariousInHindsight:
** The hairstyles on the sisters' future selves - where Phoebe and Prue's are really different but Piper's isn't - reflects how Holly Marie Combs would notably not change her hair very much throughout the series.
** Phoebe is shown levitating Cal Greene into the air in her premonition. At the end of the season she's temporarily given the power to fly - and then develops it naturally in Season 3.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fanon}}: Fans have come up with the theory that Phoebe's ShockAndAwe power is a manifestation of the empathy power she gains in Season 6.

to:

* {{Fanon}}: Fans have come up with the theory that Phoebe's ShockAndAwe power is a manifestation of the empathy power she gains in Season 6. The Season 9 comics [[IKnewIt confirm]] that she is overloading her target's brain with the negative emotions she has experienced.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanficFuel: Of what parts of the bad future were and weren't changed. Likewise what happened to other characters such as Nathaniel Pratt and Cal Greene. The Season 9 comics revisit this plot and reveal that the friend Greene murdered was [[spoiler: Elise Rothman]].
* {{Fanon}}: Fans have come up with the theory that Phoebe's ShockAndAwe power is a manifestation of the empathy power she gains in Season 6.
* FansPreferTheNewHer: Prue looks fantastic as a blonde, despite it being a reflection of her CorruptCorporateExecutive self.
* HarsherInHindsight: Everyone's shock at Phoebe's future self becoming self-centred and killing someone with her powers. In Season 6 Phoebe starts misusing her powers for personal gain - even allowing a man to be killed by demons. She even gets punished by the Elders because of it. Luckily she does grow out of it by the last season.

Top