Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / AliceGirlFromTheFuture

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FandomSpecificPlot:
** Many fanfics have Alice and her 20th century friends meet again, thanks to a SequelHook in the end of ''One Hundred Years Ahead''.
** There is also a prominent count of fanfics that reveal Alice’s utopian future as a CrapsaccharineWorld.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''A Girl From Earth'': [[spoiler:The Third Captain]] is continuously tortured for ''four years'', and if it hadn’t been for Alice [[spoiler:hearing his groans and realizing someone else was imprisoned in the dungeon]], he would have been left for dead.

to:

** ''A Girl From Earth'': ''Literature/TheVoyageOfAlice'': [[spoiler:The Third Captain]] is continuously tortured for ''four years'', and if it hadn’t been for Alice [[spoiler:hearing his groans and realizing someone else was imprisoned in the dungeon]], he would have been left for dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeBrilliance: The numerous cases of CanonDiscontinuity are actually justified, since the stories simply take place in several highly similar parallel worlds. The existence of such worlds is confirmed as canon in the short stories ''Is It You, Alice?'' (where the crew of the ''Pegasus'' meet themselves from another world) and ''Alice and Alicia'' (where Alice and Pashka are forced to have several trips between parallel worlds, thanks to Alicia – Alice’s counterpart from one of them – wishing for a butterfly from a species extinct in her universe).

to:

* FridgeBrilliance: The numerous cases of CanonDiscontinuity ContinuitySnarl are actually justified, since the stories simply take place in several highly similar parallel worlds. The existence of such worlds is confirmed as canon in the short stories ''Is It You, Alice?'' (where the crew of the ''Pegasus'' meet themselves from another world) and ''Alice and Alicia'' (where Alice and Pashka are forced to have several trips between parallel worlds, thanks to Alicia – Alice’s counterpart from one of them – wishing for a butterfly from a species extinct in her universe).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonImmigrant: Werther the robot was a CanonForeigner in ''Series/GuestFromTheFuture'' whom the fans immediately adored. After that, he made small cameos in several later-written books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Sequelitis}}: Even many of the most devoted fans admit that the plot and writing in the last stories seem forced in comparison to the earlier ones. Understandable, since the utopian future by itself has stopped being interesting (especially with real-life technology's rapid development in the 1990s and the 2000s) and the space pirates have essentially ceased to be a threat to Alice, making it difficult for the author to rely on the setting and one of the major plot lines, so that he turned to including fantasy and/or historical fiction elements. However, the point when the decline begins and the extent to which it goes (some fans outright refuse to read the later books, some think them good, just not as brilliant as the earlier ones) are the source of debate (see BrokenBase above).

to:

* {{Sequelitis}}: Even many of the most devoted fans admit that the plot and writing in the last stories seem forced in comparison to the earlier ones. Understandable, since the utopian future by itself has stopped being interesting (especially with real-life technology's rapid development in the 1990s and the 2000s) and the space pirates have essentially ceased to be a threat to Alice, making it difficult for the author to rely on the setting and one of the major plot lines, so that he turned to including fantasy and/or historical fiction elements. However, the point when the decline begins and the extent to which it goes (some fans outright refuse to read the later books, some think them good, just not as brilliant as the earlier ones) are the a source of debate (see BrokenBase above).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkhorse: Alice’s 20th-century classmates only appear in ''One Hundred Years Ahead'', and except for Kolya [[spoiler:Naumov]], only in the second part. They are among the most beloved characters of the franchise. Justified, since, first, there is the wildly popular [[Series/GuestFromTheFuture adaptation]], second, unlike the multitalented, superheroic kids of Alice's own time, the 6A class is more suitable as an AudienceSurrogate for the readers.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Alice’s 20th-century classmates only appear in ''One Hundred Years Ahead'', and except for Kolya [[spoiler:Naumov]], only in the second part. They are among the most beloved characters of the franchise. Justified, since, first, there is the wildly popular [[Series/GuestFromTheFuture adaptation]], second, unlike the multitalented, superheroic kids of Alice's own time, the 6A 6B class is more suitable as an AudienceSurrogate for the readers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CanonImmigrant: Werther the robot was a CanonForeigner in ''Series/GuestFromTheFuture'' whom the fans immediately adored. After that, he made small cameos in several later-written books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Alice’s 20th-century classmates only appear in ''One Hundred Years Ahead'', and except for Kolya [[spoiler:Naumov]], only in the second part. They are among the most beloved characters of the franchise. Justified, since, first, there is the wildly popular [[Series/GuestFromTheFuture adaptation]], second, unlike the multitalented, superheroic kids of Alice's own time, the 6A class is more suitable as an AudienceSurrogate for the readers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Sequelitis}}: Even many of the most devoted fans admit that the plot and writing in the last stories seem forced in comparison to the earlier ones. Understandable, since the utopian future by itself has stopped being interesting (especially with real-life technology's rapid development in the 1990s and the 2000s) amd the space pirates have essentially ceased to be a threat to Alice, making it difficult for the author to rely on the setting and one of the major plot lines, so that he turned to including fantasy and/or historical fiction elements. However, the point when the decline begins and the extent to which it goes (some fans outright refuse to read the later books, some think them good, just not as brilliant as the earlier ones) are the source of debate (see BrokenBase above).

to:

* {{Sequelitis}}: Even many of the most devoted fans admit that the plot and writing in the last stories seem forced in comparison to the earlier ones. Understandable, since the utopian future by itself has stopped being interesting (especially with real-life technology's rapid development in the 1990s and the 2000s) amd and the space pirates have essentially ceased to be a threat to Alice, making it difficult for the author to rely on the setting and one of the major plot lines, so that he turned to including fantasy and/or historical fiction elements. However, the point when the decline begins and the extent to which it goes (some fans outright refuse to read the later books, some think them good, just not as brilliant as the earlier ones) are the source of debate (see BrokenBase above).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Sequelitis}}: Even many of the most devoted fans admit that the plot and writing in the last stories seem forced in comparison to the earlier ones. Understandable, since the utopian future by itself has stopped being interesting (especially with real-life technology's rapid development in the 1990s and the 2000s) amd the space pirates have essentially ceased to be a threat to Alice, making it difficult for the author to rely on the setting and one of the major plot lines, so that he turned to including fantasy and/or historical fiction elements. However, the point when the decline begins and the extent to which it goes (some fans outright refuse to read the later books, some think them good, just not as brilliant as the earlier ones) are the source of debate (see BrokenBase above).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt: Related to AngstWhatAngst above. It's a long-running children's light sci-fi series, and Alice is the wildly popular protagonist and a KidHero. Can anyone (including her) believe she might die at any point at all? This gets so blatantly obvious with the growing MediumAwareness that Granny Lucretia [[spoiler:waits to rescue her from man-eating rabbits until the last second to make it properly dramatic]] and Rat tells her when she attempts a HeroicSacrifice that he won't kill her because Kir Bulychev has to write his books about ''somebody''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For all that ''The War With Lilliputians'' is one of the most cheerful books of the series, it also happens to include the Panchenga clan. Old Panchenga [[spoiler:keeps prominent academics captive and blackmails them with their loved ones’ lives to make them work for him]]. Panchenga Skuliti is a pirate. Panchenga Muliti keeps the children of his relatives’ captives as slaves on his plantation and treats them horribly (it’s implied the elder girls are subjected to sexual abuse), and if they manage to get away (by being handed over to unsuspecting patrons), they are frightened into silence and never speak of Panchenga’s crimes. The Panchengas’ crimes disgust [[EvenEvilHasStandards Rat and Jolly U]] (the same ones responsible for the FridgeHorror entry from ''A Girl From Earth'' above).

to:

** For all that ''The War With Lilliputians'' is one of the most cheerful books of the series, it also happens to include the Panchenga clan. Old Panchenga [[spoiler:keeps prominent academics captive and blackmails them with their loved ones’ lives to make them work for him]]. Panchenga Skuliti is a pirate. Panchenga Muliti keeps the children of his relatives’ captives as slaves on his plantation and treats them horribly (it’s implied the elder girls are subjected to sexual abuse), and if they manage to get away (by being handed over to unsuspecting patrons), they are frightened into silence and never speak of Panchenga’s crimes.silence. The Panchengas’ crimes disgust [[EvenEvilHasStandards Rat and Jolly U]] (the same ones responsible for the FridgeHorror entry from ''A Girl From Earth'' above).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For all that ''The War With Lilliputians'' is one of the most cheerful books of the series, it also happens to include the Panchenga clan. Old Panchenga [[spoiler:keeps prominent academics captive and blackmails them with their loved ones’ lives to make them work for him]]. Panchenga Skuliti is a pirate. Panchenga Muliti keeps the children of his relatives’ captives as slaves on his plantation and treats them horribly (it’s implied the elder girls are subjected to sexual abuse), and if they manage to get away (by being handed over to unsuspecting patrons), they are frightened into silence and never speak of Panchenga’s crimes. The Panchengas’ crimes disgust Rat and Jolly U, which is ''something''.

to:

** For all that ''The War With Lilliputians'' is one of the most cheerful books of the series, it also happens to include the Panchenga clan. Old Panchenga [[spoiler:keeps prominent academics captive and blackmails them with their loved ones’ lives to make them work for him]]. Panchenga Skuliti is a pirate. Panchenga Muliti keeps the children of his relatives’ captives as slaves on his plantation and treats them horribly (it’s implied the elder girls are subjected to sexual abuse), and if they manage to get away (by being handed over to unsuspecting patrons), they are frightened into silence and never speak of Panchenga’s crimes. The Panchengas’ crimes disgust [[EvenEvilHasStandards Rat and Jolly U, which is ''something''.U]] (the same ones responsible for the FridgeHorror entry from ''A Girl From Earth'' above).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FridgeBrilliance: The numerous cases of CanonDiscontinuity are actually justified, since the stories simply take place in several highly similar parallel worlds. The existence of such worlds is confirmed as canon in the short stories ''Is It You, Alice?'' (where the crew of the ''Pegasus'' meet themselves from another world) and ''Alice and Alicia'' (where Alice and Pashka are forced to have several trips between parallel worlds, thanks to Alicia – Alice’s counterpart from one of them – wishing for a butterfly from a species extinct in her universe).

Added: 1457

Changed: 702

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeHorror: ''Secret Of the Black Stone'', the fate of other children: [[spoiler: hundreds if not thousands of them were killed in the war already, but Alice doesn't dwell on it...]].
** Also the children in ''The Star Dog''. The BigBad kidnaps juvenile delinquents and puts them into a school where he intends to raise them into professional criminals. The subjects in that "school" include not only pickpocketing and fighting, but also, for example, [[BadPeopleAbuseAnimals torture of animals]]. Moreover, at some point all children are brainwashed into blindly worshipping their "teachers".

to:

* FridgeHorror: ''Secret The author liked to drop subtle hints at the… not so funny things.
** ''A Girl From Earth'': [[spoiler:The Third Captain]] is continuously tortured for ''four years'', and if it hadn’t been for Alice [[spoiler:hearing his groans and realizing someone else was imprisoned in the dungeon]], he would have been left for dead.
** ''The Secret
Of the Black Stone'', the fate of other children: [[spoiler: hundreds if not thousands of them were have been killed in the war already, but Alice doesn't dwell on it...]].
it…]].
** Also the children in ''The Star Dog''. The BigBad kidnaps juvenile delinquents and puts them into a school where he intends to raise them into professional criminals. The subjects in that "school" include not only pickpocketing and fighting, but also, for example, [[BadPeopleAbuseAnimals torture of animals]]. Moreover, at some point all children are brainwashed into blindly worshipping their "teachers"."teachers".
** For all that ''The War With Lilliputians'' is one of the most cheerful books of the series, it also happens to include the Panchenga clan. Old Panchenga [[spoiler:keeps prominent academics captive and blackmails them with their loved ones’ lives to make them work for him]]. Panchenga Skuliti is a pirate. Panchenga Muliti keeps the children of his relatives’ captives as slaves on his plantation and treats them horribly (it’s implied the elder girls are subjected to sexual abuse), and if they manage to get away (by being handed over to unsuspecting patrons), they are frightened into silence and never speak of Panchenga’s crimes. The Panchengas’ crimes disgust Rat and Jolly U, which is ''something''.
** See the separate Fridge entry for ''Fridge/TheCityWithoutMemory'': being set in a rather grim MedievalStasis world, sometimes the novel drips FridgeHorror.

Added: 1474

Changed: 197

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: Alice has many many close calls with death and/or AFateWorseThanDeath, but she rarely shows any trauma from this.
* FridgeHorror: ''Secret Of the Black Stone'', the fate of other children: [[spoiler: hundreds if not thousands of them were killed in the war already, but Alice doesn't dwell on it...]]

to:

* AngstWhatAngst: Alice has many many, many close calls with death and/or AFateWorseThanDeath, but she rarely shows any trauma from this.
* BrokenBase: Being so popular and long-running, the franchise is bound to have multiple cases of it. These are only the best-known ones.
** There are fans of Book!Alice, fans of [[Series/GuestFromTheFuture Natalia Guseva's Alice]], fans who like both and think they're one and the same, and fans who like both but say they are different.
** The 2009 animated adaptation of ''Alice's Birthday''. Excellent? Good enough? SoOkayItsAverage? Awful?
** Some fans are excited to see an ''Alice'' book adapted to the screen again, and some are firm in their belief that the Soviet adaptations can't be surpassed.
** Which books (if any) suffer from {{Sequelitis}}?
** Kir Bulychev's decision not to write about an aged-up Alice. Some love it, some don't care, and some hate the fact (especially considering, for example, the SequelHook for ''Literature/TheCityWithoutMemory'').
** The VillainDecay of Rat and Jolly U. Some fans think that they were much more impressive and believable in their iconic appearances in ''A Girl from Earth'' or ''One Hundred Years Ahead'', others love their FriendlyEnemy interactions with Alice in the later books.
** The {{Crossover}} with the author's own ''Intergalactic Police'' series. Some fans love the merging of the two continuities, especially Cora acting as CoolBigSis for Alice, others say that ''Intergalactic Police'' was intended as an "adult Alice for adults", so the continuities can't mix.
* FridgeHorror: ''Secret Of the Black Stone'', the fate of other children: [[spoiler: hundreds if not thousands of them were killed in the war already, but Alice doesn't dwell on it...]]]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngstWhatAngst: Alice has many many close calls with death and/or AFateWorseThanDeath, but she never shows any trauma from this.

to:

* AngstWhatAngst: Alice has many many close calls with death and/or AFateWorseThanDeath, but she never rarely shows any trauma from this.

Changed: 471

Removed: 625

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Unfortunate Implications require citations.


* UnfortunateImplications: It might be that or even GettingCrapPastTheRadar. In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is rather a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice, justified as they have a case of EnemyMine. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve'' (or thirteen, according to the fans' research – not that it makes it less squicky). Also, he used to shapeshift into her on at least one occasion.
-->'''Rat''': See you in the palace, kitten!
-->(Laughs out loud as if Alice were his best friend).
** Alice is attracted to his new form of a golden-haired young man, and muses a bit too often that the pirates aren't really that bad and that she's quite used to them. She ends up offering to bandage Rat when he's hit by a blaster shot, but he refuses. Whether all this is intentional buildup on Bulychev's part is doubtful, but in the first half of the book Alice's maturing into a teenager was explicitly mentioned and discussed by her family, and awkwardness ensued in her relations with her best friends Pavel and Arkasha.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: It might be that or even GettingCrapPastTheRadar. In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is rather a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice, justified as they have a case of EnemyMine. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve'' (or thirteen, according to the fans' research – not that it makes it less squicky). Also, he used to shapeshift into her on at least one occasion.
-->'''Rat''': See you in the palace, kitten!
-->(Laughs out loud as if Alice were his best friend).
** Alice is attracted to his new form of a golden-haired young man, and muses a bit too often that the pirates aren't really that bad and that she's quite used to them. She ends up offering to bandage Rat when he's hit by a blaster shot, but he refuses. Whether all this is intentional buildup on Bulychev's part is doubtful, but in the first half of the book Alice's maturing into a teenager was explicitly mentioned and discussed by her family, and awkwardness ensued in her relations with her best friends Pavel and Arkasha.
----

Changed: 369

Removed: 417

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also the children in ''The Star Dog''.
*** What happened to them?
** In ''The Star Dog'', the BigBad kidnaps juvenile delinquents and puts them into a school where he intends to raise them into professional criminals. The subjects in that "school" include not only pickpocketing and fighting, but also, for example, [[BadPeopleAbuseAnimals torture of animals]]. Moreover, at some point all children are brainwashed into blindly worshipping their "teachers".

to:

** Also the children in ''The Star Dog''.
*** What happened to them?
** In ''The Star Dog'', the
Dog''. The BigBad kidnaps juvenile delinquents and puts them into a school where he intends to raise them into professional criminals. The subjects in that "school" include not only pickpocketing and fighting, but also, for example, [[BadPeopleAbuseAnimals torture of animals]]. Moreover, at some point all children are brainwashed into blindly worshipping their "teachers".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications: It might be that or even GettingCrapPastTheRadar. In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is rather a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice, justified as they have a case of EnemyMine. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve''. Also, he used to shapeshift into her on at least one occasion.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: It might be that or even GettingCrapPastTheRadar. In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is rather a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice, justified as they have a case of EnemyMine. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve''.''twelve'' (or thirteen, according to the fans' research – not that it makes it less squicky). Also, he used to shapeshift into her on at least one occasion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''The Star Dog'', the BigBad kidnaps juvenile delinquents and puts them into a school where he intends to raise them into professional criminals. The subjects in that "school" include not only pickpocketing and fighting, but also, for example, [[BadPeopleAbuseAnimals torture of animals]]. Moreover, at some point all children are brainwashed into blindly worshipping their "teachers".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications: It might be that or even GettingCrapPastTheRadar. In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is rather a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice, justified as they have a case of EnemyMine. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve''.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: It might be that or even GettingCrapPastTheRadar. In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is rather a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice, justified as they have a case of EnemyMine. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve''. Also, he used to shapeshift into her on at least one occasion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


: Alice, on her side, is attracted to his new form of a golden-haired young man, and muses a bit too often that the pirates aren't really that bad and that she's quite used to them. She ends up offering to bandage Rat when he's hit by a blaster shot, but he refuses. Whether all this is intentional buildup on Bulychev's part is doubtful, but in the first half of the book Alice's maturing into a teenager was explicitly mentioned and discussed by her family, and awkwardness ensues in her relations with her best friends Pavel and Arkasha.

to:

: Alice, on her side, ** Alice is attracted to his new form of a golden-haired young man, and muses a bit too often that the pirates aren't really that bad and that she's quite used to them. She ends up offering to bandage Rat when he's hit by a blaster shot, but he refuses. Whether all this is intentional buildup on Bulychev's part is doubtful, but in the first half of the book Alice's maturing into a teenager was explicitly mentioned and discussed by her family, and awkwardness ensues ensued in her relations with her best friends Pavel and Arkasha.

Added: 638

Changed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications: In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve''.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: It might be that or even GettingCrapPastTheRadar. In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is rather a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice. Alice, justified as they have a case of EnemyMine. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve''.''twelve''.
-->'''Rat''': See you in the palace, kitten!
-->(Laughs out loud as if Alice were his best friend).
: Alice, on her side, is attracted to his new form of a golden-haired young man, and muses a bit too often that the pirates aren't really that bad and that she's quite used to them. She ends up offering to bandage Rat when he's hit by a blaster shot, but he refuses. Whether all this is intentional buildup on Bulychev's part is doubtful, but in the first half of the book Alice's maturing into a teenager was explicitly mentioned and discussed by her family, and awkwardness ensues in her relations with her best friends Pavel and Arkasha.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Moe}}: Alice.

to:

* {{Moe}}: Alice.Alice.
* UnfortunateImplications: In ''The War with Liliputs'', there is a bit of FoeYay between Rat and Alice. It wouldn't be a problem but for the fact that he's (in his true form) a scorpion-like creature and she's ''twelve''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** What happened to them?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also the children in ''The Star Dog''.

to:

** Also the children in ''The Star Dog''.Dog''.
* {{Moe}}: Alice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut for having no context; if anyone wants to re-add, discuss it here first.


* CompleteMonster: Jolly U and Rat are actually diagnosed with total atrophy of conscience. Apparently, this is the one mental disease that is still incurable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: Jolly U and Rat are actually diagnosed with total atrophy of conscience. Apparently, this is the one mental disease which is still incurable.

to:

* CompleteMonster: Jolly U and Rat are actually diagnosed with total atrophy of conscience. Apparently, this is the one mental disease which that is still incurable.

Added: 387

Changed: 214

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
transplanted examples from main page


* CompleteMonster: Jolly U and Rat are actually diagnosed with total atrophy of conscience. Apparently, this is the one mental disease which is still incurable.

to:

* AngstWhatAngst: Alice has many many close calls with death and/or AFateWorseThanDeath, but she never shows any trauma from this.
* CompleteMonster: Jolly U and Rat are actually diagnosed with total atrophy of conscience. Apparently, this is the one mental disease which is still incurable.incurable.
* FridgeHorror: ''Secret Of the Black Stone'', the fate of other children: [[spoiler: hundreds if not thousands of them were killed in the war already, but Alice doesn't dwell on it...]]
** Also the children in ''The Star Dog''.

Top