Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / BeautyAndTheBeast2017

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Jean's actor, Gerard Horan, is also in Cinderella as Lord Veneering, so if we're going incredibly meta, then Jean is an ancestor of Lord Veneering (or vice-versa).

to:

Jean's actor, Gerard Horan, is also in Cinderella as Lord Veneering, so if we're going incredibly meta, then Jean is an ancestor of Lord Veneering (or vice-versa).vice-versa).
* Adding to this, they both exist in a world where magical beings go around testing people's kindness disguised as beggars. Maybe the Fairy Godmother and the Enchantress are in cahoots?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Gaston will be SparedByTheAdaptation and, in keeping with the movie's feminist themes, his hypermasculine persona will be shown as a mask he puts on due to society's pressures on men. Belle will encourage [=LeFou=] to use love to bring out the best in him, just as she did for the Beast.

to:

Gaston will be SparedByTheAdaptation and, in keeping with the movie's feminist themes, and his hypermasculine persona will be shown as a mask he puts on due to society's pressures on men. Belle will encourage [=LeFou=] to use love to bring out the best in him, just as she did for the Beast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When the curse is explained in the intro, it's mentioned that all memories of the castle have been erased from the villagers' memories.

to:

** When the curse is explained in the intro, it's mentioned that all memories of the prince and the castle have been completely erased from the villagers' memories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** When the curse is explained in the intro, it's mentioned that all memories of the castle have been erased from the villagers' memories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Which is why Belle didn't use it to get back to the village to save her father. It's also why Belle's childhood home looks so well-preserved when they go there...I have no idea how she got the rose thing though. Magic or something.

to:

Which is why Belle didn't use it to get back to the village to save her father. It's also why Belle's childhood home looks so well-preserved when they go there...I have no idea how she got the rose thing though. Magic or something.something.

[[WMG: Beauty and the Beast and Cinderella are set in the same universe, and are linked through Jean the potter.]]
Jean's actor, Gerard Horan, is also in Cinderella as Lord Veneering, so if we're going incredibly meta, then Jean is an ancestor of Lord Veneering (or vice-versa).

Added: 418

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: One of Belle's inventions will be a ChekhovsGun.

to:

[[WMG: One of Belle's inventions will be a ChekhovsGun.]]



The propensity of magic in the story makes me want to connect it to the HarryPotter universe. Hermione decided to take a year off after the Battle of Hogwarts, went on a time travel vacation, and assumed the identity of Belle, but forgot her wand. Both characters are played by Creator/EmmaWatson, love reading, and are in excessively magical circumstances at a castle. This is a 'sequel' to Harry Potter's experiences with TheWomanInBlack.

to:

The propensity of magic in the story makes me want to connect it to the HarryPotter universe. Hermione decided to take a year off after the Battle of Hogwarts, went on a time travel vacation, and assumed the identity of Belle, but forgot her wand. Both characters are played by Creator/EmmaWatson, love reading, and are in excessively magical circumstances at a castle. This is a 'sequel' to Harry Potter's experiences with TheWomanInBlack.TheWomanInBlack.

[[WMG: The Portal Book can show you a copy of another place and time, but it cannot actually teleport a person to a physical place or show any people other than the ones using the book.]]
Which is why Belle didn't use it to get back to the village to save her father. It's also why Belle's childhood home looks so well-preserved when they go there...I have no idea how she got the rose thing though. Magic or something.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** If the film credits are anything to go by, the employee is indeed Monsieur D'Arque.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It is strongly implied the curse created by the Enchantress was actually only temporary and that the Enchantress was going to return everything back to the way it was, regardless if Belle said she loved Beast or not. Despite Belle saying she loves Beast, after the rose lost its last petal, the Enchantress who was disguised as Agathe the old woman Belle showed kindness to, knew Belle was the chosen one as Lumiere predicted and she rather set up the whole story so that Belle will break the spell. In short, the Enchantress was really a chess master and knew the prince was cold hearted at the start of the film but wanted to test his attitude. So she really only punished Beast for a limited time so he can have a chance to think about what he had done and to redeem himself and it works.

to:

It is strongly implied the curse created by the Enchantress was actually only temporary and that the Enchantress was going to return everything back to the way it was, regardless if Belle said she loved Beast or not. Despite Belle saying she loves Beast, after the rose lost its last petal, the Enchantress who was disguised as Agathe the old beggar woman Belle showed kindness to, knew Belle was the chosen one as Lumiere predicted and she rather set up the whole story so that Belle will break the spell. In short, the Enchantress was really a chess master and knew the prince was cold hearted at the start of the film but wanted to test his attitude. So she really only punished Beast for a limited time so he can have a chance to think about what he had done and to redeem himself and it works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Confirmed.''' The movie gives him an entire arc of realizing that Gaston is a much worse person than he thought he was, and taht he can do better.

to:

** '''Confirmed.''' The movie gives him an entire arc of realizing that Gaston is a much worse person than he thought he was, and taht that he can do better.



[[WMG: This Film is about what Hermoine Granger did on her Gap year before university]]
the propensity of magic in the story, makes me want to connect it to the HarryPotter universe. Hermoine decided to take a year off after the battle of Hogwarts, went on a time travel vacation, and assumed the identity of belle, but forgot her wand. both characters are played by Emma Watson, love reading, and are in excessively magical circumstances at a castle. this is a 'sequel' to harry potters experiences with TheWomanInBlack.

to:

[[WMG: This Film film is about what Hermoine Hermione Granger did on her Gap gap year before university]]
the The propensity of magic in the story, story makes me want to connect it to the HarryPotter universe. Hermoine Hermione decided to take a year off after the battle Battle of Hogwarts, went on a time travel vacation, and assumed the identity of belle, Belle, but forgot her wand. both Both characters are played by Emma Watson, Creator/EmmaWatson, love reading, and are in excessively magical circumstances at a castle. this This is a 'sequel' to harry potters Harry Potter's experiences with TheWomanInBlack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding a "jossed" and related explanation. Also fixing a potholed trope name (that wasn't even changed to boot).



to:

* '''Jossed.''' There is no M. D'Arque as such, just an unnamed asylum employee who appears for like two seconds. [[spoiler:Maurice is taken away after he attempts to lead Gaston to the Beast's castle at the latter's request, fails and is tied to a tree and left for dead. After escaping, he denounces Gaston in front of the whole village, and of course the bastard denies it and declares Maurice to be cuckoo.]] There's no crooked bargain as in the original, just [[spoiler:crooked lies]].



[[WMG: One of Belle's inventions will be a [[ChekhovsGun Chekhov's Gun]].]]

to:

[[WMG: One of Belle's inventions will be a [[ChekhovsGun Chekhov's Gun]].]]ChekhovsGun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** '''Confirmed.''' The movie gives him an entire arc of realizing that Gaston is a much worse person than he thought he was, and taht he can do better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It makes sense to have the wolves be a part of the curse in general. The wolves seem to herd Maurice to the castle at the beginning of the film and when Belle flees from the castle they give chase. . .''as if to take her back.''

to:

** It makes sense to have the wolves be a part of the curse in general. The wolves seem to herd Maurice to the castle at the beginning of the film and when Belle flees from the castle they give chase. . .''as if to take her back.''''

[[WMG: This Film is about what Hermoine Granger did on her Gap year before university]]
the propensity of magic in the story, makes me want to connect it to the HarryPotter universe. Hermoine decided to take a year off after the battle of Hogwarts, went on a time travel vacation, and assumed the identity of belle, but forgot her wand. both characters are played by Emma Watson, love reading, and are in excessively magical circumstances at a castle. this is a 'sequel' to harry potters experiences with TheWomanInBlack.

Added: 217

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Mostly Jossed''. The adults in the painting are the prince's parents. The prince was very close to his mother, which is why her face went untouched. And it was the Queen who died when the prince was still a child.



* '''Jossed.''' No such thing happens, and as in the 1991 film, Gaston remains evil to the end and suffers a DisneyVillainDeath after he seemingly kills the Beast.

to:

* '''Jossed.''' No such thing happens, and as in the 1991 film, Gaston remains evil (and straight) to the end and suffers a DisneyVillainDeath after he seemingly kills the Beast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A possibility, since this has been the most accepted name for the Prince since the film's original release

to:

** A possibility, since this has been the most accepted name for the Prince since a computer game "proposed" this as the film's original releaseright answer.



* Stephane

to:

* Stephane
Stéphane
* '''All Jossed'''. The Prince's name is never revealed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It seems wrong that Madame, Credenza, and their dog all got cursed without having a hand in the Prince's personality but the debutantes don't. Especially since they laughed at the Enchantress. In the animated film the wolves were gray. In this film they're white. What color were all the debutantes wearing?

to:

It seems wrong that Madame, Credenza, and their dog all got cursed without having a hand in the Prince's personality but the debutantes don't. Especially since they laughed at the Enchantress. In the animated film the wolves were gray. In this film they're white. What color were all the debutantes wearing?wearing?
** It makes sense to have the wolves be a part of the curse in general. The wolves seem to herd Maurice to the castle at the beginning of the film and when Belle flees from the castle they give chase. . .''as if to take her back.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It is strongly implied the curse created by the Enchantress was actually only temporary and that the Enchantress was going to return everything back to the way it was, regardless if Belle said she loved Beast or not. Despite Belle saying she loves Beast, after the rose lost its last petal, the Enchantress who was disguised as Agathe the old woman Belle showed kindness to, knew Belle was the chosen one as Lumiere predicted and she rather set up the whole story so that Belle will break the spell. In short, the Enchantress was really a chess master and knew the prince was cold hearted at the start of the film but wanted to test his attitude. So she really only punished Beast for a limited time so he can have a chance to think about what he had done and to redeem himself and it works.

to:

It is strongly implied the curse created by the Enchantress was actually only temporary and that the Enchantress was going to return everything back to the way it was, regardless if Belle said she loved Beast or not. Despite Belle saying she loves Beast, after the rose lost its last petal, the Enchantress who was disguised as Agathe the old woman Belle showed kindness to, knew Belle was the chosen one as Lumiere predicted and she rather set up the whole story so that Belle will break the spell. In short, the Enchantress was really a chess master and knew the prince was cold hearted at the start of the film but wanted to test his attitude. So she really only punished Beast for a limited time so he can have a chance to think about what he had done and to redeem himself and it works.works.

[[WMG: The debutantes from the ball at the beginning of the movie became the wolves.]]
It seems wrong that Madame, Credenza, and their dog all got cursed without having a hand in the Prince's personality but the debutantes don't. Especially since they laughed at the Enchantress. In the animated film the wolves were gray. In this film they're white. What color were all the debutantes wearing?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the final trailer Belle learns from the household servents that when the enchanted rose loses all of it's petals the Beast and the servents remain in their current physical form forever. Lumiere and Cogsworth, though, do not tell Belle Beast has to love her and for her to love him, as Beast and Belle have to have a spark between them if the curse is to be broken.

to:

In the final trailer Belle learns from the household servents that when the enchanted rose loses all of it's its petals the Beast and the servents servants remain in their current physical form forever. Lumiere and Cogsworth, though, do not tell Belle that she and the Beast has have to love her and for her to love him, each other, as Beast and Belle have to have a spark between them if the curse is to be broken.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* '''Jossed.''' The piano doesn't cause trouble.




to:

* [[spoiler: '''Jossed.''' Gaston still plummets to his death in this one.]]




to:

* '''Jossed.''' He's a war veteran, and he does hunt, but no mention of him being Bard is made.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* '''Jossed.''' No such thing happens, and as in the 1991 film, Gaston remains evil to the end and suffers a DisneyVillainDeath after he seemingly kills the Beast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It is strongly implied the curse created by the Enchantress was actually only temporary and that the Enchantress was going to return everything back to the way it was regardless if Belle said she loved Beast or not. Despite Belle saying she loves Beast after the rose lost it's last petal the Enchantress who was disguised as Agathe the old woman Belle showed kindness to knew Belle was the chosen one as Luimier predicted and she rather set up the whole story so that Belle will break the spell. In short the Enchantress was really a chess master and knew the prince was cold hearted at the start of the film but wanted to test his attitude. So she really only punished Beast for a limited time so he can have a chance to think about what he had done and to redeem himself and it works.

to:

It is strongly implied the curse created by the Enchantress was actually only temporary and that the Enchantress was going to return everything back to the way it was was, regardless if Belle said she loved Beast or not. Despite Belle saying she loves Beast Beast, after the rose lost it's its last petal petal, the Enchantress who was disguised as Agathe the old woman Belle showed kindness to to, knew Belle was the chosen one as Luimier Lumiere predicted and she rather set up the whole story so that Belle will break the spell. In short short, the Enchantress was really a chess master and knew the prince was cold hearted at the start of the film but wanted to test his attitude. So she really only punished Beast for a limited time so he can have a chance to think about what he had done and to redeem himself and it works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Gaston will be SparedByTheAdaptation and, in keeping with the movie's feminist themes, his hypermasculine persona will be shown as a mask he puts on due to society's pressures on men. Belle will encourage [=LeFou=] to use love to bring out the best in him, just as she did for the Beast.

to:

Gaston will be SparedByTheAdaptation and, in keeping with the movie's feminist themes, his hypermasculine persona will be shown as a mask he puts on due to society's pressures on men. Belle will encourage [=LeFou=] to use love to bring out the best in him, just as she did for the Beast.Beast.

[[WMG: The spell was going to be broken the whole time.]]
It is strongly implied the curse created by the Enchantress was actually only temporary and that the Enchantress was going to return everything back to the way it was regardless if Belle said she loved Beast or not. Despite Belle saying she loves Beast after the rose lost it's last petal the Enchantress who was disguised as Agathe the old woman Belle showed kindness to knew Belle was the chosen one as Luimier predicted and she rather set up the whole story so that Belle will break the spell. In short the Enchantress was really a chess master and knew the prince was cold hearted at the start of the film but wanted to test his attitude. So she really only punished Beast for a limited time so he can have a chance to think about what he had done and to redeem himself and it works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''Confirmed'''. In addition to the above, Maurice is a music box maker instead of an inventor, referencing a music box's importance in earlier drafts (first as an object he tried to sell to raise money, later as one of the Enchanted Objects).

to:

** '''Confirmed'''. In addition to the above, Maurice is a music box maker instead of an inventor, referencing a music box's importance in earlier drafts (first as an object he tried to sell to raise money, later as one of the Enchanted Objects).Objects).

[[WMG: Gaston will also be gay.]]
Gaston will be SparedByTheAdaptation and, in keeping with the movie's feminist themes, his hypermasculine persona will be shown as a mask he puts on due to society's pressures on men. Belle will encourage [=LeFou=] to use love to bring out the best in him, just as she did for the Beast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Stephane

Added: 109

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Adam'''

to:

* '''Adam'''Adam
** A possibility, since this has been the most accepted name for the Prince since the film's original release
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Adam

to:

* Adam'''Adam'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Perhaps he'll get AdaptationalKarma too. In the original movie, [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse he just kinda disappears]].

Added: 449

Changed: 731

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* '''Confirmed.''' He's Madame de Garderobe's (The Wardrobe's) CanonForeigner husband.




to:

* '''Jossed.''' The Prince is an adult when he's cursed. The painting is slashed because [[spoiler: after the Prince's loving mother died when he was a child, it was his father who raised him to be spoiled, selfish, and unkind]].




to:

* '''Jossed'''. The Prince is hosting the ball in the Prologue -- but it is indeed crashed by the Enchantress.



Wether Belle has Stockholm Syndrome or not, how much time the castle spent cursed (was Chip born a teacup, did they age naturally, was the Prince really eleven when he was cursed), where are the prince's parents, what is his name, and the weird time issues the film seems to have (Lefou staying guarding all winter, Maurice lost in the woods for months)...

to:

Wether Whether Belle has Stockholm Syndrome or not, how much time the castle spent cursed (was (Was Chip born a teacup, did teacup? Did they age naturally, was naturally? Was the Prince really eleven when he was cursed), cursed?), where are the prince's parents, Prince's parents are, what is his name, and the weird time issues the film seems to have (Lefou staying guarding all winter, Maurice lost in the woods for months)...months)...
* '''Mostly confirmed.''' Not every issue mentioned above is addressed, but quite a few are, as well as others -- the biggest one being why the villagers don't know about the castle in the first place!



In the original Disney film we only saw about 2 minutes of the Prince and his servants as humans at the end of the film once Belle unintentionally breaks the spell. This time though we will see more screentime of the Prince and his servants as human beings. Not only will we see them return as human, we will also see them be cursed by The Enchantress either at the start of the film or like in the Beauty and the Beast Enchanted Christmas via flashback.

to:

In the original Disney film we only saw about 2 minutes of the Prince and his servants as humans at the end of the film once Belle unintentionally breaks the spell. This time though we will see more screentime of the Prince and his servants as human beings. Not only will we see them return as human, we will also see them be cursed by The Enchantress either at the start of the film or like or, as in the Beauty and the Beast ''The Enchanted Christmas Christmas'', via flashback.
* '''Confirmed.''' The Prologue dramatizes the fateful night everyone was cursed, and the mid-film musical number "Days in the Sun" is an extended {{Flashback}} sequence revealing the Beast's backstory as the Prince.



In the final trailer Belle learns from the household servents that when the enchanted rose loses all of it's petals the Beast and the servents remain in their current physical form forever. Lumiere and Cogsworth though do not tell Belle Beast has to love her and for her to love him as Beast and Belle have to have a spark between them if the curse is to be broken.

to:

In the final trailer Belle learns from the household servents that when the enchanted rose loses all of it's petals the Beast and the servents remain in their current physical form forever. Lumiere and Cogsworth though Cogsworth, though, do not tell Belle Beast has to love her and for her to love him him, as Beast and Belle have to have a spark between them if the curse is to be broken.
* '''Confirmed.'''



** Seemingly confirmed by the director. Whether or not he is redeemed at the end, Lefou will struggle with sexuality due to his attraction to Gaston. It's not much, but it seems like more of an arc than the 1991 film gave him.

to:

** Seemingly confirmed '''confirmed''' by the director. Whether or not he is redeemed at the end, Lefou will struggle with sexuality due to his attraction to Gaston. It's not much, but it seems like more of an arc than the 1991 film gave him.him.



* Much like ''The Jungle Book'' borrowed some elements from the original story, the film takes cues from both the fairy tale and original ideas for the animated version. This can already be seen in how Maurice encounters the Beast (when he tries to take a rose for Belle), and Philippe's appearance in this film (a white horse that was supposed to be given to Belle by a suitor in early drafts of the animated film: possibly a gift from Gaston this time around?).

to:

* Much like ''The Jungle Book'' borrowed some elements from the original story, the film takes cues from both the fairy tale and original ideas for the animated version. This can already be seen in how Maurice encounters the Beast (when he tries to take a rose for Belle), and Philippe's appearance in this film (a white horse that was supposed to be given to Belle by a suitor in early drafts of the animated film: possibly a gift from Gaston this time around?).around?).
** '''Confirmed'''. In addition to the above, Maurice is a music box maker instead of an inventor, referencing a music box's importance in earlier drafts (first as an object he tried to sell to raise money, later as one of the Enchanted Objects).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** This name seems unlikely since [[Disney/{{Frozen}} there's already a Kristoff in Disney canon]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Seemingly confirmed by the director. Whether or not he is redeemed at the end, Lefou will struggle with sexuality due to his attraction to Gaston. It's not much, but it seems like more of an arc than the 1991 film gave him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


I'm guessing this will happen either due to the cartoon physics of the original film not being well-translated onto live-action, or maybe to make a point ("Beauty is found within", aka maybe we shouldn't judge the short fat guy of being evil just because of his looks). Maybe he starts off as the original Lefou, as Gaston's adoring doormat fanboy, but once the plot thickens he starts doubting his friend's plans and the dark path Gaston is taking.

to:

I'm guessing this will happen either due to the cartoon physics of the original film not being well-translated onto live-action, or maybe to make a point ("Beauty is found within", aka maybe we shouldn't judge the short fat guy of being evil just because of his looks). Maybe he starts off as the original Lefou, as Gaston's adoring doormat fanboy, but once the plot thickens he starts doubting his friend's plans and the dark path Gaston is taking.taking.

[[WMG: The movie will not only take inspiration from the original tale, but from early drafts of the animated version.]]
* Much like ''The Jungle Book'' borrowed some elements from the original story, the film takes cues from both the fairy tale and original ideas for the animated version. This can already be seen in how Maurice encounters the Beast (when he tries to take a rose for Belle), and Philippe's appearance in this film (a white horse that was supposed to be given to Belle by a suitor in early drafts of the animated film: possibly a gift from Gaston this time around?).

Top