History WMG / BattleForDreamIsland

* ...will be the ''real'' Dream Island as opposed to Pin's Farm Island. Because the season is ran unofficially without the Announcer's involvement, there may be a faction within the confines of the season's roster acting as a search party to find Dream Island after Leafy stole it and caused it to disappear. And once it's found, it'll be reinstated as the prize in secret, and will likely be kept a secret going forward from anyone not involved in the season or stuck in the TLC, to keep up TheMasquerade of Leafy still having Dream Island because the rest of BFDIA is unofficial.

For example, Tree dies for the first time and He is recovered as a Clone.

** Most of the recommended characters could also count, as they either died while still zombified, or weren't seen eating the steaks at the end.

[[WMG: Puffball and Coiny's deaths will become permanent similar to what happened to Bow and Dough in Inanimate Insanity.]]
* Since they died while they were still zombified in TPOT 9 and they weren't seen nor mentioned in the next episode, it's safe to say that they are gone for good, though they could come back as ghosts later on.

[[WMG: Puffball and Coiny's deaths might become permanent similar to what happened to Bow and Dough in Inanimate Insanity.]]
* Since they died while they were still zombified in TPOT 9 and they weren't seen nor mentioned in the next episode, it's safe to say that they are gone for good, though they might become ghosts later on.

* Since the TLC is locked from the inside, there will only be a smaller number of contestants who will be able to rejoin as t, meaning only one contestant will probably go back into the game.

[[/folder]]

Similar to how Flower did.

[[WMG: Ice Cube joined the alliance off screen]]
Notice how [[spoiler: after being freed by Iance, Match and Bubble suggested Ice Cube to join as a replacement for Pencil. And didn't say anything after Book asked her.]]
** Jossed: Ice Cube joins the alliance properly in BFB 13. [[spoiler:And then she parts ways with the team in BFB 16.]]

[[WMG: Dora ''ATE'' Dream Island!!]]
* In ''BFDIA 2 - Get Digging'' and various episodes in BFB, you can see that Dora eats Islands, which means that if Leafy sold it to Dora after the Announcer sold it to Leafy, this theory is correct. If only BFDIA was finished, we could’ve found out...

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Meta]]
[[WMG: We are not the ones controlling who gets eliminated.]]
The creators are, We’re simply a middleman for their own decisions. They’re the ones making the characters do bad things and potentially getting them voted off. The voters are not in control. We must fight this.

[[/folder]]

[[WMG: Leafy and Bubble are from Yoyleland.]]
Bubble's catchphrase is "Yoylecake," and she loves Yoyleberries and Yoylecake. Leafy has a map of Goiky, which she can use to teleport to Yoyleland. Both of them are clearly into Yoyleland culture, possibly because they've lived there for some time .
* [[https://youtu.be/8o2okVL9NjQ Cary Huang's video of special relativity]] focuses on Bubble and Leafy. [[WordOfGod Cary]] says that "right when Leafy and Bubble are born, Leafy watches Bubble turn on a lamp," implying that they were born close together. He also seems to use "Yoyleland" and "home" interchangeably.
** Considering that you’re using the video, this would be [[spoiler:Jossed]]. Saying that he seems to “use Yoyleland and home interchangeably” implies that you’re blind. They are most definitely two different locations, and this destroys this WMG. But the entire video is non-canon, so they could be from Yoyleland or not, nobody knows.

[[WMG: Rocky is a psychopath.]]

An aspect of Rocky's behavior is silently staring at other characters with an abnormal smile on his face. And it's never explained why he does this. His vomit is also the main part of his life and makes his character... well, Rocky. In episode 25 of the first season, Rocky's ability to vomit in copious amounts is explained by an infinite matter generator in this mouth, which allows voluntary control of barf. This generator implies that all those times Rocky has vomited on people and property were intentional, and done to cause hurt to others around him. Add in the fact that his vomit allowed him to win some contests, and you're looking at a sociopath hidden in the form of a rock.

** One line of dialogue gains a whole new meaning. He asks Pencil in Episode 19 if she was glad "he didn't vomit on her". This shows a level of awareness in Rocky that he KNOWS that vomiting is gross, yet he does it anyway. Him asking this rhetorical question could imply he wanted to throw Pencil off guard for a moment.

* Unrelated, but even if he's a psycho I still love him with all my heart! Ouch, that sounded way less messed up in my head than on screen...

[[WMG: Yoyle City is actually Toronto.]]

[[WMG: Ice Cube joined the alliance off screen]]
Notice how [[spoiler: after being freed by Iance, Match and Bubble suggested Ice Cube to join as a replacement for Pencil. And didn't say anything after Book asked her.]]
** Jossed: Ice Cube joins the alliance properly in BFB 13. [[spoiler:And then she parts ways with the team in BFB 16.]]

[[WMG: Dora ''ATE'' Dream Island!!]]
* In ''BFDIA 2 - Get Digging'' and various episodes in BFB, you can see that Dora eats Islands, which means that if Leafy sold it to Dora after the Announcer sold it to Leafy, this theory is correct. If only BFDIA was finished, we could’ve found out...

[[WMG: Four is a reality-warping species; except he's an infant.]]
This came to me when I was watching BFB and realized something. Four seems to be very...odd. This led me to believe he's an infant of whatever he is. Four seems to have the abilities to shoot lightning, scream at high pitches, revive and deform people, and suck people into the upper-right corner of his head [[spoiler: (or in Bracelety's case, inside his mouth)]] . However, he seems to just use these powers without understanding what will happen. He also gets angry a lot of the time, draws with crayons, a writing tool created for CHILDREN, and acts very childish at times.
** No, it's a writing tool used by children. It was created for factory workers to label products.
** His species' name is Algebralien. All Algebraliens behave in erratic and/or surreal manners in varying degrees. It's probably a quirk their species have.

[[WMG: In reality, Loser is what his name suggests.]]

In BFB 4, when Loser says he doesn't like papier-mâché, we cut to a flashback, where we see a few mysterious people beating up a papier-mâché construction of him, presumably made by Loser himself. Perhaps Loser isn't actually that popular at all?
** Perhaps people were only faking actually liking him...

[[WMG: Four is actually the god of the BFDI universe.]]

In BFB 1, at the part where Four recovers Pin and Pillow, turning on the Spanish subtitles nets a message reading "*Te dije que controlaba a todo el universo...*" For non-Spanish speakers, this reads, "I told you that I controlled the entire universe..." In BFB 5, he also refers to Pen's "makeover" of him from the previous episode as "blasphemous."

[[WMG: The [[NoodleIncident incident]] that started the feud between Foldy, Stapy, and Liy was Liy murdering one of the former two.]]

Liy actually killed one of them for unknown reasons, and after being recovered, they developed a hatred for Liy, along with the other, thus starting the feud. Because of this, Liy could also be TheAtoner; she clearly regretted killing them and wanted to atone for her sin, and also wanted a way to end the feud. One day, she was inspired by Pie's pacifism to form Death PACT and atone for killing Foldy/Stapy by saving lives rather than killing.
* Plausible, they have known each other since BFDI Appisiote 225555555.

[[WMG: How does Roboty move to the waterfall and other places if he doesn't have limbs?]]

[[WMG: Multiple teams will be UFE in BFB 14.]]

Four always says some variant of "the last-placing team is up for elimination" before the challenge. However, he didn't say anything like that in BFB 13, but instead that the team needs to find emeralds before X does. Plus, if multiple characters are eliminated, that could compensate for the long wait.
** Jossed. Bleh was the only team UFE.

[[WMG: Alternatively, all of BFDI is a story by Leafy.]]

Firey is just some guy she had a crush on. [[spoiler: She got mad at Firey between BFDI and BFDIA.]]

[[WMG: The characters ethnicities.]]

It's never been said on the show, but here's a possible guess on the characters' race based on personality.

Asian: Gelatin, Spongy

Japanese: Flower, Pillow

Hispanic: Firey, Firey Jr.

Latino: Ruby, Stapy

Italian: Eraser

Canadian: Gaty, Saw

Black: 8-Ball, Blocky, Bomby, Lightning, Nickel, Snowball

Australian: Tree

Sweden: Rocky

Russian: Fanny

Indian: Balloony

Britain: Two

The rest are American.

* The BFDI Map doesn't show any real places so these places likely don't exist in BFDI and Algebralians such as Two are aliens so unless Britain is in outer space that part is Jossed.

[[WMG: The characters ages.]]

Although the ages of the objects are unknown, here's the possibilities based on personality. (Gelatin mentioned that he's 5, but that was just a joke).

Ages 6-11: Profily, Price Tag, Firey Jr., Cake, Marker, Pillow, Naily, Lightning, Grassy, Bracelety, Bomby, Ruby, Ice Cube, Rocky, Teardrop, Woody, Spongy

Age 12-14: Winner, Liy, Loser, Stapy, Foldy, Taco, Fanny, Remote, Pie, Bell, Barf Bag, Eggy, Clock, Gaty, Saw, Book, Fries, Puffball, Nickel, Gelatin, Needle, Coiny, Bubble, Firey, Pin, Leafy

Age 15-17: Purple Face, TV, Black Hole, 8-Ball, Robot Flower, Balloony, Basketball, Cloudy, Lollipop, Roboty, Tree, Bottle, Dora, Donut, Yellow Face, Blocky, Match, Pencil, Snowball, Flower, Pen, Eraser, Tennis Ball, Golf Ball, David

Two, X, Four, and the speaker boxes will be aged 22.

* Actually, Gelatin stating that he's a six-year-old actually makes sense, considering that many events in BFB follow the same timeline as real life.

* WMG is {{Jossed}}. Gelatin really is 8.
* Golf Ball wrote a Book that was 1 billion Years Old as of BFDIA, so this WMG is further Jossed.

[[WMG: Roboty told Woody about the waterfall.]]

In BFB 2, Woody didn't know Roboty was at the waterfall, [[spoiler: but when he is falling trough the waterfall at BFB 14, it reminds him of Roboty.]]
-->'''Woody:''' [[spoiler: Wuh? Woboty?]]
At some point between BFB 2 and 6, Roboty told Woody about the waterfall as he believes Woody to be a good secret keeper.

[[WMG: All of BFDI is a delusion by which a group of political prisoners locked in a prison camp in a PeoplesRepublicOfTyranny cope with their incarceration.]]
The prisoners have to deal with a surveillance loudspeaker operated by the constantly-changing dictator of the country, who forces them into torturing themselves in over-the-top ways until they are freed and sent to their native country by order of the United Nations, and if the government tells one of the prisoners the phrase "YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness", it's off to a gas chamber, aka the "Locker of Losers" or the "Tiny Loser Chamber", for their execution. To cope with this torture, the prisoners have covered all of this by replacing it in their minds with a wacky game show with inanimate objects as contestants and crazy stunts in order to win an island of their own.
* Then what the hell is IDFB?!? I honestly think IDFB means that this entire thing is Jossed.
** IDFB is the prisoners, one-by-one, getting released from jail now that the U.S. military has invaded and regime change is in progress in the country,
* What about Two and the new season that came with him?
** The new regime isn't much better and opened the prison camps back up. Some of the prisoners somehow got sent back.
* what about the rejoins in BFDI 9, BFDI 21, & BFB 11?
** New prisoners, but the old prisoners imagine them as being past ones.
[[WMG: Teardrop is mute for a reason similar to [[VideoGame/MOTHER3 Leder]].]]
The reason she's mute is that she's trying to hide the fact that [[spoiler: the entire world of BFDI is a lie.]]

[[WMG: Is Firey Jr. Related To Firey?]]
[[WMG: Objects lay eggs.]]
* Remember in the stinger of BFB 4 when Eggy said that she remembers being "an egg inside of an egg"? Well, what if that's how objects reproduce (if they can)? I mean, they have to come from somewhere..
[[WMG: Black Hole will sacrifice himself and be eliminated.]]
* With how overpowered and popular the guy is, I can see him giving up his own safety to ensure his friends will survive in an auto elimination challenge. JacknJellify tends to do this sometimes like with Ice Cube in Season 1 being contestant voted off despite how popular she was.
** Weren't auto-eliminations and the like deconfirmed?
[[WMG: BFDI is pre-apocalyptic.]]
Not post-apocalyptic, pre-apocalyptic. It takes place sometime during the era of prehistoric fish/sharks (and some dinosaurs), and eventually objects will be wiped out by a meteoroid (or one of them's stupidity).
Their fossils later become used as tools by early humans, thus creating their inanimate counterparts.
This would explain the fish monsters and also why BFDI's earth looks like Earth from a long time ago.
* As for David and Dora? They could be a super early form of primate.
* Yoyle City could either be a city founded by timeline travelers, or a city that used to be inhabited by these early primates.

[[WMG: Loser Was Never Supposed to Be Eliminated]]
* Remember in BFB 6 when Eggy blurted out that Clock screwed everything up and made their team UFE? Sure it was random, but it was probably intentional. Now, remember how characters with "mean" personalities tend to be voted off? Yeah.

Well, what if Cary and Michael had originally planned for Eggy to become one of those "mean" characters (and get eliminated)? What if Loser was supposed to have a different story instead of the one he has now?

* The official character guide book states that Cary's (and probably Michael's too) favorite character is Loser. Judging by their desperate attempts to save him from elimination and make him more likable, they really didn't want him gone so early. I will never like him though.

* Confimed? Flower and other characters at least start wearing sweaters in BFB 25

[[WMG:What happens if Firey never existed]]
So Firey won and is not eliminated yet but what if He didn’t exist, here’s the following things that Would’ve happened if he is not in the show

* Dream island migh’ve existed or didn’t got stolen by leafy
* leafy Would have Died
* A few more characters would’ve joined BFDIA
* Team no name Didn’t die in evil leafy while freesmart died
* Team No name Wins BFDIA 5E
* BFDIA would’ve Continued
* All characters in the TLC would’ve escaped in IDFB
* The berry seeds will be not Explosive
* BEEP wins the 2nd contest
* The Losers won the twinkle contest
* Loser is safe
* Book would’ve be nice to taco prior to BFB 14
* Cake answers his question bravely without pin’s speech
* Leafy would’ve not rejoined
* The Lava apocalypse didn’t happen
* Two never Stolen Four show
* BRB never existed
* Have Nots would’ve won BFB 20 and 21’s contest

Yeah that’s what I thought

* Umm...Most of those things have nothing to do with Firey.

[[WMG: The series doesn't take place on Dream Island, or even anywhere on Earth.]]
The series takes place in a pocket dimension created by the Website/SCPFoundation. Why? Because these are objects that should be inanimate but are 100% sentient, and therefore were deemed by the Foundation to be anomolies. All are designated as a collective SCP, SCP-6000, and although they are Threat Level Green, they are also Esoteric-class, meaning they are unpredictable (Black Hole was originally considered a Thaumiel-class object at Threat Level Black, but after he was made smaller, he was reassigned to Keter-class, Threat Level Yellow).

The Announcer was created to keep the objects distracted, while Four is a completely different SCP part of another collective SCP for sentient numbers, SCP-6001. Four himself is considered a Keter-class object at Threat Level Red due to being an unpredictable RealityWarper, but fortunately, he doesn't have the will to cause an HK-class deific subjugation scenario as is often feared. Instead, he seems more interested in continuing the Announcer's job. X, on the other hand, is a Safe-class object at Threat Level White because he's, well, X.

* What about Two? What class would he fall into?
** Same as Four, if not more so

[[WMG: The Objects were once humans]]
Due to their Human attitude, They are Humans but then a strange virus Happens and A lot of people got affected and turned into Objects. The Survivours of this virus was sent to another planet and So the Objects too over earth.

Theres also a hint in BFB 7 that Tennis ball said that remote's a person which means the objects might used to be humans

* That last point doesn’t prove anything. While the definition of “person” is confined to humans and only humans, do you think it’d be that way if there were other sentient species? I don’t.
* Plus, it is implied that objects are "born" when they make their first BFDI appearance.

* Jossed, [[spoiler: The Actual Prize was the BFDI, along with the BFB and The Grand Cake, but the contestants and hosts realized that the true prize was all the memories they spent together which is why the prize has value, but that is not why Four made them battle, Four made them battle because he was a fan and wanted to host a Season]]

[[WMG: Objects have blood.]]
There are SO many things that point to them having blood. I'll try to name them all, and if I miss anything, fill me in please.

* On Pencil's infinite doodle, there's something that says "Ew! Blood!" and a red blood cell for scale.
* In BFDIA when the prize for Cake at Stake was Donut's corpse, Ruby comments on how good his "blood" tastes. I mean, [[ItMakesSenseInContext out of context]] that's disgusting, but I agree with her.
* In IDFB, there's a bloodstain on the wall that says "STOP HER", probably referring to Evil Leafy since for a split second she appears behind Tennis Ball.
* Marker looks through Lightning's camera as he takes a picture of Donut. At first, you can't see him, and Marker confirms his theory about Donut being a vampire, until the camera zooms out from his donut hole to reveal he actually is there. Vampires existing in BFDI means there is blood to suck, otherwise all the vampires would starve. And it's proven more when he comments "Meh, still have OTHER evidence..." implying that Donut sucked his blood (ink, probably) or he saw him sucking another character's blood. That last part probably was just a delusion though, with him being a {{Cloudcuckoolander}} and all.
* Flower in BFB 23 says "My ears, they bleed!" to which Firey replies "Plants have blood?" implying that different types of objects have different blood or none at all.
* A few episodes before that, she is shown to have a brain. Of course it has no blood, but that is even worse, because now we know objects have organs. Wait, if she has organs, where do they put them in her stick body?
** Actually, now that I think about it, I should've known that from the very start. In the stinger of s1ep3, Tennis Ball says he has to go to the bathroom. That means he has a bladder and/or bowels. Ewww! [[FridgeHorror And it's even worse when you take into consideration that he was in a stack, AT THE TOP.]]
* This is not canon, but it deserves a mention. In the "If VideoGame/AmongUs Was a BFDI Challenge" video, as Match and Pencil go to scan in [=MedBay=], Pencil mentions being able to see 3D renders of Match's '''internal organs''', height, weight, '''blood type''', wood type, and [[BreadEggsMilkSquick eyeball fluid viscosity]].

[[WMG: BFDI Is an private TV show]]
Four decided to Throw a object show on youtube but he was injured and asked the announcer to host season 1. later in season 4, he finally got better and hosts S4 on a private Tv channel no one had known
** Then what about BFDIA, IDFB, and TPOT?
* Jossed, BFDI is a TV show, but not a private one, as in BFB 30, [[spoiler: Four was seen watching it in a flashback and he has no relation to the announcer]], Four took the show from Announcer, who is the true creator of BFDI, stating that it's his life's work.

[[WMG: Leafy Has Bipolar.]]
* She shows several symptoms, such as mood swings (going from friendly and kind to bashful and hurtful, as seen with her friendship with Bubble), excessive energy, and bouts of sadness (as shown among her feud with Firey and other contestants).

As of late seaon 4, however, she seems to be improving.

[[WMG: X getting despawned by Four will be the thing that makes him snap.]]

[[WMG: The Whole series was Scripted all along]]
When BFDI gets to it's Series Finale, they'll be a huge plot twist that the whole series was Scripted Meaning all the contestants were Just actors.

[[WMG: Recovered contestants were Just clones]]
After Someone Dies for the first time, They will recover as a Clone now that the original one died.

For example, Tree dies for the first time and He is recovered as a Clone.

Every time a clone contestant dies, there are many of them left (probably around 1 million clones)
** But in BFDIA 4, Coiny tried to recover Book and the machine cannot do that because she is still alive.

[[WMG: Everyone will eventually learn that the show is ruining their friendship]]
Since I've saw a bunch of Friendships destroyed. (For example, Ice Cube betrays Book due to her thinking Taco abandoning them but it was Four who caused Taco to stay in the jawbreaker) By the Grand finale, they'll realise Friendship is better than battling for something like Friendship is more important than money.

[[WMG: Four will have a OneWingedAngel moment]]
When BFB and/or TPOT gets to the finale, due to Four's personality, he will transform into his true form.
* Unusual Confirmed/Jossed limbo. He merged with Earth in BFB 28.

[[WMG: Ice Cube is autistic]]
* Ice Cube barely talks and shows little emotion.
* Ice Cube has trouble making friends (besides Bubble and maybe Clock.)
* Ice Cube's former voice actress (Kenzie Bryant) mentioned being autistic on her card page.
It's ethier because of this, or because [[CreatorsPest Ice Cube is just hated by Cary and Michael]].

[[WMG: BFDI takes place in a world mostly controlled by real life humans through the comments, Patreon, etc.]]
Evidence for this is spread throughout BFDI, particularly the fourth season.
* The biggest support for this theory is Gelatin's age. In BFB 6, Gelatin claims to be a 6-year-old. In BFB 21, Gelatin additionally states that his birthday is June 29th. Do the math, and you get one day before the release of BFDIA 1.
* According to Book in BFB 13, the first thing she remembers saying is, "I'm a dictionary and you'd better believe it", her first coherent line in the show in BFDI 19.
* In BFB 18, Ruby cryptically asks "mommy" if she "did a no-no again". I theorize that Ruby is referring to the viewers that created her in this scene.
* Finally, BFDI 23 has Bubble obtain a letter from the Youtubers Flykyd Fly and yummysimon4 claiming that they are building an Announcer Recovery Center. Said recovery center appears later in the episode. Perhaps the viewers are capable of more than just creating life and voting.
* In BFB 29, Blocky states that attempting to save the show might be "the last thing they get to do together", as if their existence is tied to competing on the show.

[[WMG: 8-Ball is a Magic 8-Ball.]]
8-Ball foresaw his elimination in BFB 8, so in order to prevent the DramaticIrony of being eliminated on his favorite episode number, he keeps trying to deny that he has a favorite number at all to almost obnoxious degrees. Further proving this is how 8-Ball shows rare emotion when he is annoyed at Donut claiming that he was eliminated on his favorite number episode, the fact that 8-Ball never actually claimed that he doesn't have a favorite number after he was eliminated, and all but stating that 8 is his favorite number in his speech to convince voters to vote him back in the game in BFB 10.

[[WMG: An EXITOR/Contestant from Battle for BFB will be able to join TPOT at some point]]
At the risk of making it longer sure, but there are some characters that fans may want to see
* Appears Jossed at least for the Battle for BFB contestants as of BFB 30. The only contestants that may be 100% Jossed are [[spoiler: Firey and Leafy, as they sailed off into the sunset]]
* Confirmed. Teardrop joined in episode 2.

[[WMG: IDFB is ExiledFromContinuity]]
None of the plot threads from that were awnsered in BFB's Conclusion and no one seems to remember their stay in Yoyle City. Therefore, it must not be canon anymore.

[[WMG: Alternatively, IDFB did happen.]]
We can assume it did because everyone was released from the TLC and Golf Ball and Tennis Ball explicitly reference the Wall Teleporter in BFB 12. But what if some NoodleIncident occurred that caused everyone's memories to be wiped except GB & TB? Also, Yoyleland seems to have slowly disappeared after IDFB, as we can see the Yoyle Needy in early BFB episodes, but then it just disappears. Not to mention, every recommended character related to Yoyleland in BFB is a cardboard cutout.
** Yoyle Mountain is seen in BFB 16 when Two showcases their power. But maybe their stay in Yoyleland did come with some LaserGuidedAmnesia blocking their memories.

[[WMG: Two actually isn't all powerful]]
Maybe their [[spoiler: hesitation in getting involved when Four became the Sun isn't due to wanting to actually stay out of it, but to not be proven wrong that he is not stronger than 4 and his power isn't all too impressive. I mean, 4 is a power of Two]]

[[WMG: Roboty's Waterfall is a junction between the real world and metaphysical space]]
Judged as Woody falling through it into the real world and then into Four's Eye, as that is where it is as of being absorbed by Four. It is likely the fall has a bottom that leads to the real world.

[[WMG: Most of The Objects are Time Lords or Immortal]]
Pencil has claimed to have to deal with Spongy for ''Millions'' of years and Golf Ball wrote a book published ''One Billion Years Ago'', how else do we explain this massive time discrepancy.
* Maybe they were exaggerating? But then again it'd be hilarious if it turned out [[spoiler:they weren't]].
* Considering they have recovery centers, it is possible they never age.

[[WMG: Four or X planted the Cyanide undergound]]
Consider the fact that Four [[spoiler: always wanted to be on the show]], he could have buried the cyanide undergound near Flower, knowing that Flower would not be able to open the jar, causing Black Hole to float down and absorb all the recovery centers, causing the contestants to rely on Four for recovery and have to compete on his show so he can recover them.

[[WMG:Lightning was created by Cloudy]]
In "The Reveal" and "No More Snow!", Lightning can be seen popping out of Cloudy when he gets mad. And in "The Escape From Four", Cloudy holds onto Lightning with his mouth when trying to free the eliminated contestants with many others. I mean, Cloudy is a cloud and Lightning is Lightning?
[[WMG:Flower isn’t really a flower.]]
Flower is human, she just uses cosmetics to make herself look like one. also, in BFDI 23 during the last mini-contest one of her “petals” falls of her head, and clearly makes a loud noise when the petals hit the ground. And in an unspecified episode on BFB Season B flower reveals she has “Rotting Flesh” in her head, which turns out to be her brain.
** To add even more fuel to the fire, one of the show’s creators Carykh, draws humans as a stick figure with a yellow head, now add petals to their heads…
** And she is one of two contestants who use the term “Oh my God” implying the existence of Christianity and dare I say, humans.

[[WMG:Tennis Ball and Golf Ball are siblings.]]
They are (and were, consider Squashy Grapes, Another Name, and No Name and ABNTT) in the same team, have a good relationship, and according to sources, some of the over 80% of kids who grow up with siblings get along well, so the good relationship and team parts make sense. And they also have a conflicting relationship, like most siblings sometimes do. So is it possible that they are siblings? Probably.

[[WMG:"Needy" is a slur in the object universe.]]
Slapping someone over a nickname you don't like is a bit extreme, and Pencil uses it as a plural in one episode. Maybe it's a lot more offensive than we think.

[[WMG: Two is evil.]]

[[WMG: Snowball is actually an artificial indoor snowball.]]
Despite being allegedly made out of snow, Snowball remains entirely intact when falling from a great height or when colliding with an object at great speeds (examples include when he falls off the tower of blocks in TPOT 2 or when he collided with the mountain on his hang glider in the first episode of BFDI), and he didn't melt when the Sun got teleported into the TLC in BFDI 24. Either he's not made out of actual snow and is artificially made, or it's simply cartoon logic.

[[WMG: Souls are confirmed to exist in the BFDI universe.]]
In the original script of BFDIA 5, there is a part where the HPRC gets "delimbified" (limbs get shot out of it), which suggests that if there is a stock of limbs inside, there may also be stocks of the bodies of the objects inside in order to assemble them together when recovering them. Furthermore, in BFDIA 5D when the Freesmarters keep drowning and recovering each other, we can see that despite them being recovered, their former bodies do not vanish. (Another example is in TPOT when Yellow Face's corpse from when he died in BFDIA 5E is found in the desert.)

Maybe at first the soul of the dead character wanders around, and when their name is typed on the HPRC some kind of metaphysical black hole attracts the soul to the recovery center and then puts it in the body that's stored inside.

[[WMG: All of the objects taste like something besides the object they are based on.]]
This is how Nonexisty is somehow able to taste like peanut butter.

* What reinforces the theory is that Snowball gets pulled off the balance beam in TPOT 8 due to the density of yoylemetal and immediately falls.

Jacknjellify is making sure BFDIA leads perfectly to IDFB, with all major holes between being filled. One plothole yet to be filled is Bubble being out of the TLC on IDFB. This is how they will fill it: It's revealed that Bubble never landed in the TLC. When she was flung in BFDIA 5e, she was under the yoyleberry effect, and the metal weighed her down enough for her to just hit the ground. [[https://youtu.be/6OfKK5Rt3fY?t=430 It happened before.]] Once she gets found out, she will be allowed to join the game, similar to how Teardrop joined in TPOT, except she will be on Freesmart instead of flying solo due to the team freedom in BFDIA.

Jacknjellify is making sure BFDIA leads perfectly to IDFB, with all major holes between being filled. One plothole yet to be filled is Bubble being out of the TLC on IDFB. This is how they will fill it:
* It's revealed that Bubble never landed in the TLC. When she was flung in BFDIA 5e, she was under the yoyleberry effect, and the metal weighed her down enough for her to just hit the ground. [[https://youtu.be/6OfKK5Rt3fY?t=430 It happened before.]] Once she gets found out, she will be allowed to join the game, similar to how Teardrop joined in TPOT, except she will be on Freesmart instead of flying solo due to the team freedom in BFDIA.

* Marker looks through Lightning's camera as he takes a picture of Donut. At first you can't see him, and Marker confirms his theory about Donut being a vampire, until the camera zooms out from his donut hole to reveal he actually is there. Vampires existing in BFDI means there is blood to suck, otherwise all the vampires would starve. And it's proven more when he comments "Meh, still have OTHER evidence..." implying that Donut sucked his blood (ink, probably) or he saw him sucking another character's blood. That last part probably was just a delusion though, with him being a {{Cloudcuckoolander}} and all.

Jacknjellify has lots of secret schemes to keep firey in the game

** But in BFDIA 4 Coiny tried to recover Book and the machine cannot do that because she is still alive.

Since I've saw a bunch of Friendships destroyed (For example, Ice cube betrays book due to her thinking taco abandoning them but it was four who caused taco to stay in the jawbreaker) By the Grand finale, They'll realise Friendship is better than battling for something like Friendship is more important than money.

The prize is actually a fraction of his true power

In the original script of BFDIA 5, there is a part where the HPRC gets "delimbified" (limbs get shot out of it), which suggests that if there is a stock of limbs inside, there may also be stocks of the bodies of the objects inside in order to assemble them together when recovering them. Furthermore, in BFDIA 5D when the Freesmarters keep drowning and recovering each other, we can see that despite them being recovered, their former bodies do not vanish. (Another example is in TPOT when Yellow Face's corpse from when he died in BFDIA 5E is found in the desert)