Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / TheCommitments

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Doyle:''' “The punch line itself was very funny, but he wouldn’t have been going to Confession. That’s much more important.”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age to go to confession, and it was exactly the kind of stereotypical [[{{Oirish}} uber-Catholic Oirish]] trope the book was [[DefiedTrope written to defy]]. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.

to:

* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age to go to confession, and it was exactly the kind of stereotypical [[{{Oirish}} [[{{Oireland}} uber-Catholic Oirish]] trope the book was [[DefiedTrope written to defy]]. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age to go to confession, and was exactly the kind of stereotypical uber-Catholic [[OireLand Oirish]] trope the book avoided. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.

to:

* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age to go to confession, and it was exactly the kind of stereotypical [[{{Oirish}} uber-Catholic [[OireLand Oirish]] trope the book avoided.was [[DefiedTrope written to defy]]. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CastTheRunnerUp: Robert Arkins (Jimmy Rabbitte) has auditioned to play Deco before he was cast as Jimmy. He gets to demonstrate his singing in the movie's opening song, a cover of Roy Head and the Traits' "Treat Her Right," and in a cover of Clarence Carter's "Slip Away" in the soundtrack album.
* TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents.

to:

* TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents.
* CastTheRunnerUp: Robert Arkins (Jimmy Rabbitte) has auditioned to play Deco before he was cast as Jimmy. He gets to demonstrate his singing in the movie's opening song, a cover of Roy Head and the Traits' "Treat Her Right," and in a cover of Clarence Carter's "Slip Away" in the soundtrack album.
* TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents.
album.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatCouldHaveBeen: The film-makers considered getting Rory Gallagher or Music/VanMorrison to play Joey Fagan; Morrison was interested until director Alan Parker rejected his condition for taking the role, specifically that he would get some of his own songs in the soundtrack.

to:

* WhatCouldHaveBeen: The film-makers considered getting Rory Gallagher or Music/VanMorrison to play Joey Fagan; Morrison was interested until director Alan Parker Creator/AlanParker rejected his condition for taking the role, specifically that he would get some of his own songs in the soundtrack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Useful Notes pages are not tropes


* UsefulNotes/BFITop100BritishFilms: #38. Though it's a bit of a stretch, as although the director and producers were English, the source material, cast and location are all Irish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age, and exactly the kind of stereotypical [[OireLand Oirish]] trope the book avoided. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.

to:

* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age, age to go to confession, and was exactly the kind of stereotypical uber-Catholic [[OireLand Oirish]] trope the book avoided. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age, and exactly the kind of stereotypical {{Oirish}} trope the book avoided. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.

to:

* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age, and exactly the kind of stereotypical {{Oirish}} [[OireLand Oirish]] trope the book avoided. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreatorBacklash: A mild example, but Roddy Doyle dislikes the scene of Steven going to confession and mixing up Marvin Gaye and Percy Sledge, added by Clement and La Frenais, because it was unrealistic for someone Steven’s age, and exactly the kind of stereotypical {{Oirish}} trope the book avoided. He concedes [[ActuallyPrettyFunny the actual joke is pretty funny though.]] He disliked Joey’s mother’s holy statues for the same reason.

Changed: 479

Removed: 420

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV


* RetroactiveRecognition:
** Music/TheCorrs all have parts in the film. Andrea plays Jimmy's younger sister (ironically named Sharon, like her own older sister in real life), while Jim, Caroline, and Sharon have cameo roles as musicians.
** A young [[Film/{{Once}} Glen Hansard]] plays Outspan.
** [[Series/TheTudors Catharine of Aragon]] sings a smokin' cover of ''Bye Bye Baby''.
* WhatCouldHaveBeen: The film-makers considered getting Rory Gallagher or Music/VanMorrison to play Joey Fagan; Morrison was interested until director Alan Parker rejected his condition for taking the role, specifically that he would get some of his own songs in the soundtrack.

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition:
** Music/TheCorrs all have parts in the film. Andrea plays Jimmy's younger sister (ironically named Sharon, like her own older sister in real life), while Jim, Caroline, and Sharon have cameo roles as musicians.
** A young [[Film/{{Once}} Glen Hansard]] plays Outspan.
** [[Series/TheTudors Catharine of Aragon]] sings a smokin' cover of ''Bye Bye Baby''.
* WhatCouldHaveBeen: The film-makers considered getting Rory Gallagher or Music/VanMorrison to play Joey Fagan; Morrison was interested until director Alan Parker rejected his condition for taking the role, specifically that he would get some of his own songs in the soundtrack.soundtrack.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UsefulNotes/BFITop100BritishFilms: #38

to:

* UsefulNotes/BFITop100BritishFilms: #38#38. Though it's a bit of a stretch, as although the director and producers were English, the source material, cast and location are all Irish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatCouldHaveBeen: The film-makers considered getting Rory Gallagher or Music/VanMorrison to play Joey Fagan.

to:

* WhatCouldHaveBeen: The film-makers considered getting Rory Gallagher or Music/VanMorrison to play Joey Fagan.Fagan; Morrison was interested until director Alan Parker rejected his condition for taking the role, specifically that he would get some of his own songs in the soundtrack.

Added: 98

Changed: 121

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents, Robert Arkins (Jimmy Rabbitte) included. Having initially auditioned to play Deco before he was cast as Jimmy, he gets to demonstrate his singing in the movie's opening song, a cover of Roy Head and the Traits' "Treat Her Right," and in a cover of Clarence Carter's "Slip Away" in the soundtrack album.

to:

* TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents, CastTheRunnerUp: Robert Arkins (Jimmy Rabbitte) included. Having initially has auditioned to play Deco before he was cast as Jimmy, he Jimmy. He gets to demonstrate his singing in the movie's opening song, a cover of Roy Head and the Traits' "Treat Her Right," and in a cover of Clarence Carter's "Slip Away" in the soundtrack album.album.
* TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents, Robert Arkins (Jimmy Rabbitte) included. He gets to demonstrate his singing in the movie's opening song, a cover of Roy Head and the Traits' "Treat Her Right," and in a cover of Clarence Carter's "Slip Away" in the soundtrack album.
* DawsonCasting: Inverted in the case of Andrew Strong, who played Deco. He was sixteen when ''The Commitments'' was filmed but was selected for the role because his singing voice sounded older. One of his anecdotes in the DVD "Making of" featurette involved a listener estimating his age as twenty-one based on his voice alone.

to:

* TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents, Robert Arkins (Jimmy Rabbitte) included. He Having initially auditioned to play Deco before he was cast as Jimmy, he gets to demonstrate his singing in the movie's opening song, a cover of Roy Head and the Traits' "Treat Her Right," and in a cover of Clarence Carter's "Slip Away" in the soundtrack album.
* DawsonCasting: Inverted in the case of Andrew Strong, who played Deco. He was sixteen when ''The Commitments'' was filmed but was selected for the role because his singing voice sounded older. One of his anecdotes in the DVD "Making of" featurette involved a listener estimating his age as twenty-one more than twice that based on his voice alone.

Added: 353

Changed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition: Music/TheCorrs all have parts in the film. Andrea plays Jimmy's younger sister (ironically named Sharon, like her own older sister in real life), while Jim, Caroline, and Sharon have cameo roles as musicians.

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition: RetroactiveRecognition:
**
Music/TheCorrs all have parts in the film. Andrea plays Jimmy's younger sister (ironically named Sharon, like her own older sister in real life), while Jim, Caroline, and Sharon have cameo roles as musicians.musicians.
** A young [[Film/{{Once}} Glen Hansard]] plays Outspan.
** [[Series/TheTudors Catharine of Aragon]] sings a smokin' cover of ''Bye Bye Baby''.

Changed: 130

Removed: 257

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCastShowoff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents, Robert Arkin (Jimmy Rabitte) included (he gets to demonstrate his singing in a bonus song included on the DVD and the soundtrack album).

to:

* TheCastShowoff: TheCastShowOff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents, Robert Arkin Arkins (Jimmy Rabitte) included (he Rabbitte) included. He gets to demonstrate his singing in a bonus song included on the DVD movie's opening song, a cover of Roy Head and the Traits' "Treat Her Right," and in a cover of Clarence Carter's "Slip Away" in the soundtrack album).album.



* ThePeteBest: Ray, the hammy lead singer of Outspan and Derek's earlier band, And And And. Jimmy makes it clear that he doesn't like Ray, and when Outspan and Derek tell Ray he's out, he takes it surprisingly well, saying he was planning to go solo anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UsefulNotes/BFITop100BritishFilms: #38

Added: 234

Changed: 299

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition: Music/TheCorrs all have parts in the film. Andrea plays Jimmy's younger sister, while Jim, Caroline, and Sharon have cameo roles as musicians.

to:

* ThePeteBest: Ray, the hammy lead singer of Outspan and Derek's earlier band, And And And. Jimmy makes it clear that he doesn't like Ray, and when Outspan and Derek tell Ray he's out, he takes it surprisingly well, saying he was planning to go solo anyway.
* RetroactiveRecognition: Music/TheCorrs all have parts in the film. Andrea plays Jimmy's younger sister, sister (ironically named Sharon, like her own older sister in real life), while Jim, Caroline, and Sharon have cameo roles as musicians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RetroactiveRecognition: Music/TheCorrs all have parts in the film. Andrea plays Jimmy's younger sister, while Jim, Caroline, and Sharon have cameo roles as musicians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Irony}}: Johnny Murphy plays Joey Fagan, the most talented and most experienced member of the Commitments. But he's the only one who [[http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/culturenews/10341635/Whatever-happened-to-The-Commitments.html didn't know how to play a musical instrument]] in real life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hey Its That Guy and Hey Its That Voice examples are being cut per TRS.


* HeyItsThatGuy
** Jimmy's father is [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration Miles]] [[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine O'Brien]].
** The guy with the crazy hair is [[{{Once}} Glen Hansard]]!
** [[TheTudors Catharine of Aragon]] is a soul singer!

Added: 557

Changed: 245

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Defictionalization}}: To this day, the band still tours the pub circuit in Ireland.

to:

* TheCastShowoff: The actors playing the Commitments were mostly chosen for their musical talents, Robert Arkin (Jimmy Rabitte) included (he gets to demonstrate his singing in a bonus song included on the DVD and the soundtrack album).
* DawsonCasting: Inverted in the case of Andrew Strong, who played Deco. He was sixteen when ''The Commitments'' was filmed but was selected for the role because his singing voice sounded older. One of his anecdotes in the DVD "Making of" featurette involved a listener estimating his age as twenty-one based on his voice alone.
* {{Defictionalization}}: To this day, Members of the band still tours cast/band have toured under the pub circuit in Ireland.Commitments name from time to time for kicks.



** [[TheTudors Catharine of Aragon]] is a soul singer!

to:

** [[TheTudors Catharine of Aragon]] is a soul singer!singer!
* WhatCouldHaveBeen: The film-makers considered getting Rory Gallagher or Music/VanMorrison to play Joey Fagan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Defictionalization}}: To this day, the band still tours the pub circuit in Ireland.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved \"Hey It\'s That Guy\" entry to Trivia page.

Added DiffLines:

* HeyItsThatGuy
** Jimmy's father is [[Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration Miles]] [[Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine O'Brien]].
** The guy with the crazy hair is [[{{Once}} Glen Hansard]]!
** [[TheTudors Catharine of Aragon]] is a soul singer!

Top