Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TearJerker / MLPAnalysis

Go To

OR

Changed: 559

Removed: 7159

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No rela life examples plus Zaid has proven to not practice what he preaches regarding death threats


* In his "Drama" confession video, Zaid Magenta[[note]]previously called [=MisAnthroPony=][[/note]] went on an anger-induced tirade after he found out that one of the writers of the show was given ''death threats'', and ''this was after he had hope for the fandom''. The tirade part can be especially heartbreaking to watch, because his previous confession video is called ''"[[HarsherInHindsight Fandom]]"'' and he stated he was very proud to be in it:
-->'''Zaid Magenta:''' When "Pinkie Pride" first came out, I honestly let out a sigh of relief [[TemptingFate because nobody said anything bad about her that week]] and then, ''"Filli Vanilli" happened''. I knew from the ''moment this episode aired'' that everybody was going to use it as a straw man fallacy for how Pinkie Pie was degrading into a terrible character.\\
''(shows a picture of [[WesternAnimation/PeterPan Captain Hook]] briefly, before cutting to the infamous clip from said episode)''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' ''(mockingly)'' Oh what's that, she made Fluttershy ''cry?''\\
''(shows an equally infamous clip from [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E19PuttingYourHoofDown Putting Your Hoof Down]])''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' ''(angrily)'' She[[note]][Fluttershy][[/note]] made ''Pinkie and '''Rarity''' cry'' [[{{Hypocrite}} you stupid morons]], ''in a much more intentional and mean-spirited way!''\\
'''[=Zaid Magenta=]:''' If people were hating her[[note]][Pinkie Pie][[/note]] ''before'' that episode, oh they were ''really'' starting to hate her ''now'', and even with all that in mind, ''nothing quite prepared me for the horrifying news through this [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UVhe2feX0CU video]] that I saw months later.''\\
''(cut to a Golden Fox video called "[[OvershadowedByControversy Rant on Amy Keating Roger's Death Threats]]", the same one in the link above)''\\
'''Golden Fox:''' ''(audio from video, sounding disappointed)'' I... You know I could underestimate and you know the public of the internet and, you know there's... was gonna be those bunch of people who doesn't... who do nothing more than either {{troll}}, [[YouBastard spread hateful comments]], etc. You know, there's always the amateur responses and feedback that is always thrown, you know, to the ''deep ends of Hell'', etc. ''However'', one of the comments stated something that I had no idea what was going on, I briefly like look just through the web and found something going on with Amy. Uh, Amy Keating Rogers who wrote "Filli Vanilli" and apparently, not only were people pissed off about the way Pinkie was written, but ''she was given death threats!'' I was completely unaware of this, and... ''Jesus Christ!'' I knew that I was going to get myself into a bit of a mess where people would disagree with me on some.. you know, on something ''controversial'' but I didn't expect something ''this big'', something this... ''notorious''. So, do you have my piece on the matter? I had no involvement with that whatsoever.\\
''(cut back to Zaid Magenta, who's [[DeathGlare glaring at the camera]])''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' ''([[TranquilFury calmly]])'' ''So that's it? You really had to go there didn't you?!'' Your ''spitefulness'' towards Pinkie Pie, your growing hatred for her got ''so bad'', that you sent ''[[DisproportionateRetribution death threats]]'' to Amy Keating Rogers ''[[UngratefulBastard after all the times you've told her you loved her writing]].'' ''(growing angrier)'' Is... is that it?! Is that what ''all this is to you?!'' You ''constantly demand'' that the writers give you well-written stories and episodes. ''(getting even angrier)'' And when you ''don't get that'', you send them hate mail and ''death threats?!?!'' ''Death threats...'' just because of how much you started to hate Diane.[[note]]"Pinkamena '''Diane''' Pie", is Pinkie's full name.[[/note]]\\
''(Zaid Magenta continues to glare for several seconds without saying anything. And, as we hear noises in the background followed by piano music starting up, the screen goes black as a warning appears, then it disappears leaving just a black screen)''\\
'''Zaid Magenta (offscreen):''' ''Stupid!!'' '''''IT WAS ALL A COMPLETE [[PrecisionFStrike FUCKING]] WASTE OF TIME!!!'''''\\
''([[RageBreakingPoint a really pissed off]] Zaid Magenta appears back on screen)''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' '''''ALL OF IT!!!''''' All of... ''({{facepalm}})'' ''IT WAS ALL LEADING TO'' '''''THIS!!'''''\\
''(cut back to the video by Golden Fox, the piano music still playing over it)''\\
'''Golden Fox:''' ''(audio from video)'' ''Why death threats?!'' Are you going to be ''this over-reactive?!'' To those of you who ever did that, who you gave that to her, ''do I even need to say it?!'' It is a huge disservice to yourself, to the Brony fandom just... but I think it's even more screwed up that somebody, somewhere, ''somehow'' would get ''this'' overreactive, to get this over-the-top and throw it towards Amy because they weren't pleased with the way the episode was written. I-I'm utterly speechless. You've given us a bad name by doing that... just [[PrecisionFStrike fucking]] wow!\\
''(we cut back to Zaid Magenta)''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' ''THIS IS IT?! '''THIS''' IS WHAT I PUT UP WITH THOSE HATEFUL COMMENTS FOR?! ALL THAT TIME I SPENT DOING MY BEST TO DEFEND YOU AND '''STICK UP''' FOR YOU AND IT TURNS OUT, YOU'RE NO BETTER THAN THE IDIOTS OF THE [[TakeThat YOUTUBE COMMENT SECTION]], WHO BLINDLY HATE YOU!!'' THIS IS BULLSHIT! I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT I CONVINCED MYSELF FOR A SINGLE MICROSECOND THAT THIS FANDOM WAS ''SPECIAL!'' YOU SPEND ''LESS TIME'' UNITING EACH OTHER IN THE VERY THING THAT HAS GIVEN YOU YOUR '''''IDENTITY''''' AND SPEND ''MORE TIME'' THINKING OF NEW REASONS TO '''HATE EACH OTHER!!''' DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA HOW '''EMBARRASSING THAT IS,''' HOW '''''HUMILIATING THAT FEELS?!?!''''' WHY THE '''HELL''' DID I EVEN BOTHER! I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN BETTER THAN TO BELIEVE THIS FANDOM WAS SPECIAL! I CAN'T EVEN THINK OF A REASON AS TO WHY I WANTED TO BE IN THIS FANDOM TO BEGIN WITH! I DON'T KNOW WHY YOU WASTED SO MUCH TIME TRYING TO PERSUADE OTHERS THAT YOU'RE BETTER THAN OTHERS WHEN ''YOU'RE ALL THE'' '''''EXACT SAME!!''''' [[ItsAllAboutMe YOU'RE A SELFISH POPULATION OF PEOPLE WHO DON'T CARE ABOUT ANYONE BUT THEMSELVES]]! AND THE SAME GOES FOR ''YOU'' [[WhamLine BROANALYSIS COMMUNITY]], [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech ALL THAT TIME YOU SPENT TRICKING ME INTO BELIEVING YOU WERE A BEACON OF HOPE FOR THIS FANDOM AND AS IT TURNS OUT, YOU ARE SOME OF THE WORST EXAMPLES OF PEOPLE WHO EVER STARTED WATCHING THIS SHOW IN THE FIRST PLACE!]] I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHY I WANTED TO BE ASSOCIATED WITH ANY OF YOU, YOU'RE ALL A BUNCH OF [[LazyBum LAZY]], [[IgnoranceIsBliss IGNORANT]], [[{{hypocrite}} HYPOCRITICAL]], [[DisproportionateRetribution OVERREACTING]], [[EntitledBastard SELF-ENTITLED]], NON-NEGOTIABLE, OVERBEARING, KNOW-IT-ALL, ILL-MANNERED, ''[[ChronicBackstabbingDisorder BACKSTABBING]], [[SmallNameBigEgo EGOTISTICAL]], [[TrashTalk TRASH-TALKING]], CONFUSING, ARGUMENTATIVE, [[ItsAllAboutMe SELFISH]], ASS-KISSING, OBLIVIOUS, '''CERTIFIABLY INSANE, [[{{Jerkass}} JERKS!!!]]'''''
** Him tearfully apologizing to everyone in the fandom in his "Guilt" confession video.
-->'''Zaid Magenta:''' I'm sorry... I'm sorry to everyone that I hurt through my selfish ranting...
** He sounds genuinely upset at certain points during his video breaking down how the Grogar twist in the finale of "Friendship is Magic" trashed Discord's character development, especially when he showed clips from the Season 4 finale where Discord was giving Twilight the medallion that was given to him by Tirek.

to:

* In his "Drama" confession video, Zaid Magenta[[note]]previously called [=MisAnthroPony=][[/note]] went on an anger-induced tirade after he found out that one of the writers of the show was given ''death threats'', and ''this was after he had hope for the fandom''. The tirade part can be especially heartbreaking to watch, because his previous confession video is called ''"[[HarsherInHindsight Fandom]]"'' and he stated he was very proud to be in it:
-->'''Zaid Magenta:''' When "Pinkie Pride" first came out, I honestly let out a sigh of relief [[TemptingFate because nobody said anything bad about her that week]] and then, ''"Filli Vanilli" happened''. I knew from the ''moment this episode aired'' that everybody was going to use it as a straw man fallacy for how Pinkie Pie was degrading into a terrible character.\\
''(shows a picture of [[WesternAnimation/PeterPan Captain Hook]] briefly, before cutting to the infamous clip from said episode)''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' ''(mockingly)'' Oh what's that, she made Fluttershy ''cry?''\\
''(shows an equally infamous clip from [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E19PuttingYourHoofDown Putting Your Hoof Down]])''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' ''(angrily)'' She[[note]][Fluttershy][[/note]] made ''Pinkie and '''Rarity''' cry'' [[{{Hypocrite}} you stupid morons]], ''in a much more intentional and mean-spirited way!''\\
'''[=Zaid Magenta=]:''' If people were hating her[[note]][Pinkie Pie][[/note]] ''before'' that episode, oh they were ''really'' starting to hate her ''now'', and even with all that in mind, ''nothing quite prepared me for the horrifying news through this [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UVhe2feX0CU video]] that I saw months later.''\\
''(cut to a Golden Fox video called "[[OvershadowedByControversy Rant on Amy Keating Roger's Death Threats]]", the same one in the link above)''\\
'''Golden Fox:''' ''(audio from video, sounding disappointed)'' I... You know I could underestimate and you know the public of the internet and, you know there's... was gonna be those bunch of people who doesn't... who do nothing more than either {{troll}}, [[YouBastard spread hateful comments]], etc. You know, there's always the amateur responses and feedback that is always thrown, you know, to the ''deep ends of Hell'', etc. ''However'', one of the comments stated something that I had no idea what was going on, I briefly like look just through the web and found something going on with Amy. Uh, Amy Keating Rogers who wrote "Filli Vanilli" and apparently, not only were people pissed off about the way Pinkie was written, but ''she was given death threats!'' I was completely unaware of this, and... ''Jesus Christ!'' I knew that I was going to get myself into a bit of a mess where people would disagree with me on some.. you know, on something ''controversial'' but I didn't expect something ''this big'', something this... ''notorious''. So, do you have my piece on the matter? I had no involvement with that whatsoever.\\
''(cut back to Zaid Magenta, who's [[DeathGlare glaring at the camera]])''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' ''([[TranquilFury calmly]])'' ''So that's it? You really had to go there didn't you?!'' Your ''spitefulness'' towards Pinkie Pie, your growing hatred for her got ''so bad'', that you sent ''[[DisproportionateRetribution death threats]]'' to Amy Keating Rogers ''[[UngratefulBastard after all the times you've told her you loved her writing]].'' ''(growing angrier)'' Is... is that it?! Is that what ''all this is to you?!'' You ''constantly demand'' that the writers give you well-written stories and episodes. ''(getting even angrier)'' And when you ''don't get that'', you send them hate mail and ''death threats?!?!'' ''Death threats...'' just because of how much you started to hate Diane.[[note]]"Pinkamena '''Diane''' Pie", is Pinkie's full name.[[/note]]\\
''(Zaid Magenta continues to glare for several seconds without saying anything. And, as we hear noises in the background followed by piano music starting up, the screen goes black as a warning appears, then it disappears leaving just a black screen)''\\
'''Zaid Magenta (offscreen):''' ''Stupid!!'' '''''IT WAS ALL A COMPLETE [[PrecisionFStrike FUCKING]] WASTE OF TIME!!!'''''\\
''([[RageBreakingPoint a really pissed off]] Zaid Magenta appears back on screen)''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' '''''ALL OF IT!!!''''' All of... ''({{facepalm}})'' ''IT WAS ALL LEADING TO'' '''''THIS!!'''''\\
''(cut back to the video by Golden Fox, the piano music still playing over it)''\\
'''Golden Fox:''' ''(audio from video)'' ''Why death threats?!'' Are you going to be ''this over-reactive?!'' To those of you who ever did that, who you gave that to her, ''do I even need to say it?!'' It is a huge disservice to yourself, to the Brony fandom just... but I think it's even more screwed up that somebody, somewhere, ''somehow'' would get ''this'' overreactive, to get this over-the-top and throw it towards Amy because they weren't pleased with the way the episode was written. I-I'm utterly speechless. You've given us a bad name by doing that... just [[PrecisionFStrike fucking]] wow!\\
''(we cut back to Zaid Magenta)''\\
'''Zaid Magenta:''' ''THIS IS IT?! '''THIS''' IS WHAT I PUT UP WITH THOSE HATEFUL COMMENTS FOR?! ALL THAT TIME I SPENT DOING MY BEST TO DEFEND YOU AND '''STICK UP''' FOR YOU AND IT TURNS OUT, YOU'RE NO BETTER THAN THE IDIOTS OF THE [[TakeThat YOUTUBE COMMENT SECTION]], WHO BLINDLY HATE YOU!!'' THIS IS BULLSHIT! I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT I CONVINCED MYSELF FOR A SINGLE MICROSECOND THAT THIS FANDOM WAS ''SPECIAL!'' YOU SPEND ''LESS TIME'' UNITING EACH OTHER IN THE VERY THING THAT HAS GIVEN YOU YOUR '''''IDENTITY''''' AND SPEND ''MORE TIME'' THINKING OF NEW REASONS TO '''HATE EACH OTHER!!''' DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA HOW '''EMBARRASSING THAT IS,''' HOW '''''HUMILIATING THAT FEELS?!?!''''' WHY THE '''HELL''' DID I EVEN BOTHER! I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN BETTER THAN TO BELIEVE THIS FANDOM WAS SPECIAL! I CAN'T EVEN THINK OF A REASON AS TO WHY I WANTED TO BE IN THIS FANDOM TO BEGIN WITH! I DON'T KNOW WHY YOU WASTED SO MUCH TIME TRYING TO PERSUADE OTHERS THAT YOU'RE BETTER THAN OTHERS WHEN ''YOU'RE ALL THE'' '''''EXACT SAME!!''''' [[ItsAllAboutMe YOU'RE A SELFISH POPULATION OF PEOPLE WHO DON'T CARE ABOUT ANYONE BUT THEMSELVES]]! AND THE SAME GOES FOR ''YOU'' [[WhamLine BROANALYSIS COMMUNITY]], [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech ALL THAT TIME YOU SPENT TRICKING ME INTO BELIEVING YOU WERE A BEACON OF HOPE FOR THIS FANDOM AND AS IT TURNS OUT, YOU ARE SOME OF THE WORST EXAMPLES OF PEOPLE WHO EVER STARTED WATCHING THIS SHOW IN THE FIRST PLACE!]] I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHY I WANTED TO BE ASSOCIATED WITH ANY OF YOU, YOU'RE ALL A BUNCH OF [[LazyBum LAZY]], [[IgnoranceIsBliss IGNORANT]], [[{{hypocrite}} HYPOCRITICAL]], [[DisproportionateRetribution OVERREACTING]], [[EntitledBastard SELF-ENTITLED]], NON-NEGOTIABLE, OVERBEARING, KNOW-IT-ALL, ILL-MANNERED, ''[[ChronicBackstabbingDisorder BACKSTABBING]], [[SmallNameBigEgo EGOTISTICAL]], [[TrashTalk TRASH-TALKING]], CONFUSING, ARGUMENTATIVE, [[ItsAllAboutMe SELFISH]], ASS-KISSING, OBLIVIOUS, '''CERTIFIABLY INSANE, [[{{Jerkass}} JERKS!!!]]'''''
** Him tearfully apologizing to everyone in the fandom in his "Guilt" confession video.
-->'''Zaid Magenta:''' I'm sorry... I'm sorry to everyone that I hurt through my selfish ranting...
** He
sounds genuinely upset at certain points during his video breaking down how the Grogar twist in the finale of "Friendship is Magic" trashed Discord's character development, especially when he showed clips from the Season 4 finale where Discord was giving Twilight the medallion that was given to him by Tirek.

Top