Follow TV Tropes

Following

History SpiritualAntithesis / LiveActionFilms

Go To

OR

Changed: 627

Removed: 445

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/DarkestHour'' is this to ''Film/{{Downfall}}'': in both the audience is following a UsefulNotes/WorldWarII leader who is in an utterly desperate situation, seen largely from the point of view of their respective secretaries. Both are surrounded by advisors who urge surrender. The major difference is that Churchill's "mad" suggestion for evacuating Dunkirk succeeds, whereas Hitler's mad hopes of an eleventh hour victory over the Allied forces are crushed.
** Also, the Churchill of ''Darkest Hour'' is the OnlySaneMan who understands the Nazi menace, compared to the delusional peace faction, who believe that Hitler will stop short of invading England if offered the right incentive, with the right amount of obsequiousnesss; while the Hitler of ''Downfall'' is a delusional madman, surrounded by sane men who know that Germany's choices have been reduced to humiliating defeat or utter annihilation.

to:

* ''Film/DarkestHour'' is this to ''Film/{{Downfall}}'': in ''Film/{{Downfall}}''. In both films, the audience is following a UsefulNotes/WorldWarII leader who is in an utterly desperate situation, situation while his advisors urge surrender, seen largely from the point of view of their respective secretaries. Both are surrounded by ''Downfall'' presents its subject, UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler, as a madman whose advisors who urge surrender. The major difference is realize that Churchill's "mad" suggestion for evacuating Dunkirk succeeds, whereas Hitler's mad his hopes of for an eleventh hour eleventh-hour victory over the Allied forces are crushed.
** Also, the Churchill of ''Darkest Hour'' is the OnlySaneMan who understands the Nazi menace, compared to the delusional peace faction, who believe that Hitler will stop short of invading England if offered the right incentive, with the right amount of obsequiousnesss; while the Hitler of ''Downfall'' is a delusional madman, surrounded by sane men who know
delusional, and that Germany's choices have been reduced to humiliating defeat or utter annihilation.annihilation. ''Darkest Hour'', meanwhile, presents its subject UsefulNotes/WinstonChurchill as the OnlySaneMan who understands the Nazi menace and whose "mad" suggestion for evacuating Dunkirk succeeds, while the peace faction who believe that Hitler will stop short of invading the United Kingdom if offered the right incentive are portrayed as the delusional ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wick change


** ''Film/ThorRagnarok'' to ''Film/CaptainAmericaCivilWar''. At the barest level, the two films do have a vaguely similar premise: [[Characters/MCUSteveRogers Captain America]] and [[Characters/MCUThorOdinson Thor]] are faced with a situation that [[ICantDoThisByMyself they cannot handle on their own]], [[{{Crossover}} so they form alliances with heroes outside their solo franchises]] in a manner similar to ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'' [[Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron films]]. However, that is the only similarity the two films have. ''Captain America: Civil War'' is a [[DarkerAndEdgier gritty]], Earth-based political thriller that [[DestructiveHero emphasizes the collateral damage of superhero battles]] and [[DysfunctionJunction how traumatized the heroes themselves are]], and depicts [[Characters/MCUSteveRogers Captain America]] and [[Characters/MCUTonyStark Iron Man]] fighting [[spoiler:due to the machinations of [[Characters/MCUHelmutZemo Helmut Zemo]], a non-powered, non-costumed villain]] [[BreakingTheFellowship effectively ending the Avengers as we know them]]. ''Thor: Ragnarok'', by contrast, is a giddy SpaceOpera and BuddyPicture that embraces the cosmic aesthetic of Creator/JackKirby, and involves [[Characters/MCUThorOdinson Thor]] ''assembling'' a team [[PuttingTheBandBackTogether of fellow former Avengers and warriors of Asgard]] such as [[Characters/MCUBruceBanner The Hulk]], [[Characters/MCUAsgard Valkyrie]], and his former enemy [[Characters/MCULokiLaufeyson Loki]] against [[Characters/MCUHela Hela]], a superpowered, scenery-chewing [[KnightOfCerebus Goddess of Death]]. Also, while ''Civil War'' was largely set up by the events of second ''Avengers'' movie ''Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron'', ''Ragnarok'' plays an important role in setting up the ''third'' ''Avengers'' movie, ''Film/AvengersInfinityWar''.

to:

** ''Film/ThorRagnarok'' to ''Film/CaptainAmericaCivilWar''. At the barest level, the two films do have a vaguely similar premise: [[Characters/MCUSteveRogers Captain America]] and [[Characters/MCUThorOdinson Thor]] are faced with a situation that [[ICantDoThisByMyself they cannot handle on their own]], [[{{Crossover}} so they form alliances with heroes outside their solo franchises]] in a manner similar to ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'' [[Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron films]]. However, that is the only similarity the two films have. ''Captain America: Civil War'' is a [[DarkerAndEdgier gritty]], Earth-based political thriller that [[DestructiveHero emphasizes the collateral damage of superhero battles]] and [[DysfunctionJunction how traumatized the heroes themselves are]], and depicts [[Characters/MCUSteveRogers Captain America]] and [[Characters/MCUTonyStark Iron Man]] fighting [[spoiler:due to the machinations of [[Characters/MCUHelmutZemo Helmut Zemo]], a non-powered, non-costumed villain]] [[BreakingTheFellowship effectively ending the Avengers as we know them]]. ''Thor: Ragnarok'', by contrast, is a giddy SpaceOpera and BuddyPicture that embraces the cosmic aesthetic of Creator/JackKirby, and involves [[Characters/MCUThorOdinson Thor]] ''assembling'' a team [[PuttingTheBandBackTogether of fellow former Avengers and warriors of Asgard]] such as [[Characters/MCUBruceBanner The Hulk]], [[Characters/MCUAsgard Valkyrie]], and his former enemy [[Characters/MCULokiLaufeyson Loki]] against [[Characters/MCUHela [[Characters/MCUHelaOdinsdottir Hela]], a superpowered, scenery-chewing [[KnightOfCerebus Goddess of Death]]. Also, while ''Civil War'' was largely set up by the events of second ''Avengers'' movie ''Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron'', ''Ragnarok'' plays an important role in setting up the ''third'' ''Avengers'' movie, ''Film/AvengersInfinityWar''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by [[Creator/RadioSilence Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett]] and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. [[spoiler:Both films also end with a [[FinalGirl lone woman surviving the carnage]] after earning some VillainRespect from the BigBad.]] However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of [[AntiHero sympathetic criminals]] seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnapper her captors]].

to:

* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by [[Creator/RadioSilence Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett]] and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. [[spoiler:Both Both films also make prominent use of people exploding into LudicrousGibs, [[spoiler:and end with a [[FinalGirl lone woman surviving the carnage]] after earning some VillainRespect from the BigBad.]] However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of [[AntiHero sympathetic criminals]] seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnapper her captors]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. [[spoiler:Both films also end with a [[FinalGirl lone woman surviving the carnage]] after earning some VillainRespect from the BigBad.]] However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of [[AntiHero sympathetic criminals]] seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnapper her captors]].

to:

* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by [[Creator/RadioSilence Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett Gillett]] and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. [[spoiler:Both films also end with a [[FinalGirl lone woman surviving the carnage]] after earning some VillainRespect from the BigBad.]] However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of [[AntiHero sympathetic criminals]] seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnapper her captors]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of sympathetic criminals seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnapper her captors]].

to:

* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. [[spoiler:Both films also end with a [[FinalGirl lone woman surviving the carnage]] after earning some VillainRespect from the BigBad.]] However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of [[AntiHero sympathetic criminals criminals]] seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnapper her captors]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse of the page/link. Spiritual Antithesis is for stories, not characters.


* A character example rather than a story one: ''Film/MyNameIsEmily'' has Emily Egan as the SpiritualAntithesis of ''Film/HarryPotter'''s Luna Lovegood. Both girls have {{Missing Mom}}s who died in accidents when they were children. Both have a CloudCuckooLander writer for a father and both are bullied at school for their oddness. Luna is ThePollyanna about her situation, has a close-knit relationship with her father and her quirky attitude causes CharacterDevelopment for others -- not to mention that she is portrayed as lovably odd. Emily meanwhile is bitter and depressed, is estranged from her father, is nearly DrivenToSuicide over her situation and undergoes CharacterDevelopment herself through friendships -- and her oddness is used to show how detached she is from reality. The kicker? ''Both'' are played by Creator/EvannaLynch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of sympathetic criminals seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnappers her captors]].

to:

* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of sympathetic criminals seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnappers [[PityTheKidnapper her captors]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/Abigail2024'' to ''Film/ReadyOrNot2019''. Both are horror films with strong BlackComedy elements directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett and written by Guy Busick that are set in a BigFancyHouse in which a female character faces off against a group of people who are trying to kill her. However, in ''Ready or Not'' said female character is the hero, a young newlywed from a [[WorkingClassHero working-class background]] who married into a family of [[UpperClassTwit Upper-Class Twits]] only for that family to try and [[HumanSacrifice sacrifice her]] as part of a DealWithTheDevil. In ''Abigail'', meanwhile, the titular female character is the villain, a [[UndeadChild child vampire]] who is kidnapped by a group of sympathetic criminals seeking to extort her wealthy father and proceeds to [[MuggingTheMonster turn the tables]] on [[PityTheKidnappers her captors]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s), Crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

*''Film/LastNightInSoho'' and ''Film/MidnightInParis'', as both protagonists believe they are BornInTheWrongCentury according to the city they are visiting (London & Paris respectively). Both find a way to magically transport back to the golden age of each city, but while ''Film/MidnightInParis'' is a romantic comedy that explores nostalgia [[spoiler: in general by unlocking further time travelling to a more distant past]], ''Film/LastNightInSoho'' is a a PsychologicalHorror {{Deconstruction}} of the NostalgiaFilter we tend to have for older eras.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/PansLabyrinth'' is the antithesis to ''Literature/AliceInWonderland'', having the same plot structure of a girl going DownTheRabbitHole to a fantasy world, escaping from the real world. Where Alice generally faces whimsical and harmless characters, with no great danger, Ofelia faces the terror of the Spanish Civil War and the danger posed by her new stepfather, the cruel Captain Vidal.[[note]]Captain Vidal, in fact, kills people left and right throughout the film, and only tolerates Ofelia because her mother is pregnant with his son.[[/note]] The tone is notably darker, mixing elements of Brother's Grimm dark fairy tales and the tone of a war movie where AnyoneCanDie. It calls attention to being an antithesis by having Ofelia wear a green color swapped version of the Blue dress Alice is typically depicted in. Whereas Alice's dress is usually pristine and clean no matter what happens, at one point Ofelia angers her mother and stepfather by coming in a soiled dress after one of her supernatural tests.

Added: 656

Removed: 626

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The antisemitic UsefulNotes/{{Nazi|Germany}} propaganda film ''[[Film/JewSuss1940 Jud Süss]]'' is a case of this to a little known British film ''[[Film/JewSuss1934 Jew Süss]]'', which adapted a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jud_Suss_(Feuchtwanger_novel) novel of the same name]] by German-Jewish author Lion Feuchtwanger. The earlier novel/film is based upon a [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_S%C3%BC%C3%9F_Oppenheimer historical person]] and a MiscarriageOfJustice that lead to his execution, which the Nazi film turns into karma for a GreedyJew. This also makes the Nazi film a combination of AdaptationalVillainy and HistoricalVillainUpgrade.



* The anti-semitic Nazi propaganda film ''[[Film/JewSuss1940 Jud Süss]]'' is a case of this to a little known British film ''Film/{{Jew Suss|1934}}'', which adapted a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jud_Suss_(Feuchtwanger_novel) novel of the same name]] by German-Jewish author Lion Feuchtwanger. The earlier novel/film is based upon a [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_S%C3%BC%C3%9F_Oppenheimer historical person]] and a MiscarriageOfJustice that lead to his execution, which the Nazi film turns into karma for a GreedyJew. This also makes the Nazi film a combination of AdaptationalVillainy and HistoricalVillainUpgrade.


* ''Film/TheThirdMan'' for ''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. Seriously, watch them back to back. It's amazing. And depressing.

to:

* %%* ''Film/TheThirdMan'' for ''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. Seriously, watch them back to back. It's amazing. And depressing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Daybreakers}}'' is this to ''Film/Ultraviolet2006'', as both take place in TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture {{Dystopia}}s featuring [[OurVampiresAreDifferent Vampires]]. However, Film/{{Daybreakers}} is set in a world where vampires rule but [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything are running out of human blood]], while in Ultraviolet, the [[NotUsingTheZWord Hematophages]] are a FantasticUnderclass suffering from discrimination and attacks by humans.

to:

* ''Film/{{Daybreakers}}'' is this to ''Film/Ultraviolet2006'', as both take place in TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture {{Dystopia}}s featuring [[OurVampiresAreDifferent Vampires]]. However, Film/{{Daybreakers}} ''Film/{{Daybreakers}}'' is set in a world where vampires rule but [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything are running out of human blood]], while in Ultraviolet, ''Ultraviolet'', the [[NotUsingTheZWord Hematophages]] are a FantasticUnderclass suffering from [[FantasticRacism discrimination and attacks by humans.humans]].

Top