Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / TheFallOfTheHouseOfUsher2023

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Frederick receives [[spoiler: the bag of cocaine he asked Napoleon for, and which caused his most vile tendencies to ramp up when he started using it. Fittingly, given Verna's admission of taking a more direct hand in his death, it's also very simply the method with which he was killed - that is, it also contains the nightshade powder Verna distracted him into filling it with that paralysed him before he was cut in two; and as a mark of Verna's distain for him, she simply drops the bag on his tombstone as opposed to being careful when setting it in place.]]

to:

** Frederick receives [[spoiler: the bag of cocaine he asked Napoleon for, and which caused his most vile tendencies to ramp up when he started using it. Fittingly, given Verna's admission of taking a more direct hand in his death, it's also very simply the method with which he was killed - that is, it also contains the nightshade powder Verna distracted him into filling it with that paralysed him before he was cut in two; and as a mark of Verna's distain disdain for him, she simply drops the bag on his tombstone as opposed to being careful when setting it in place.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also averted by [[spoiler: Arthur, when offered his own DealWithTheDevil by Verna; despite the fact that he will spend the rest of his life in prison if he doesn't take it, whatever "leverage" it would cost him isn't worth what Verna's offering.]]

Added: 146

Changed: 93

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryManHasHisPrice: Defied by Verna, who laughs off Roderick and Madeline's attempts to "renegotiate" their deal and insists the terms are set.



* PartingWordsRegret: It weighs on Roderick that the last time he saw some of his children alive was the family dinner he spent trying to flush out the informant.

to:

* PartingWordsRegret: It weighs on Roderick that the last time he saw some of his children alive was the family dinner he spent trying to flush out the informant. [[spoiler: Especially since the informant wasn't even real.]]



* PracticallyDifferentGenerations: Many of the children have considerable gaps in age due to being from different mothers. For example, Frederick and Prospero, the oldest and youngest respectively, are played by actors about thirty years apart in age, and in-universe Prospero is barely older than Frederick's daughter Lenore.

to:

* PracticallyDifferentGenerations: Many of the children have considerable gaps in age due to being from different mothers. For example, Frederick and Prospero, the oldest and youngest respectively, are played by actors about thirty years apart in age, and in-universe Prospero is barely roughly ten to thirteen years older than Frederick's daughter Lenore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InnBetweenTheWorlds: [[spoiler:Verna's bar, which she herself describes as "outside of time and space," though this particular variation on the trope also carries notes of TheLittleShopThatWasntThereYesterday. ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmicDeath [[spoiler:After torturing Morrie with a paralytic and torturing her while she can't fight back and peeing in the spot where Perry died, Frederick is paralyzed by the same paralytic and dies in the same spot as his brother in a puddle of his own piss, utterly powerless as he is slowly sliced apart.]]

to:

* KarmicDeath KarmicDeath: [[spoiler:After torturing Morrie with a paralytic and torturing her while she can't fight back and peeing in the spot where Perry died, Frederick is paralyzed by the same paralytic and dies in the same spot as his brother in a puddle of his own piss, utterly powerless as he is slowly sliced apart.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse (not what Rule of Three is)


** Camille L'Espanaye, [[RuleOfThree yet another one of Roderick Usher's illegitimate children]], shares her name with one of the murder victims in the first Literature/CAugusteDupin story, ''The Murders in the Rue Morgue''.

to:

** Camille L'Espanaye, [[RuleOfThree yet another one of Roderick Usher's illegitimate children]], children, shares her name with one of the murder victims in the first Literature/CAugusteDupin story, ''The Murders in the Rue Morgue''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
per discussion, tying to real life tragedy is discouraged. Removing.


* BodyHorror: [[spoiler:What starts as the beginning of a sexy anonymous masked party filled with hunky men and beautiful women quickly turns into a horrific nightmare as acidic chemicals rain down on them from the ceiling, causing their skin, flesh and even ''bones'' to start burning, smoking and ''melting like candle wax'', all while they are screaming, crying and banging on the locked doors in a fruitless attempt to escape. It bears a disturbing resemblance to RealLife shootings and other horrific attacks on nightclubs and the innocent people whose lives were ended while they desperately tried to flee. Between this and the distressing sounds and visuals, one could argue this is the most dismaying and brutal death in the entire show, and can be triggering for anyone who has experienced an event turned violent. It's revealed in the aftermath of this tragedy that upwards of 78 people and counting had died this way, their flesh and internal organs melted into a bloody goo on the floor. The fact Verna took the time to evacuate all the wait staff, but none of the guests other than Morella, implies she considered them deserving of dying alongside Prospero, but without any exposition on this matter the audience is left to wonder [[DisproportionateRetribution what on Earth they could have possibly done to deserve such a scary and horrific death]].]]

to:

* BodyHorror: [[spoiler:What starts as the beginning of a sexy anonymous masked orgy party filled with hunky men and beautiful women quickly turns into a horrific nightmare as acidic chemicals rain down on them from the ceiling, causing ceiling--causing their skin, flesh and even ''bones'' to start burning, smoking and ''melting like candle wax'', all while they are screaming, crying and banging on the locked doors in a fruitless attempt to escape. It bears a disturbing resemblance to RealLife shootings and other horrific attacks on nightclubs and the innocent people whose lives were ended while they desperately tried to flee. Between this and With the distressing sounds and visuals, one could argue this is the most dismaying and brutal death in the entire show, and can be triggering for anyone who has experienced an event turned violent. show. It's revealed in the aftermath of this tragedy that upwards of 78 people and counting had died this way, their flesh and internal organs melted into a bloody goo on the floor. The fact Verna took the time to evacuate all the wait staff, but none of the guests other than Morella, implies she considered them deserving of dying alongside Prospero, but Prospero. But without any exposition on this matter matter, the audience is left to wonder [[DisproportionateRetribution what on Earth they the victims could have possibly done to deserve such a scary and horrific death]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Roderick's boss Rufus Griswold exploits Roderick in a number of ways, but most egregiously, sets it up so that [[spoiler: the US government's case against Fortunato rests on Roderick's testimony, which Roderick then withdraws at the hearing; the case collapses, and Fortunato goes on to create the modern opioid crisis.]] When the twins [[spoiler: brick Longfellow up behind a wall in the basement of the new company headquarters]], it's hard not to feel some satisfaction.

to:

** Roderick's boss Rufus Griswold exploits Roderick in a number of ways, but most egregiously, sets it up so that [[spoiler: the US government's case against Fortunato rests on Roderick's testimony, which Roderick then withdraws at the hearing; the case collapses, and Fortunato goes on to create the modern opioid crisis.]] When the twins [[spoiler: brick Longfellow Griswold up behind a wall in the basement of the new company headquarters]], it's hard not to feel some satisfaction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Griswold and Longfellow's name were swapped


** Madeline and Roderick's biological father Rufus Griswold. When, as curious children, they're caught sneaking onto his property, he threatens them; when their mother Elizabeth, who was his secretary, becomes mentally ill, he fires her; when they come to him begging for help because Elizabeth is dying, he laughs in their faces. [[spoiler: Elizabeth then [[KarmicDeath murders him during a dissociative episode.]] ]]
** Roderick's boss William Longfellow exploits Roderick in a number of ways, but most egregiously, sets it up so that [[spoiler: the US government's case against Fortunato rests on Roderick's testimony, which Roderick then withdraws at the hearing; the case collapses, and Fortunato goes on to create the modern opioid crisis.]] When the twins [[spoiler: brick Longfellow up behind a wall in the basement of the new company headquarters]], it's hard not to feel some satisfaction.

to:

** Madeline and Roderick's biological father Rufus Griswold.William Longfellow. When, as curious children, they're caught sneaking onto his property, he threatens them; when their mother Elizabeth, who was his secretary, becomes mentally ill, he fires her; when they come to him begging for help because Elizabeth is dying, he laughs in their faces. [[spoiler: Elizabeth then [[KarmicDeath murders him during a dissociative episode.]] ]]
** Roderick's boss William Longfellow Rufus Griswold exploits Roderick in a number of ways, but most egregiously, sets it up so that [[spoiler: the US government's case against Fortunato rests on Roderick's testimony, which Roderick then withdraws at the hearing; the case collapses, and Fortunato goes on to create the modern opioid crisis.]] When the twins [[spoiler: brick Longfellow up behind a wall in the basement of the new company headquarters]], it's hard not to feel some satisfaction.

Added: 1583

Changed: 336

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssholeVictim: TheSeries. It's probably easier to list the characters who ''don't'' deserve to die. The Usher clan is (with four notable exceptions, two of whom married into the family), a bunch of amoral and corrupt one-percenters willing to do anything to get to and stay on the top of the world, comfortable in the knowledge that their money and power [[spoiler:and a little bit of supernatural aid]] will keep them consequence free.

to:

* AssholeVictim: TheSeries. It's probably easier to list the characters who ''don't'' deserve to die.
**
The Usher clan is (with four notable exceptions, two of whom married into the family), a bunch of amoral and corrupt one-percenters willing to do anything to get to and stay on the top of the world, comfortable in the knowledge that their money and power [[spoiler:and a little bit of supernatural aid]] will keep them consequence free.free.
** Madeline and Roderick's biological father Rufus Griswold. When, as curious children, they're caught sneaking onto his property, he threatens them; when their mother Elizabeth, who was his secretary, becomes mentally ill, he fires her; when they come to him begging for help because Elizabeth is dying, he laughs in their faces. [[spoiler: Elizabeth then [[KarmicDeath murders him during a dissociative episode.]] ]]
** Roderick's boss William Longfellow exploits Roderick in a number of ways, but most egregiously, sets it up so that [[spoiler: the US government's case against Fortunato rests on Roderick's testimony, which Roderick then withdraws at the hearing; the case collapses, and Fortunato goes on to create the modern opioid crisis.]] When the twins [[spoiler: brick Longfellow up behind a wall in the basement of the new company headquarters]], it's hard not to feel some satisfaction.


Added DiffLines:

* DistinctionWithoutADifference: The Ushers and their cronies insist that Ligadone is not addictive. Roderick does, however, acknowledge that people who decide to taper off it are going to experience an EpicCatalog of very unpleasant symptoms that sounds, if anything, worse than what most opioid addicts go through when experiencing withdrawal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's a curious example with Creator/EdgarAllanPoe; his poetry does ''exist'' since it's quoted by numerous characters, but in-universe Roderick seems to have written at least two of Poe's poems himself and [[spoiler:in the alternate universe where he didn't take Verna's deal, he would have been a poet.]]

to:

** There's a curious example with Creator/EdgarAllanPoe; his poetry does ''exist'' since it's quoted by numerous characters, but he himself is never mentioned and in-universe Roderick seems to have written at least two of Poe's poems himself and [[spoiler:in the alternate universe where he didn't take Verna's deal, he would have been a poet.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:The audience never finds out what did the guests at Perry's orgy did to merit their dying gruesomely alongside him.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:The audience never finds out what did exactly the guests at Perry's orgy did to merit their dying gruesomely alongside him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Annabel[[spoiler:’s ghost]] to Roderick, raking him across the coals for his [[AbusiveParents neglectful, malignant parenting]] of their children. It’s notably one of the only times in the entire series that Roderick [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone shows genuine remorse.]]
-->'''Annabel:''' “He’s rich.” When people asked how you took them, how you convinced them away from me, [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney “he’s rich,”]] I’d say. “He’s rich.” And you don’t understand what that word means. They were young. They only knew appetite, and “Here,” you said, “come with me. Gorge yourselves.” ''How could I compete with that?'' You didn’t feed them, though, did you? You '''starved them.''' Less and less of them came back each time until one day, they were ''empty.'' They were ''siphoned.'' [[TheCorrupter You started filling them up with…]] [[ArmorPiercingQuestion What]] ''[[ArmorPiercingQuestion did]]'' [[ArmorPiercingQuestion you fill them up with, Roderick? What did you]] ''[[ArmorPiercingQuestion have]]'' [[ArmorPiercingQuestion to fill them up with??]] Because you weren’t rich, were you? I thought you were a rich man, all this time, but… I see you now. I look at you and I see… ''you.'' [[LonelyAtTheTop The poverty of you.]]

to:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Annabel[[spoiler:’s ghost]] delivers one to Roderick, raking him across the coals for his [[AbusiveParents neglectful, malignant parenting]] of their children. It’s notably one of the only times in the entire series that Roderick [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone shows genuine remorse.]]
-->'''Annabel:''' “He’s rich.” When people asked how you took them, how you convinced them away from me, [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney “he’s rich,”]] I’d say. “He’s rich.” And you don’t understand what that word means. They were young. They only knew appetite, and “Here,” you said, “come with me. Gorge yourselves.” ''How could I compete with that?'' You didn’t feed them, though, did you? You '''starved them.''' Less and less of them came back each time until one day, they were ''empty.'' They were ''siphoned.'' [[TheCorrupter You started filling them up with…]] [[ArmorPiercingQuestion What]] ''[[ArmorPiercingQuestion did]]'' [[ArmorPiercingQuestion you fill them up with, Roderick? What did you]] ''[[ArmorPiercingQuestion have]]'' [[ArmorPiercingQuestion to fill them up with??]] Because you weren’t rich, were you? I thought you were a rich man, all this time, but… I see you now. I look at you and I see… ''you.'' [[LonelyAtTheTop The poverty of you.]]

Added: 546

Changed: 233

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CelebrityParadox: A character watches ''Film/GeraldsGame'', [[ProductionThrowback a prior work]] of Creator/MikeFlanagan. No word on who plays that film's protagonists while Creator/CarlaGugino and Creator/BruceGreenwood play Verna and Roderick here.

to:

* CelebrityParadox: CelebrityParadox:
**
A character watches ''Film/GeraldsGame'', [[ProductionThrowback a prior work]] of Creator/MikeFlanagan. No word on who plays that film's protagonists while Creator/CarlaGugino and Creator/BruceGreenwood play Verna and Roderick here. here.
** There's a curious example with Creator/EdgarAllanPoe; his poetry does ''exist'' since it's quoted by numerous characters, but in-universe Roderick seems to have written at least two of Poe's poems himself and [[spoiler:in the alternate universe where he didn't take Verna's deal, he would have been a poet.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Morella is a beloved wife and mother to Frederick and Lenore, who is often ridiculed by the other Usher family members, but not only is she invited to Perry's pop-up orgy just so that Perry can attempt to blackmail Frederick to get back at him, she becomes hideously burned and deformed by the acidic sprinklers. When she shows signs of recovery, to Lenore's joy, she's brought home by Frederick - but it's revealed that he didn't do this to get her better care. [[spoiler:It was to medically torture and abuse her with paralytic drugs to keep her unable to move and forcibly pull her teeth with pliers, because Frederick, deranged by cocaine, deeply believed that because of her mysterious phone and Morrie being at the party, Morella was cheating on him with his younger brother.]]
** Juno. She continues tries to be a part of the family and thoroughly mourns the death of each Usher, despite the kids' varying levels of hatred towards her. Roderick is essentially keeping her on Ligodone as a spokesperson and mocks her requests to stop taking it, despite her fears of becoming addicted once more and of suffering the side effects others have undergone.

to:

** Morella is a beloved wife and mother to Frederick and Lenore, who is often ridiculed by the other Usher family members, but not only is she invited to Perry's pop-up orgy just so that Perry can attempt to blackmail Frederick to get back at him, she becomes hideously burned and deformed by the acidic sprinklers. When she shows signs of recovery, to Lenore's joy, she's brought home by Frederick - but it's revealed that he didn't do this to get her better care. [[spoiler:It was to medically torture and abuse her with paralytic drugs to keep her unable to move and forcibly pull her teeth with pliers, because Frederick, deranged by cocaine, deeply believed that because of her mysterious burner phone and Morrie being at the party, Morella was cheating on him with his younger brother.]]
** Juno. She continues continually tries to be a part of the family and thoroughly mourns the death of each Usher, despite the kids' varying levels of hatred towards her. Roderick is essentially keeping her on Ligodone as a spokesperson and mocks her requests to stop taking it, despite her fears of becoming addicted once more and of suffering the side effects others have undergone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney: Pretty much the Usher family motto, one more or less directly articulated by various members of the family when they face any resistance. The family has been able to use its extraordinary wealth to evade consequences for its crimes going back nearly 50 years. Of course, that ethos finds its limits when it runs up against Verna, who can't be bribed [[spoiler: and will ruthlessly enforce the rules of her agreement with Roderick and Madeline.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Annabel[[spoiler:’s ghost]] to Roderick, raking him across the coals for his [[AbusiveParents neglectful, malignant parenting]] of their children. It’s notably one of the only times in the entire series that Roderick [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone shows genuine remorse.]]
-->'''Annabel:''' “He’s rich.” When people asked how you took them, how you convinced them away from me, [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney “he’s rich,”]] I’d say. “He’s rich.” And you don’t understand what that word means. They were young. They only knew appetite, and “Here,” you said, “come with me. Gorge yourselves.” ''How could I compete with that?'' You didn’t feed them, though, did you? You '''starved them.''' Less and less of them came back each time until one day, they were ''empty.'' They were ''siphoned.'' [[TheCorrupter You started filling them up with…]] [[ArmorPiercingQuestion What]] ''[[ArmorPiercingQuestion did]]'' [[ArmorPiercingQuestion you fill them up with, Roderick? What did you]] ''[[ArmorPiercingQuestion have]]'' [[ArmorPiercingQuestion to fill them up with??]] Because you weren’t rich, were you? I thought you were a rich man, all this time, but… I see you now. I look at you and I see… ''you.'' [[LonelyAtTheTop The poverty of you.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HollywoodGenetics: Victorine is Roderick's natural daughter, making her half white, but actress Creator/TNiaMiller clearly has no significant white ancestry at all.

to:

* HollywoodGenetics: Victorine is Roderick's natural daughter, making her half white, but actress Creator/TNiaMiller clearly has no significant white ancestry at all. [[RealityIsUnrealistic Though people of biracial ancestry often can and do take after one of their backgrounds more than the other]].

Top