Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / DrDeath

Go To

OR

Added: 509

Changed: 237

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidYouActuallyBelieve: A reporter chastises Benita on how she could truly think the Pope was going to officiate the wedding for two divorced non-Catholics packed with major celebrities. Benita defends it on how Paolo could convince you of just about anything.

to:

* DidYouActuallyBelieve: DidYouActuallyBelieve:
**
A reporter chastises Benita on how she could truly think the Pope was going to officiate the wedding for two divorced non-Catholics packed with major celebrities. Benita defends it on how Paolo could convince you of just about anything.
** At their tribunal hearing, Gamelli says their only mistake was limiting their report to the patients Paolo treated in Sweden rather than all the others abroad. Seeing the confused looks of the presiding doctors, Gamelli dryly asks "you thought there were only three?"

Added: 422

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lasbrey gets this when a patient she encouraged to totally trust Paolo and his procedure dies. When the widow snaps "When you remember this day, will you feel shame?" Lasbrey can only give a tearful nod in reply.

to:

** Lasbrey gets this when a patient she encouraged to totally trust Paolo and his procedure dies. When the widow snaps snaps, "When you remember this day, will you feel shame?" Lasbrey can only give a tearful nod in reply.reply.
* TheNeedsOfTheMany: This is the excuse one doctor gives Gamelli as to why Karolinska is so adamant about protecting Paolo, because if it comes out they've been backing a fraud who killed patients, their reputation will be shattered and funding will dry up. Gamelli is appalled they're willing to cover a killer to help others.
-->'''Gamelli''': I can't believe you're taking his side.
-->'''Burt''': His side...is our side.

Added: 240

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LoopholeAbuse: The doctors think they have Paolo because of how he never got ethical approval for his procedures. Paolo just uses the loophole that his patients were in life-threatening conditions and he had no time to wait for red tape.



* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Invoked as Benita's coverage of Paolo had hospitals so convinced he was a "miracle worker" that they blackball the doctors trying to expose him. The worst is the doctors wondering how Paolo got past a key test needed for his procedures only to discover he never applied for it and no one bothered to check because they were so sure he was this genius pioneer.

to:

* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Invoked as Benita's coverage of Paolo had hospitals so convinced he was a "miracle worker" that they blackball the doctors trying to expose him. The worst is the doctors wondering how Paolo got past a key test ethical approval needed for his procedures only to discover he never applied for it and no one bothered to check because they were so sure he was this genius pioneer.

Added: 262

Changed: 252

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidYouActuallyBelieve: A reporter chastises Benita on how she could truly think the Pope was going to officiate the wedding for two divorced non-Catholics packed with major celebrities. Benita defends it on how Paolo could convince you of just about anything.




to:

* WomanScorned: A reporter warns Benita that any attempt by her to expose Paolo is only going to come off as her jealous about being dumped. Rather than weakening her resolve, Benita is ready to go forward, convincing the man her version is the truth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Invoked as Benita's coverage of Paolo had hospitals so convinced he was a "miracle worker" that they blackball the doctors trying to expose him. The worst is the doctors wondering how Paolo got past a key test needed for his procedures only to discover he never applied for it and no one bothered to check because they were so sure he was this genius pioneer.

Added: 1598

Changed: 1217

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Earlier, Paolo wowed Benita by playing a lovely concerto on a piano. During a brief power failure, the piano suddenly starts playing the same tune by itself with Benita realizing Paolo was never playing it in the first place.
* ConMan: Supposed top surgeon Paolo turns out to be this. All his research is based on fraudulent data and he's been running a score of scams on the side.
* FailedASpotCheck: Benita is kicking herself on how she got engaged to Paolo before really checking on him only to find his long trail of lies...such as the tiny detail he was married for almost thirty years before they met. There was also his claims of having been a thoracic surgeon at the University of Alabama only to find the university didn't ''have'' a thoracic department.

to:

** Paolo had also claimed the wedding would be attended by the likes of the Obamas and the Putins, that Andrea Bocelli would sing the wedding song and Enoteca Pinchiorri would cater it.
** Earlier, Paolo wowed Benita by playing a lovely concerto on a piano. During a brief power failure, the piano suddenly starts playing the same tune by itself itself, with Benita realizing Paolo was never playing it in the first place.
* ConMan: Supposed top surgeon Paolo turns out to be this. All his research is based on fraudulent data and he's been running a score of scams on the side.side while bragging of non-existent connections to the rich and powerful.
* CryLaughing: Benita has this when she heads to Italy for the address of Paolo's home, where she was ready to send all her belongings, only to find it's an empty lot.
* DidntThinkThisThrough: Invoked by Benita in what Paolo thought was going to happen when 300 people showed up in Italy for a celebrity-filled wedding that didn't exist while she had all her worldly possessions sent to an address that was an empty lot. "What was the plan?" It's indicated this shows how Paolo is so focused on the immediate outcomes that he never has any long-term goals besides his next big payday.

* FailedASpotCheck: Benita is kicking herself on how she got engaged to Paolo before really checking on him only to find his long trail of lies...such as the tiny detail he was married for almost thirty years before they met. There was also his claims of having been a thoracic surgeon at the University of Alabama only to find the university didn't ''have'' a thoracic department.department and being a "personal physician" for the Pope when the Vatican had never heard of him and that the Pope already had plenty of doctors.



* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? [[spoiler: A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.]][[note]] In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/note]]
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: A major push for Benita in exposing Paolo is how she helped him become famous.

to:

* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? gets from the Swedish courts? [[spoiler: A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.]][[note]] In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/note]]
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: MyGodWhatHaveIDone:
**
A major push for Benita in exposing Paolo is how she helped him become famous.


Added DiffLines:

** Lasbrey gets this when a patient she encouraged to totally trust Paolo and his procedure dies. When the widow snaps "When you remember this day, will you feel shame?" Lasbrey can only give a tearful nod in reply.


Added DiffLines:

* SpannerInTheWorks: Benita's investigation into Paolo in Italy is almost derailed when Lasbrey convinces Paolo's Russian patient to cancel a planned surgery so Paolo returns home earlier than expected.

Added: 229

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Earlier, Paolo wowed Benita by playing a lovely concerto on a piano. During a brief power failure, the piano suddenly starts playing the same tune by itself with Benita realizing Paolo was never playing it in the first place.



* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.[[note]] In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/note]]

to:

* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? [[spoiler: A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.[[note]] ]][[note]] In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.[[Note: In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/Note]]

to:

* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.[[Note: [[note]] In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/Note]][[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.[[note: In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/note]]

to:

* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.[[note: [[Note: In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/note]][[/Note]]

Added: 503

Changed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FailedASpotCheck: Benita is kicking herself on how she got engaged to Paolo before really checking on him only to find his long trail of lies...such as the tiny detail he was married for almost thirty years before they met.

to:

* FailedASpotCheck: Benita is kicking herself on how she got engaged to Paolo before really checking on him only to find his long trail of lies...such as the tiny detail he was married for almost thirty years before they met. There was also his claims of having been a thoracic surgeon at the University of Alabama only to find the university didn't ''have'' a thoracic department.


Added DiffLines:

* KarmaHoudini: After being given evidence of all of Paolo's lies and crimes, the worst he gets? A suspended sentence for causing bodily harm, allowing him to continue to practice.[[note: In June of 2023, after production was completed, the courts increased the sentence to two years and six months imprisonment.[[/note]]
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: A major push for Benita in exposing Paolo is how she helped him become famous.
-->'''Benita''': The entire world thinks he's this miracle worker because of me.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Gaslighting}}: As befitting a sociopath con man, Paolo has this in spades. He manages to convince a patient that he saved her life but ''removing her lung'' which was completely unneeded.

to:

* {{Gaslighting}}: As befitting a sociopath con man, Paolo has this in spades. He manages to convince a patient that he saved her life but by ''removing her lung'' which was completely unneeded.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Gaslighting}}: As befitting a sociopath con man, Paolo has this in spades. He manages to convince a patient that he saved her life but ''removing her lung'' which was completely unneeded.

Added: 603

Changed: 1295

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlatantLies: Paolo not only claimed to have been a longtime friend of Pope Francis but operated on the likes of Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and numerous other famous people. When representatives for these people deny his claims, Paolo merely says that [[ConvenientlyUnverifiableCoverStory he has to keep these operations secret because of the high profile people involved]].

to:

* BlatantLies: BlatantLies:
**
Paolo not only claimed to have been a longtime friend of Pope Francis but operated on the likes of Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and numerous other famous people. When representatives for these people deny his claims, Paolo merely says that [[ConvenientlyUnverifiableCoverStory he has to keep these operations secret because of the high profile people involved]].
** Having already started realizing Paolo is full of crap, Benita is thrown that her gay designer friend totally believes Paolo's tale that ''the Pope'' is going to give the designer and his husband holy communion to attend the ceremony.



* SpottingTheThread: Benita's eyes are opened to Paolo's lies when he'd claimed he'd talked his "good friend" Pope Francis into performing their wedding. But Benita discovered from a friend that Francis would be in South America all that summer. She then started calling up the hotels supposedly set for their wedding/honeymoon (which was to be just a few weeks off) to find none of them had any record of any events set up.
* TwoHalvesMakeAPlot: The first half of the season is divided between Benita meeting Paolo, falling for his lies only to discover he's a fraud while Svensson and Gamelli uncover Paolo's supposed research is all fraudulent.

to:

* SimultaneousArcs: The first half of the season is divided between Benita meeting Paolo, falling for his lies only to discover he's a fraud while Svensson and Gamelli uncover Paolo's supposed research is all fraudulent. It then moves to how each side tries to expose the truth.
* SpottingTheThread: Benita's eyes are opened to Paolo's lies when he'd claimed he claims he'd talked his "good friend" Pope Francis into performing their wedding. But Benita discovered from a friend that Francis would be in South America all that summer. She then started calling up the hotels supposedly set for their wedding/honeymoon (which was to be just a few weeks off) to find none of them had any record of any events set up.
* TwoHalvesMakeAPlot: The first half of the season is divided between Benita meeting Paolo, falling for his lies only to discover he's a fraud while Svensson and Gamelli uncover Paolo's supposed research is all fraudulent.

Added: 94

Changed: 2

Removed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlatantLies: Paolo not only claimed to have been a longtime friend of Pope Francis but operated on the likes of Barack Obama, HIllary Clinton and numerous other famous people. When representatives for these people deny his claims, Paolo merely says that [[ConvenientlyUnverifiableCoverStory he has to keep these operations secret because of the high profile people involved]].

to:

* BlatantLies: Paolo not only claimed to have been a longtime friend of Pope Francis but operated on the likes of Barack Obama, HIllary Hillary Clinton and numerous other famous people. When representatives for these people deny his claims, Paolo merely says that [[ConvenientlyUnverifiableCoverStory he has to keep these operations secret because of the high profile people involved]].



* CoughOfDoom: As soon as one of Paolo's "cured" patients starts having this, they're doomed.


Added DiffLines:

* IncurableCoughOfDeath: As soon as one of Paolo's "cured" patients has this, they're doomed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Season 1]]


Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Season 2]]
* BlatantLies: Paolo not only claimed to have been a longtime friend of Pope Francis but operated on the likes of Barack Obama, HIllary Clinton and numerous other famous people. When representatives for these people deny his claims, Paolo merely says that [[ConvenientlyUnverifiableCoverStory he has to keep these operations secret because of the high profile people involved]].
* ConMan: Supposed top surgeon Paolo turns out to be this. All his research is based on fraudulent data and he's been running a score of scams on the side.
* CoughOfDoom: As soon as one of Paolo's "cured" patients starts having this, they're doomed.
* FailedASpotCheck: Benita is kicking herself on how she got engaged to Paolo before really checking on him only to find his long trail of lies...such as the tiny detail he was married for almost thirty years before they met.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Even though it violates a few rules, a doctor gives Svensson evidence on Paolo's fraudulent data, knowing it's far more important to expose him than let confidentiality rules cost other patients their lives.
* SpottingTheThread: Benita's eyes are opened to Paolo's lies when he'd claimed he'd talked his "good friend" Pope Francis into performing their wedding. But Benita discovered from a friend that Francis would be in South America all that summer. She then started calling up the hotels supposedly set for their wedding/honeymoon (which was to be just a few weeks off) to find none of them had any record of any events set up.
* TwoHalvesMakeAPlot: The first half of the season is divided between Benita meeting Paolo, falling for his lies only to discover he's a fraud while Svensson and Gamelli uncover Paolo's supposed research is all fraudulent.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WrongLineOfWork: Invoked as a former classmate says Duntsch was truly gifted in med school but his strength was as a researcher and was totally unsuited for surgical work. She openly says if Duntsch stuck to research, "he'd be living in a mansion in Germantown right now."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IRejectYourReality: Pretty much Duntsch's entire worldview. It starts from refusing to hear anyone against him to when he's arrested and claiming "I came here on my own" when the cops had to pick him up and then the detective has to spell it out for Duntsch he's under arrest and can't just leave for Denver. Oh and both Duntsch's father and his public defender are stunned silent that Duntsch is seriously talking about getting his medical license back as soon as the trial is done.


Added DiffLines:

* ImplausibleDeniability: Episode 7 opens with Duntsch trying to blame everyone else for his mistakes to the point he claims the ''anesthesiolgist'' was responsible for a patient who died of ''blood loss''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MyGodYouAreSerious: A common reaction to the realization that yes, Duntsch is dead serious about some of his surgical choices. Also Kim's reaction when she realizes not only is he still treating patients after crippling Jerry but he honestly doesn't see why he shouldn't.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: Dr. Kirby's contempt for rules and regulations doesn't accomplish anything other than driving a wedge between himself and Dr. Henderson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A second season of the show was greenlit in 2022 and finished filming in 2023. This season will star Creator/EdgarRamirez as Paolo Macchiarini, an Italian thoracic surgeon who was discovered to have performed illegal experiments on patients with synthetic tracheas of his own design that turned out to cause fatal rejection, as Creator/MandyMoore as Benita Alexander, an NBC News producer who became romantically involved with Macchiarini only to discover his deceptions regarding his medical practices and their relationship.

to:

A second season of the show was greenlit in 2022 and finished filming in 2023. This season will star Creator/EdgarRamirez as Paolo Macchiarini, an Italian thoracic surgeon who was discovered to have performed illegal experiments on patients with synthetic tracheas of his own design that turned out to cause fatal rejection, as and Creator/MandyMoore as Benita Alexander, an NBC News producer who became romantically involved with Macchiarini only to discover his deceptions regarding his medical practices and their relationship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


A second season of the show was greenlit in 2022 and finished filming in 2023. This season will star Creator/EdgarRamirez as Paolo Macchiarini, an Italian thoracic surgeon who was discovered to have performed illegal experiments on patients with synthetic tracheas of his own design that turned out to cause fatal rejection, as Creator/MandyMoore as Benita Alexander, an NBC News producer who became romantically involved with Macchiarini only to discover his deceptions regarding his medical practices and their relationship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PsychopathicManchild: Duntsch reacts with petulant anger whenever someone questions his skills and continues to insist that he's a world-class surgeon even as his patients suffer from painful and sometimes fatal side effects, throwing the blame at everyone from the nurses and anesthesiologists to the patients themselves. He also tends to harass nurses, PAs, and fellow physicians like a grade school bully and shows an extreme sense of entitlement in his relationships with others.

to:

* PsychopathicManchild: Duntsch reacts with petulant anger whenever someone questions his skills and continues to insist that he's a world-class surgeon even as his patients suffer from painful and sometimes fatal side effects, throwing the blame at everyone from the nurses and anesthesiologists to the patients themselves. He also tends to harass nurses, PAs, [=PAs=], and fellow physicians like a grade school bully and shows an extreme sense of entitlement in his relationships with others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PsychopathicManchild: Duntsch reacts with petulant anger whenever someone questions his skills and continues to insist that he's a world-class surgeon even as his patients suffer from painful and sometimes fatal side effects, throwing the blame at everyone from the nurses and anesthesiologists to the patients themselves. He also tends to harass nurses, PAs, and fellow physicians like a grade school bully and shows an extreme sense of entitlement in his relationships with others.

Added: 488

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulEcho: "Maybe this is a good thing." First Betts says it to Duntsch in regards to his losing his football scholarship, then many years later, Duntsch's father says it to him in regards to him losing his medical license. Both football and medicine are things Duntsch has devoted years of his life to and tried again and again to be accomplished at with no success, but while being forced out of the first one isn't too significant, losing his license will inevitably save lives.



* MedicineShow: Duntsch creates a slick informercial for himself, complete with a testimonial from one of his less-disastrous patients.

to:

* MedicineShow: Duntsch creates a slick informercial infomercial for himself, complete with a testimonial from one of his less-disastrous patients.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed typo


** When Henderson performs a revision surgery one one of Duntsch's patients, he notes (with disbelief) the mess Duntsch made, including the dura mater (protective sheath around the spinal cord) dissected, offering no protection to the nerves. Ligaments cut and just hanging loose, bone fragments piercing nerves and otherwise messily smashed into the spinal canal "like putty".

to:

** When Henderson performs a revision surgery one on one of Duntsch's patients, he notes (with disbelief) the mess Duntsch made, including the dura mater (protective sheath around the spinal cord) dissected, offering no protection to the nerves. Ligaments cut and just hanging loose, bone fragments piercing nerves and otherwise messily smashed into the spinal canal "like putty".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This adaptation doesn't depict the full extent of the emotional and physical abuse that he inflicted on Wendy, which included an incident where he broke into her apartment and was found covered in blood and bruises while holding a knife and gun with a ransom note written in blood nearby.

to:

** This adaptation doesn't depict As nasty as his [[DomesticAbuse treatment of Wendy is]] in the full extent of show, it was even ''worse'' in real life. The show omits the emotional and physical abuse worst of it, such as a time when he beat her so badly while she was pregnant that he inflicted on Wendy, which included she needed to go to the emergency room, or an incident where after they'd separated when he drunkenly broke into her apartment and was found covered in blood and bruises while holding a knife and gun with a ransom note written in blood nearby.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CripplingOverspecialization: Duntsch gets on Kirby's radar precisely because they have vastly differeing specialties , orthopedics and vascular, respectively. Some spinal surgeries require access through the front of the body rather than the back. Orthopedic surgeons, however, lack the training to get to the spine through all the organs so they bring on vascular surgeons to clear the way, so to speak. Kirby came into assist Duntsch, thinking everything would be routine only to get an up-close look at Duntsch's horrifying behavior in the operating room.

to:

* CripplingOverspecialization: Duntsch gets on Kirby's radar precisely because they have vastly differeing specialties , differing specialties, orthopedics and vascular, respectively. Some spinal surgeries require access through the front of the body rather than the back. Orthopedic surgeons, however, lack the training to get to the spine through all the organs so they bring on vascular surgeons to clear the way, so to speak. Kirby came into assist Duntsch, thinking everything would be routine only to get an up-close look at Duntsch's horrifying behavior in the operating room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CripplingOverspecialization: Duntsch gets on Kirby's radar precisely because they have vastly differeing specialties , orthopedics and vascular, respectively. Some spinal surgeries require access through the front of the body rather than the back. Orthopedic surgeons, however, lack the training to get to the spine through all the organs so they bring on vascular surgeons to clear the way, so to speak. Kirby came into assist Duntsch, thinking everything would be routine only to get an up-close look at Duntsch's horrifying behavior in the operating room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TranquilFury: Dr. Henderson's testimony at Duntsch's trial is scalding, but Baldwin delivers each word in a calm, graceful manner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BodyHorror: Lots and lots of it. The show doesn't hold back at all from showing just how horrific Duntsch's surgeries were and the gruesome effects they had.

Top