Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / SMG4sMarioBloopersWarOfTheFatItalians2022

Go To

OR

Added: 112

Changed: 1011

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseLaw: Where to even START? Of course, since the trial is one giant homage to ''Franchise/AceAttorney'', itself a satire of Japan's legal system, this is to be expected. Nonetheless, some things stand out (stuff A.A. gets right)…

to:

* ArtisticLicenseLaw: Where to even START? Of course, since the trial is one giant homage to ''Franchise/AceAttorney'', itself a satire of Japan's legal system, this is to be expected. Nonetheless, some things stand out (stuff the A.A. series gets right)…



** Lawyer Kong breaks procedure by objecting to Meggy's defense on spurious grounds in the wrong part of the trial. "He's still Mario though!" is a counter-argument, not grounds for objection. Kirby should have overruled him. Yes, Meggy also crossed the line by getting into a shouting match with Kong, but her complaint about being interrupted was valid.
** A "Parody Contract" isn't a real thing – the real thing would be a brief citing Fair Use statutes and case law, then using the trial to prove their show fits the definition (which [=SMG4=] and Meggy ''do'', obliquely), [[RuleOfCool not exactly riveting viewing compared to a cool rap battle]].
** Finally and most obviously, Meggy should not even be allowed to present [=SMG4's=] case since she's not a licensed attorney/barrister (just "in training"). Lawyer Kong correctly points this out, but she's all they've got and Kirby really wants this trial, so…
* ArtifactTitle: Like the past two [=WOTFI=]s, other characters participate in [=SMG4=] and Mario's titular war.

to:

** Lawyer Kong breaks procedure by objecting to Meggy's defense on spurious grounds in the wrong part of the trial. "He's still Mario though!" is a counter-argument, not grounds for objection. Kirby should have overruled him. Yes, Meggy also crossed the line by getting into a shouting match with Kong, Kong and then attacking him, but her complaint about being interrupted during direct was valid.
** A "Parody Contract" isn't a real thing – the real thing would be is a counterclaim in the form of a brief citing Fair Use statutes and case law, then using the trial to prove their show fits the definition (which [=SMG4=] and Meggy ''do'', obliquely), falls under an exemption (Meggy to her credit seems to be building a decent case before things go off the rails). [[RuleOfCool not Not exactly riveting viewing compared to a cool rap battle]].
battle.]]
** During the bridge of "Objection!", Luigi – at this point under Lawyer Kong's control and supporting Nintendo's case – accidentally gives lyric-testimony that undercuts his own side. Pointing out how stupid and nonsensical the show is typically ''strengthens'' a parody defense.
** Finally and most obviously, notably, Meggy should not even be allowed to present [=SMG4's=] case before the Court since she's not a licensed attorney/barrister (just "in training"). Lawyer Kong correctly points this out, but she's all they've got and Kirby really wants this trial, so…
* ArtifactTitle: Like the past two [=WOTFI=]s, [=WOTFIs=], other characters participate in [=SMG4=] and Mario's titular war.



* CanonCharacterAllAlong: After accepting his loss and making a HeelFaceTurn, Lawyer Kong turns out to be the [=SMG4=] version of Funky Kong.

to:

* CanonCharacterAllAlong: After accepting his loss and making a HeelFaceTurn, Lawyer Kong turns out to be the [=SMG4=] version of Funky Kong.Kong, who had appeared in episodes before this arc ever started.



* ExcusePlot: The whole trial aspect, while a more justified setup than last year, is still a very loose setup for this year's War of the Fat Italians. Lawyer Kong even {{Lampshade|Hanging}}s this, stating a series of weird competition between eccentric characters has nothing to do with law.

to:

* ExcusePlot: The whole trial aspect, while a more justified setup than last year, 2021's WOTFI, is still a very loose setup for this year's War of the Fat Italians. Lawyer Kong even {{Lampshade|Hanging}}s this, stating a series of weird competition between eccentric characters has nothing to do with law.



* ShoutOut: The video's thumbnail is directly based on the main artwork for ''VisualNovel/PhoenixWrightAceAttorneyDualDestinies'', with [=SMG4=] standing in for Phoenix Wright, Mario for Apollo Justice, Meggy for Athena Cykes, and Lawyer Kong for Simon Blackquill.

to:

* ShoutOut: The video's thumbnail is directly based on the main artwork for ''VisualNovel/PhoenixWrightAceAttorneyDualDestinies'', ''[[VisualNovel/PhoenixWrightAceAttorneyDualDestinies Dual Destinies]]'', with [=SMG4=] standing in for Phoenix Wright, Mario for Apollo Justice, Meggy for Athena Cykes, and Lawyer Kong for Simon Blackquill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Inverted in the "who can be the least funny" challenge between [=SMG3=] and Luigi. [=SMG3=] is so desperately unfunny that Luigi having an attack of stage fight is considered comic gold by comparison, netting [=SMG3=] a very unwanted win.

to:

** Inverted in the "who can be the least funny" challenge between [=SMG3=] and Luigi. [=SMG3=] is so desperately unfunny that Luigi having an attack of stage fight is considered comic gold by comparison, netting [=SMG3=] a very unwanted win.win.
* YourHeadAsplode: Happens to [[Franchise/KingdomHearts Sora]] when he looks in on the Kirby lore challenge. And given how convoluted his own series’ lore is, that’s really saying something.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExcusePlot: The whole trial aspect is a very loose setup for this year's War of the Fat Italians. Lawyer Kong even {{Lampshade|Hanging}}s this, stating a series of weird competition between eccentric characters has nothing to do with law.

to:

* ExcusePlot: The whole trial aspect aspect, while a more justified setup than last year, is still a very loose setup for this year's War of the Fat Italians. Lawyer Kong even {{Lampshade|Hanging}}s this, stating a series of weird competition between eccentric characters has nothing to do with law.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed spelling error


* GratuitousRap: There's not really any reason for the rap at the end to take place. Kirby merely pulls out a radio, queues up some music, and says it's time for the closing statement. Meggy makes the decision to turn said closing statement into a rap battle. Of course with Lawyer Kong voiced by a text-to-speech modelled after the [[VideoGame/DonkeyKog64 DK Rap voice]] and Kirby already leaning heavily into RuleOfCool, it was inevitable.

to:

* GratuitousRap: There's not really any reason for the rap at the end to take place. Kirby merely pulls out a radio, queues up some music, and says it's time for the closing statement. Meggy makes the decision to turn said closing statement into a rap battle. Of course with Lawyer Kong voiced by a text-to-speech modelled after the [[VideoGame/DonkeyKog64 [[VideoGame/DonkeyKong64 DK Rap voice]] and Kirby already leaning heavily into RuleOfCool, it was inevitable.

Added: 195

Changed: 847

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added new information


** A "Parody Contract" isn't a real thing – the real thing would be a brief citing Fair Use statutes and case law, then using the trial to prove their show fits the definition (which [=SMG4=] and Meggy ''do'', obliquely), not really riveting viewing compared to a cool rap battle.

to:

** A "Parody Contract" isn't a real thing – the real thing would be a brief citing Fair Use statutes and case law, then using the trial to prove their show fits the definition (which [=SMG4=] and Meggy ''do'', obliquely), [[RuleOfCool not really exactly riveting viewing compared to a cool rap battle.battle]].



* GratuitousRap: There's not really any reason for the rap at the end to take place. Kirby merely pulls out a radio and says it's time for the closing statement. Meggy makes the decision to turn said closing statement into a rap battle.

to:

* GratuitousRap: There's not really any reason for the rap at the end to take place. Kirby merely pulls out a radio radio, queues up some music, and says it's time for the closing statement. Meggy makes the decision to turn said closing statement into a rap battle. Of course with Lawyer Kong voiced by a text-to-speech modelled after the [[VideoGame/DonkeyKog64 DK Rap voice]] and Kirby already leaning heavily into RuleOfCool, it was inevitable.



* MirrorMatch: One of the challenges leads Melony to this, getting into a fight with her doppelganger, while Toad and his doppelganger [[PassThePopcorn drink coffee as they watch]].

to:

* MirrorMatch: One of the challenges leads Melony to this, getting into a fight with her doppelganger, doppelganger over a bed, while Toad and his doppelganger [[PassThePopcorn drink coffee as they watch]].



** Lawyer Kong all but says this outright after he loses the case.



* ShowsDamage: During the rap battle, as Meggy and the gang progressively shut down Lawyer Kong's arguments, the Super DMCA starts to become increasingly cracked and damage before finally exploding after Kirby rules in favor of [=SMG4=].
* ShutUpHannibal: The rap battle sees Meggy, Mario, and [=SMG4=] systemically dismantle Lawyer Kong's case against the channel:

to:

** Meggy and Lawyer Kong bobbing their heads to the music is a direct reference to the style of Ben Magnum's [[WebAnimation/MysterySkullsAnimated animated music videos]], specifically [[https://youtu.be/lhjk5x54bsE The Turntable Turnabout – Money]], itself an ''Ace Attorney'' parody.
* ShowsDamage: During the rap battle, as Meggy and the gang progressively shut down Lawyer Kong's arguments, the Super DMCA starts to become increasingly cracked and damage damaged before finally exploding after Kirby rules in favor of [=SMG4=].
* ShutUpHannibal: The rap battle sees Meggy, Mario, and [=SMG4=] systemically systematically dismantle Lawyer Kong's case against the channel:



* TrueCompanions: Mario at the end starts crying, relieved that the whole mess has been resolved since he couldn't bear imagine a world without his friends.

to:

* TrueCompanions: Mario at the end starts crying, relieved that the whole mess has been resolved since he couldn't bear imagine a world without his friends.



* WinsByDoingAbsolutelyNothing

to:

* WinsByDoingAbsolutelyNothingWinsByDoingAbsolutelyNothing:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TalkingToHimself: Averted, despite several people voicing multiple characters in this episode, none of those characters ever converse.
** Luke, as usual, voices [=SMG4=] and Shroomy
** [=VoicesExtremus=] again raps Mario and Luigi but they don't interact here
** Elsie Lovelock voices Meggy and Karen but, again, they never converse

Added: 1744

Changed: 92

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added examples


->WOTFI 2022 is finally here... This marks the end of the Lawsuit Arc and also a turning point for [=SMG4=], Mario, Meggy and friends.

The trial of [=SMG4=] vs. Nintendo begins, but when things quickly go off the rails, the trial takes a different turn; the Glitch characters and the Nintendo characters must compete in various challenges to determine if the former will be allowed to stay in the Mushroom Kingdom. Will [=SMG4=] and his gang be able to win out and send Lawyer Kong packing?

to:

->WOTFI 2022 is finally here... This marks the end of the Lawsuit Arc and also a turning point for [=SMG4=], Mario, Meggy Meggy, and friends.

The trial of [=SMG4=] vs. Nintendo begins, but begins. But, when things quickly go off the rails, the trial takes a different turn; the Glitch characters and the Nintendo characters must compete in various challenges to determine if the former will be allowed to stay in the Mushroom Kingdom. Will [=SMG4=] and his gang be able to win out and send Lawyer Kong packing?



* ArtisticLicenseLaw: Where to even START? Of course, since the trial is one giant homage to ''Franchise/AceAttorney'', itself a satire of Japan's legal system, this is to be expected. Nonetheless, some things stand out (stuff A.A. gets right)…
** The parties to the trial are in the wrong order – since Nintendo is bringing suit, it should be listed first and [=SMG4=] second.
** The trial opens with Meggy's argument, but in a real trial the plaintiff (in this case Nintendo via Lawyer Kong) presents its case first.
** Lawyer Kong breaks procedure by objecting to Meggy's defense on spurious grounds in the wrong part of the trial. "He's still Mario though!" is a counter-argument, not grounds for objection. Kirby should have overruled him. Yes, Meggy also crossed the line by getting into a shouting match with Kong, but her complaint about being interrupted was valid.
** A "Parody Contract" isn't a real thing – the real thing would be a brief citing Fair Use statutes and case law, then using the trial to prove their show fits the definition (which [=SMG4=] and Meggy ''do'', obliquely), not really riveting viewing compared to a cool rap battle.
** Finally and most obviously, Meggy should not even be allowed to present [=SMG4's=] case since she's not a licensed attorney/barrister (just "in training"). Lawyer Kong correctly points this out, but she's all they've got and Kirby really wants this trial, so…



* BittersweetEnding: From a meta standpoint. The trial is won and [=SMG4=]'s channel lives to see another day, with Lawyer Kong simply giving up and returning to his original form of the [=SMG4=] version of Funky Kong. But Miyamoto has one condition for letting [=SMG4=] go: he can no longer look like Mario. Wanting to stay with his friends, he accepts, and his appearance, along with those of [=SMG3=], Bob and Boopkins are [[NothingIsTheSameAnymore changed to original models]], which Boopkins admits will take some getting used to.

to:

* BittersweetEnding: From a meta standpoint. The trial is won and [=SMG4=]'s channel lives to see another day, with Lawyer Kong simply giving up and returning to his original form of the [=SMG4=] version of Funky Kong. But Miyamoto has one condition for letting [=SMG4=] go: he can no longer look like Mario. Wanting to stay with his friends, he accepts, and his appearance, along with those of [=SMG3=], Bob Bob, and Boopkins are [[NothingIsTheSameAnymore changed to original models]], which Boopkins admits will take some getting used to.



* TheCameo: During the rap battle, various dead [=SMG4=] characters briefly appear as ghostly images during Melony's line, Desti, [=SMG0=], Terrence and Axol.

to:

* TheCameo: During the rap battle, various dead [=SMG4=] characters briefly appear as ghostly images during Melony's line, line – Desti, [=SMG0=], Terrence Terrence, and Axol.



* EarnYourHappyEnding: After encountering legal troubles, and even DYING, [=SMG4=] and his friends are revived, and are able to win the trial, saving the channel and returning life to normal. Though it takes some getting used to, [=SMG4=], Bob and Boopkins also starting warming up to their new bodies.
** Mario stands out in this case. After going through so much grief and heartache, even temporarily losing his personality, memories and friends, he fights to get them back and win the trial, allowing him to keep all of his friends and return to his ordinary life.

to:

* EarnYourHappyEnding: After encountering legal troubles, and even DYING, [=SMG4=] and his friends are revived, and are able to win the trial, saving the channel and returning life to normal. Though it takes some getting used to, [=SMG4=], Bob Bob, and Boopkins also starting warming up to their new bodies.
** Mario stands out in this case. After going through so much grief and heartache, even temporarily losing his personality, memories memories, and friends, he fights to get them back and win the trial, allowing him to keep all of his friends and return to his ordinary life.



* MirrorMatch: One of the challenges lead Melony to this, getting into a fight with her doppelganger, while Toad and his doppelganger [[PassThePopcorn drink coffee as they watch]].

to:

* MirrorMatch: One of the challenges lead leads Melony to this, getting into a fight with her doppelganger, while Toad and his doppelganger [[PassThePopcorn drink coffee as they watch]].



-->'''[=SMG3=]''': AHH! I'M ASIAN!

to:

-->'''[=SMG3=]''': AHH! "AHH! I'M ASIAN!ASIAN!"



* ShutUpHannibal: The rap battle sees Meggy, Mario and [=SMG4=] systemically dismantle Lawyer Kong's case against the channel:

to:

* ShutUpHannibal: The rap battle sees Meggy, Mario Mario, and [=SMG4=] systemically dismantle Lawyer Kong's case against the channel:



** Finally, Lawyer Kong pulls out his trump card: Claiming that the channel using Mario as it does constitutes copyright infringement. Meggy counters with the parody contract, backing it up by showing how much of a dumbass [=SMG4=] Mario is compared to his canon counterpart.
* SuddenlySpeaking: Karen has a fully voiced line during the rap as opposed to the [[VideoGame/TeamFortress2 Femscout]]'s voice clips.

to:

** Finally, Lawyer Kong pulls out his trump card: Claiming that the channel using Mario as it does in itself constitutes copyright infringement. Meggy counters with the parody contract, backing it up by showing how much of a dumbass [=SMG4=] Mario is compared to his canon counterpart.
* SuddenlySpeaking: Karen has a fully voiced line during the rap as opposed to the [[VideoGame/TeamFortress2 Femscout]]'s voice clips. Coincidentally, she shares a voice actress with Meggy.
* TalkingToHimself: Averted, despite several people voicing multiple characters in this episode, none of those characters ever converse.
** Luke, as usual, voices [=SMG4=] and Shroomy
** [=VoicesExtremus=] again raps Mario and Luigi but they don't interact here
** Elsie Lovelock voices Meggy and Karen but, again, they never converse



-->'''Boopkins (weakly):''' Have we found the One Piece yet...?

to:

-->'''Boopkins (weakly):''' Have -->'''Boopkins:''' ''(weakly)'' "Have we found the One Piece yet...??"

Added: 37

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IBangedYourMum: Whimpu's response to the best ship contest is to announce that the best ship is himself and Bowser's mum, shocking Bowser.

to:

* IBangedYourMum: IBangedYourMom: Whimpu's response to the best ship contest is to announce that the best ship is himself and Bowser's mum, shocking Bowser.Bowser into defeat.
-->'''Whimpu:''' WebAnimation/YoMama!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TakeThat: Boopkins and Melony's challenge to find the ''Manga/OnePiece'' contains a swipe at the length of the aforementioned series. After 145,229 episodes of not finding the treasure, reducing the entire crew to bones and giving Boopkins a TimePassageBeard, the challenge ends in a stalemate.
-->'''Boopkins (weakly):''' Have we found the One Piece yet...?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChestMonster: During his SnipeHunt, Boopkins finds a chest in a cave on his quest. To his shock, it grows a body and tries to eat him.


Added DiffLines:

* IBangedYourMum: Whimpu's response to the best ship contest is to announce that the best ship is himself and Bowser's mum, shocking Bowser.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BlackComedyCannibalism: During a mushroom eating challenge, [[MushroomMan Shroomy]] refuses to eat any mushrooms, before trying just one and loving it, and then begins to shovel them into his mouth. Cue [[MushroomMan Toad]] looking on in horror.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GratuitousRap: There's not really any reason for the rap at the end to take place. Kirby merely pulls out a radio and says it's time for the closing statement. Meggy makes the decision to turn said closing statement into a rap battle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtifactTitle: Like the past two WOTFIs, other characters participate in [=SMG4=] and Mario' titular war.

to:

* ArtifactTitle: Like the past two WOTFIs, [=WOTFI=]s, other characters participate in [=SMG4=] and Mario' Mario's titular war.

Added: 434

Changed: 913

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtifactTitle: For the third year in a row, more characters than [=SMG4=] and Mario participate in the titular war.
* BittersweetEnding: The trial is won and [=SMG4=]'s channel lives to see another day, with Lawyer Kong simply giving up and returning to his original form of the [=SMG4=] version of Funky Kong. But Miyamoto has one condition for letting [=SMG4=] go: he can no longer look like Mario. He accepts, and his appearance, along with those of [=SMG3=], Bob and Boopkins are all forever changed from Nintendo characters to original models. Despite their victory, NothingIsTheSameAnymore.

to:

* ArtifactTitle: For Like the third year in a row, more past two WOTFIs, other characters than [=SMG4=] and Mario participate in the [=SMG4=] and Mario' titular war.
* BittersweetEnding: From a meta standpoint. The trial is won and [=SMG4=]'s channel lives to see another day, with Lawyer Kong simply giving up and returning to his original form of the [=SMG4=] version of Funky Kong. But Miyamoto has one condition for letting [=SMG4=] go: he can no longer look like Mario. He Wanting to stay with his friends, he accepts, and his appearance, along with those of [=SMG3=], Bob and Boopkins are all forever [[NothingIsTheSameAnymore changed from Nintendo characters to original models. Despite their victory, NothingIsTheSameAnymore.models]], which Boopkins admits will take some getting used to.



* EarnYourHappyEnding: For Mario. After going through so much grief and heartache, even temporarily losing his personality, memories and friends, he and the gang are able to win the trial, allowing Mario to keep all of his friends and return to his ordinary life.

to:

* EarnYourHappyEnding: For Mario. After encountering legal troubles, and even DYING, [=SMG4=] and his friends are revived, and are able to win the trial, saving the channel and returning life to normal. Though it takes some getting used to, [=SMG4=], Bob and Boopkins also starting warming up to their new bodies.
** Mario stands out in this case.
After going through so much grief and heartache, even temporarily losing his personality, memories and friends, he fights to get them back and the gang are able to win the trial, allowing Mario him to keep all of his friends and return to his ordinary life.



* ForcedTransformation: [=SMG4=], [=SMG3=] (by proxy), Bob and Boopkins are forced to take on new appearances, by order of Miyamoto as his one condition for sparing [=SMG4=] and his friends.

to:

* ForcedTransformation: [=SMG4=], [=SMG4=] and [=SMG3=] (by proxy), Bob and Boopkins proxy) are forced to take on new appearances, by order of Miyamoto as his one condition for sparing [=SMG4=] and his friends.friends. Miyamoto also forces Bob and Fishy Boopkins to change, as he's tired of seeing [=YouTube=] comments on videos featuring Spikes and Garos constantly bringing them up.



* NothingIsTheSameAnymore: The channel has a future, but now [=SMG4=], [=SMG3=], Boopkins, and Bob have gotten a design overhaul.

to:

* NothingIsTheSameAnymore: The channel has a future, but now Similar to Meggy and Saiko getting new designs, [=SMG4=], [=SMG3=], Fishy Boopkins, and Bob have gotten each get a design overhaul.overhaul.
* RacialTransformation: Miyamoto's contract gives [=SMG4=] and [=SMG3=] new bodies, turning them from fat Italians to Asian Australians.
-->'''[=SMG3=]''': AHH! I'M ASIAN!



** Next, the brainwashed Nintendo characters vent their frustations about working with the channel. Each of their complaints are effectively countered (with [=SMG3=] straight up telling Bob to shut up when the latter claims that the channel cares only about the money).

to:

** Next, the brainwashed Nintendo characters vent their frustations frustrations about working with the channel. Each of their complaints are effectively countered (with [=SMG3=] straight up telling Bob to shut up when the latter claims that the channel cares only about the money).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShowsDamage: During the rap battle, as Meggy and the gang progressively shut down Lawyer Kong's arguments, the Super DMCA starts to become increasingly cracked and damage before finally exploding after Kirby rules in favor of [=SMG4=].

Top