Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 8 (click to see context) from:
* AcquittedTooLate: The episode starts off with Siobhan stumbling out of an elevator during a hotel opening. The staff shuttles her off to the side, and Russell Ramsay (who is on the sex offender registry as a pedophile) is later arrested. Turns out it's a scam to get money from the hotel, the supposedly under-age "victim" was in her 20s rather than her teens, the sex was consensual, and the "suspect" was a patsy set up by Siobhan and her family. Unfortunately, by the time anyone remembers that they have an innocent man in jail, Russell had already been killed in prison (pedophiles being very unpopular in prison populations). Fortunately, that made Siobhan and her accomplices legally culpable for murder.
to:
* AcquittedTooLate: The episode starts off with Siobhan stumbling out of an elevator during a hotel opening. The staff shuttles her off to the side, and Russell Ramsay (who is on the sex offender registry as a pedophile) pedophile for having otherwise consensual sex with his girlfriend who was below the age of consent at the time) is later arrested. Turns out it's a scam to get money from the hotel, the supposedly under-age "victim" was in her 20s rather than her teens, the sex was consensual, and the "suspect" was a patsy set up by Siobhan and her family. Unfortunately, by the time anyone remembers that they have an innocent man in jail, Russell had already been killed in prison (pedophiles being very unpopular in prison populations). Fortunately, that made Siobhan and her accomplices legally culpable for murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 8 (click to see context) from:
* AcquittedTooLate: The episode starts off with a Siobhan stumbling out of an elevator during a hotel opening. The staff shuttles her off to the side, and Russell Ramsay (who is on the sex offender registry as a pedophile) is later arrested. Turns out it's a scam to get money from the hotel, the supposedly under-age "victim" was in her 20s rather than her teens, the sex was consensual, and the "suspect" was a patsy set up by Siobhan and her family. Unfortunately, by the time anyone remembers that they have an innocent man in jail, Russell had already been killed in prison (pedophiles being very unpopular in prison populations). Fortunately, that made Siobhan and her accomplices legally culpable for murder.
to:
* AcquittedTooLate: The episode starts off with a Siobhan stumbling out of an elevator during a hotel opening. The staff shuttles her off to the side, and Russell Ramsay (who is on the sex offender registry as a pedophile) is later arrested. Turns out it's a scam to get money from the hotel, the supposedly under-age "victim" was in her 20s rather than her teens, the sex was consensual, and the "suspect" was a patsy set up by Siobhan and her family. Unfortunately, by the time anyone remembers that they have an innocent man in jail, Russell had already been killed in prison (pedophiles being very unpopular in prison populations). Fortunately, that made Siobhan and her accomplices legally culpable for murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected typos.
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
Russell Ramsay, a man with a prior statutory rape conviction is accused of having raped a young woman at a hotel opening, a case that John Munch (Creator/RichardBelzer) takes very seriously after meeting the accused's girlfriend. However, upon digging more deeply into the case, Munch learns that the victim, Siobhan Miller's, brother, Beau, is actually a con artist.
to:
Russell Ramsay, a man with a prior statutory rape conviction is accused of having raped a young woman Siobhan Miller at a hotel opening, a case that John Munch (Creator/RichardBelzer) takes very seriously after meeting the accused's girlfriend. However, upon digging more deeply into the case, Munch learns that the victim, Siobhan Miller's, victim's brother, Beau, is actually a con artist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 8 (click to see context) from:
* AcquittedTooLate: The episode starts off with a Siobahn stumbling out of an elevator during a hotel opening. The staff shuttles her off to the side, and Russell Ramsay (who is on the sex offender registry as a pedophile) is later arrested. Turns out it's a scam to get money from the hotel, the supposedly under-age "victim" was in her 20s rather than her teens, the sex was consensual, and the "suspect" was a patsy set up by Siobahn and her family. Unfortunately, by the time anyone remembers that they have an innocent man in jail, Russell had already been killed in prison (pedophiles being very unpopular in prison populations). Fortunately, that made Siobahn and her accomplices legally culpable for murder.
to:
* AcquittedTooLate: The episode starts off with a Siobahn Siobhan stumbling out of an elevator during a hotel opening. The staff shuttles her off to the side, and Russell Ramsay (who is on the sex offender registry as a pedophile) is later arrested. Turns out it's a scam to get money from the hotel, the supposedly under-age "victim" was in her 20s rather than her teens, the sex was consensual, and the "suspect" was a patsy set up by Siobahn Siobhan and her family. Unfortunately, by the time anyone remembers that they have an innocent man in jail, Russell had already been killed in prison (pedophiles being very unpopular in prison populations). Fortunately, that made Siobahn Siobhan and her accomplices legally culpable for murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 9 (click to see context) :
* KilledOffScreen: Serena Benson, Olivia's mother, dies after an alcohol induced fall. This isn't shown on screen, but Captain Donald Cragen informs Benson about her mother's death.
Added DiffLines:
* KilledOffscreen:
** Serena Benson, Olivia's mother, dies after an alcohol induced fall. This isn't shown on screen, but Captain Donald Cragen informs Benson about her mother's death.
** Happens to Russell Ramsay while in prison as a result of PrisonRape.
** Serena Benson, Olivia's mother, dies after an alcohol induced fall. This isn't shown on screen, but Captain Donald Cragen informs Benson about her mother's death.
** Happens to Russell Ramsay while in prison as a result of PrisonRape.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not this trope
Deleted line(s) 24 (click to see context) :
* TheUnfairSex: Siobhan apparently manipulated her whole family, including her criminal brother, into committing the con.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* GenderBlenderName: In order to get a job at the hotel, Kyle takes on the identity of some Terry Wilde, a hotel clerk with a good resume. It turns out the real Terry is a woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
* SkewedPriorities: At the end of the episode, the team feels victorious due the fact that they got Siobhan and her family, [[NoSympathy not at all concerned]] over the fact that an innocent man had died because of their actions. The only one who feels bad about it is [[OnlySaneMan Munch]], who takes the time to Ramsey's girlfriend.
to:
* SkewedPriorities: At the end of the episode, the team feels victorious due the fact that they got Siobhan and her family, [[NoSympathy not at all concerned]] over the fact that an innocent man had died because of their actions. The only one who feels bad about it is [[OnlySaneMan Munch]], who takes the time to talk to Ramsey's girlfriend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cut trope
Deleted line(s) 15,17 (click to see context) :
* MoralDissonance:
** Munch accurately points out that statutory rape is still a sexual offence. However, this is completely forgotten when it turns out that his second "victim" is lying about him and has set him up, when Munch apparently thinks that the statutory rape was actually quite a moral thing to do.
** Munch is also horrified that Ramsay was the victim of a savage rape that resulted in his death while at Rikers, but he and Cragen are relieved that Beau will be facing that same amount of rape and violence there. Only because Ramsay is innocent, mind, as before when he thought he had raped Siobhan, he thought being murdered was actually justified.
** Munch accurately points out that statutory rape is still a sexual offence. However, this is completely forgotten when it turns out that his second "victim" is lying about him and has set him up, when Munch apparently thinks that the statutory rape was actually quite a moral thing to do.
** Munch is also horrified that Ramsay was the victim of a savage rape that resulted in his death while at Rikers, but he and Cragen are relieved that Beau will be facing that same amount of rape and violence there. Only because Ramsay is innocent, mind, as before when he thought he had raped Siobhan, he thought being murdered was actually justified.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 11 (click to see context) from:
* TheFamilyThatSlaysTogether: The Millers, although they didn't intend for Ramsay to be killed (they still put him in an extremely dangerous and violent situation). Brother, sister, and sister-in-law are ''all'' {{ConArtist}}s, and we even learn that the siblings' off-screen parents are ones, too.
to:
* TheFamilyThatSlaysTogether: The Millers, although they didn't intend for Ramsay to be killed (they still put him in an extremely dangerous and violent situation). Brother, sister, and sister-in-law are ''all'' {{ConArtist}}s, {{Con Artist}}s, and we even learn that the siblings' off-screen parents are ones, too.
Added DiffLines:
* SkewedPriorities: At the end of the episode, the team feels victorious due the fact that they got Siobhan and her family, [[NoSympathy not at all concerned]] over the fact that an innocent man had died because of their actions. The only one who feels bad about it is [[OnlySaneMan Munch]], who takes the time to Ramsey's girlfriend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* KilledOffScreen: Serena Benson, Olivia's mother, dies after an alcohol induced fall. This isn't shown on screen, but Captain Donald Cragen informs Benson about her mother's death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* AcquittedTooLate: The episode starts off with a Siobahn stumbling out of an elevator during a hotel opening. The staff shuttles her off to the side, and Russell Ramsay (who is on the sex offender registry as a pedophile) is later arrested. Turns out it's a scam to get money from the hotel, the supposedly under-age "victim" was in her 20s rather than her teens, the sex was consensual, and the "suspect" was a patsy set up by Siobahn and her family. Unfortunately, by the time anyone remembers that they have an innocent man in jail, Russell had already been killed in prison (pedophiles being very unpopular in prison populations). Fortunately, that made Siobahn and her accomplices legally culpable for murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
Written By Creator/LisaMariePetersen and Creator/DawnDeNoon
Directed By Creator/MichaelFields
Directed By Creator/MichaelFields
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 2 (click to see context) :
Changed line(s) 4 (click to see context) from:
to:
!!"Taken" provides examples of:
Deleted line(s) 9,11 (click to see context) :
* IdiotPlot: Or possibly just a very large PlotHole.
** When the detectives learn that Beau was in prison for grifting, they don't learn that his and Siobhan's parents actually ''aren't'' dead, or else they wouldn't have been anywhere near as surprised to learn that Siobhan herself is in on the scam.
** When the detectives are trying to dig for Beau's conviction, they also don't find out that his parents are also in prison for the very same crime, because this is apparently a surprise to them.
** When the detectives learn that Beau was in prison for grifting, they don't learn that his and Siobhan's parents actually ''aren't'' dead, or else they wouldn't have been anywhere near as surprised to learn that Siobhan herself is in on the scam.
** When the detectives are trying to dig for Beau's conviction, they also don't find out that his parents are also in prison for the very same crime, because this is apparently a surprise to them.
Added DiffLines:
* RoguishRomani: The family of con artists have all the earmarks of Irish Travellers, but are never referred to as such in the episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 22 (click to see context) from:
* TheUnfairSex: Siobhan apparently manipulated her whole family, including her criminal brother, into committing the con.
to:
* TheUnfairSex: Siobhan apparently manipulated her whole family, including her criminal brother, into committing the con.con.
* WoundedGazelleGambit: Siobhan. First with her rape story. Then, when the family has been caught, she immediately starts whimpering that her brother forced her into it.
* WoundedGazelleGambit: Siobhan. First with her rape story. Then, when the family has been caught, she immediately starts whimpering that her brother forced her into it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wrong guy
Changed line(s) 10,11 (click to see context) from:
** When the detectives learn that Russell was in prison for grifting, they don't learn that his and Siobhan's parents actually ''aren't'' dead, or else they wouldn't have been anywhere near as surprised to learn that Siobhan herself is in on the scam.
** When the detectives are trying to dig for Russell's conviction, they also don't find out that his parents are also in prison for the very same crime, because this is apparently a surprise to them.
** When the detectives are trying to dig for Russell's conviction, they also don't find out that his parents are also in prison for the very same crime, because this is apparently a surprise to them.
to:
** When the detectives learn that Russell Beau was in prison for grifting, they don't learn that his and Siobhan's parents actually ''aren't'' dead, or else they wouldn't have been anywhere near as surprised to learn that Siobhan herself is in on the scam.
** When the detectives are trying to dig forRussell's Beau's conviction, they also don't find out that his parents are also in prison for the very same crime, because this is apparently a surprise to them.
** When the detectives are trying to dig for
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* NiceJobFixingItVillain: If Siobhan hadn't been so keen to take the deal and tell everyone exactly how they planned the con, she would've gone to prison for her con artistry, but not for manslaughter, which Alex ends up getting her on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
Russell Ramsay, a man with a prior statutory rape conviction is accused of having raped a young woman at a hotel opening, a case that John Munch (Creator/RichardBelzer) takes very seriously after meeting the accused's girlfriend. However, upon digging more deeply into the case, Munch learns that the victim, Siobhan Miller's, brother, Beau, is actually a con artist.
----
* FalseRapeAccusation: Concocted by the whole family, as it turns out.
* TheFamilyThatSlaysTogether: The Millers, although they didn't intend for Ramsay to be killed (they still put him in an extremely dangerous and violent situation). Brother, sister, and sister-in-law are ''all'' {{ConArtist}}s, and we even learn that the siblings' off-screen parents are ones, too.
* GetRichQuickScheme: Essentially the Miller family's plot.
* HoistByTheirOwnPetard: Siobhan's monotonous, remorseless delivery of her confession that she set Russell up purposefully and intentionally is exactly how Alex and Munch take her down, mere ''moments'' later, once she gets off the stand and they reveal that Ramsay actually died due to her accusation, and so she's on the hook for manslaughter, too.
* IdiotPlot: Or possibly just a very large PlotHole.
** When the detectives learn that Russell was in prison for grifting, they don't learn that his and Siobhan's parents actually ''aren't'' dead, or else they wouldn't have been anywhere near as surprised to learn that Siobhan herself is in on the scam.
** When the detectives are trying to dig for Russell's conviction, they also don't find out that his parents are also in prison for the very same crime, because this is apparently a surprise to them.
* JusticeByOtherLegalMeans: Siobhan manages to make an extremely generous plea deal for probation if she tells them everything about the scam. However, this very confession is what allows her to be thrown in prison for a much harsher crime she at least didn't intend (though totally caused): the manslaughter of Russell Ramsay, after confessing that she and her family deliberately targeted him.
* MoralDissonance:
** Munch accurately points out that statutory rape is still a sexual offence. However, this is completely forgotten when it turns out that his second "victim" is lying about him and has set him up, when Munch apparently thinks that the statutory rape was actually quite a moral thing to do.
** Munch is also horrified that Ramsay was the victim of a savage rape that resulted in his death while at Rikers, but he and Cragen are relieved that Beau will be facing that same amount of rape and violence there. Only because Ramsay is innocent, mind, as before when he thought he had raped Siobhan, he thought being murdered was actually justified.
* MoreDeadlyThanTheMale: It's Siobhan's sister-in-law who beats the hell out of her and makes it look like Ramsay did it, but it's Siobhan herself who concocted and motivated the whole plan.
* PrisonRape:
** Ramsay is on the receiving end of it, which ultimately leads to his death.
** Beau Miller is threatened with this at the end.
* SuddenDownerEnding: The con artist family is exposed, they don't get their money, and they're going to prison (although Siobhan is getting an unjustifiably light sentence due to being the first to flip). Then Munch learns that Ramsay has died from being raped and brutally beaten, rather than being reunited with his loving girlfriend. About the only silver lining is that Siobhan now faces the prison time she deserves, but it seems like small comfort in comparison to everything else that's gone wrong.
* TheUnfairSex: Siobhan apparently manipulated her whole family, including her criminal brother, into committing the con.
----
* FalseRapeAccusation: Concocted by the whole family, as it turns out.
* TheFamilyThatSlaysTogether: The Millers, although they didn't intend for Ramsay to be killed (they still put him in an extremely dangerous and violent situation). Brother, sister, and sister-in-law are ''all'' {{ConArtist}}s, and we even learn that the siblings' off-screen parents are ones, too.
* GetRichQuickScheme: Essentially the Miller family's plot.
* HoistByTheirOwnPetard: Siobhan's monotonous, remorseless delivery of her confession that she set Russell up purposefully and intentionally is exactly how Alex and Munch take her down, mere ''moments'' later, once she gets off the stand and they reveal that Ramsay actually died due to her accusation, and so she's on the hook for manslaughter, too.
* IdiotPlot: Or possibly just a very large PlotHole.
** When the detectives learn that Russell was in prison for grifting, they don't learn that his and Siobhan's parents actually ''aren't'' dead, or else they wouldn't have been anywhere near as surprised to learn that Siobhan herself is in on the scam.
** When the detectives are trying to dig for Russell's conviction, they also don't find out that his parents are also in prison for the very same crime, because this is apparently a surprise to them.
* JusticeByOtherLegalMeans: Siobhan manages to make an extremely generous plea deal for probation if she tells them everything about the scam. However, this very confession is what allows her to be thrown in prison for a much harsher crime she at least didn't intend (though totally caused): the manslaughter of Russell Ramsay, after confessing that she and her family deliberately targeted him.
* MoralDissonance:
** Munch accurately points out that statutory rape is still a sexual offence. However, this is completely forgotten when it turns out that his second "victim" is lying about him and has set him up, when Munch apparently thinks that the statutory rape was actually quite a moral thing to do.
** Munch is also horrified that Ramsay was the victim of a savage rape that resulted in his death while at Rikers, but he and Cragen are relieved that Beau will be facing that same amount of rape and violence there. Only because Ramsay is innocent, mind, as before when he thought he had raped Siobhan, he thought being murdered was actually justified.
* MoreDeadlyThanTheMale: It's Siobhan's sister-in-law who beats the hell out of her and makes it look like Ramsay did it, but it's Siobhan herself who concocted and motivated the whole plan.
* PrisonRape:
** Ramsay is on the receiving end of it, which ultimately leads to his death.
** Beau Miller is threatened with this at the end.
* SuddenDownerEnding: The con artist family is exposed, they don't get their money, and they're going to prison (although Siobhan is getting an unjustifiably light sentence due to being the first to flip). Then Munch learns that Ramsay has died from being raped and brutally beaten, rather than being reunited with his loving girlfriend. About the only silver lining is that Siobhan now faces the prison time she deserves, but it seems like small comfort in comparison to everything else that's gone wrong.
* TheUnfairSex: Siobhan apparently manipulated her whole family, including her criminal brother, into committing the con.