Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / LawAndOrderS18E3Misbegotten

Go To

OR

Added: 214

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* DidntThinkThisThrough: Lupo accesses a psychiatrist's Blackberry phone behind his back to get enough of a hint that sends the detectives Dean's way in figuring out the ingredients used for the bomb. Green rightfully [[WhatTheHellHero calls him on it]], but it's enough to get them a warrant to search Dean's house -- yet not enough to hold up in the chain of evidence, as [=McCoy=] points out the only way it could've been seen would've been through unlawful possession of the phone, no matter how temporary. This results in most of the evidence being stricken from the record and their having to rework the case.

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: Lupo accesses a psychiatrist's Blackberry phone behind his back to get enough of a hint that sends the detectives Dean's way in figuring out the ingredients used for the bomb. Green rightfully [[WhatTheHellHero calls him on it]], but it's enough to get them a warrant to search Dean's house -- yet not enough to hold up in the chain of evidence, as [=McCoy=] points out the only way it could've been seen would've been through unlawful possession of the phone, no matter how temporary. This results in most of the evidence being stricken from the record and their they’re having to rework the case.case.
* HomophobicHateCrime: Played with. Ryan wants to abort his baby for having a gay gene. Ryan suggests that he wants to keep the baby from experiencing homophobia, but Dean views it as an act of homophobic genocide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: Lupo accesses a psychiatrist's Blackberry phone behind his back to get enough of a hint that sends the detectives Dean's way in figuring out the ingredients used for the bomb. Green rightfully [[WhatTheHellHero calls him on it]], but it's enough to get them a warrant to search Dean's house -- yet not enough to hold up in the chain of evidence, as [=McCoy=] points out the only way it could've been seen would've been through unlawful possession of the phone, no matter how temporary. This results in most of the evidence being stricken from the record and their having to rework the case.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Green and Lupo investigate a package bombing at a research laboratory owned by a company called Genotech. A pregnant security guard, Lori Emerson, was seriously injured and is now in a coma. Dr. Sheldon Hoffman, who works at the laboratory, plans to publish controversial research that he claims is proof of homosexuality being genetic. The detectives learn that Lori's brother-in-law Dean Emerson has been researching Hoffman and has a regular psychiatrist's appointment in the same building as Genotech - which coincides with the time the bomb was left to be picked up by a courier. With evidence that he used his father-in-law's heart medication as an ingredient in the bomb, he is arrested.

to:

Green and Lupo investigate a package bombing at a research laboratory owned by a company called Genotech. A pregnant security guard, Lori Emerson, was seriously injured and is now in a coma. Dr. Sheldon Hoffman, who works at the laboratory, plans to publish controversial research that he claims is proof of homosexuality being genetic. The detectives learn that Lori's brother-in-law Dean Emerson has been researching Hoffman and has a regular psychiatrist's appointment in the same building as Genotech - which coincides with the time the bomb was left to be picked up by a courier. With evidence that he Dean used his father-in-law's father's heart medication as an ingredient in the bomb, he is arrested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Green and Lupo investigate a package bombing at a research laboratory owned by a company called Genotech; a pregnant security guard, Lori Emerson, was seriously injured and is now in a coma. Dr. Sheldon Hoffman, who works at the laboratory, plans to publish controversial research that he claims is proof of homosexuality being genetic. The detectives learn that Lori's brother-in-law Dean Emerson has been researching Hoffman and has a regular psychiatrist's appointment in the same building as Genotech - at the same time the bomb was left to be picked up by a courier. With evidence that he used his father-in-law's heart medication as an ingredient in the bomb, he is arrested.

to:

Green and Lupo investigate a package bombing at a research laboratory owned by a company called Genotech; a Genotech. A pregnant security guard, Lori Emerson, was seriously injured and is now in a coma. Dr. Sheldon Hoffman, who works at the laboratory, plans to publish controversial research that he claims is proof of homosexuality being genetic. The detectives learn that Lori's brother-in-law Dean Emerson has been researching Hoffman and has a regular psychiatrist's appointment in the same building as Genotech - at which coincides with the same time the bomb was left to be picked up by a courier. With evidence that he used his father-in-law's heart medication as an ingredient in the bomb, he is arrested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FoolishSiblingResponsibleSibling: Lori's father describes Ryan and Dean as this; Ryan doesn't have consistent work, while Dean is expected to provide for the family financially and to take care of their sick father.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Dean confesses he didn't want Hoffman's research to be published so that parents would not try to abort potentially gay children in-utero. He begs Ryan not to go ahead with the abortion, but Ryan says he has to; Dean has experienced a lifetime of homophobic abuse and Ryan does not want his own child to go through it. Cutter later tells [=McCoy=] and Rubirosa that Ryan agreed to postpone the abortion but will probably go ahead with it anyway. [=McCoy=] reflects that there's no way to test for a gene that causes poor decisions.

to:

Dean confesses he to the bombing. He didn't want Hoffman's research to be published published, so that parents would not try to abort potentially gay children in-utero. He begs Ryan not to go ahead with the abortion, but Ryan says he has to; Dean has experienced a lifetime of homophobic abuse and Ryan does not want his own child to go through it. Cutter later tells [=McCoy=] and Rubirosa that Ryan agreed to postpone the abortion but will probably go ahead with it anyway. [=McCoy=] reflects that there's no way to test for a gene that causes poor decisions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Lori's father now comes forward with an alibi for Dean, even though it's clear he strongly dislikes Dean. Cutter and Rubirosa learn that Lori's baby is due to be aborted the following day; there is a very slim chance of saving her even with the abortion, whereas the baby would otherwise survive. They realize that Lori's father does not want a gay grandchild, so he provided an alibi in exchange for her husband Ryan agreeing to the abortion. When the trial judge judge refuses [=McCoy=]'s request to prohibit the abortion, Cutter confronts Dean and Ryan with his knowledge of the abortion.

to:

Lori's father now comes forward with an alibi for Dean, even though it's clear he strongly dislikes Dean. Cutter and Rubirosa learn that Lori's baby is due to be aborted the following day; there is a very slim chance of saving her even with the abortion, whereas the baby would otherwise survive. They realize that Lori's father does not want a gay grandchild, so he provided an alibi in exchange for her husband Ryan agreeing to the abortion. When the trial judge judge refuses [=McCoy=]'s request to prohibit force a delay in the abortion, procedure, Cutter confronts Dean and Ryan with his knowledge of the abortion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


However, the defence gets most of the evidence excluded. While looking to shore up the case, Cutter and Rubirosa discover that Lori was part of Hoffman's current study. He is trying to find a way to identify the "gene" for homosexuality in an unborn child, and since Dean is gay, Hoffman wanted to see if Lori's child would inherit the gene. Dean now wants a plea deal to spare his elderly parents the embarrassment of a trial, but Cutter refuses. At trial, Dean's defence challenges Hoffman over his controversial research; Hoffman says he can prove it's scientifically sound, and that he has identified the gene for homosexuality in Lori's baby.

to:

However, the defence gets most of the evidence excluded. While looking to shore up the case, Cutter and Rubirosa discover that Lori was part of Hoffman's current study. He is trying to find a way to identify the "gene" for homosexuality in an unborn child, and since Dean is gay, Hoffman wanted to see if Lori's child would inherit the gene. Dean now wants a plea deal to spare his elderly parents the embarrassment of a trial, but Cutter refuses. At trial, Dean's defence challenges Hoffman over his controversial research; Hoffman says he can prove it's scientifically sound, and that he has identified the gene for homosexuality in Lori's baby.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


However, the defence gets most of the evidence excluded. While looking to shore up the case, Cutter and Rubirosa discover that Lori was part of Hoffman's current study. He is trying to find a way to identify the "gene" for homosexuality in an unborn child, and since Dean is gay, he wanted to see if Lori's child would inherit the gene. Dean now wants a plea deal to spare his elderly parents the embarrassment of a trial, but Cutter refuses. At trial, Dean's defence challenges Hoffman over his controversial research; Hoffman says he can prove it's scientifically sound, and that he has identified the gene for homosexuality in Lori's baby.

to:

However, the defence gets most of the evidence excluded. While looking to shore up the case, Cutter and Rubirosa discover that Lori was part of Hoffman's current study. He is trying to find a way to identify the "gene" for homosexuality in an unborn child, and since Dean is gay, he Hoffman wanted to see if Lori's child would inherit the gene. Dean now wants a plea deal to spare his elderly parents the embarrassment of a trial, but Cutter refuses. At trial, Dean's defence challenges Hoffman over his controversial research; Hoffman says he can prove it's scientifically sound, and that he has identified the gene for homosexuality in Lori's baby.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SomeoneToRememberHerBy: Lori's baby was supposed to be this although her husband and parents do not want to keep the child.

to:

* SomeoneToRememberHerBy: [[SomeoneToRememberHimBy Someone to Remember Her By]]: Lori's baby was supposed to be this although her husband and parents do not want to keep the child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Green and Lupo investigate a package bombing at a research laboratory owned by a company called Genotech; a pregnant security guard, Lori Emerson, was seriously injured and is now in a coma. Dr. Sheldon Hoffman, who works at the laboratory, plans to publish controversial research that he claims is proof of homosexuality being genetic. The detectives learn that Lori's brother-in-law Dean Emerson has been researching Hoffman and has a regular psychiatrist's appointment in the same building as Genotech - at the same time the bomb was left to be picked up by a courier. With evidence that he used his father-in-law's heart medication as an ingredient in the bomb, he is arrested.

However, the defence gets most of the evidence excluded. While looking to shore up the case, Cutter and Rubirosa discover that Lori was part of Hoffman's current study. He is trying to find a way to identify the "gene" for homosexuality in an unborn child, and since Dean is gay, he wanted to see if Lori's child would inherit the gene. Dean now wants a plea deal to spare his elderly parents the embarrassment of a trial, but Cutter refuses. At trial, Dean's defence challenges Hoffman over his controversial research; Hoffman says he can prove it's scientifically sound, and that he has identified the gene for homosexuality in Lori's baby.

Lori's father now comes forward with an alibi for Dean, even though it's clear he strongly dislikes Dean. Cutter and Rubirosa learn that Lori's baby is due to be aborted the following day; there is a very slim chance of saving her even with the abortion, whereas the baby would otherwise survive. They realize that Lori's father does not want a gay grandchild, so he provided an alibi in exchange for her husband Ryan agreeing to the abortion. When the trial judge judge refuses [=McCoy=]'s request to prohibit the abortion, Cutter confronts Dean and Ryan with his knowledge of the abortion.

Dean confesses he didn't want Hoffman's research to be published so that parents would not try to abort potentially gay children in-utero. He begs Ryan not to go ahead with the abortion, but Ryan says he has to; Dean has experienced a lifetime of homophobic abuse and Ryan does not want his own child to go through it. Cutter later tells [=McCoy=] and Rubirosa that Ryan agreed to postpone the abortion but will probably go ahead with it anyway. [=McCoy=] reflects that there's no way to test for a gene that causes poor decisions.

!!!This episode contains examples of:
* CampStraight: Ryan describes Dean as this trope.
* NoEnding: The ending of the episode does not reveal whether Lori survived, whether Ryan went ahead with the abortion, or what sentence Dean received.
* RippedFromTheHeadlines: Based on then-current news stories about studies attempting to prove a genetic cause for homosexuality.
* SomeoneToRememberHerBy: Lori's baby was supposed to be this although her husband and parents do not want to keep the child.

Top