Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / HowIMetYourMotherS3E17TheGoat

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Hypocrite}}: Ted calls out Barney for sleeping with Robin and breaking TheBroCode, but he's not exactly on the moral high ground as he had previously cheated on Victoria with Robin himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Barney:''' There's something that I have to tell you, and I wanted you to be in the best possible frame of mind before you heard it.
-->'''Ted:''' You slept with Robin.

to:

-->'''Barney:''' --->'''Barney:''' There's something that I have to tell you, and I wanted you to be in the best possible frame of mind before you heard it.
-->'''Ted:'''
it.\\
'''Ted:'''
You slept with Robin.



-->'''Robin:''' I slept with Barney.

to:

-->'''Robin:''' --->'''Robin:''' I slept with Barney.



--> '''Barney''': So, you're not mad?
--> '''Ted''': No, I'm not mad. Well, Robin and I broke up a year ago, we both dated lots of people since then, I'm with Stella now. Seriously, I'm fine with this.
--> '''Barney''': I'm so relieved to hear you say that.
-->'''Ted''': Yeah, yeah. [[TranquilFury Oh, I just remembered, my mom is coming into town next month]]. '''Maybe you'd like to''' '''''[[SuddenlyShouting NAIL HER TOO]]'''''!!!

to:

--> ---> '''Barney''': So, you're not mad?
-->
mad?\\
'''Ted''': No, I'm not mad. Well, Robin and I broke up a year ago, we both dated lots of people since then, I'm with Stella now. Seriously, I'm fine with this.
-->
this.\\
'''Barney''': I'm so relieved to hear you say that.
-->'''Ted''':
that.\\
'''Ted''':
Yeah, yeah. [[TranquilFury Oh, I just remembered, my mom is coming into town next month]]. '''Maybe you'd like to''' '''''[[SuddenlyShouting NAIL HER TOO]]'''''!!!



-->'''Ted:''' You know Barney, earlier this week I started putting things in a box, and that box is labeled "stuff I have no use for anymore".
-->'''Barney:''' And what does that mean?
-->'''Ted:''' It means, maybe you belong in that box.
-->'''Barney:''' Are you saying you don't wanna be bros anymore?
-->'''Ted:''' I'm saying I don't wanna be friends anymore.

to:

-->'''Ted:''' --->'''Ted:''' You know Barney, earlier this week I started putting things in a box, and that box is labeled "stuff I have no use for anymore".
-->'''Barney:'''
anymore".\\
'''Barney:'''
And what does that mean?
-->'''Ted:'''
mean?\\
'''Ted:'''
It means, maybe you belong in that box.
-->'''Barney:'''
box.\\
'''Barney:'''
Are you saying you don't wanna be bros anymore?
-->'''Ted:'''
anymore?\\
'''Ted:'''
I'm saying I don't wanna be friends anymore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/himym_3x17.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I fixed the misspellings & bad punctuations as I scrolled down the whole page.


* CassandraTruth: Future!Ted tells that he was right about believing that keeping a goat in the apartment is a bad idea.

to:

* CassandraTruth: Future!Ted tells says that he was right about believing that keeping a goat in the apartment is a bad idea.



* LoopHoleAbuse: Barney hires Marshall to find any loop holes that could redeem his actions. Unfortunately, he wrote it so iron clad that Marshall couldn't find any. And any chances of finding if Ted breaking the Bro Code is rendered mute because Ted has followed it no matter what the situation (He once pretended to be a Russian Transvestite just to help Barney).

to:

* LoopHoleAbuse: Barney hires Marshall to find any loop holes loopholes that could redeem his actions. Unfortunately, he wrote it so iron clad that Marshall couldn't find any. And any chances of finding if Ted breaking the Bro Code is rendered mute because Ted has followed it no matter what the situation (He once pretended to be a Russian Transvestite just to help Barney).



** Marshall reads over some documents, and is concered that they could be at war with Portugal if signed incorrectly. [[ButForMeItWasTuesday Barney say's that's a Tuesday for him]].

to:

** Marshall reads over some documents, and is concered concerned that they could be at war with Portugal if signed incorrectly. [[ButForMeItWasTuesday Barney say's that's a Tuesday for him]].



** Barney keeps insisting that Ted comes with him so he'll gradually break the news, but...

to:

** Barney keeps insisting that Ted comes come with him so he'll gradually break the news, but...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, AltruCell did something to the water in Lisbin that caused Marshall to refuse to listen at first

to:

** Also, AltruCell [=AltruCell=] did something to the water in Lisbin Lisbon that caused Marshall to refuse to listen at first
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Creator/BenjaminFranklin and Creator/GeorgeWashington appear in "the origins of TheBroCode" story.

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Creator/BenjaminFranklin and Creator/GeorgeWashington UsefulNotes/GeorgeWashington appear in "the origins of TheBroCode" story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Noodle Incident:

to:

* Noodle Incident:NoodleIncident:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LoopHoleAbuse: Barney hires Marshall to find any loop holes that could redeem his actions. Unfortunately, he wrote it so iron clad that Marshall couldn't find any. And any chances of finding if Ted breaking the Bro Code is rendered mute because Ted has followed it no matter what the situation (He once pretended to be a Russian Transvestite just to help Barney).


Added DiffLines:

* Noodle Incident:
** Marshall reads over some documents, and is concered that they could be at war with Portugal if signed incorrectly. [[ButForMeItWasTuesday Barney say's that's a Tuesday for him]].
** Also, AltruCell did something to the water in Lisbin that caused Marshall to refuse to listen at first
** Later on, we see Barney shredding documents while talking to the phone in Chinese. He then proceeds to shred the phone afterwards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And just as one thought that it gets any calmer...

to:

** And just as one thought that when it gets any calmer...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShaggyDogStory: After having hyped how Missy the Goat ruined his thirtieth birthday for the entire, Older Ted remembers at the very last minute that it actually happened on his thirty-''first'' birthday.

to:

* ShaggyDogStory: After having hyped how Missy the Goat ruined his thirtieth birthday for the entire, entire episode, Older Ted remembers at the very last minute that it actually happened on his thirty-''first'' birthday.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShaggyDogStory: After having hyped how Missy the Goat ruined his thirtieth birthday for the entire, Older Ted remembers at the very last minute that it actually happened on his thirty-''first'' birthday.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuitySnarl: Future!Ted put the goat story in his 30th birthday, but it actually happened in his 31st.

to:

* ContinuitySnarl: Future!Ted put the goat story in his 30th birthday, but it actually happened in his 31st. [[LampshadedTrope Which he winds up remembering in the ending stinger.]]



* {{Foreshadowing}}: Future!Ted says that Robin will live with him by the time of his 31st birthday, which she eventually does starting next season until midway of Season 7.

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: Future!Ted says that Robin will live with him by the time of his 31st birthday, which she eventually does starting next season until midway of through Season 7.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And just as one thought that it gets any calmer...
--> '''Barney''': So, you're not mad?
--> '''Ted''': No, I'm not mad. Well, Robin and I broke up a year ago, we both dated lots of people since then, I'm with Stella now. Seriously, I'm fine with this.
--> '''Barney''': I'm so relieved to hear you say that.
-->'''Ted''': Yeah, yeah. [[TranquilFury Oh, I just remembered, my mom is coming into town next month]]. '''Maybe you'd like to''' '''''[[SuddenlyShouting NAIL HER TOO]]'''''!!!

Changed: 96

Removed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BecarefulWhatYouWishFor: Barney, feeling guilty for sleeping with Robin, allows Ted to hit him anywhere but NotInTheFace. Ted gave him a GroinAttack.
* BirthdayEpisode: Ted's 30th to be exact.

to:

* BecarefulWhatYouWishFor: BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: Barney, feeling guilty for sleeping with Robin, allows Ted to hit him anywhere but NotInTheFace. Ted gave gives him a GroinAttack.
* BirthdayEpisode: Ted's 30th 30th, to be exact.



* TheBroCode: TropeNamer. This episode marks its debut, and it is integral to its plot.
* BrutalHonesty: The farmer who owns Missy blatantly told Lily's class what he'll do to Missy.

to:

* TheBroCode: TropeNamer. This episode marks its debut, and it is integral to its the plot.
* BrutalHonesty: The farmer who owns Missy blatantly told tells Lily's class what he'll the butcher will do to Missy.



** Ted mentions the goat late in season 1.
** Ted and Barney's fallout is because of what happened [[Recap/HowIMetYourMotherS3E16SandcastlesInTheSand the previous episode]].
** Ted mentions a box where he will put his old stuff that he has no longer use for early in the episode. He will refer to it in a metaphorical way after his and Barney's fallout.

to:

** Ted mentions first mentioned the goat late in season 1.
** Ted and Barney's fallout falling out is because of what happened in [[Recap/HowIMetYourMotherS3E16SandcastlesInTheSand the previous episode]].
** Ted mentions a box where he will put his old stuff that he has no longer use for early in the episode. He will refer to it in a metaphorical way after his and Barney's fallout.falling out.



** Robin briefly mentions Simon when she confessed what happened between him and Barney.
** Ted referenced Barney's [[Recap/HowIMetYourMotherS2E03Brunch hots for his mother in season 2]] and used it against him in his TheReasonYouSuckSpeech.

to:

** Robin briefly mentions Simon when she confessed confesses what happened between him her and Barney.
** Ted referenced references Barney's [[Recap/HowIMetYourMotherS2E03Brunch hots for his mother in season 2]] and used uses it against him in his TheReasonYouSuckSpeech.



* EarlyBirdCameo: Missy the goat was introduced a year earlier than she supposed to be.
* ExactWords: Ted still play by some of the demeaning rules of TheBroCode by saying these.

to:

* EarlyBirdCameo: Missy the goat was is introduced a year earlier than she was supposed to be.
* ExactWords: Ted still play by some of the demeaning rules of TheBroCode by saying these.
be.



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Creator/BenjaminFranklin and Creator/GeorgeWashington appears in "the origins of TheBroCode" story.
* IdenticalGrandson: If Barnibus Stinson from the origins of TheBroCode really did existed.

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Creator/BenjaminFranklin and Creator/GeorgeWashington appears appear in "the origins of TheBroCode" story.
* IdenticalGrandson: If Barnibus Barney is this if Barnabas Stinson from the origins of TheBroCode really did existed.exist.



* TranquilFury: Subverted. By the time Barney picks him up from work, Ted already knew what happened between him and Robin. Once it's out though, Ted eventually snaps.

to:

* TranquilFury: Subverted. By the time Barney picks him up from work, Ted already knew knows what happened between him and Robin. Once it's out though, Ted eventually snaps.



* WhamEpisode: Robin tells Ted about what happened between her and Barney, which results in Ted and Barney's fallout.

to:

* WhamEpisode: Robin tells Ted about what happened between her and Barney, which results in Ted and Barney's fallout.falling out.

Added: 42

Changed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BirthdayEpisode: Ted's 30th to be exact.



* {{Foreshadowing}}: Future!Ted says that Robin will live with him by the time of his 31st birthday, which she eventually does starting next season.

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: Future!Ted says that Robin will live with him by the time of his 31st birthday, which she eventually does starting next season.season until midway of Season 7.

Added: 138

Changed: 127

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntagonistTitle: Subverted. Missy the goat actually "terrorizes" Ted in his 31st birthday. Also counts as SecondaryCharacterTitle since Missy is [[UnreliableNarrator presented]] as the [[TokenEvilTeammate Token Evil]] TeamPet.

to:

* AntagonistTitle: Subverted. Missy the goat actually "terrorizes" Ted in his 31st birthday. Also counts as Overlaps with SecondaryCharacterTitle since as Missy is [[UnreliableNarrator presented]] as the [[TokenEvilTeammate Token Evil]] TeamPet.



* BitchInSheepsClothing: ''Almost''. Future!Ted keeps describing the goat as a monster complete with an ominous {{Leitmotif}}.

to:

* BitchInSheepsClothing: ''Almost''. Future!Ted keeps describing the goat Missy as a monster complete with an ominous {{Leitmotif}}.



** Ted and Barney's fallout is because of what happened in TheStinger of [[Recap/HowIMetYourMotherS3E16SandcastlesInTheSand the previous episode]].
** Ted mentions a box where he will put his old stuff that he has no longer use for early in the episode. He will refer to it in a metaphorical way after his and barney's fallout.

to:

** Ted and Barney's fallout is because of what happened in TheStinger of [[Recap/HowIMetYourMotherS3E16SandcastlesInTheSand the previous episode]].
** Ted mentions a box where he will put his old stuff that he has no longer use for early in the episode. He will refer to it in a metaphorical way after his and barney's Barney's fallout.



** Ted referenced Barney's hots for his mother in season 2 and used it against him.

to:

** Ted referenced Barney's [[Recap/HowIMetYourMotherS2E03Brunch hots for his mother in season 2 2]] and used it against him.him in his TheReasonYouSuckSpeech.


Added DiffLines:

* TrivialTitle: Not only is Missy [[EarlyBirdCameo wrongfully placed]] in the story, but her being OutOfFocus is lampshaded in TheStinger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BitchInSheepsClothing: ''Almost''. Future!Ted keeps describing the goat as a CompleteMonster complete with an ominous {{Leitmotif}}.

to:

* BitchInSheepsClothing: ''Almost''. Future!Ted keeps describing the goat as a CompleteMonster monster complete with an ominous {{Leitmotif}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Changed: 138

Removed: 124

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntagonistTitle: Subverted. Missy the goat actually "terrorizes" Ted in his 31st birthday.
** SecondaryCharacterTitle: Since Missy is [[UnreliableNarrator presented]] as the [[TokenEvilTeammate Token Evil]] TeamPet.

to:

* AntagonistTitle: Subverted. Missy the goat actually "terrorizes" Ted in his 31st birthday.
** SecondaryCharacterTitle: Since
birthday. Also counts as SecondaryCharacterTitle since Missy is [[UnreliableNarrator presented]] as the [[TokenEvilTeammate Token Evil]] TeamPet.



* CassandraTruth" Future!Ted tells that he was right about believing that keeping a goat in the apartment is a bad idea.

to:

* CassandraTruth" CassandraTruth: Future!Ted tells that he was right about believing that keeping a goat in the apartment is a bad idea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** SecondaryCharacterTitle: Since Missy is [[UnreliableNarrator presented]] as the [[TokenEvilTeammate Token Evil]] TeamPet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Barney tries to find a loophole in the Bro Code when he feels guilty about sleeping with Robin, Ted's ex, and Lily decides to rescue a goat, all while Ted's surprise birthday party is being planned.

----
!!This episode provides examples of:

* AntagonistTitle: Subverted. Missy the goat actually "terrorizes" Ted in his 31st birthday.
* BecarefulWhatYouWishFor: Barney, feeling guilty for sleeping with Robin, allows Ted to hit him anywhere but NotInTheFace. Ted gave him a GroinAttack.
* BitchInSheepsClothing: ''Almost''. Future!Ted keeps describing the goat as a CompleteMonster complete with an ominous {{Leitmotif}}.
* TheBroCode: TropeNamer. This episode marks its debut, and it is integral to its plot.
* BrutalHonesty: The farmer who owns Missy blatantly told Lily's class what he'll do to Missy.
* CallBack:
** Ted mentions the goat late in season 1.
** Ted and Barney's fallout is because of what happened in TheStinger of [[Recap/HowIMetYourMotherS3E16SandcastlesInTheSand the previous episode]].
** Ted mentions a box where he will put his old stuff that he has no longer use for early in the episode. He will refer to it in a metaphorical way after his and barney's fallout.
* CassandraTruth" Future!Ted tells that he was right about believing that keeping a goat in the apartment is a bad idea.
* ContinuityNod:
** Robin briefly mentions Simon when she confessed what happened between him and Barney.
** Ted referenced Barney's hots for his mother in season 2 and used it against him.
* ContinuitySnarl: Future!Ted put the goat story in his 30th birthday, but it actually happened in his 31st.
* EarlyBirdCameo: Missy the goat was introduced a year earlier than she supposed to be.
* ExactWords: Ted still play by some of the demeaning rules of TheBroCode by saying these.
* {{Foreshadowing}}: Future!Ted says that Robin will live with him by the time of his 31st birthday, which she eventually does starting next season.
* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Creator/BenjaminFranklin and Creator/GeorgeWashington appears in "the origins of TheBroCode" story.
* IdenticalGrandson: If Barnibus Stinson from the origins of TheBroCode really did existed.
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: Barney's main dilemma.
* OutOfFocus: Missy the goat, which is lampshaded by Future!Ted in TheStinger.
* TranquilFury: Subverted. By the time Barney picks him up from work, Ted already knew what happened between him and Robin. Once it's out though, Ted eventually snaps.
* WhamEpisode: Robin tells Ted about what happened between her and Barney, which results in Ted and Barney's fallout.
* WhamLine: Done in succession.
** Barney keeps insisting that Ted comes with him so he'll gradually break the news, but...
-->'''Barney:''' There's something that I have to tell you, and I wanted you to be in the best possible frame of mind before you heard it.
-->'''Ted:''' You slept with Robin.
** An InUniverse example in relation to the above...
-->'''Robin:''' I slept with Barney.
** Barney and Ted's fallout is not pretty...
-->'''Ted:''' You know Barney, earlier this week I started putting things in a box, and that box is labeled "stuff I have no use for anymore".
-->'''Barney:''' And what does that mean?
-->'''Ted:''' It means, maybe you belong in that box.
-->'''Barney:''' Are you saying you don't wanna be bros anymore?
-->'''Ted:''' I'm saying I don't wanna be friends anymore.

Top