Follow TV Tropes

Following

History RaceLift / ChangingTheMinority

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/DDay'' the Russian ForeignRemake of ''Film/{{Commando}}'', have it's entire cast being white due to being filmed in Russia (save for a Japanese henchman who's not in the original). As such, non-white characters from the original film like Cindy, Cooke, Henriques and some of the enemy mooks are all white Russians.

to:

* ''Film/DDay'' ''Film/DDay'', the Russian ForeignRemake of ''Film/{{Commando}}'', have it's ''Film/Commando1985'', has its entire cast being white due to being filmed in Russia (save for a Japanese henchman who's not in the original). As such, non-white characters from the original film like Cindy, Cooke, Henriques and some of the enemy mooks are all white Russians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* ''Film/ExodusGodsAndKings'' came under fire for casting white folks as the Egyptian and Israelite lead characters, including Creator/ChristianBale as Moses and Creator/JoelEdgerton as Ramses II. For added UnfortunateImplications, servants, assassins, workers and so on are portrayed by actors of colour. However, as of 2016 it was discovered that Ramses was fair-skinned.

to:

* ''Film/ExodusGodsAndKings'' came under fire for casting white folks as the Egyptian and Israelite lead characters, including Creator/ChristianBale as Moses and Creator/JoelEdgerton as Ramses II. For added UnfortunateImplications, unfortunate implications, servants, assassins, workers and so on are portrayed by actors of colour. However, as of 2016 it was discovered that Ramses was fair-skinned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rose Wilson of ''ComicBook/TeenTitans'' and the '90s ''Deathstroke'' series was introduced as the illegitimate daughter of Slade Wilson and a Cambodian woman named Lillian Worth. While most artists didn't really reflect Rose's Cambodian heritage as much, she was still meant to be mixed-race, albeit with pure white hair and blue (or green) eyes. In ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeagueCrisisOnTwoEarths'', Rose became a red-haired Caucasian girl (although she was basically an InNameOnly incarnation) who had Adeline Kane as her mother). In post-Flashpoint comics continuity, Rose is now also entirely Caucasian with Adeline Kane as her mother, although as said before, since Rose's ethnicity was barely drawn consistently, there is little visual difference and she retains her white hair. The change was undone in ''ComicBook/DCRebirth'', with Rose once again being of mixed white and Cambodian descent.

to:

* Rose Wilson of ''ComicBook/TeenTitans'' and the '90s ''Deathstroke'' series was introduced as the illegitimate daughter of Slade Wilson and a Cambodian woman named Lillian Worth. While most artists didn't really reflect Rose's Cambodian heritage as much, she was still meant to be mixed-race, albeit with pure white hair and blue (or green) eyes. In ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeagueCrisisOnTwoEarths'', Rose became a red-haired Caucasian girl (although she was basically an InNameOnly incarnation) who had Adeline Kane as her mother).mother. In post-Flashpoint comics continuity, Rose is now also entirely Caucasian with Adeline Kane as her mother, although as said before, since Rose's ethnicity was barely drawn consistently, there is little visual difference and she retains her white hair. The change was undone in ''ComicBook/DCRebirth'', with Rose once again being of mixed white and Cambodian descent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misplaced, moving to the correct tab


* The ''Manga/DeathNote'' adaptations vary between depicting Rodd Loss as black or white. In the black and white manga pages, his skin is light though his exaggerated facial features are similar to a few other darker-skinned gang members, suggesting that he could possibly be biracial. In the anime, he definitely appears more on the white side. The DS game goes in the opposite direction and depicts him as an unambiguously dark-skinned black man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
deleted the example i just added because this isn't the correct page sorry :P


** The [[Film/DeathNote2017 American version]] depicts the originally pale-skinned and biracial (European and Asian, by the way) L as a black man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

** The [[Film/DeathNote2017 American version]] depicts the originally pale-skinned and biracial (European and Asian, by the way) L as a black man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s), Crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/HazbinHotel'': St. Peter in Literature/TheBible is a Middle-Eastern man. In this show, he's Caucasian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Creator/ArthurCClarke's novel ''Film/TwoThousandTenTheYearWeMakeContact'', the scientist responsible for the HAL 9000, Dr. Sivasubramanian Chandrasegarampillai -- or Dr. Chandra -- is from India. In the film version, he's Creator/BobBalaban. But still named Dr. Chandra.

to:

* In Creator/ArthurCClarke's novel ''Film/TwoThousandTenTheYearWeMakeContact'', ''2010: Odyssey Two'', the scientist responsible for who created the HAL 9000, Dr. Sivasubramanian Chandrasegarampillai -- or Dr. Chandra -- is from India. In the film version, ''Film/TwoThousandTenTheYearWeMakeContact'', he's Creator/BobBalaban. But still named Dr. Chandra. (Oddly, as the preceding film ''[[Film/TwoThousandOneASpaceOdyssey 2001]]'' had changed HAL's creator's name to "Mr Langley".)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Master Miller, FOX HOUND's drill instructor in the Franchise/MetalGear series, had a distinctively Asian appearance in his debut in the [=MSX2=] version of ''VideoGame/MetalGear2SolidSnake''. When he "returned" in ''VideoGame/MetalGearSolid'', he was turned into a blond haired and fair-skinned man with a Japanese heritage [[spoiler:making it easier for Liquid Snake to impersonate Miller by simply giving himself a ponytail and sunglasses.]]

to:

* Master Miller, FOX HOUND's drill instructor in the Franchise/MetalGear VideoGame/MetalGear series, had a distinctively Asian appearance in his debut in the [=MSX2=] version of ''VideoGame/MetalGear2SolidSnake''. When he "returned" in ''VideoGame/MetalGearSolid'', he was turned into a blond haired and fair-skinned man with a Japanese heritage [[spoiler:making it easier for Liquid Snake to impersonate Miller by simply giving himself a ponytail and sunglasses.]]

Changed: 5

Removed: 87

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ComicBook/WonderWoman2006'': Akila, a dark skinned black haired Amazon who has always had Arabic features in the past, is depicted as a blonde white woman. It's unlikely to just be a coloring mistake as her appearance is radically altered.

to:

* ''ComicBook/WonderWoman2006'': Akila, a dark skinned black haired Amazon who has always had Arabic Arab features in the past, is depicted as a blonde white woman. It's unlikely to just be a coloring mistake as her appearance is radically altered.



** In ''Film/TheDarkKnightRises'', BigBad ComicBook/{{Bane}}, half-British and half-Hispanic[[note]]British father and Santa Priscan mother, born and raised in a ''high-security prison'' in Santa Prisca, a Spanish-colonized Caribbean island. The trait is important to the character but not established in his first appearance.[[/note]] in the comics, is played by Brit Creator/TomHardy. Hardy's features and accent are ambiguous and distorted, so his race could go any which way. Except as it turns out, he's from a Chinese/Arab prison instead of a South American one, [[spoiler: and the protector of [[BigBadDuumvirate fellow villain]] [=Talia Al Ghul/Miranda Tate=], daughter of Ra's. Interestingly, Talia is only a downplayed example; her actress Creator/MarionCotillard has some amount of Kabyle (North African) ancestry.]].

to:

** In ''Film/TheDarkKnightRises'', BigBad ComicBook/{{Bane}}, half-British and half-Hispanic[[note]]British father and Santa Priscan mother, born and raised in a ''high-security prison'' in Santa Prisca, a Spanish-colonized Caribbean island. The trait is important to the character but not established in his first appearance.[[/note]] in the comics, is played by Brit Creator/TomHardy. Hardy's features and accent are ambiguous and distorted, so his race could go any which way. Except as it turns out, he's from a Chinese/Arab prison instead of a South American one, [[spoiler: and the protector of [[BigBadDuumvirate fellow villain]] [=Talia Al Ghul/Miranda Tate=], daughter of Ra's. Interestingly, Talia is only a downplayed example; her actress Creator/MarionCotillard has some amount of Kabyle (North African) ancestry.]].ancestry]].



-->Trillian was a girl that Zaphod had picked up recently whilst visiting a planet, just for fun, incognito. She was slim, darkish, humanoid, with long waves of black hair, a full mouth, an odd little nob of a nose and ridiculously brown eyes. With her red head scarf knotted in that particular way and her long flowing silky brown dress she looked vaguely Arabic.

to:

-->Trillian was a girl that Zaphod had picked up recently whilst visiting a planet, just for fun, incognito. She was slim, darkish, humanoid, with long waves of black hair, a full mouth, an odd little nob of a nose and ridiculously brown eyes. With her red head scarf knotted in that particular way and her long flowing silky brown dress she looked vaguely Arabic.Arab.



* Creator/LiamNeeson plays the Arabic villain Comicbook/RasAlGhul in Film/BatmanBegins.

Added: 1195

Changed: 2366

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/Tekken2010'' had Brazilian Christie played by white Creator/KellyOverton. When she was cast, cue dozens of internet arguments claiming that Christie was really black, Hispanic or even Asian ethnicity. In what may count as an inversion, the Irish Anna Williams was played by a Spanish actress but Anna's background is never stated.

to:

* ''Film/Tekken2010'' had :
**
Brazilian Christie is played by white Creator/KellyOverton. When she was cast, cue dozens of internet arguments claiming that Christie was really black, Hispanic or even Asian ethnicity. In what may count as an inversion,
** Kazuya Mishima, a full Japanese in
the Irish Anna Williams was games, is played by a Spanish actress but Anna's background Creator/IanAnthonyDale, who is never stated.mixed-race (white father and Japanese mother). Kazuya's son, Jin Kazama, is played by Creator/JonFoo, who is similarly mixed-race (Chinese father and white mother). It's worth noting that Heihachi ''did'' father a son with a white woman in the games, so Kazuya may be a CompositeCharacter here.[[note]]However, said son, Lars Alexandersson, is [[PhenotypeStereotype far more stereotypically European-looking]] (blond hair, blue eyes) than Dale, who looks realistically mixed.[[/note]]



* In ''Film/TheDarkKnightRises'', BigBad ComicBook/{{Bane}}, half-British and half-Hispanic[[note]]British father and Santa Priscan mother, born and raised in a ''high-security prison'' in Santa Prisca, a Spanish-colonized Caribbean island. The trait is important to the character but not established in his first appearance.[[/note]] in the comics, is played by Brit Creator/TomHardy. Hardy's features and accent are ambiguous and distorted, so his race could go any which way. Except as it turns out, he's from a Chinese\Arabic prison instead of a South American one, [[spoiler: and the protector from [[BigBadDuumvirate fellow villain]] and example of this trope [=Talia Al Ghul/Miranda Tate=]. Her father, ComicBook/RasAlGhul, who in the comics is Chinese and/or Arabic, is played by Irish actor Creator/LiamNeeson and Talia is played by Creator/MarionCotillard, who is French]].
** Bane was also played by white wrestler Creator/RobertSwenson in ''Film/BatmanAndRobin'', but as a stereotypical DumbMuscle character (with ''green'' skin). The less said about it, the better.
** Blonde haired, blue eyed actress Teresa Palmer was going to play Talia in the cancelled ''Script/JusticeLeagueMortal'' film even though she's described in the script as being "exotic" and "from some other country, some other world, maybe".

to:

* ''Film/TheDarkKnightTrilogy'':
** The ''real'' Ra's al Ghul, of Chinese and/or Arab descent in the comics, is played by [[spoiler:Irishman Creator/LiamNeeson]].
**
In ''Film/TheDarkKnightRises'', BigBad ComicBook/{{Bane}}, half-British and half-Hispanic[[note]]British father and Santa Priscan mother, born and raised in a ''high-security prison'' in Santa Prisca, a Spanish-colonized Caribbean island. The trait is important to the character but not established in his first appearance.[[/note]] in the comics, is played by Brit Creator/TomHardy. Hardy's features and accent are ambiguous and distorted, so his race could go any which way. Except as it turns out, he's from a Chinese\Arabic Chinese/Arab prison instead of a South American one, [[spoiler: and the protector from of [[BigBadDuumvirate fellow villain]] and example of this trope [=Talia Al Ghul/Miranda Tate=]. Her father, ComicBook/RasAlGhul, who in the comics is Chinese and/or Arabic, is played by Irish actor Creator/LiamNeeson and Tate=], daughter of Ra's. Interestingly, Talia is played by Creator/MarionCotillard, who is French]].
**
only a downplayed example; her actress Creator/MarionCotillard has some amount of Kabyle (North African) ancestry.]].
*
Bane was also played by white wrestler Creator/RobertSwenson in ''Film/BatmanAndRobin'', but as a stereotypical DumbMuscle character (with ''green'' skin). The less said about it, the better.
** * Blonde haired, blue eyed actress Teresa Palmer was going to play Talia in the cancelled ''Script/JusticeLeagueMortal'' film even though she's described in the script as being "exotic" and "from some other country, some other world, maybe".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The wrestling BioPic ''Film/FightingWithMyFamily'' features Wrestling/AJLee submitting a blonde woman at ''Wrestling/WrestleMania XXX'' to retain her Diva's Championship for the final time before losing it to protagonist Wrestling/{{Paige}} the very next night. In the actual event, AJ submitted Wrestling/{{Naomi}}, who is African-American.

to:

* The wrestling BioPic ''Film/FightingWithMyFamily'' features Wrestling/AJLee submitting a blonde woman at ''Wrestling/WrestleMania XXX'' to retain her Diva's Championship for the final time before losing it to protagonist Wrestling/{{Paige}} the very next night. In the actual event, AJ submitted Wrestling/{{Naomi}}, Wrestling/{{Naomi|Wrestler}}, who is African-American.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Almost happened during the production of ''WesternAnimation/JorelsBrother''. In the series' early lineup, one of the main characters was a black housemaid, who was inspired by a housemaid who worked at the show's creator's house. She made it to the show's pilot, but then the executives demanded her to be altered to a white woman, as having the only black character being the housemaid could potentially be inspired as a racial stereotype, even if inspired on real people. However, they decided that a housemaid character as a whole, regardless of race, wouldn't be really appropriate for a children's show, so they replaced her with an octopus babysitter.

to:

* Almost happened during the production of ''WesternAnimation/JorelsBrother''. In the series' early lineup, one of the main characters was a black housemaid, who was inspired by a housemaid who worked at the show's creator's house. She That iteration of the character made it to as far as the show's pilot, but then the executives demanded her to be altered to a white woman, as since having the only black character being the housemaid could potentially be inspired interpreted as a racial stereotype, even if inspired on real people. However, they decided that a housemaid character as a whole, regardless of race, wouldn't be really appropriate for a children's show, so they replaced her with an octopus babysitter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Almost happened during the production of ''WesternAnimation/JorelsBrother''. In the series' early lineup, one of the main characters was a black housemaid, who was inspired by a housemaid who worked at the show's creator's house. She made it to the show's pilot, but then the executives demanded her to be altered to a white woman, as having the only black character being the housemaid could potentially be inspired as a racial stereotype, even if inspired on real people. However, they decided that a housemaid character as a whole, regardless of race, wouldn't be really appropriate for a children's show, so they replaced her with an octopus babysitter.

Added: 308

Changed: 213

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mike [=McMahon=] drew ComicBook/JudgeDredd as a black man for a while during his early years. Because the comic was in black and white, nobody noticed and [[AbortedArc he abandoned the idea after a while]]. Judge Guthrie is a more straight example, starting off as AmbiguouslyBrown DependingOnTheArtist (Carlos Ezquerra drew him as out and out black). In more recent years, he's been unambiguously white.

to:

* Mike [=McMahon=] drew ComicBook/JudgeDredd as a black man for a while during his early years. Because the comic was in black and white, nobody noticed and [[AbortedArc he abandoned the idea after a while]]. Judge Guthrie is a more straight example, starting off as AmbiguouslyBrown DependingOnTheArtist (Carlos Ezquerra drew him as out and out black). In more recent years, he's been unambiguously white. white ... until the time-travel story "One-Eyed Jacks" introduced seventies African-American detective Eartha Fargo as the grandmother of the man he was cloned from. This still isn't reflected in his appearance, thought.


Added DiffLines:

* The ''WesternAnimation/TomAndJerry'' strip in the 1970s British AnthologyComic ''TV Comic'' features [[https://leagueofcomicgeeks.com/comic/7447039/tv-comic-1175 a white woman in a maid's uniform]], [[EveryoneCallsHimBarkeep referred to only as "Maid"]], who essentially serves the role of Mammy Two-Legs.

Top