Follow TV Tropes

Following

History NightmareFuel / Goodfellas

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''.

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''. \n]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''.

to:

\n* Two [[caption-width-right:350:Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''. [=DeVito=]'''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/img_0773_8.JPG]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even worse: Scorsese had to ''tone down'' some of the things Tommy did ''in real life''...

to:

** Even worse: Scorsese had to ''tone down'' some of the things Tommy did ''in ''[[RealityIsUnrealistic in real life''...life]]''...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* One of the things that really drives home the casual brutality of mobster mentality is in the famous "how am I funny?" scene. After Henry realizes Tommy is just messing with him, and everyone laughs it off, a waiter comes up to talk to Tommy about an outstanding bill he has, and Tommy gets pissed, and ends up smashing a bottle over the poor guy's head, and all the other mobsters don't just act like assaulting someone for basically no reason is no big deal, it's ''funny'' to them, even though just moments ago they were honestly afraid Tommy was going to possibly murder Henry for no reason other than accidentally offending him. Also, who's to say [[HairTriggerTemper Tommy]] wasn't [[MoodSwinger serious]], and [[JustJokingJustification just changed his mind when Henry called him out]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not Nightmare Fuel: it may be annoying that gangsters could live like kings while in prison, but if it gives you actual nightmares, you are too emotionally invested in the concept of punishment


* The scene where we see what happens to these gangsters when they go to prison: they live like kings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even worse: Scorsese had to ''tone down'' some of the things Tommy did ''[[RealityIsUnrealistic in real life]]''...
** Tommy's execution is pretty horrifying, especially as he realizes whats about to happen a fraction of a second before a bullet blows off half his face.

to:

** Even worse: Scorsese had to ''tone down'' some of the things Tommy did ''[[RealityIsUnrealistic in ''in real life]]''...
life''...
** Tommy's execution is pretty horrifying, especially as he realizes whats what's about to happen a fraction of a second before a bullet blows off half his face.



* After everything, after all the horrible things he's been a part of, all Hill really cares about is the loss of his gangster status. He doesnt care that he's been partially responsible for the murder and ruining the lives of countless innocent people, all he ever gave a fuck about was himself. Atleast Tommy's sociopathy was out on the surface.

to:

* After everything, after all the horrible things he's been a part of, all Hill really cares about is the loss of his gangster status. He doesnt doesn't care that he's been partially responsible for the murder and ruining the lives of countless innocent people, all he ever gave a fuck about was himself. Atleast At least Tommy's sociopathy was out on the surface.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This was intentional, Scorsese got complaints at the previews and he said that the audience should be angry, "The nerve of this guy" and that people should question the mentality and values of the culture that makes being a "schnook" such a bad thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* After everything, after all the horrible things he's been a part of, all Hill really cares about is the loss of his gangster status. He doesnt care that he's been partially responsible for the murder and ruining the lives of countless innocent people, all he ever gave a fuck about was himself. Atleast Tommy's sociopathy was out on the surface.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Tommy's execution is pretty horrifying, especially as he realizes whats about to happen a raction of a second before a bullet blows off half his face.

to:

** Tommy's execution is pretty horrifying, especially as he realizes whats about to happen a raction fraction of a second before a bullet blows off half his face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Tommy's execution is pretty horrifying, especially as he realizes whats about to happen a raction of a second before a bullet blows off half his face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even worse: Scorsese had to ''tone down'' some of the things Tommy did ''in real life''...

to:

** Even worse: Scorsese had to ''tone down'' some of the things Tommy did ''in ''[[RealityIsUnrealistic in real life''...life]]''...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Even worse: Scorsese had to ''tone down'' some of the things Tommy did ''in real life''...

Changed: 941

Removed: 471

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''. He is generally frightening when he's mad. And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not tolerate words misinterpreted by himself, not to mention his twisted sense of humor, notably in the grave digging scene.
** If you pay attention to the personality of Tommy, is pure FridgeHorror. He is incredibly irrational and paranoid, and any word misunderstood by himself can lead to murder. So here, it is very likely already committed other killings or beatings before the movie. Worse, you can imagine how he must have been in school?
** Then there is the Billy's brutal death scene, where Tommy hits him until he bled and even some blood falls to his face, most disturbing of all is that he wanted to continue the beating, even when his partners stopped him. Even Henry is visibly disturbed for this action.
* The scene where we see what happens to these gangsters when they go to prison: they live like kings. The prisons have been reformed quite a bit since then, but even a prison system one tenth as corruptable as then one presented in the film lets career-complete-monsters off sickeningly lightly.
* The scene where Jimmy starts thinking about whacking Morrie and all the other hired mooks. He just sits there smoking but then music goes up and you know he's up to no good.

to:

* Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''. He is generally frightening when he's mad. And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not tolerate words misinterpreted by himself, not to mention his twisted sense of humor, notably in the grave digging scene.\n** If you pay attention to the personality of Tommy, is pure FridgeHorror. He is incredibly irrational and paranoid, and any word misunderstood by himself can lead to murder. So here, it is very likely already committed other killings or beatings before the movie. Worse, you can imagine how he must have been in school? \n** Then there is the Billy's brutal death scene, where Tommy hits him until he bled and even some blood falls to his face, most disturbing of all is that he wanted to continue the beating, even when his partners stopped him. Even Henry is visibly disturbed for this action.\n
* The scene where we see what happens to these gangsters when they go to prison: they live like kings. The prisons have been reformed quite a bit since then, but even a prison system one tenth as corruptable as then one presented in the film lets career-complete-monsters off sickeningly lightly.
kings.
* The scene where Jimmy starts thinking about whacking Morrie and all the other hired mooks. He just sits there smoking but then the music goes up and you know he's up to no good.



* The way Henry's father beats his son when he's a teenager is brutally realistic setting for early in the film, and highly disturbing.

to:

* The way Henry's father beats his son when he's a teenager is brutally realistic setting for realistic. It's early on in the film, and highly disturbing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''. He is generally frightening when he's mad. And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not usually tolerate jokes or words misinterpreted by himself, not to mention his twisted sense of humor, notably in the grave digging scene.

to:

* Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''. He is generally frightening when he's mad. And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not usually tolerate jokes or words misinterpreted by himself, not to mention his twisted sense of humor, notably in the grave digging scene.

Added: 273

Changed: 560

Removed: 669

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start ''laughing'' again, as if nothing has happened.
* Tommy [=DeVito=] is generally frightening when he's mad. And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not usually tolerate jokes or words misinterpreted by himself, not to mention his twisted sense of humor, notably in the grave digging scene.

to:

* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start ''laughing'' again, as if nothing has happened.
* Tommy [=DeVito=]
Two words: '''Tommy [=DeVito=]'''. He is generally frightening when he's mad. And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not usually tolerate jokes or words misinterpreted by himself, not to mention his twisted sense of humor, notably in the grave digging scene.



** Then there is the Billy's brutal death scene, where Tommy hits him until he bled and even some blood falls to his face, most disturbing of all is that he wanted to continue the beating, even when his partners stopped him. Even Henry is visibly disturbed for this action.



* Then there is the Billy's brutal death scene, where Tommy hits him until he bled and even some blood falls to his face, most disturbing of all is that he wanted to continue the beating, even when his partners stopped him. Even Henry is horrified by this action.
** Henry isn't horrified by the murder. He's horrified by the fact Tommy whacked a ''made man'', which is a death sentence if you don't get permission from a Don.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If you pay attention to the personality of Tommy, is pure FridgeHorror. He is incredibly irrational and paranoid, and any word misunderstood by himself can lead to murder. So here, it is very likely already committed other killings or beatings before the movie. Worse, you can imagine how he must have been in school?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened.
* Tommy [=DeVito=] is generally frightening when he's mad. And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not usually tolerate jokes or words misinterpreted by himself, not to mention his twisted sense of humor.

to:

* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING ''laughing'' again, as if nothing has happened.
* Tommy [=DeVito=] is generally frightening when he's mad. And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not usually tolerate jokes or words misinterpreted by himself, not to mention his twisted sense of humor.humor, notably in the grave digging scene.

Changed: 356

Removed: 128

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of an extreme BlackComedy in a live action version of ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark''.
* Tommy [=DeVito=] is generally frightening when he's mad. It is not pleasant interact with him, can not stand sarcasm, or any word misunderstood by him is enough to be willing to kill.
* The montage of [[spoiler:the fates of those involved in the Lufthansa heist]]. Especially how they're revealed in slow motion.

to:

* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of an extreme BlackComedy in a live action version of ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark''.
happened.
* Tommy [=DeVito=] is generally frightening when he's mad. It And the most chilling in Tommy is that does not pleasant interact with him, can usually tolerate jokes or words misinterpreted by himself, not stand sarcasm, or any word misunderstood by him is enough to be willing to kill.
* The montage
mention his twisted sense of [[spoiler:the fates of those involved in the Lufthansa heist]]. Especially how they're revealed in slow motion.humor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of an extreme BlackComedy in a live action version of ''SouthPark''.

to:

* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of an extreme BlackComedy in a live action version of ''SouthPark''.''WesternAnimation/SouthPark''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Henry isn't horrified by the murder. He's horrified by the fact Tommy whacked a ''made man'', which is a death sentence if you don't get permission from a Don.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Then there is the Billy's brutal death scene, where Tommy hits him until he bled and even some blood falls to his face, most disturbing of all is that he wanted to continue the beating, even when his partners stopped him. Even Henry is horrified by this action.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of an extreme BlackComedy in a live action version of ''SouthPark''.

to:

* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing.killing, specially Tommy and Jimmy. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of an extreme BlackComedy in a live action version of ''SouthPark''.

Added: 135

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of a DeadBabyComedy in a live action version of ''SouthPark''.

to:

* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of a DeadBabyComedy an extreme BlackComedy in a live action version of ''SouthPark''.


Added DiffLines:

* The way Henry's father beats his son when he's a teenager is brutally realistic setting for early in the film, and highly disturbing.

Added: 185

Changed: 711

Removed: 473

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tommy [=DeVito=] is creepy in himself when he's mad. It is not pleasant interact with him, can not stand sarcasm, or any word misunderstood by him is enough to be willing to kill.

to:

* The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The most disturbing moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened... Hell, NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy. It almost seems as if it were of a DeadBabyComedy in a live action version of ''SouthPark''.
* Tommy [=DeVito=] is creepy in himself generally frightening when he's mad. It is not pleasant interact with him, can not stand sarcasm, or any word misunderstood by him is enough to be willing to kill.



** The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The scariest moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened.....NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
We need more examples

Added DiffLines:

**The most chilling thing about this movie is just how desensitized these people are to killing. They have a family, they talk, they laugh-and yet the littlest thing anyone does can set them off and make them kill. The scariest moment was probably where the poor bartender is beaten over the head and stomped on and shot in the face, and they cover the corpse up with a cloth and start LAUGHING again, as if nothing has happened.....NothingisScarier than cold sociopathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tommy [=DeVito=] himself is generally creepy when he's mad. It is not pleasant interact with him, can not stand sarcasm, or any word misunderstood by him is enough to be willing to kill.

to:

* Tommy [=DeVito=] is creepy in himself is generally creepy when he's mad. It is not pleasant interact with him, can not stand sarcasm, or any word misunderstood by him is enough to be willing to kill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Tommy [=DeVito=] himself is generally creepy when he's mad. It is not pleasant interact with him, can not stand sarcasm, or any word misunderstood by him is enough to be willing to kill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The scene where Jimmy starts thinking about whacking Morty. He just sits there smoking but then music goes up and you know he's up to no good.

to:

* The scene where Jimmy starts thinking about whacking Morty.Morrie and all the other hired mooks. He just sits there smoking but then music goes up and you know he's up to no good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The montage of [[spoiler:the fates of those involved in the Lufthansa heist]]. Especially how they're revealed in slow motion.
* The scene where we see what happens to these gangsters when they go to prison: they live like kings. The prisons have been reformed quite a bit since then, but even a prison system one tenth as corruptable as then one presented in the film lets career-complete-monsters off sickeningly lightly.
* The scene where Jimmy starts thinking about whacking Morty. He just sits there smoking but then music goes up and you know he's up to no good.
** [=DeNiro=]'s eyes in that scene. They just say, with such incredible subtlety, "Time to go on a killing spree."
----

Top