Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Wintergirls

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Jerkass}}: Despite most people in Lia's life wanting to help her, there are a number of unpleasant characters around.
** Cassie's father, a strict, unloving and authoritarian parent who treats his only daughter like a TrophyChild, never seems to be satisfied with her achievements, and is always berating her for not being perfect.
** Thatcher, a bully who tormented Cassie in fifth grade and went as far as to sexually harass her by snapping the back of her bra and drawing a picture of her with massive breasts that he passed around to the entire class.
** "Lettuce&ketchup," an unnamed girl who is referred to as that because she only eats lettuce, celery, and ketchup for lunch. She keeps giving Lia dirty looks for being thinner than her and basically calls her a terrible friend to Cassie in front of their entire lunch table.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Lia isn't the only girl at school with weight issues, either. One girl only referred to as "lettuce&ketchup" because that's all she eats for lunch is frustrated that she's not losing weight as quickly as she wants and keeps giving Lia jealous looks. If only she knew...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** David isn't there because he's at an early meeting, but his absence (especially during a time like this) shows that he's not a great family man.

to:

** David isn't there because he's at an early meeting, but his absence (especially during a time like this) shows that he's not a great family man.man, especially during a time like this when his daughter's best friend has just been found dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SoapPunishment: A self-inflicted one after Lia eats a bunch of cookies and cupcakes at the elementary school bake sale, can't force herself to vomit them back up, and gargles with liquid soap to punish herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lia insists that she's fine even after hearing about Cassie's death and refuses Jennifer's offers of toast or frozen waffles, instead saying she'll eat some cereal and then dumping it down the drain after Jennifer and Emma leave the house. Clearly she's troubled, but doesn't feel comfortable sharing how she feels with Jennifer.

to:

** Lia insists that she's fine even after hearing about Cassie's death and refuses Jennifer's offers of toast or frozen waffles, instead saying she'll eat some cereal and then dumping cereal. She dumps most of it down the drain after Jennifer and Emma leave the house.house, instead opting for a handful of raisins and almonds, a pear, and her medication. Clearly she's troubled, but doesn't feel comfortable sharing how she feels with Jennifer.

Added: 239

Changed: 368

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** David isn't there because he's at an early meeting, but his absence (even during an important time like this) shows that he's not a great family man.
** Emma is a CheerfulChild who happily waves to Lia as she goes out the door. She's also having big expectations placed on her by her mother, drives her to school early four mornings a week for violin lessons and conversational French.

to:

** David isn't there because he's at an early meeting, but his absence (even (especially during an important a time like this) shows that he's not a great family man.
** Chloe isn't there either, but Lia comments that she prefers talking to her ex-husband David over the phone because face-to-face takes too much time and usually ends in screaming, implying an acrimonious divorce.
** Emma is a CheerfulChild who happily waves to Lia as she goes out the door. She's also having big expectations placed on her by her mother, who drives her to school early four mornings a week for violin lessons and conversational French.

Added: 1129

Changed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon. She also had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration.

to:

** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon. She also surgeon, but her family life isn't so great. In college, she had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration.


Added DiffLines:

* EstablishingCharacterMoment: The opening scene in the kitchen establishes the characterization of Lia and her family.
** Jennifer breaks the news about Cassie's death to Lia and shows concern about her stepdaughter's physical and mental well-being, while still getting ready for work and making sure Emma gets ready for school. She's juggling two children, housework, and a job, and she's also a SlaveToPR.
** Lia insists that she's fine even after hearing about Cassie's death and refuses Jennifer's offers of toast or frozen waffles, instead saying she'll eat some cereal and then dumping it down the drain after Jennifer and Emma leave the house. Clearly she's troubled, but doesn't feel comfortable sharing how she feels with Jennifer.
** David isn't there because he's at an early meeting, but his absence (even during an important time like this) shows that he's not a great family man.
** Emma is a CheerfulChild who happily waves to Lia as she goes out the door. She's also having big expectations placed on her by her mother, drives her to school early four mornings a week for violin lessons and conversational French.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Cassie was a model student who actively participated in sports and night, but suffered from bulimia, alcoholism, self-esteem issues, and was always fighting with her parents. Until the moment of her death, she was pretending everything was fine at school, while feeling dead inside and hating herself for dumping Lia as a best friend, but not being able to apologize to her until she was in the middle of a drinking binge. When Lia didn't answer after 33 calls, Cassie continued binging, purging, and drinking until her esophagus ruptured and she died alone on the bathroom floor of her motel room.

to:

** Cassie was a model student who actively participated in sports and night, theatre, but suffered from bulimia, alcoholism, self-esteem issues, and was always fighting with her parents. Until the moment of her death, she was pretending everything was fine at school, while feeling dead inside and hating herself for dumping Lia as a her best friend, friend Lia, but not being able to apologize to her until she was in the middle of a drinking binge. When Lia didn't answer after 33 calls, Cassie continued binging, purging, and drinking until her esophagus ruptured and she died alone on the bathroom floor of her motel room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenAce:
** Cassie was a model student who actively participated in sports and night, but suffered from bulimia, alcoholism, self-esteem issues, and was always fighting with her parents. Until the moment of her death, she was pretending everything was fine at school, while feeling dead inside and hating herself for dumping Lia as a best friend, but not being able to apologize to her until she was in the middle of a drinking binge. When Lia didn't answer after 33 calls, Cassie continued binging, purging, and drinking until her esophagus ruptured and she died alone on the bathroom floor of her motel room.
** Lia's mother Dr. Chloe Marrigan is a genius cardiologist and surgeon. She also had a ShotgunWedding to Lia's father and spent several years in a loveless marriage with him before finally getting a divorce. Her only daughter has a troubled relationship with her and doesn't even want to live with her. Currently, she lives alone and her house is covered in half-hearted attempts at redecoration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShroudedInMyth: Rumors fly around the school regarding Cassie's death that she was murdered, hung herself, died of a heroin overdose or worse. Only Lia finds out the truth: [[spoiler:her esophagus ripped open when she was binging, purging, and drinking in a motel room, alone]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PercussiveTherapy: When Lia can't stop thinking about Cassie, she bakes a gingerbread cookie representing her and smashes it with the rolling pin until it's a pile of dust.

to:

* PercussiveTherapy: When Lia can't stop thinking about Cassie, she bakes a gingerbread cookie representing shaped like her and smashes it with the rolling pin until it's a pile of dust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EducationMama: Jennifer wants only the best opportunities for Emma, pushing her into sports, violin, and French while she's still in elementary school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PercussiveTherapy: When baking gingerbread cookies, Lia makes a cookie representing Cassie and smashes it with the rolling pin until it's a pile of dust.

to:

* PercussiveTherapy: When baking Lia can't stop thinking about Cassie, she bakes a gingerbread cookies, Lia makes a cookie representing Cassie her and smashes it with the rolling pin until it's a pile of dust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdvancedTech2000: In her head, Lia refers to the bathroom scale in her house as the "Blubber-O-Meter 3000".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Bowdlerise}}: On page 115, when Lia's therapist asks her what words are in her head, Lia thinks "pissed, pig, hate". Some editions of the book change "pissed" to "fury".

Added: 209

Changed: 106

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SelfHarm: Lia is addicted to it, viewing it as the only way to expunge all the dirt inside of her.

to:

* SelfHarm: Lia is addicted to it, viewing it as the only way to expunge all the dirt inside of her. She started doing it in middle school as a way to deal with the pain of puberty and her parents' divorce.


Added DiffLines:

* TextileWorkIsFeminine: One of Lia's few hobbies is knitting. Instead of buying new yarn from a craft store, she buys old sweaters from thrift shops and unravels them to knit them into the shawl she's making.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PercussiveTherapy: When baking gingerbread cookies, Lia makes a cookie representing Cassie and smashes it with the rolling pin until it's a pile of dust.


Added DiffLines:

* SupremeChef: Ironically, Lia's pretty good at cooking and baking. She makes muffins and an omelette for her mom, and bakes Christmas cookies for Emma.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope.


* YourCheatingHeart:
** Lia's father, David, frequently cheated on her mother with at least four or five different women, maybe more. Lia observes about halfway through the novel that the same crop of excuses he'd given for his late nights and distant behaviour are starting to resurface, and [[TheReasonYousuckSpeech accuses him of cheating on his new wife Jennifer as well]] during a heated argument.
** When thinking about Cassie dumping her as a best friend, Lia thinks about the time that she stopped Cassie from overdosing on sleeping pills when she found out her boyfriend had cheated on her.

Added: 577

Changed: 724

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoodStepmother: Jennifer. Lia has a complex, but much better relationship with with her stepmother than she does with her biological mother.

to:

* GoodStepmother: Jennifer. Lia has a complex, but much better relationship with with her stepmother than she does with her biological mother. Although Jennifer can be mildly insensitive at times and doesn't really understand Lia all that well, she sincerely cares about Lia and wants to help her get better.



* LastDisrespects: Some of the yearbook staff who believe the rumors that Cassie died of a heroin overdose want her memorial to be a tiny quarter panel in the back of the book, with the local hardware store, insurance agency, and florist.

to:

* LastDisrespects: Some of the yearbook staff who believe the rumors that Cassie died of a heroin overdose want to make her memorial to be page as small as possible, a tiny quarter panel in the back of the book, book with the local hardware store, insurance agency, and florist.



* RuleOfThree: [[spoiler:Lia is admitted a total of three separate times to New Seasons, a clinic for girls with eating disorders. Her third stay is when she actually tries to get help, cooperate with the doctors, and put her life back together.]]

to:

* RuleOfThree: [[spoiler:Lia is admitted a total of three separate times to New Seasons, a clinic for girls patients with eating disorders. Her third stay is when she actually tries to get help, cooperate with the doctors, and put her life back together.]]



* UndignifiedDeath: [[spoiler: Cassie.]]

to:

* UndignifiedDeath: [[spoiler: Cassie.Cassie died alone in her motel room from a rupture of the esophagus, caused by repeated binging and purging in a very short period of time.]]



* YourCheatingHeart: Lia's father, David, frequently cheated on her mother with at least four or five different women, maybe more. Lia observes about halfway through the novel that the same crop of excuses he'd given for his late nights and distant behaviour are starting to resurface, and [[TheReasonYousuckSpeech accuses him of cheating on his new wife Jennifer as well]] during a heated argument.

to:

* YourCheatingHeart: YourCheatingHeart:
**
Lia's father, David, frequently cheated on her mother with at least four or five different women, maybe more. Lia observes about halfway through the novel that the same crop of excuses he'd given for his late nights and distant behaviour are starting to resurface, and [[TheReasonYousuckSpeech accuses him of cheating on his new wife Jennifer as well]] during a heated argument.argument.
** When thinking about Cassie dumping her as a best friend, Lia thinks about the time that she stopped Cassie from overdosing on sleeping pills when she found out her boyfriend had cheated on her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BreakHerHeartToSaveHer: Played with. [[spoiler:Elijah abandons Lia at the climax at the book in Charlie's hotel, but he has good intentions - he realizes there's no way he, in good faith, can let her go with him, since it'd be enabling her to run from her problems.]]


Added DiffLines:

* CruelAndUnusualDeath: [[spoiler: '''Cassie.''' As brutally described: her esophagus ''rips open'' after drunkenly binging and purging for two days, sending her into shock and killing her. Lia's mother outright tells her that she "died in terror and she died alone", even lampshading the trope with "It is an awful way to go".]]


Added DiffLines:

* DrugsAreBad: Downplayed, but it's definitely there.
** [[spoiler: Cassie's death was exacerbated by alcohol.]]
** Lia mentions that a rumor spreads throughout the school that Cassie died of a heroin overdose. [[spoiler: She hesitates to correct the rumor, since she's unsure if it's better or worse than Cassie's [[UndignifiedDeath actual cause of death.]]]]
** [[spoiler: Lia nearly dies towards the end, in part due to an overdose of sleeping meds.]]


Added DiffLines:

* UndignifiedDeath: [[spoiler: Cassie.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Catch22Dilemma: Lia notes this as she tricks her family into thinking she's in recovery. Though Lia does manage to fool a few people, she secretly hates herself even more for having to resort to more and more lying. So Lia avoids eating to stop feeling depressed, but she's depressed because she avoids eating.

Removed: 145

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The page is being cut per TRS.


* BiTheWay: Lia twice reflects that she could see herself with either a boy or a girl, and doesn't dwell at all on how to classify her sexuality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LastDisrespects: Some of the yearbook staff who believe the rumors that Cassie died of a heroin overdose want her memorial to be a tiny quarter panel in the back of the book, with the local hardware store, insurance agency, and florist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DaintyLittleBalletDancers: Lia is a former ballet dancer with a small, waifish figure.

to:

* DaintyLittleBalletDancers: Lia is a former ballet dancer with who has always had a small, waifish figure.figure even before her bout with anorexia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnmityWithAnObject: Lia hates the bathroom scale she has to weigh herself on every Tuesday to prove to her family that she's gaining weight, calling it the "Blubber-O-Meter 3000". She tampers with it to make it look like she weighs more than she actually does, while keeping track of her real weight using an undamaged scale in her room.

to:

* EnmityWithAnObject: Lia hates the bathroom scale she has to weigh herself on every Tuesday to prove to her family that she's gaining weight, calling it the "Blubber-O-Meter 3000". She tampers with it to make it look like she weighs more than she actually does, while privately keeping track of her real weight using an undamaged scale in her room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnmityWithAnObject: Lia hates the bathroom scale she has to weigh herself on every Tuesday to prove to her family that she's gaining weight, calling it the "Blubber-O-Meter 3000". She tampers with it to make it look like she weighs more than she actually does, while keeping track of her real weight using an undamaged scale in her room.

Added: 247

Changed: 109

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RuleOfThree: [[spoiler:Lia is admitted a total of three separate times to New Seasons, a clinic for girls with eating disorders. Her third stay is when she actually tries to get help, cooperate with the doctors, and put her life back together.]]



* ShipTease: Lia and Elijah have a little but it doesn't really amount to anything.

to:

* ShipTease: Lia and Elijah have a little little, but it doesn't really amount to anything.anything because Lia is ''really'' not in a position in her life where she has time or energy to think about romance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SleepyHead: One consequence of Lia's anorexia is having zero energy because of how little she eats. She spends much of her time at school sleeping in the nurse's office.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ObsessedWithFood: Lia, though in her case she's obsessed with avoiding it, eating as little calories as possible, and trying to force herself to stop thinking about being constantly hungry.

to:

* ObsessedWithFood: Lia, though in her case the usual spirit of the trope is inverted because she's obsessed with avoiding it, ''avoiding'' food rather than eating it. In her case, she's eating as little calories as possible, she possibly can and constantly trying to force herself to stop thinking about being constantly hungry.hungry all the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DaintyLittleBalletDancers: Lia is a former ballet dancer with a small, waifish figure.

Top