Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / JohnPutnamThatcher

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCreon: In ''Ashes to Ashes'', after the head of the Flensburg Parents League community activist group is murdered, two of his main lieutenants display this in different ways: Mary Foster, the organizing genius of the group, declines to step up while Bob Hovarth is shocked to be nominated and feels that Mary is the natural choice. Bob only accepts the job after realizing that Mary's reluctance may be out of fear that she'd be the next victim that it would be cowardly of him to assume a risk he is better prepared to fight than Mary. [[spoiler:Actually, it turns out that Mary is the killer and is simply trying to stay BeneathSuspicion, which would fail if she was openly deciding the group's agenda (which she is manipulating to prompt a real estate selling spree so she can buy local buildings cheaply).]]

Added: 281

Changed: 158

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IRememberBecause: In ''Going for the Gold,'' Thatcher questions how an extremely busy salesgirl can remember a transaction involving a fake check five days after it happened.

to:

* IRememberBecause: IRememberBecause:
** In ''Come to Dust'', a witness to a hit-and-run remembers three digits of the license plate because they match his own.
**
In ''Going for the Gold,'' Thatcher questions how an extremely busy salesgirl can remember a transaction involving a fake check five days after it happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheSociopath: Robert Schneider, the murder victim in ''Banking on Death'', is a man who seems incapable of love, courtesy, or consideration for other people's feelings, with perhaps a few exceptions like his parents and aunt but pointedly not his own sons, who he never bothered to ask his estranged wife about in letters or even take a few seconds to look down at the older boy in his cradle while coming home from work every day. He also lacks any social grace and is obsessed with his ambitions, [[spoiler:with the murderer saying he was driven into a homicidal rage when Robert excitedly began talking to himself about a business coup that would enrich him and ruin his visitor/estranged cousin's family-owned company while acting as if the other man wasn't even there.]]
--> '''[[spoiler:Arthur Schneider]]''': [H]e just didn't notice my existence at all; I just wasn't important enough to his plans for him to pretend, even though [[spoiler:he was planning to ruin me and my family.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added linking


A long running mystery series about an investment banker/amateur detective, written by Emma Lathen (a pseudonym for co-authors Mary Jane Latsis and Martha Hennisart).

to:

A long running mystery series about an investment banker/amateur detective, written by Emma Lathen Creator/EmmaLathen (a pseudonym for co-authors Mary Jane Latsis and Martha Hennisart).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Thatcher:'' [[spoiler:Ralph]] was not born to be a criminal. He was an accidental one if there ever was one.

to:

--> '''Thatcher:'' '''Thatcher:''' [[spoiler:Ralph]] was not born to be a criminal. He was an accidental one if there ever was one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThePerryMasonMethod: A civil-case version in ''Brewing Up a Storm''. A brewery is being sued in the DrunkDriver death of an intoxicated nineteen year old - the brewery's new non-alcoholic beer is being packaged just like their flagship regular brand, the plaintiff is claiming the nineteen year old wouldn't have gotten drunk in the first place if the brewery hadn't "put him in training" with the non-alcoholic stuff. Paul Jackson gets the witness he's cross-examining to use that phrasing in court, then starts pulling out evidence the kid had a record of drunk-driving and being suspended from school for drinking long before that non-alcoholic beer ever hit the market.

Added: 186

Removed: 311

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
rich idiot with no day job was disambiguated by TRS. Moving examples to proper tropes. https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=16723903170.78923100&


* RichIdiotWithNoDayJob: Averted for Thatcher himself. He is a hard worker, and expects the same of his subordinates. Played straight for bank president Bradford Withers, who appears to see his job as a collection of social contacts. On the rare occasion when Withers takes an active role, something goes wrong.


Added DiffLines:

* UpperClassTwit: Bank president Bradford Withers appears to see his job as a collection of social contacts. On the rare occasion when Withers takes an active role, something goes wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MinorMajorCharacter: Francis Devane is a partner at a bank which frequently partners with the Sloan for plot-relevant business deals, but his partner and polar opposite Tom Robichaux is always the one to interact with Thatcher and relay Devane's opinions about business deals or suspects in their social circle. The only book Devane physically appears in is ''Death Shall Overcome'', where he attends the party where the murder takes place. Even then, he doesn't talk with any of the main characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Public relations official Lincoln Hauser (who appears in the second and fourth books) views himself as an ingenious spin doctor who needs a good challenge, when he is really a dense man whose efforts are either completely unnecessary, threaten to make things look worse than they are, or are being manipulated by a villain.


Added DiffLines:

** In ''Brewing up a Storm'', Madeline Underwood views herself as an inspiring visionary and the cornerstone of the DryCrusader moment. Almost everyone else views her as TheMillstone, a KnowNothingKnowItAll, or both.
** In ''A Shark out of Water'', Stefan Zabriski views himself as a BadassBureaucrat and the OnlySaneMan of the trade organization he works for. Any attempts to get through to him about his poor staffing procedures and inability to be impartial toward various shipping tycoons get an IRejectYourReality reception.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> ''Rarely had a charitable impulse been more untimely. And, though Thatcher, it wasn't as if [[spoiler:Curtis Yeoman]] had so many.''

to:

--> ''Rarely had a charitable impulse been more untimely. And, though thought Thatcher, it wasn't as if [[spoiler:Curtis Yeoman]] had so many.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllForNothing: The villain from ''[[spoiler:Murder Without Icing]]'' commits two murders to delay [[spoiler:his creditors seizing assets that he needs for an upcoming business deal that he believes will keep him from going bankrupt. The business deal is a scam, so committing the murders wouldn't have done a thing to persevere his company and reputation, even if he hadn't been exposed as a killer.]]





Added DiffLines:

* SpringtimeForHitler: A passive version appears in ''Murder Without Icing''. [[spoiler:Unsuccessful entrepreneur Winthrop Holland tries to hide from his creditors by hanging around a losing hockey team that he owns a piece of, certain this will keep him below the radar. Then the team starts winning and he ends up being regularly mentioned in the sports pages of papers that some of his creditors read.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In many books, John exposing the killer will further the Sloan's financial purposes and can be seen as EnlightenedSelfInterest. However, there are other books, such as ''[[spoiler:The Longer the Thread]]'' and ''[[spoiler:Murder Without Icing]]'' where exposing the killer will cause the Sloan financial ''difficulties'' and/or send someone John likes to prison for murder. In those cases, Thatcher could easily keep quiet and do nothing, but he still tells the police what he knows and ensures the killer won't escape justice.

to:

** In many books, John exposing the killer will further the Sloan's financial purposes and can be seen as EnlightenedSelfInterest. However, there are other books, such as ''[[spoiler:The Longer the Thread]]'' ''[[spoiler:By Hook or by Crook]]'' and ''[[spoiler:Murder Without Icing]]'' where exposing the killer will cause the Sloan financial ''difficulties'' and/or send someone John likes to prison for murder. In those cases, Thatcher could easily keep quiet and do nothing, but he still tells the police what he knows and ensures the killer won't escape justice.

Added: 1695

Changed: 1162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatYouAreInTheDark: This plays a major role in the BackStory of ''[[spoiler:By Hook or by Crook]].'' [[spoiler:Shortly before UsefulNotes/WorldWarII Haig Parajian [[DeadPersonImpersonation assumed the identity of his recently deceased brother Paul]] to save their business from going under (everything was in Paul's name). The rest of their family was trapped in Europe by the war and then spent years living in extreme poverty in a refugee camp. He could have easily left them for dead. Doing so would have reduced the risk that they'd recognize him as their uncle and not their father. Abandoning them would have also ensured that if his deception failed, the children, as Paul's legal heirs, would never take away the millions of dollars Haig made running the business. Instead, Haig tracked them down in 1948 at no small expense and then spent the next 30 years raising them as a loving father. His youngest nephew Greg (who feels that [[BecomingTheMask Haig truly became Paul]]) returns the favor in the denouement of the novel, destroying evidence of Haig's true identity when he could have used it to sue Haig's wife and (actual) son for their share of the family fortune.]]

to:

* WhatYouAreInTheDark: WhatYouAreInTheDark:
**
This plays a major role in the BackStory of ''[[spoiler:By Hook or by Crook]].'' [[spoiler:Shortly before UsefulNotes/WorldWarII Haig Parajian [[DeadPersonImpersonation assumed the identity of his recently deceased brother Paul]] to save their business from going under (everything was in Paul's name). The rest of their family was trapped in Europe by the war and then spent years living in extreme poverty in a refugee camp. He could have easily left them for dead. Doing so would have reduced the risk that they'd recognize him as their uncle and not their father. Abandoning them would have also ensured that if his deception failed, the children, as Paul's legal heirs, would never take away the millions of dollars Haig made running the business. Instead, Haig tracked them down in 1948 at no small expense and then spent the next 30 years raising them as a loving father. His youngest nephew Greg (who feels that [[BecomingTheMask Haig truly became Paul]]) returns the favor in the denouement of the novel, destroying evidence of Haig's true identity when he could have used it to sue Haig's wife and (actual) son for their share of the family fortune.]]


Added DiffLines:

** In many books, John exposing the killer will further the Sloan's financial purposes and can be seen as EnlightenedSelfInterest. However, there are other books, such as ''[[spoiler:The Longer the Thread]]'' and ''[[spoiler:Murder Without Icing]]'' where exposing the killer will cause the Sloan financial ''difficulties'' and/or send someone John likes to prison for murder. In those cases, Thatcher could easily keep quiet and do nothing, but he still tells the police what he knows and ensures the killer won't escape justice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IvyLeagueForEveryone: Pretty much everyone who holds a notable rank at the Sloan or one of its contemporary banks, brokerage houses, or big corporations went to either Harvard or Dartmouth. ''Come to Dust'' heavily features Dartmouth's admissions process and endowment system.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CompanyTown: In ''Sweet and Low'', Dreyer, New York changed its name (it used to be Roosendal, New York) decades ago to honor Leonard Dreyer, the founder of a famous chocolate factory that acts as the town's biggest employer and tourist attraction. Most of the townspeople are knowledgable about the cocoa market that Dreyer depends on. However, while the local officials are accommodating to the Dreyer executives, those executives don't really try to push them around. Thatcher also admits that the town is far nicer than most company towns due to the nature of the company and the generous spending of a trust that Leonard set up (Thatcher is one of the trustees).
--> ''Far from being a grimy company town, Dreyer boasted a superabundance of parks, fountains, and playing fields. All these amenities, Thatcher feared, were about to become his responsibility.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YourMakeupIsRunning: In ''Brewing Up a Storm,'' "tears and tissues" smear the makeup the victim's secretary is wearing when the police interview her. She only wears mascara on half of her face, making her smeared makeup more disconcerting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''Murder Makes the Wheels Go Round'';
*** Former Michigan Motors president Eberhart was directly involved in a multi-billion dollar price-fixing conspiracy in the BackStory. While he had to resign, he stayed out of jail due to lack of proof, the [=DOJ=] doesn't get that proof over the course of the novel, and Eberhart still holds a lot of influence and prestige within the company.
*** Chairman of the board Dennis French is complicit in the conspiracy at least to the extent that he's hiding evidence of Eberhart's involvement months later, and also refuses to fire the executives who did get convicted after their release from prison when every other auto company involved in the conspiracy fires its malefactors. French doesn't even suffer the minimal punishment Eberhart got, and comes out of the book with his job and reputation intact.
** While the main villain from ''When in Greece'' gets his just deserts, his circle of friends suffer nothing worse than the failure of their plan despite [[spoiler:plotting to overthrow the government, murder a political opponent, and nationalize a foreign business under a false pretext.]]


Added DiffLines:

* MeetCute: In ''Murder Makes the Wheels Go Round'', [=DOJ=] investigator F.X. Riley runs into Susan Price, the secretary of a man he arrested, at a dry cleaner. She accidentally overshoots her basket and dumps her laundry on his head. He hands her some lingerie that she dropped, and that she's embarrassed by due to it being slightly slinky. She points out to him that he forgot to take his clothing out of the machine due to being distracted by her and that his folding methods leave too many wrinkles. The chemistry is really sealed when she asks his full name and he reluctantly complies, with the two going on dates the next several nights.
--> '''Riley''' ''(stiffly)'' It is Fabian Xerxes. Father was a socialist.
--> '''Susan''': ''(giggling)'' I think it's a respectable name ... My name is Susan B. Anthony Price. Mother was a feminist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''Double, Double, Oil and Trouble'', Thatcher gives his summation to two executives who missed the media coverage of the arrest due to briefly-mentioned interesting problems of their own (a CEO preventing a hostile takeover and an accounting expert and college professor thwarting her university's efforts to push her into retirement in favor of an unseasoned up-and comer. Although, given the CEO's "famous tolerance for bribery", he could qualify as the VillainOfAnotherStory instead.





Added DiffLines:

* InsufferableGenius:
** Recurring character Paul Jackson is a celebrated attorney who is always supremely confident in his eventual victory. His skill in the courtroom is everything he implies it is.
** Scott Wenzel from ''Green Grow the Dollars'' is a self-absorbed botanist (albeit with some {{Morality Pet}}s) who thinks that he's miles ahead of his rivals and doesn't hesitate to mock them. [[spoiler:He has single-handedly outpaced the efforts of a big corporation by a wide margin and the people he's most contemptuous of are indeed incompetent and/or crooked.]]


Added DiffLines:

* SmallNameBigEgo: Dozens of people Thatcher deals with are arrogant but can't live up to their own expectations.
** Klaus Englehart from ''Double, Double, Oil, and Trouble'' is involved in the bidding for an oil pipeline. By everyone's account, he spends far more time bragging about how his proposal and his company are naturally superior than he does actually trying to conform to the client's needs.
** Craig Phibbs from ''Sweet and Low'' views himself as a genius filmmaker who brilliantly exposes greed, corruption, and sleaze in a way that enlightens and captures the public. While he does have his admirers and past successes, he's a patronizing, snide man who is too self-absorbed to realize that he has valuable evidence in a murder. He's also insulting and disrespectful toward people he wants to appear in his films, openly talking about how unflatteringly he'll portray them while expecting that they'll still be honored to accommodate him.
** Mitch Scovil from ''Something in the Air'' considers himself a blessedly lucky, brilliant, entrepreneur and is in total denial about how his plans for expansion are full of holes, while deriding the idea that anyone knows better than him.

Added: 695

Changed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* INeedAFreakingDrink: In ''Green Grow the Dollars'', when Gloria Vandam hears that her husband and several of his relatives are murder suspects, she suggests that they have some brandy before bed and makes it clear that it isn't just for her husband.

to:

* INeedAFreakingDrink: INeedAFreakingDrink:
**
In ''Green Grow the Dollars'', when Gloria Vandam hears that her husband and several of his relatives are murder suspects, she suggests that they have some brandy before bed and makes it clear that it isn't just for her husband.husband.
** Zigzagged in ''[[spoiler:Double, Double, Oil, and Trouble]]''. One of the directors of the company the mystery centers around orders a drink after hearing Thatcher's summation. Another executive gloomily reviews the company's woes and agrees a stiff drink is in order. His colleague admonishes him, going into a detailed analysis of how the situation is only bad in the short term, while the future looks bright. The alcohol is actually for a celebratory toast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeroOfAnotherStory:
** In ''Accounting for Murder'', NYPD accountant Fred Cohen has just wrapped up an investigation of a mobster who he helped get deported and casually mentions that he and his superior officer got shot at by a mobster during TheRoaringTwenties.
** Kate and Lorna, the archaeologists from ''When in Greece'', make some brief references to being part of the Greek Resistance in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* INeedAFreakingDrink: In ''Green Grow the Dollars'', when Gloria Vandam hears that her husband and several of his relatives are murder suspects, she suggests that they have some brandy before bed and makes it clear that it isn't just for her husband.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatYouAreInTheDark: This plays a major role in the BackStory of ''[[spoiler:By Hook or by Crook]].'' [[spoiler:Shortly before UsefulNotes/WorldWarII Haig Parajian [[DeadPersonImpersonation assumed the identity of his recently deceased brother Paul]] to save their business from going under (everything was in Paul's name). The rest of their family was trapped in Europe by the war and then spent years living in extreme poverty in a refugee camp. He could have easily left them for dead. Doing so would have reduced the risk that they'd recognize him as their uncle and not their father. Abandoning them would have also ensured that if his deception, the children, as Paul's legal heirs, would never take away the millions of dollars Haig made from his deception. Instead, Haig tracked them down at no small expense and then spent the next 30 years raising them as a loving father. His youngest nephew Greg (who feels that [[BecomingTheMask Haig truly became Paul]]) returns the favor in the denouement of the novel, destroying evidence of Haig's true identity when he could have used it to sue Haig's wife and (actual) son for their share of the family fortune.]]

to:

* WhatYouAreInTheDark: This plays a major role in the BackStory of ''[[spoiler:By Hook or by Crook]].'' [[spoiler:Shortly before UsefulNotes/WorldWarII Haig Parajian [[DeadPersonImpersonation assumed the identity of his recently deceased brother Paul]] to save their business from going under (everything was in Paul's name). The rest of their family was trapped in Europe by the war and then spent years living in extreme poverty in a refugee camp. He could have easily left them for dead. Doing so would have reduced the risk that they'd recognize him as their uncle and not their father. Abandoning them would have also ensured that if his deception, deception failed, the children, as Paul's legal heirs, would never take away the millions of dollars Haig made from his deception. running the business. Instead, Haig tracked them down in 1948 at no small expense and then spent the next 30 years raising them as a loving father. His youngest nephew Greg (who feels that [[BecomingTheMask Haig truly became Paul]]) returns the favor in the denouement of the novel, destroying evidence of Haig's true identity when he could have used it to sue Haig's wife and (actual) son for their share of the family fortune.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SecondPlaceIsForWinners: In ''Going for the Gold'', Olympic skier Dick Noyes comes in second to last in his event, but is perfectly content, as he sees qualifying in the first place as a sufficient achievement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ConfessToALesserCrime: In ''[[spoiler:Double, Double Oil and Trouble]]'', the exposed BigBad confesses to the bribery scheme that led to the murders (there's too much evidence to pretend otherwise) but denies committing the murders themselves, even as more evidence is uncovered. No one buys his story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: Downplayed in ''Sweet and Low''. When one character offers to get the murderer a lawyer, his SitComArchnemesis pounces on how the guy didn't extend ''him'' the same courtesy when he was WrongfullyAccused.
--> ''Rarely had a charitable impulse been more untimely. And, though Thatcher, it wasn't as if [[spoiler:Curtis Yeoman]] had so many.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrimeAfterCrime: In nearly all of the books, the villain engages in some illegal or unethical scheme to make money and/or preserve a certain status with no intention of killing anyone, but then commits murder to try and either avoid exposure or keep the plan from being derailed. The only exceptions are ''[[spoiler:Banking on Death]]'', where the murder is an unpremeditated crime of passion not related to any other crime and ''[[spoiler:When in Greece]]'', where the murder is ruthlessly premeditated and a key part of the villain's plan from the start.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DefectorFromCommieLand: A minor plot point in ''Going for the Gold'' has a figure skater at the Winter Olympics abruptly defect to the U.S. Unusually, her coaches and handlers don't try to stop her, or even care that much.

Top