Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 14 (click to see context) from:
* DressHitsFloor: Gallinger, having been waked late at night to recite Braxa the poem he wrote for her, suggests they go back (separately) to bed. This trope happens instead.
to:
* DressHitsFloor: Gallinger, having been waked woken up late at night to recite Braxa the poem he wrote for her, suggests they go back (separately) to bed. This trope happens instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 12 (click to see context) from:
* ApologeticAttacker: Gallinger has to fight his way into the temple. The guard explains that [[YouShallNotPass he must do his duty]], even he does not at all want to.
to:
* ApologeticAttacker: Gallinger has to fight his way into the temple. The guard explains that [[YouShallNotPass he must do his duty]], even though he does not at all want to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 14,18 (click to see context) from:
%%* DressHitsFloor: Braxa does this.
%%* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler: Gallinger, when it turns out Braxa never loved him.]]
%%* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
%%* FieryRedhead: Gallinger describes himself as looking like a poplar in autumn: tall, skinny, and red on top.
%%* TheIngenue: Braxa...[[spoiler: subverted. She's actually a FemmeFatale.]]
%%* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler: Gallinger, when it turns out Braxa never loved him.]]
%%* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
%%* FieryRedhead: Gallinger describes himself as looking like a poplar in autumn: tall, skinny, and red on top.
%%* TheIngenue: Braxa...[[spoiler: subverted. She's actually a FemmeFatale.]]
to:
%%*
* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler:
%%*
* FieryRedhead: Gallinger describes himself as looking like a poplar in autumn: tall, skinny, and red on
%%*
* GeniusBruiser: Gallinger is a genius linguist and writer who has also studied martial arts and can hold his own in a fight.
* TheIngenue:
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
%%* LadyInRed: Braxa, who also has red hair.
to:
Changed line(s) 29 (click to see context) from:
%%* WellDoneSonGuy:...Gallinger has Issues. Quite a lot of them.
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 25 (click to see context) from:
* NoNameGiven: Gallinger's first name is never mentioned.
to:
* NoNameGiven: NoFullNameGiven: Gallinger's first name is never mentioned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Commented out zces
%% Administrivia/ZeroContextExample entries are not allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out. Add context to the entries before uncommenting them.
Changed line(s) 12,16 (click to see context) from:
* DressHitsFloor: Braxa does this.
* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler: Gallinger, when it turns out Braxa never loved him.]]
* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
* FieryRedhead: Gallinger describes himself as looking like a poplar in autumn: tall, skinny, and red on top.
* TheIngenue: Braxa...[[spoiler: subverted. She's actually a FemmeFatale.]]
* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler: Gallinger, when it turns out Braxa never loved him.]]
* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
* FieryRedhead: Gallinger describes himself as looking like a poplar in autumn: tall, skinny, and red on top.
* TheIngenue: Braxa...[[spoiler: subverted. She's actually a FemmeFatale.]]
to:
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
* LadyInRed: Braxa, who also has red hair.
to:
Changed line(s) 27 (click to see context) from:
* WellDoneSonGuy:...Gallinger has Issues. Quite a lot of them.
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 7 (click to see context) from:
The story has been republished at least five times, in ''Magazine/VentureScienceFiction'' (The UK issue of April 1964), ''Literature/TenthAnnualEditionTheYearsBestSF'' (1965), ''Literature/ScienceFictionHallOfFameVolumeOne'' (1970), ''Literature/TheDoorsOfHisFaceTheLampsOfHisMouthAndOtherStories'' (1973), and ''Literature/IsaacAsimovPresentsTheGreatSFStories25 (1963)'' (1992).
to:
The story has been republished at least five times, in ''Magazine/VentureScienceFiction'' (The UK issue of April 1964), ''Literature/TenthAnnualEditionTheYearsBestSF'' (1965), ''Literature/ScienceFictionHallOfFameVolumeOne'' ''Literature/TheScienceFictionHallOfFameVolumeOne'' (1970), ''Literature/TheDoorsOfHisFaceTheLampsOfHisMouthAndOtherStories'' (1973), and ''Literature/IsaacAsimovPresentsTheGreatSFStories25 (1963)'' (1992).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed ymmv pothole
Changed line(s) 22 (click to see context) from:
* MalignedMixedMarriage: The Survey commander had one. [[TearJerker His wife died when he was deployed, and he never found out what happened to his children.]]--which is why he is willing to go to the bat for Gallinger.
to:
* MalignedMixedMarriage: The Survey commander had one. [[TearJerker His wife died when he was deployed, and he never found out what happened to his children.]]--which children, which is why he is willing to go to the bat for Gallinger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 7,8 (click to see context) from:
The story has been republished at least five times, in ''Magazine/VentureScienceFiction'' (The UK issue of April 1964), ''Literature/TenthAnnualEditionTheYearsBestSF'' (1965), ''Literature/ScienceFictionHallOfFameVolumeOne'' (1970), ''Literature/TheDoorsOfHisFaceTheLampsOfHisMouthAndOtherStories'' (1973), and ''Literature/IsaacAsimov resentsThe
GreatSFStories25 (1963)'' (1992).
GreatSFStories25 (1963)'' (1992).
to:
The story has been republished at least five times, in ''Magazine/VentureScienceFiction'' (The UK issue of April 1964), ''Literature/TenthAnnualEditionTheYearsBestSF'' (1965), ''Literature/ScienceFictionHallOfFameVolumeOne'' (1970), ''Literature/TheDoorsOfHisFaceTheLampsOfHisMouthAndOtherStories'' (1973), and ''Literature/IsaacAsimov resentsThe
GreatSFStories25''Literature/IsaacAsimovPresentsTheGreatSFStories25 (1963)'' (1992).
GreatSFStories25
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding Red Links to encourage more work pages.
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction short story by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in ''The Magazine Of Fantasy And ScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
to:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction short {{Novelette}} by Creator/RogerZelazny, first published in ''Magazine/TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction'' (November 1963 issue). It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
The storyby Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published
The story has been republished at least five times, inNovember 1963 in ''The Magazine Of Fantasy And ScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction. ''Magazine/VentureScienceFiction'' (The UK issue of April 1964), ''Literature/TenthAnnualEditionTheYearsBestSF'' (1965), ''Literature/ScienceFictionHallOfFameVolumeOne'' (1970), ''Literature/TheDoorsOfHisFaceTheLampsOfHisMouthAndOtherStories'' (1973), and ''Literature/IsaacAsimov resentsThe
GreatSFStories25 (1963)'' (1992).
The story
The story has been republished at least five times, in
GreatSFStories25 (1963)'' (1992).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction short story by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in ''Magazine/TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
to:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction short story by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in ''Magazine/TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction''.''The Magazine Of Fantasy And ScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
Added line(s) 8 (click to see context) :
* ApologeticAttacker: Gallinger has to fight his way into the temple. The guard explains that [[YouShallNotPass he must do his duty]], even he does not at all want to.
* ChoreographyPorn: Literary example. Braxa knows the sacred dances of their race...all 234 of them.
* DressHitsFloor: Braxa does this.
* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler: Gallinger, when it turns out Braxa never loved him.]]
* ChoreographyPorn: Literary example. Braxa knows the sacred dances of their race...all 234 of them.
* DressHitsFloor: Braxa does this.
* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler: Gallinger, when it turns out Braxa never loved him.]]
Added line(s) 8 (click to see context) :
* FieryRedhead: Gallinger describes himself as looking like a poplar in autumn: tall, skinny, and red on top.
* TheIngenue: Braxa...[[spoiler: subverted. She's actually a FemmeFatale.]]
* InsufferableGenius: Gallinger, who certainly knows he's a genius, and is pretty insufferable to most other people.
* KirkSummation: Gallinger gives one to the Martians to convince them that living and associating with humans isn't
* LadyInRed: Braxa, who also has red hair.
* TheIngenue: Braxa...[[spoiler: subverted. She's actually a FemmeFatale.]]
* InsufferableGenius: Gallinger, who certainly knows he's a genius, and is pretty insufferable to most other people.
* KirkSummation: Gallinger gives one to the Martians to convince them that living and associating with humans isn't
* LadyInRed: Braxa, who also has red hair.
Changed line(s) 8 (click to see context) from:
* MarsNeedsWomen: Treated quite soberly and gender-flipped. All male Martians and most females have become sterile, not long before humans visit their world. Unusual in that the female who has an affair with a human linguist didn't realize he could impregnate her, and because her lover then has to talk the other Martians out of their prior resignation to extinction. How often does Mars have to be ''convinced'' it needs women/men? [[spoiler:She knew/believed she would get pregnant, based on an ancient Martian prophecy describing how someone who met the description of her accomplishments (something about mastering "the 1,000 dances") would get pregnant by a man from Earth (who would convince the Martians to live) and thus save their species. She just hoped it wasn't true because she didn't love him back (but did her duty for her people) and, like most of the Martians, was resigned to the extinction of her people.]]
to:
* MarsNeedsWomen: Treated quite soberly and gender-flipped. All male Martians and most females have become sterile, not long before humans visit their world. Unusual in that the female who has an affair with a human linguist didn't realize he could impregnate her, and because her lover then has to talk the other Martians out of their prior resignation to extinction. How often does Mars have to be ''convinced'' it needs women/men? [[spoiler:She [[spoiler: She knew/believed she would get pregnant, based on an ancient Martian prophecy describing how someone who met the description of her accomplishments (something about mastering "the 1,000 dances") would get pregnant by a man from Earth (who would convince the Martians to live) and thus save their species. species, based on prophecy. She just hoped it wasn't true because she didn't love him back (but did her duty for her people) and, like most of the Martians, back.]]
* MalignedMixedMarriage: The Survey commander had one. [[TearJerker His wife died when he wasresigned deployed, and he never found out what happened to his children.]]--which is why he is willing to go to the extinction of her people.]]bat for Gallinger.
* MalignedMixedMarriage: The Survey commander had one. [[TearJerker His wife died when he was
Added DiffLines:
* PlanetaryRomance: Features a Mars of the "dead cities and dust-choked canals" type.
Added DiffLines:
* WellDoneSonGuy:...Gallinger has Issues. Quite a lot of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I checked; it's not a novelette. It won the Best Short Story Hugo.
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in ''Magazine/TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
to:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette short story by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in ''Magazine/TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* LiteraryAllusionTitle: Alluding to the Literature/BookOfEcclesiastes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
from trope page
Added DiffLines:
* MarsNeedsWomen: Treated quite soberly and gender-flipped. All male Martians and most females have become sterile, not long before humans visit their world. Unusual in that the female who has an affair with a human linguist didn't realize he could impregnate her, and because her lover then has to talk the other Martians out of their prior resignation to extinction. How often does Mars have to be ''convinced'' it needs women/men? [[spoiler:She knew/believed she would get pregnant, based on an ancient Martian prophecy describing how someone who met the description of her accomplishments (something about mastering "the 1,000 dances") would get pregnant by a man from Earth (who would convince the Martians to live) and thus save their species. She just hoped it wasn't true because she didn't love him back (but did her duty for her people) and, like most of the Martians, was resigned to the extinction of her people.]]
Added DiffLines:
* ScrewDestiny: The protagonist is studying the dying Martian culture, which is in slow decline since a mysterious catastrophe has rendered the population sterile. The Martians, following the predictions of an ancient prophet, believe this to be inevitable and make no effort to stop it. When the protagonist [[spoiler:discovers that his local lover, whom he impregnated (proving that the sterility problem can be fixed), is about to terminate because of this]], he bursts into the main temple and carries a blasphemous sermon, claiming that the greatness of humankind stems from our ability to ignore our own prophets of doom and carry on anyway. [[spoiler:It works, but is still subverted: he was actually fulfilling ''another'' prophecy about a man from space who will save Mars.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 2 (click to see context) from:
[[caption-width-right:350:]]"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in ''Magazine/TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
to:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in ''Magazine/TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 2 (click to see context) from:
[[caption-width-right:350:]]"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction. It was nominated for the 1964 Hugo Award for Short Fiction.
to:
[[caption-width-right:350:]]"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction. ''Magazine/TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction''. It was nominated for the 1964 Hugo Award UsefulNotes/HugoAward for Short Fiction.
Changed line(s) 4 (click to see context) from:
!!"A Rose For Ecclesiastes" contains Examples of:
to:
!!"A Rose For Ecclesiastes" contains Examples examples of:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1 (click to see context) from:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction. It was nominated for the 1964 Hugo Award for Short Fiction.
to:
[[caption-width-right:350:]]"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction. It was nominated for the 1964 Hugo Award for Short Fiction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 4 (click to see context) :
Changed line(s) 7 (click to see context) from:
* OnlyYouCanRepopulateMyRace: Gallinger fell in love with a woman of the dying Martian race; he doesn't learn until afterwards that the whole thing was this trope and that the woman was not happy about having to sleep with him (each of them fulfilled a described role in a Martian prophecy about the only way to save their race, even her not being in love with him was part of it).
to:
* OnlyYouCanRepopulateMyRace: Gallinger fell in love with a woman of the dying Martian race; he doesn't learn until afterwards that the whole thing was this trope and that the woman was not happy about having to sleep with him (each of them fulfilled a described role in a Martian prophecy about the only way to save their race, even her not being in love with him was part of it).it).
----
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5,6 (click to see context) from:
* OnlyYouCanRepopulateMyRace: Gallinger fell in love with a woman of the dying Martian race; he doesn't learn until afterwards that the whole thing was this trope and that the woman was not happy about having to sleep with him (each of them fulfilled a described role in a Martian prophecy about the only way to save their race, even her not being in love with him was part of it).
* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
to:
* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
*NoNameGiven: Gallinger's first name is never mentioned.
* OnlyYouCanRepopulateMyRace: Gallinger fell in love with a woman of the dying Martian race; he doesn't learn until afterwards that the whole thing was this trope and that the woman was not happy about having to sleep with him (each of them fulfilled a described role in a Martian prophecy about the only way to save their race, even her not being in love with him was part ofit).
* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].it).
*NoNameGiven: Gallinger's first name is never mentioned.
* OnlyYouCanRepopulateMyRace: Gallinger fell in love with a woman of the dying Martian race; he doesn't learn until afterwards that the whole thing was this trope and that the woman was not happy about having to sleep with him (each of them fulfilled a described role in a Martian prophecy about the only way to save their race, even her not being in love with him was part of
* DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
OnlyYouCanRepopulateMyRace: Gallinger fell in love with a woman of the dying Martian race; he doesn't learn until afterwards that the whole thing was this trope and that the woman was not happy about having to sleep with him (each of them fulfilled a described role in a Martian prophecy about the only way to save their race, even her not being in love with him was part of it).
to:
*DyingRace: [[spoiler:The Martians]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1 (click to see context) from:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars.
to:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars.Mars in the near future. In it, a linguist and poet named Gallinger is chosen by the reclusive Martians as the first human to learn about their society. The story follows his attempts to understand their alien culture,and explore the mystery of their past. It was first published in November 1963 in TheMagazineOfFantasyAndScienceFiction. It was nominated for the 1964 Hugo Award for Short Fiction.
----
!!"A Rose For Ecclesiastes" contains Examples of:
OnlyYouCanRepopulateMyRace: Gallinger fell in love with a woman of the dying Martian race; he doesn't learn until afterwards that the whole thing was this trope and that the woman was not happy about having to sleep with him (each of them fulfilled a described role in a Martian prophecy about the only way to save their race, even her not being in love with him was part of it).
----
!!"A Rose For Ecclesiastes" contains Examples of:
OnlyYouCanRepopulateMyRace: Gallinger fell in love with a woman of the dying Martian race; he doesn't learn until afterwards that the whole thing was this trope and that the woman was not happy about having to sleep with him (each of them fulfilled a described role in a Martian prophecy about the only way to save their race, even her not being in love with him was part of it).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
"A Rose for Ecclesiastes" is a ScienceFiction novelette by Creator/RogerZelazny. It takes place on Mars.