Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Robocop2014

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Robocop vs Robot performance]]
* Why do Maddox and the CEO make such a huge deal about Murphy's performance being slightly lower than the robot in the same situation? Those robots are illegal to deploy within the States, so from a market perspective this comparison is a moot point. Omnicorp is not trying to sell Robocop based on the performance, but the human element.

Added: 11

Changed: 211

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because that would piss him off. Remember his reaction when he found out he was a cyborg? He '''freaked out'''. What do you think would happen if he realized that he was being flat out mind controlled?[[/folder]]

to:

** Because that would piss him off. Remember his reaction when he found out he was a cyborg? He '''freaked out'''. What do you think would happen if he realized that he was being flat out mind controlled?[[/folder]]
controlled?
** depends on how they PHRASE it. of COURSE he'd freak at being told he's being mind controlled, but selling it as a reflex booster package or something similar... (which isnt THAT far from the truth)
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Facial skin is ''not'' like the rest. That's why facial skin graft recipients take a dip right into the abyss of the Uncanny Valley.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** "Non-lethal" has become a bit of a misnomer in many such weapons in real life; the term now is "less lethal" reflecting the fact that it's not perfectly nonlethal. It still has a far less chance of lethality than a bullet, however.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Likely even MORE inline recall how the Redtags are told NOT to shoot or get out of line, just in case. Guess what Sellars does? Threaten two unarmed civilians. Likely the program weakened AND Alex resolved more because Sellars went from unthreatening asset of the highest priority to threatening criminal to civilians.

to:

*** Likely even MORE inline recall how the Redtags are told NOT to shoot or get out of line, just in case. Guess what Sellars does? Threaten two unarmed civilians. Likely the program weakened AND Alex resolved more because Sellars went from unthreatening asset of the highest priority to threatening criminal to violent crime on civilians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Tasers have killed people in real life, and so have blanks for that matter- So a bullet that slams into someone and then shocks them has two ways it could kill someone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* why not keep Alex's other organs? They seemed to be intact after the bomb and this would simplify his care requirements significantly, allowing his to eat normal food and making the nightly blood transfer unnecessary. Just chuck in a couple of waste bags and change those nightly.
* If you think about it, it's effectively another leash they have on Murphy. The old Robo was more or less autonomous and could wander off to do his own thing for extended lenghts of time, but this Robo has to return every night for his blood cleanup and nutrient dose, or he will die.

to:

* why Why not keep Alex's other organs? They seemed to be intact after the bomb and this would simplify his care requirements significantly, allowing his to eat normal food and making the nightly blood transfer unnecessary. Just chuck in a couple of waste bags and change those nightly.
* ** If you think about it, it's effectively another leash they have on Murphy. The old Robo was more or less autonomous and could wander off to do his own thing for extended lenghts of time, but this Robo has to return every night for his blood cleanup and nutrient dose, or he will die.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Tasers]]
* If the reason that the US doesn't want police robots is because they use guns, why not just give them all the taser gun that Murphy has? That seemed to work just fine when it came to incapacitating people without killing them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Likely even MORE inline recall how the Redtags are told NOT to shoot or get out of line, just in case. Guess what Sellars does? Threaten two unarmed civilians. Likely the program weakened AND Alex resolved more because Sellars went from unthreatening asset of the highest priority to threatening criminal to civilians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***It's probably cheaper to build robot limbs than to clone new ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* If you think about it, it's effectively another leash they have on Murphy. The old Robo was more or less autonomous and could wander off to do his own thing for extended lenghts of time, but this Robo has to return every night for his blood cleanup and nutrient dose, or he will die.


Added DiffLines:

** Much like the original ED-209, these robots are military hardware, literally tanks with legs, employed to police civilians. It's possible that it's programming didn't include a way for the robot to assess that a knife holds a different kind of threat than of a gun or a bomb, simply because it wasn't meant to ever go against non-combatants, and Omni simply doesn't care .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It could have thought the knife was a 'Threat' to other people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** 'Threats' in this case are dangers to its human controllers and the red assets. It also highlights why robots are not always the best way to handle situations like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because that would piss him off. Remember his reaction when he found out he was a cyborg? He '''freaked out'''. What do you think would happen if he realized that he was being flat out mind controlled?

to:

** Because that would piss him off. Remember his reaction when he found out he was a cyborg? He '''freaked out'''. What do you think would happen if he realized that he was being flat out mind controlled?
controlled?[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: disproportionate force]]
* Why did the EM-209 gun down the Iranian kid in the opening for holding a knife? Why would the programmers consider a knife to be a threat to a robot?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because that would piss him off. Remember his reaction when he found out he was a cyborg? He '''freaked out'''. What do you think would happen if he realized that he was being flat out mind controlled?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rather than have the computer take over "and he won't know the difference" why not ''tell Murphy'' about this aspect and that they can reverse it if it doesn't work out? He's already aware he's half machine anyway.

to:

* Rather than have the computer take over "and he won't know the difference" why not ''tell Murphy'' about this aspect and that they can reverse it if it doesn't work out? He's already aware he's half machine anyway. Heck, he's not at all surprised when they upload the whole police database into his brain - he knows there's computers in there and some back-and-forth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Why not clue him in?]]
*Rather than have the computer take over "and he won't know the difference" why not ''tell Murphy'' about this aspect and that they can reverse it if it doesn't work out? He's already aware he's half machine anyway.

Added: 115

Changed: 103

Removed: 113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** One of the cut scenes reveals that Sellars asked Norton to save Murphy's right hand for the sake of handshakes.



* There is also the fact the hand probably would work properly, given how much hand function depends on tendons in the arm.
* One of the cut scenes reveals that Sellars asked Norton to save Murphy's right hand for the sake of handshakes.

to:

* There is also the fact the hand probably would requires a ton of technobabble to explain how it can work properly, given how much hand function depends on without the tendons in the arm.
* One of the cut scenes reveals that Sellars asked Norton to save Murphy's right hand for the sake of handshakes.
arm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the cut scenes reveals that Sellars asked Norton to save Murphy's right hand for the sake of handshakes.



[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There is also the fact the hand probably would work properly, given how much hand function depends on tendons in the arm.



[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]][[/folder]]

[[folder: All the other organs]]
* why not keep Alex's other organs? They seemed to be intact after the bomb and this would simplify his care requirements significantly, allowing his to eat normal food and making the nightly blood transfer unnecessary. Just chuck in a couple of waste bags and change those nightly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Notice that when Murphy goes to shake Maddox's hand he offers him his left (robotic) one. in a subtle "Fuck you too."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Also it's Murphy's right hand (that is, the one you shake with) with represents the bridge between man and machine.

to:

*** Also it's Murphy's right hand (that is, the one you shake with) with which represents the bridge between man and machine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also it's kind of the point. As pointed out on the main page unbiased robots controlled but highly biased creators is an allegory for lawmakers exempting themselves from the rules they create.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Also it's Murphy's right hand (that is, the one you shake with) with represents the bridge between man and machine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The droids are maneuvering him towards Maddox because only his gun is powerful enough to take Murphy out. So yeah, the test was pretty biased. On the other hand it is also a pretty good benchmark, if Maddox (who ''is'' just a guy in a suit) can take out their top-of-the-line cyborg then what's the point of him tactically in the first place?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's established in the movie that whenever Robo's visor is down for combat situations, the software takes over and Murphy's brain has no actual input on what's going on. In that case, why was Robocop so much better while fighting the Omnicorp drones? Under such conditions, He would be operating as he was yet another robot.

to:

* It's established in the movie that whenever Robo's visor is down for combat situations, the software takes over and Murphy's brain has no actual input on what's going on. In that case, why was Robocop so much better while fighting the Omnicorp [=OmniCorp=] drones? Under such conditions, He would be operating as he was yet another robot.



** also kind of WMG but Norton was literally in Murphy's head at the time perhaps he added some additional hardware to Murphy's subconscious to get the software to shave off those few seconds that everyone worried about.

to:

** also Also kind of WMG but Norton was literally in Murphy's head at the time perhaps he added some additional hardware to Murphy's subconscious to get the software to shave off those few seconds that everyone worried about.



** They also don't have access to the processing power needed to sort and cross-reference all that data. The police would have whatever government funding could get for them, and whatever that is is probably long since obsolete. Robocop has the bleeding edge technology from OmniCorp. It's almost literally the difference between your couple years old desktop versus a supercomputer.

to:

** They also don't have access to the processing power needed to sort and cross-reference all that data. The police would have whatever government funding could get for them, and whatever that is is probably long since obsolete. Robocop has the bleeding edge technology from OmniCorp.[=OmniCorp=]. It's almost literally the difference between your couple years old desktop versus a supercomputer.



* OmniCorp surely can't have their products turned against them and those who they do business with (e.g criminals, politicians), can they? Robocop's "Priority" on solving cases is a subtle example; its true purpose is to keep him away from cases that might damage OmniCorp's interests. This stand point is, astonishingly, never even mentioned in the whole movie. Senator Dreyfus, in what little screen time he has to oppose mechanized crime control, keeps blabbering about the "human factor" and whatnot, while ignoring this obvious flaw.
** Well, consider that in this continuity, Omni is a lot cleaner than OCP was. Dick Jones' goals were A) turn Detroit into an even worse hellhole by any means necessary (which included having a psychotic gang leader on his payroll) so the company could buy the city cheap, screwing everybody in the processe, and B) selling to the goverment a highly defective military product. Sellars only became a card-carrying villain towards the end of the movie, and his initial goals were to simply sell a good, efficient product to the goverment. He doesn't even have any contact with the equivalent to Clarence Boddiker in the reboot. Seeing that OmniCorp finances an expensive research on advanced prosthetics, odds are they are villains with good publicity, so if a Senator suddendly put in question their motives and suggested stuff like that without any base, it would be damaging to his argument.

to:

* OmniCorp [=OmniCorp=] surely can't have their products turned against them and those who they do business with (e.g criminals, politicians), can they? Robocop's "Priority" on solving cases is a subtle example; its true purpose is to keep him away from cases that might damage OmniCorp's [=OmniCorp=]'s interests. This stand point is, astonishingly, never even mentioned in the whole movie. Senator Dreyfus, in what little screen time he has to oppose mechanized crime control, keeps blabbering about the "human factor" and whatnot, while ignoring this obvious flaw.
** Well, consider that in this continuity, Omni is a lot cleaner than OCP was. Dick Jones' goals were A) turn Detroit into an even worse hellhole by any means necessary (which included having a psychotic gang leader on his payroll) so the company could buy the city cheap, screwing everybody in the processe, process, and B) selling to the goverment government a highly defective military product. Sellars only became a card-carrying villain towards the end of the movie, and his initial goals were to simply sell a good, efficient product to the goverment.government. He doesn't even have any contact with the equivalent to Clarence Boddiker in the reboot. Seeing that OmniCorp [=OmniCorp=] finances an expensive research on advanced prosthetics, odds are they are villains with good publicity, so if a Senator suddendly suddenly put in question their motives and suggested stuff like that without any base, it would be damaging to his argument.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Robocop is a PR stunt, so the hand probably was left there to give him a bit more of a symbolic human touch, that the finger pulling the trigger is human, not robotic. I do agree that it was odd to see such detail left untouched, a couple of lines of dialogue addresing it would have been enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, consider that in this continuity, Omni is a lot cleaner than OCP was. Dick Jones' goals were A) turn Detroit into an even worse hellhole by any means necessary (which included having a psychotic gang leader on his payroll) so the company could buy the city cheap, screwing everybody in the processe, and B) selling to the goverment a highly defective military product. Sellars only became a card-carrying villain towards the end of the movie, and his initial goals were to simply sell a good, efficient product to the goverment. He doesn't even have any contact with the equivalent to Clarence Boddiker in the reboot. Seeing that OmniCorp finances an expensive research on advanced prosthetics, odds are they are villains with good publicity, so if a Senator suddendly put in question their motives and suggested stuff like that without any base, it would be damaging to his argument.

Top