Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Psych

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Scam artists not knowing who's after them in "Christmas Joy"]]
* The episode's plot kicks off because "Santa" got arrested for getting into a fight while on duty. Later, it turns out "Santa" is a con man, the man who attacked him is a former partner he turned against, and is now out to kill him and his partner (and succeeds in killing the latter, resulting in the con man turning himself in.) Well, then why did the episode still need Shawn and Jules to go through the con-man's records to find out who the killer was? The "Santa" had already turned himself in by that point to save himself from an unknown killer, the flashbacks show he almost certainly saw his attacker's face, and who else does he think killed his partner besides the former partner they both betrayed and attacked him less than 24 hours ago?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Why wasn't Betty killed instead of or along with Bianca in "Scary Sherry: Bianca's Toast?"]]
* Sure, Alice had reason to hate Bianca, but her spying showed her that Betty was just as complicit in Doreen's death as Bianca and was less remorseful. Nonetheless, Alice spends days tormenting Bianca before killing her (and then trying to kill undercover new sorority member Jules despite her having only arrived after Doreen died). Even if she was planning to kill Betty before she got arrested, it seems odd that she left Betty alone with her ScoobyDooHoax while putting Bianca through borderline mental torture before killing her.
[[/folder]]

[[folder:How was Lucy able to contort her body so well without training in "The Devil's in the Details...And the Upstairs Bedroom"?]]
* Her mother specifically says that Lucy has no experience with yoga or gymnastics, and an internet search suggests it would take weeks to master those moves. It would be deliciously ironic if she really was possessed by a demon the one time Shawn is a completely inflexible AgentScully, only with her possession causing her to commit the crimes against poor Agatha rather than beginning after Agatha died.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The only confirmed change Shawn made from what really happened (aside from the songs, presumably) is an oil lamp being used for the FieryCoverUp of the critic's murder. Is it possible that that's the extent of his artistic license, or is the whole event only VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory? I personally felt that Z was a little too mellow after reading the script for a man who had really lost his girlfriend in addition to being re-institutionalized.

to:

* The only confirmed change Shawn made from what really happened (aside from the songs, presumably) is an oil lamp being used for the FieryCoverUp of the critic's murder. Is it possible that that's the extent of his artistic license, or is the whole event only VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory? I personally felt that Z was a little too mellow after reading the script for a man who had really lost the love of his girlfriend life in addition to being re-institutionalized.re-institutionalized and having the play he wrote possibly ruined for a second time.

Added: 549

Changed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:How was Shawn planning to explain away having a number admitting he fakes his visions for the musical he wrote?]]

to:

[[folder:How was Shawn planning to explain away having a number admitting he fakes his visions for the musical he wrote?]]wrote in ''Psych the Musical''?]]


Added DiffLines:


[[folder:What parts of ''Psych the Musical'' is Shawn most likely to have made up?]]
* The only confirmed change Shawn made from what really happened (aside from the songs, presumably) is an oil lamp being used for the FieryCoverUp of the critic's murder. Is it possible that that's the extent of his artistic license, or is the whole event only VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory? I personally felt that Z was a little too mellow after reading the script for a man who had really lost his girlfriend in addition to being re-institutionalized.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:What was the deal with how the car was stolen twice in "Shawn and Gus in Drag... Racing" (5x5)?]]
Shawn says the victim stole the car to gain some kind of leverage over Tommy, but the original owner of the car says he hired the victim to steal it back. On a related note: What kept the owner from reporting the theft to the police?
[[/folder]]

[[folder:Why was the first (shown) victim killed in "There Might be Blood" (3x6)?]]
Shawn does a SherlockScan that shows that guy murdered the geologist to keep him from exposing how the oil rig was drilling on a fault line. So why would the killer then murder that guy to protect that same secret when he was already invested in keeping it? Was the killing to silence a man who knew too much or out of anger and fear toward the guy after he killed the geologist? As funny as that episode is, the ending makes very little sense to me.
[[/folder]]

[[folder:How was Shawn planning to explain away having a number admitting he fakes his visions for the musical he wrote?]]
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The riddle to Juliet's location was also incredibly simple. It took Gus, Vick, Henry, and Lassiter all of fifteen seconds to solve it--Shawn could have cracked it instantly. Juliet probably knew Shawn didn't need any help finding her, but he might not know that there was still time to get to Abigail. She chose to give him information he didn't have rather than the solution to a riddle that he didn't need help with anyway.

Added: 232

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Have not seen the episode but,speaking as someone who come from a family where ADD and ADHD is not uncommon, I can assure you not everyone reacts the same way on medication. in fact, in some people, medication can make their symptoms worse depending.

to:

* Have not seen the episode but,speaking but, speaking as someone who come from a family where ADD and ADHD is not uncommon, I can assure you not everyone reacts the same way on medication. in fact, in some people, medication can make their symptoms worse depending.


Added DiffLines:

*** It hasn't been officially established as far as I know, but if I remember correctly, James Roday Rodriguez has ADHD and he said himself he played Shawn as though he had ADHD. So still not outright confirmation, but close enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Central Kentuckian (horse capital of the world) here: Betting on horses is legally not considered gambling. It is called "parimutuel wagering," in which the pot is split among all winning bets. Wagerers are betting against each other, not against the house, which is why it's legal in the US even though most forms of sports gambling are (as of now still) illegal. The "house always wins" concept doesn't exist in horse betting, and therefore Henry's lesson doesn't apply. Simple matter of definition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's HandWaved in the pilot: if he doesn't prove ''immediately'' how he provided all that info, he's going to jail. And now he's claimed he's psychic, so he can't stop because reason reason reason go to jail.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A seventh season episode confirms that Juliet really did believe Shawn was psychic and was terribly hurt to learn he'd been lying to her for six and a half years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There are a couple of vaguely supernatural elements that turn up in later episodes. After Mary Lightly's death, he appears to escort Yang into the afterlife, and Lassiter's hallucinations of his father in the second movie are presented as MaybeMagicMaybeMundane. It seems actual supernatural phenomena are extremely rare and subtle in the show's universe, but not completely absent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut per this thread.


[[folder: Why does the Psych fandom think the Psych slashers are racist?]]
* I've seen a lot of people believing the Psych slashers to be racist just because Shassie is more popular than Gus/Shawn. It isn't racist- it's just normal. In practically every fandom I've seen to date, slash between rivals is more popular than slash between friends. Personally, I think that there's a normal amount of Gus/Shawn slash...
** There's a good part of every fandom and a bad part of each fandom, this applies to every fandom and if you say 'not my fandom!' you're probably part of the bad part. It's honestly not that racist unless you say "You can't ship Gawn because Gus is black!". That is racist. What's not racist is "I like Shassie more than Gawn because I think they have better chemistry." TL;DR: It's probably due to a misunderstanding of racism.
** The main argument as I understand it is that slashers generally ship male characters at the drop of a hat, for little or no reason, even if the two characters are [[{{Series/Supernatural}} biologically related]]. Considering the closeness and chemistry between the two leads, and the AmbiguouslyBi tendencies of Shawn, the lack of shipping between the two is suspicious. You see similar arguments with [[Film/IronMan Tony Stark and James Rhodes]].
** What people choose to ignore is that, often, what is called "preference" is the product of lots of social factors. It's not uncommon for people who believe that they hold no racial biases to have very deep-running subconscious ones. As stated, shippers are not above taking a single line or even 3 seconds worth of on-camera posture and building elaborate headcanon around it. People who question Shassie shippers are probably noticing that there's TONS more to work with that is directly handed to you by the writers of show, yet a more popular pairing is made out of a fraction of in-universe material. Canon gives you a ship that's pretty much on par with [[Series/TheMightyBoosh Howard and Vince]] or [[Series/{{Misfits}} Nathan and Simon]]... and fans walk away trying to make Vince and Dixon happen. There could be a variety of reasons for this, but to deny that a level of racism is possible is... naive. It's overtly happened in many fandoms and is sure to happen in many more.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I know the outside answer is: 1. RuleOfFunny to allow James Roday do so silly things, 2. the show would end or just be ''Series/{{Monk}}'', ''Series/TheMentalist'', or ''Series/{{Unforgettable}}'', and 3. MST3KMantra and BellisariosMaxim applies. But what's the InUniverse reason?

to:

* I know the outside answer is: 1. RuleOfFunny to allow James Roday Creator/JamesRodayRodriguez do so silly things, 2. the show would end or just be ''Series/{{Monk}}'', ''Series/TheMentalist'', or ''Series/{{Unforgettable}}'', and 3. MST3KMantra and BellisariosMaxim applies. But what's the InUniverse reason?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Henry asks Shawn and Gus "how much" they saw. He probably assumed that Shawn (and maybe Gus) did look, but also that they ''kept looking'' and saw the whole thing. They would have seen Henry pulling Sherry back inside, and thus ends the tale. Henry probably thought that the two options were: 1) Shawn and Gus saw nothing, and no explanation is necessary, or 2) Shawn and Gus saw everything, and no explanation is necessary. He didn't consider that they would have missed part of the incident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In an interview Maggie Lawson, the actress who plays Juliet, said that her character ''does'' believe in Shawn's abilities. Whether or not this counts as WordOfGod, however, is debatable.

to:

** In an interview Maggie Lawson, Creator/MaggieLawson, the actress who plays Juliet, said that her character ''does'' believe in Shawn's abilities. Whether or not this counts as WordOfGod, however, is debatable.

Top