Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MyLittlePonyEquestriaGirls

Go To

OR

Added: 74

Changed: 213

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** the element of magic transmutated to represent twilight ascension to alicorndom besides if it part of her royal she can alway use the magic of said crown to defend herself in a pinch. like a power boost.
*** Let me ask that question with another question. Who be stupid enough to steal from a alicorn, in there own room? since to ponies alicorn are like gods, doing that would be just plain suicidal.

to:

*** the It wasn't her choice. The element of magic transmutated shifted to represent twilight ascension to alicorndom besides if it part of become her royal crown, when she can alway use the magic of said crown to defend herself in a pinch. like a power boost.
ascended.
*** Let me ask that question with another question. Who be stupid enough to steal from a alicorn, in there own room? since Since to ponies alicorn are like gods, doing that would be just plain suicidal.



*** might also be seen as a VERY elaborate prank.

to:

*** might also be seen as a VERY elaborate prank.prank.
** She didn't think she could get believed, and saw another, 'better' way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** be sent to a asylum for being crazy and doing ventriloguism wih some dog or be sent to some lab to be dissected.

to:

** be sent to a asylum for being crazy and doing ventriloguism wih some dog or be sent to some lab to be dissected.dissected.
*** might also be seen as a VERY elaborate prank.

Added: 196

Changed: 306

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Let me ask that question with another question. Who be stupid enough to steal from a alicorn, in there own room. since to ponies alicorn are like gods, doing that would be just plain suicidal.

to:

*** the element of magic transmutated to represent twilight ascension to alicorndom besides if it part of her royal she can alway use the magic of said crown to defend herself in a pinch. like a power boost.
*** Let me ask that question with another question. Who be stupid enough to steal from a alicorn, in there own room. room? since to ponies alicorn are like gods, doing that would be just plain suicidal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding to it


* Why didn't Twilight ask Principal Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?

to:

* Why didn't Twilight ask Principal Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?proof?
** be sent to a asylum for being crazy and doing ventriloguism wih some dog or be sent to some lab to be dissected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Besides, all they'd need is the element of surprise, which Sunset Shimmer got. She caught Twilight off guard and got away with stealing the crown. Or alternately, gain their trust before striking, which is kind of like what Chrysalis did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
grammar, learn it.


* Why didn't Twilight ask Principal Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?
** Oh yeah a new world where she doesn't know the inhabitant well enough and may very well sigh herself to a insane asylum or if we go with the dog bit, either think, A a very realistic ventriloguist or B get dissected by that world scientist. dumb idiot.

to:

* Why didn't Twilight ask Principal Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?
** Oh yeah a new world where she doesn't know the inhabitant well enough and may very well sigh herself to a insane asylum or if we go with the dog bit, either think, A a very realistic ventriloguist or B get dissected by that world scientist. dumb idiot.
proof?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** [[spoiler:And who's gonna upload it? The entire school was hypnotized immediately, no reasonable adult is going to believe Snips and Snails, and even if any of the students took pictures of the mane cast with wings and pony ears, they can just lie and say that those were just props.]]

to:

**** [[spoiler:And who's gonna upload it? The entire school was hypnotized immediately, no [[spoiler:No reasonable adult is going to believe Snips and Snails, that those videos are real. People post a lot of the same stuff all the time and even if any of the students anyone took pictures of the mane cast with wings and pony ears, they can just lie and say that those were just props.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Flowy-maned alicorns like Celestia and Luna are like unto gods. Lesser Alicorns have proven to be quite smiteable. Cadance was completely incapable of freeing herself from Chrysalis' prison, and the unnamed princess from Hearts and Hooves Day fell victim to a poison made from everyday (for their world) substances.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** And who's gonna upload it? The entire school was hypnotized immediately, no reasonable adult is going to believe Snips and Snails, and even if any of the students took pictures of the mane cast with wings and pony ears, they can just lie and say that those were just props.

to:

**** And [[spoiler:And who's gonna upload it? The entire school was hypnotized immediately, no reasonable adult is going to believe Snips and Snails, and even if any of the students took pictures of the mane cast with wings and pony ears, they can just lie and say that those were just props.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And who's gonna upload it? The entire school was hypnotized immediately, no one's gonna believe Snips and Snails, and even if any of the students took pictures of the mane cast with wings and pony ears adults are going to just think that their fake.

to:

** **** And who's gonna upload it? The entire school was hypnotized immediately, no one's gonna reasonable adult is going to believe Snips and Snails, and even if any of the students took pictures of the mane cast with wings and pony ears adults are going to ears, they can just think lie and say that their fake.those were just props.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**And who's gonna upload it? The entire school was hypnotized immediately, no one's gonna believe Snips and Snails, and even if any of the students took pictures of the mane cast with wings and pony ears adults are going to just think that their fake.

Added: 387

Changed: 245

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding answers


* Why didn't Twilight ask Principal Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?

to:

*** Let me ask that question with another question. Who be stupid enough to steal from a alicorn, in there own room. since to ponies alicorn are like gods, doing that would be just plain suicidal.
* Why didn't Twilight ask Principal Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?proof?
** Oh yeah a new world where she doesn't know the inhabitant well enough and may very well sigh herself to a insane asylum or if we go with the dog bit, either think, A a very realistic ventriloguist or B get dissected by that world scientist. dumb idiot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't Twilight ask Princess Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?

to:

* Why didn't Twilight ask Princess Principal Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Here's a more important question. Why the hell did they make her Element of Magic crown her princess crown?! They were just ASKING for it to be stolen. Surely they could have just made a replica or something to be used.

to:

** Here's a more important question. Why the hell did they make her Element of Magic crown her princess crown?! They were just ASKING for it to be stolen. Surely they could have just made a replica or something to be used.used.
*Why didn't Twilight ask Princess Celestia for the crown, be honest about her motives and present Spike the talking dog as proof?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't twilight have her crown protected? If they knew it was so important, and they were staying in a different place that night, why take the risk of causing all the elements of harmony to stop working and causing [[spoiler:anyone who steals it to become evil demons bent on taking over the world?]]

to:

* Why didn't twilight Twilight have her crown protected? If they knew it was so important, and they were staying in a different place that night, why take the risk of causing all the elements of harmony to stop working and causing [[spoiler:anyone who steals it to become evil demons bent on taking over the world?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't twilight have her crown protected? If they knew it was so important, and they were staying in a different place that night, why take the risk of causing all the elements of harmony to stop working and causing [[spoiler:anyone who steals it to become evil demons bent on taking over the world?]]

to:

* Why didn't twilight have her crown protected? If they knew it was so important, and they were staying in a different place that night, why take the risk of causing all the elements of harmony to stop working and causing [[spoiler:anyone who steals it to become evil demons bent on taking over the world?]]world?]]
** Here's a more important question. Why the hell did they make her Element of Magic crown her princess crown?! They were just ASKING for it to be stolen. Surely they could have just made a replica or something to be used.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[spoiler: This also raises a further question. Consider that not just Demons, but magical pony-girl things suddenly appear in "normal" Earth, wouldn't this entire event be earth-shattering as it proves the existence of "aliens"? Considering YouTube exists as well, there's not really gonna be anyway that this doesn't become a global issue after about 2000 videos of "DEMONS VS MAGIC HORSEWOMEN @ CANTERLOT HIGH" are uploaded in the aftermath by the student body.]]

to:

*** [[spoiler: This also raises a further question. Consider that not just Demons, but magical pony-girl things suddenly appear in "normal" Earth, wouldn't this entire event be earth-shattering as it proves the existence of "aliens"? Considering YouTube Website/YouTube exists as well, there's not really gonna be anyway that this doesn't become a global issue after about 2000 videos of "DEMONS VS MAGIC HORSEWOMEN @ CANTERLOT HIGH" are uploaded in the aftermath by the student body.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: This also raises a further question. Consider that not just Demons, but magical pony-girl things suddenly appear in "normal" Earth, wouldn't this entire event be earth-shattering as it proves the existence of "aliens"? Considering YouTube exists as well, there's not really gonna be anyway that this doesn't become a global issue after about 2000 videos of "DEMONS VS MAGIC HORSEWOMEN @ CANTERLOT HIGH" are uploaded in the aftermath by the student body.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon seem to care more about harassing Applebloom than any magical rump tattoo. Their attitudes in their debut episode seemed to indicate they've been doing it for some time despite Diamond Tiara only having Cutie Mark for a week by that point, they didn't seem to know who Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo were until they became Applebloom's friends despite the fact they should have shared several classes with them, they were dismissive of Applebloom's Cutie Mark when she supposedly got hers in The Cutie Pox, sided with a Blank Flank when she proved willing to harass Applebloom and her friends, and Diamond Tiara got a Hearts and Hooves Day card from a Blank Flank (the yellow, purple-maned Pegasus filly commonly referred to as 'Alula') with Silver Spoon seemingly encouraging her. IIRC, the only time either of the bully duo have ever attacked a Blank Flanked character that wasn't in some way associated with Applebloom was when DT bodychecked the yellow-maned purple unicorn filly commonly referred to as 'Dinky', and that wasn't even anything to do with Cutie Marks. The whole Blank Flank thing seems just something they do to cheese off Applebloom, so if they do pick on the human [=CMCs=], whatever they'd call themselves, it would probably be over whatever Applebloom's anxiety button is in the human world, and Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo would have joined her over that.

to:

** Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon seem to care more about harassing Applebloom than any magical rump tattoo. Their attitudes in their debut episode seemed to indicate they've been doing it for some time despite Diamond Tiara only having Cutie Mark for a week by that point, they didn't seem to know who Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo were until they became Applebloom's friends despite the fact they should have shared several classes with them, they were dismissive of Applebloom's Cutie Mark when she supposedly got hers in The Cutie Pox, sided with a Blank Flank when she proved willing to harass Applebloom and her friends, and Diamond Tiara got a Hearts and Hooves Day card from a Blank Flank (the yellow, purple-maned Pegasus filly commonly referred to as 'Alula') with Silver Spoon seemingly encouraging her. IIRC, the only time either of the bully duo have ever attacked a Blank Flanked character that wasn't in some way associated with Applebloom was when DT bodychecked the yellow-maned purple unicorn filly commonly referred to as 'Dinky', and that wasn't even anything to do with Cutie Marks. The whole Blank Flank thing seems just something they do to cheese off Applebloom, so if they do pick on the human [=CMCs=], whatever they'd call themselves, it would probably be over whatever Applebloom's anxiety button is in the human world, and Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo would have joined her over that.that.
*Why didn't twilight have her crown protected? If they knew it was so important, and they were staying in a different place that night, why take the risk of causing all the elements of harmony to stop working and causing [[spoiler:anyone who steals it to become evil demons bent on taking over the world?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Depends on how much range the mind control artifact has. If she can brainwash everyone in town, legitimate question. If she can only brainwash people within a certain radius, then if that radius is less than a decent-sized sniper rifle, she's pretty screwed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:If Sunset Shimmer had the ability to mind control anyone for her invasion plan, why did she take control of a bunch of High School students? Why didn't she go after a far more powerful group like, say, the U.S. Marines?]]

to:

* [[spoiler:If Sunset Shimmer had the ability to mind control anyone for her invasion plan, why did she take control of a bunch of High School students? Why didn't she go after a far more powerful group like, say, the U.S. Marines?]]Marines?]]
* If the Human Cutie Mark Crusaders are friends in this realm, then what would they have become friends for in a world where cutie marks don't exist? By extension, do Human Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon bully them? If so, then what do they bully them for if cutie marks don't exist?
** Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon seem to care more about harassing Applebloom than any magical rump tattoo. Their attitudes in their debut episode seemed to indicate they've been doing it for some time despite Diamond Tiara only having Cutie Mark for a week by that point, they didn't seem to know who Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo were until they became Applebloom's friends despite the fact they should have shared several classes with them, they were dismissive of Applebloom's Cutie Mark when she supposedly got hers in The Cutie Pox, sided with a Blank Flank when she proved willing to harass Applebloom and her friends, and Diamond Tiara got a Hearts and Hooves Day card from a Blank Flank (the yellow, purple-maned Pegasus filly commonly referred to as 'Alula') with Silver Spoon seemingly encouraging her. IIRC, the only time either of the bully duo have ever attacked a Blank Flanked character that wasn't in some way associated with Applebloom was when DT bodychecked the yellow-maned purple unicorn filly commonly referred to as 'Dinky', and that wasn't even anything to do with Cutie Marks. The whole Blank Flank thing seems just something they do to cheese off Applebloom, so if they do pick on the human [=CMCs=], whatever they'd call themselves, it would probably be over whatever Applebloom's anxiety button is in the human world, and Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo would have joined her over that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** So what are we international bronies supposed to do? Just stay off the internet till August to avoid spoilers?

to:

*** So what are we international bronies supposed to do? Just stay off the internet till August to avoid spoilers?spoilers?
* [[spoiler:If Sunset Shimmer had the ability to mind control anyone for her invasion plan, why did she take control of a bunch of High School students? Why didn't she go after a far more powerful group like, say, the U.S. Marines?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They're counting bronies being the only significant moviegoers. Younger kids will probably be the ones to see it on DVD.

to:

** They're counting bronies being the only significant moviegoers. Younger kids will probably be the ones to see it on DVD.DVD.
***So what are we international bronies supposed to do? Just stay off the internet till August to avoid spoilers?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wait... it's only going to be released in select theatres in the U.S? Wouldn't it just be better for Ha$bro to release it as a direct to DVD like they will in the rest of the world? "In Select Theatres" in the U.S. means "a handful of theatres 99% of the country and 85% of the local population has virtually no access to... but there will be commercials for it on TV like there will every other movie."

to:

* Wait... it's only going to be released in select theatres in the U.S? Wouldn't it just be better for Ha$bro to release it as a direct to DVD like they will in the rest of the world? "In Select Theatres" in the U.S. means "a handful of theatres 99% of the country and 85% of the local population has virtually no access to... but there will be commercials for it on TV like there will every other movie.""
** They're counting bronies being the only significant moviegoers. Younger kids will probably be the ones to see it on DVD.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Wait... it's only going to be released in select theatres in the U.S? Wouldn't it just be better for Ha$bro to release it as a direct to DVD like they will in the rest of the world? "In Select Theatres" in the U.S. means "a handful of theatres 99% of the country and 85% of the local population has virtually no access to... but there will be commercials for it on TV like there will every other movie."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I don\'t think there needs to be a headscratchers page until after the movie comes out.


* Why is Twilight going solo? isn't the whole premise the Friendship is Magic?
** Spike goes with her.
*** Think the person means "Why doesn't ''her friends'' go with her"? Spike assumingly snuck in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Spike goes with her.

to:

** Spike goes with her.her.
*** Think the person means "Why doesn't ''her friends'' go with her"? Spike assumingly snuck in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Twilight going solo? isn't the whole premis the Friendship is Magic?

to:

* Why is Twilight going solo? isn't the whole premis premise the Friendship is Magic?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Twilight going solo? isn't the whole premis the Friendship is Magic?

to:

* Why is Twilight going solo? isn't the whole premis the Friendship is Magic?Magic?
** Spike goes with her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Creating page.

Added DiffLines:

* Why is Twilight going solo? isn't the whole premis the Friendship is Magic?

Top