Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Cinderella2015

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The film is not set in France, but rather a small FictionalCountry in Europe, and the characters speaking French as if it were a foreign language to them only goes to emphasise that point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Did the Captain know that Ella was "the one" when he came upstairs to fetch her? Considering he saw her with the Kit in the forest and at the ball, him not surprised at Kit disguising himself amongst the Duke's entourage, and his kind manner to Ella as he requests she come downstairs to try on the slipper.

to:

* Did the Captain know that Ella was "the one" when he came upstairs to fetch her? Considering he saw her with the Kit in the forest and at the ball, him not surprised at Kit disguising himself amongst the Duke's entourage, and his kind manner to Ella as he requests she come downstairs to try on the slipper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Did the Captain know that Ella was "the one" when he came upstairs to fetch her? Considering he saw her with the Kit in the forest and at the ball, him not surprised at Kit disguising himself amongst the Duke's entourage, and his kind manner to Ella as he requests she come downstairs to try on the slipper.
* One detail I hope someone can help clarify me on that I hope is true. When the Captain comes to escort Ella downstairs to try on the slipper, Lady Tremaine physically grabs Ella's arm as she walks by as a last resort to stop her from going down. She starts to threaten her, but then her face starts to fall and she lets her go anyway. Why? One thing I noticed before she does so, it looks like Ella is turning her head to give her a brief glare. It's so nonchalant and brief that I cannot tell if this passive, but compassionate young girl actually cowed her abusive stepmother to back off once and for all. Am I correct?

to:

* Did the Captain know that Ella was "the one" when he came upstairs to fetch her? Considering he saw her with the Kit in the forest and at the ball, him not surprised at Kit disguising himself amongst the Duke's entourage, and his kind manner to Ella as he requests she come downstairs to try on the slipper.
* One detail I hope someone can help clarify me on that I hope is true. When the Captain comes to escort Ella downstairs to try on the slipper, Lady Tremaine physically grabs Ella's arm as she walks by as a last resort to stop her from going down. She starts to threaten her, but then her face starts to fall and she lets her go anyway. Why? One thing I noticed before she does so, it looks like Ella is turning her head to give her a brief glare. It's so nonchalant and brief that I cannot tell if this passive, but compassionate young girl actually cowed her abusive stepmother to back off once and for all. Am I correct?
slipper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Drizella isn't the brightest bulb, and there's theory she may have lied to save face about not understanding French.

to:

** Drizella isn't the brightest bulb, and there's theory she may have lied to save face about not understanding French.French.
* Did the Captain know that Ella was "the one" when he came upstairs to fetch her? Considering he saw her with the Kit in the forest and at the ball, him not surprised at Kit disguising himself amongst the Duke's entourage, and his kind manner to Ella as he requests she come downstairs to try on the slipper.
*One detail I hope someone can help clarify me on that I hope is true. When the Captain comes to escort Ella downstairs to try on the slipper, Lady Tremaine physically grabs Ella's arm as she walks by as a last resort to stop her from going down. She starts to threaten her, but then her face starts to fall and she lets her go anyway. Why? One thing I noticed before she does so, it looks like Ella is turning her head to give her a brief glare. It's so nonchalant and brief that I cannot tell if this passive, but compassionate young girl actually cowed her abusive stepmother to back off once and for all. Am I correct?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not a question for this movie


*** On a similar note, what if Prince Adam showed kindness to the Enchantress (I’m only talking about the Beauty and the Beast remake, since I feel that that film and this remake of Cinderella are connected)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


What if Cinderella had absolutely broken down from her stepfamily’s abuse and thus turned down the old woman (the Fairy Godmother)? Would she have turned Ella into a Beastess, like how the Enchantress turned Prince Adam into a Beast in Beauty and the Beast?

to:

What *What if Cinderella had absolutely broken down from her stepfamily’s abuse and thus turned down the old woman (the Fairy Godmother)? Would she have turned Ella into a Beastess, like how the Enchantress turned Prince Adam into a Beast in Beauty and the Beast?




This movie is set in France, why does Drizella think it was Italian? She's literally French.

to:

\nThis *This movie is set in France, why does Drizella think it was Cinderella spoke Italian? She's literally French.
** Drizella isn't the brightest bulb, and there's theory she may have lied to save face about not understanding
French.

Added: 92

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** On a similar note, what if Prince Adam showed kindness to the Enchantress (I’m only talking about the Beauty and the Beast remake, since I feel that that film and this remake of Cinderella are connected)?

to:

*** On a similar note, what if Prince Adam showed kindness to the Enchantress (I’m only talking about the Beauty and the Beast remake, since I feel that that film and this remake of Cinderella are connected)?connected)?

This movie is set in France, why does Drizella think it was Italian? She's literally French.

Changed: -4

Removed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ghost wick fixing


*** On a similar note, what if Prince Adam showed kindness to the Enchantress (I’m only talking about the Beauty and the Beast remake, since I feel that that film and this remake of Cinderella are connected)?
{{Wick}}

to:

*** On a similar note, what if Prince Adam showed kindness to the Enchantress (I’m only talking about the Beauty and the Beast remake, since I feel that that film and this remake of Cinderella are connected)?
{{Wick}}
connected)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Oops


{{Wick}

to:

{{Wick}{{Wick}}

Added: 7

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ghost wick fixing


*** On a similar note, what if Prince Adam showed kindness to the Enchantress (I’m only talking about the Beauty and the Beast remake, since I feel that that film and this remake of Cinderella are connected)?

to:

*** On a similar note, what if Prince Adam showed kindness to the Enchantress (I’m only talking about the Beauty and the Beast remake, since I feel that that film and this remake of Cinderella are connected)?connected)?
{{Wick}
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maybe she would have just left, since this one specifically says she's Ella's fairy godmother, and Ella not showing her any kindness might have indicated that she couldn't help her. The Enchantress just seemed to be an independent fae.

to:

** Maybe she would have just left, since this one specifically says she's Ella's fairy godmother, and Ella not showing her any kindness might have indicated that she couldn't help her. The Enchantress just seemed to be an independent fae.fae.
*** On a similar note, what if Prince Adam showed kindness to the Enchantress (I’m only talking about the Beauty and the Beast remake, since I feel that that film and this remake of Cinderella are connected)?

Added: 238

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


What if Cinderella had absolutely broken down from her stepfamily’s abuse and thus turned down the old woman (the Fairy Godmother)? Would she have turned Ella into a Beastess, like how the Enchantress turned Prince Adam into a Beast in Beauty and the Beast?

to:

What if Cinderella had absolutely broken down from her stepfamily’s abuse and thus turned down the old woman (the Fairy Godmother)? Would she have turned Ella into a Beastess, like how the Enchantress turned Prince Adam into a Beast in Beauty and the Beast?Beast?
** Maybe she would have just left, since this one specifically says she's Ella's fairy godmother, and Ella not showing her any kindness might have indicated that she couldn't help her. The Enchantress just seemed to be an independent fae.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


What if Cinderella had absolutely broken down from her stepfamily’s abuse and thus turned down the old woman (the Fairy Godmother)? Would she have turned Ella into a Beastess, like how the Enchantress turned Prince Adam into a Beast in BeautyandtheBeast?

to:

What if Cinderella had absolutely broken down from her stepfamily’s abuse and thus turned down the old woman (the Fairy Godmother)? Would she have turned Ella into a Beastess, like how the Enchantress turned Prince Adam into a Beast in BeautyandtheBeast?Beauty and the Beast?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

What if Cinderella had absolutely broken down from her stepfamily’s abuse and thus turned down the old woman (the Fairy Godmother)? Would she have turned Ella into a Beastess, like how the Enchantress turned Prince Adam into a Beast in BeautyandtheBeast?

Top