Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / CastleInTheAir

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why was the genie able to transport Jamaal to [[spoiler:the transformed moving castle]] but not detect [[spoiler:Flower-in-the-Night and transport Aldullah to her location]] though they were both in the same place?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When the plot of ''Castle in the Air'' begins, how long exactly has it been since the moving castle was stolen? When Sophie talks about what happened in Chapter 16, it sounds as if it happened quite a while ago. But [[spoiler: Howl as the genie]] makes his first appearance in the story and the genie bottle looks new and unopened, and even the genie acts as if it's the first time the bottle's been opened. Could the genie really have been with [[spoiler: Hasruel]] for that long without being used at all?

to:

* When the plot of ''Castle in the Air'' begins, how long exactly has it been since the moving castle was stolen? When Sophie talks about what happened in Chapter 16, it sounds as if it happened quite a while ago. But [[spoiler: Howl as the genie]] makes his first appearance in the story and the genie bottle looks new and unopened, and even the genie acts as if it's the first time the bottle's been opened. Could the genie really have been with [[spoiler: Hasruel]] for that long without being used at all?all?
** Makes sense to me: [[spoiler:Hasruel]] didn't need a genie's wishes himself, after all. Maybe he just tucked the bottle away somewhere tidy until he thought of a use for it [[spoiler:as part of the lesson he decided to teach Abdullah]].
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When the plot of ''Castle in the Air'' begins, how long exactly has it been since the moving castle was stolen? When Sophie talks about what happened in Chapter 16, it sounds as if it happened quite a while ago. But [[spoiler: Howl as the genie]] makes his first appearance in the story and the genie bottle looks new and unopened, and even the genie acts as if it's the first time the bottle's been opened. Could the genie really have been with [[spoiler: Hasruel]] for that long without being used at all?

Top