Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / AssassinsCreedIII

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** So the Animus has "Medieval French to Current Day English" "Medieval French to Modern English" & "Medieval Arab to Common Day English" dictionaries. But Mohawk (A language that is still practiced nowadays in a roughly unchanged form) to Modern English... That she can't get? Plus the algorithm is clearly implanted in the Animus, since Connor's inner monologues are translated. And I'd assume that he monologues in his own language.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** And? It's a glitch or content left untranslated, due to the Animus. Maybe Rebecca left it in because she didn't have time to code a proper Mohawk-to-English translation algorithm. The subtitles take care of the rest. Technically, the translation is only there for ease of use, and it would be easier to not translate it and just use subtitles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Did you really need to include that many question marks?


*** The first DID translate those (What language do you think Altair is speaking?????). Untranslated bit were handwaved as a glitch. Here Mohawk is ''never'' translated. It goes beyond the occasional bit left in for flavors, as almost an entire segment is entirely in Mohawk.

to:

*** The first DID translate those (What language do you think Altair is speaking?????).speaking?. Untranslated bit were handwaved as a glitch. Here Mohawk is ''never'' translated. It goes beyond the occasional bit left in for flavors, as almost an entire segment is entirely in Mohawk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The first DID translate those (What language do you think Altair is speaking?????). Untranslated bit were handwaved as a glitch. Here Mohawk is ''never'' translated. It goes beyond the occasional bit left in for flavors, as almost an entire segment is entirely in Mohawk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Animus limitations.

to:

** Animus limitations. Rebecca patched in seasonal and weather changes but forgot to alter clothing to match.

Added: 205

Changed: 220

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How come people's clothing doesn't update to match the seasons? Boston is filled with people who apparently go around ''barefoot'' in the snow. No one wears coats or winter clothes.

to:

** The Animus has always had languages that do not translate; French, German and Arabic in the first, untranslated French and Italian in the second, and so on.
* How come people's clothing doesn't update to match the seasons? Boston is filled with people who apparently go around ''barefoot'' in the snow. No one wears coats or winter clothes.clothes.
** Animus limitations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Besides English being the "default" language of the setting, the use of different languages is important in various instances. It would seem all the weirder if we heard a native character speaking what sounds like English, only for the English speaker to not understand them and/or be surprised that they reveal their ability to speak English.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why does the Animus not translate the Mohawk language spoken by Connor, his mother, and others? It translated Arab into English, Italian into English, etc... Why does it stop working for native american languages?

to:

* Why does the Animus not translate the Mohawk language spoken by Connor, his mother, and others? It translated Arab into English, Italian into English, etc... Why does it stop working for native american languages?languages?
* How come people's clothing doesn't update to match the seasons? Boston is filled with people who apparently go around ''barefoot'' in the snow. No one wears coats or winter clothes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Connor "fakes" being a Spaniard for all of five minutes in which he has to talk to a single merchant, and everyone who sees him immediately identifies him as native.

to:

** Connor "fakes" being a Spaniard for all of five minutes in which he has to talk to a single merchant, and everyone who sees him immediately identifies him as native.native.
* Why does the Animus not translate the Mohawk language spoken by Connor, his mother, and others? It translated Arab into English, Italian into English, etc... Why does it stop working for native american languages?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Connor fakes being a Spaniard... while wearing moccassins, a uniform with Native American beadwork, and using a tomahawk?

to:

* Connor fakes being a Spaniard... while wearing moccassins, a uniform with Native American beadwork, and using a tomahawk?tomahawk?
** Connor "fakes" being a Spaniard for all of five minutes in which he has to talk to a single merchant, and everyone who sees him immediately identifies him as native.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It was hidden under his coat and carrying cross is not all that big of a deal, anyway. Most people wouldn't recognise it as a symbol of a secret society. It's not all that unlike with the Freemasons who also were a secret organization in their early days, but their members still liked to wear signs that only a fellow Mason would recognise.

to:

** It was hidden under his coat and carrying cross is not all that big of a deal, anyway. Most people wouldn't recognise it as a symbol of a secret society. It's not all that unlike with the Freemasons who also were a secret organization in their early days, but their members still liked to wear signs that only a fellow Mason would recognise.recognise.
* Connor fakes being a Spaniard... while wearing moccassins, a uniform with Native American beadwork, and using a tomahawk?

Added: 344

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ...So, in the trailer, why did the Templar redcoat have a chain around his neck with the Templar insignia? Aren't the Templars supposed to be a secret organisation?

to:

* ...So, in the trailer, why did the Templar redcoat have a chain around his neck with the Templar insignia? Aren't the Templars supposed to be a secret organisation?organisation?
** It was hidden under his coat and carrying cross is not all that big of a deal, anyway. Most people wouldn't recognise it as a symbol of a secret society. It's not all that unlike with the Freemasons who also were a secret organization in their early days, but their members still liked to wear signs that only a fellow Mason would recognise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Musket balls are ''huge'' and do enormous damage to organs. The chances are that a blast from point blank range would penetrate the entire body, although it would emerge at a lot slower speed in a completely uncontrollable direction. But if the enemy behind is at a point blank range as well, it wouldn't really matter much.

to:

*** Musket balls are ''huge'' and do enormous damage to organs. The chances are that a blast from point blank range would penetrate the entire body, although it would emerge at a lot slower speed in a completely uncontrollable direction. But if the enemy behind is at a point blank range as well, it wouldn't really matter much.much.
* ...So, in the trailer, why did the Templar redcoat have a chain around his neck with the Templar insignia? Aren't the Templars supposed to be a secret organisation?

Added: 328

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Thats its own problem, the bullet almost certainly wouldnt pass through his body and even if it did you would be making an incredibly risky move given how if it fails he would die.

to:

*** Thats its own problem, the bullet almost certainly wouldnt pass through his body and even if it did you would be making an incredibly risky move given how if it fails he would die.
*** Musket balls are ''huge'' and do enormous damage to organs. The chances are that a blast from point blank range would penetrate the entire body, although it would emerge at a lot slower speed in a completely uncontrollable direction. But if the enemy behind is at a point blank range as well, it wouldn't really matter much.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Good lord, three comments and nobody gets it yet. He's stabbing the soldier with the musket and then firing ''through him'' to hit the other.

to:

** Good lord, three comments and nobody gets it yet. He's stabbing the soldier with the musket and then firing ''through him'' to hit the other.other.
*** Thats its own problem, the bullet almost certainly wouldnt pass through his body and even if it did you would be making an incredibly risky move given how if it fails he would die.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He doesnt wear a robe, he wears a white hooded longcoat, its been adapted for the times and other than the hood would be pretty normal cold weather outfit (and even then the hood works since it covers the eyes from snow).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Even if he is strong enough to do that the gun wouldnt be able to fire afterwards, it would be too clogged with blood and gore. The damn thing's misfired if they where slightly damp, I doubt it would be able to do much when clogged with a dudes bowels.

to:

*** Even if he is strong enough to do that the gun wouldnt be able to fire afterwards, it would be too clogged with blood and gore. The damn thing's misfired if they where slightly damp, I doubt it would be able to do much when clogged with a dudes bowels.bowels.
**Good lord, three comments and nobody gets it yet. He's stabbing the soldier with the musket and then firing ''through him'' to hit the other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Genetic Assassins are explicitly superhuman. Their behavior across all the previous games to date has been consistent with that, and we know as of ''Brotherhood'' that genetic Assassins are the descendants of deliberate genetic gene-splicing between Those Who Came Before and humans. Conner, as a genetic Assassin, is not wholly human.

to:

** Genetic Assassins are explicitly superhuman. Their behavior across all the previous games to date has been consistent with that, and we know as of ''Brotherhood'' that genetic Assassins are the descendants of deliberate genetic gene-splicing between Those Who Came Before and humans. Conner, as a genetic Assassin, is not wholly human.human.
*** Even if he is strong enough to do that the gun wouldnt be able to fire afterwards, it would be too clogged with blood and gore. The damn thing's misfired if they where slightly damp, I doubt it would be able to do much when clogged with a dudes bowels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Remember, this is the same guy who, earlier in that very gameplay demo, freed someone from a stockade by knocking off the lock with his bare fist. Assassins are not ordinary people.

to:

** Remember, this is the same guy who, earlier in that very gameplay demo, freed someone from a stockade by knocking off the lock with his bare fist. Assassins are not ordinary people.people.
** Genetic Assassins are explicitly superhuman. Their behavior across all the previous games to date has been consistent with that, and we know as of ''Brotherhood'' that genetic Assassins are the descendants of deliberate genetic gene-splicing between Those Who Came Before and humans. Conner, as a genetic Assassin, is not wholly human.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not fridge logic


* Am I the only person who thought that this game should have been called Assassin's Creed Revolutions? It's delightfully punny and fits with the previous game being called Revelations. I mean, 3 hardly makes any sense considering that there have been 4 games already.
** The developers have said that numbered sequels are for games that introduce a new assassin and time period.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Remember, this is the same guy who, earlier in that very demo, smashed someone of of a stockade with his bare fist. Assassins are not ordinary people.

to:

** Remember, this is the same guy who, earlier in that very gameplay demo, smashed freed someone of of from a stockade by knocking off the lock with his bare fist. Assassins are not ordinary people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Remember, this is the same guy who, earlier in that very demo, smashed someone of of a stockade with bare fist. Assassins are not ordinary people.

to:

** Remember, this is the same guy who, earlier in that very demo, smashed someone of of a stockade with his bare fist. Assassins are not ordinary people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Impaling a British soldier with a musket and shooting another one on the other side of him. While cool to see, that isn't how bayonets on muskets at the time worked. Socket bayonets are set off to the side from the barrel so you can still fire with a bayonet attached, but you wouldn't be able to stick your musket all the way through the target. You could shove the bayonet itself through a person, but how is the musket getting through? the barrel would just hit flesh and stop.

to:

* Impaling a British soldier with a musket and shooting another one on the other side of him. While cool to see, that isn't how bayonets on muskets at the time worked. Socket bayonets are set off to the side from the barrel so you can still fire with a bayonet attached, but you wouldn't be able to stick your musket all the way through the target. You could shove the bayonet itself through a person, but how is the musket getting through? the barrel would just hit flesh and stop.stop.
** Remember, this is the same guy who, earlier in that very demo, smashed someone of of a stockade with bare fist. Assassins are not ordinary people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The developers have said that numbered sequels are for games that introduce a new assassin and time period.

to:

** The developers have said that numbered sequels are for games that introduce a new assassin and time period.period.
* Impaling a British soldier with a musket and shooting another one on the other side of him. While cool to see, that isn't how bayonets on muskets at the time worked. Socket bayonets are set off to the side from the barrel so you can still fire with a bayonet attached, but you wouldn't be able to stick your musket all the way through the target. You could shove the bayonet itself through a person, but how is the musket getting through? the barrel would just hit flesh and stop.

Added: 353

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And as we saw in other works, the Assassin's robes stayed in use until the 20th century, with the last confirmed use of it being around about the time of the Russian Revolution.

to:

*** And as we saw in other works, the Assassin's robes stayed in use until the 20th century, with the last confirmed use of it being around about the time of the Russian Revolution.
*** Technically the last robed Assassin who we've seen is Desmond. Yes, it's just a hoodie, but it invokes exactly the same image in contemporary styles as the old school robes. They all fit to the setting they're shown in; the only things off about them are the colour scheme and the hood, usually an unfashionable, though not entirely unknown garment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Am I the only person who thought that this game should have been called Assassin's Creed Revolutions? It's delightfully punny and fits with the previous game being called Revelations. I mean, 3 hardly makes any sense considering that there have been 4 games already.

to:

* Am I the only person who thought that this game should have been called Assassin's Creed Revolutions? It's delightfully punny and fits with the previous game being called Revelations. I mean, 3 hardly makes any sense considering that there have been 4 games already.already.
** The developers have said that numbered sequels are for games that introduce a new assassin and time period.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And as we saw in other works, the Assassin's robes stayed in use until the 20th century, with the last confirmed use of it being around about the time of the Russian Revolution.

to:

*** And as we saw in other works, the Assassin's robes stayed in use until the 20th century, with the last confirmed use of it being around about the time of the Russian Revolution.Revolution.
* Am I the only person who thought that this game should have been called Assassin's Creed Revolutions? It's delightfully punny and fits with the previous game being called Revelations. I mean, 3 hardly makes any sense considering that there have been 4 games already.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Most of the trailers and early gameplay show Connor in a snowy environment so he uses it as camouflage.

to:

** Most of the trailers and early gameplay show Connor in a snowy environment so he uses it as camouflage.camouflage.
*** And as we saw in other works, the Assassin's robes stayed in use until the 20th century, with the last confirmed use of it being around about the time of the Russian Revolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Conner still walking around in a white robe? There aren't priests or gaudy Renaissance nobles to blend in with anymore.

to:

* Why is Conner still walking around in a white robe? There aren't priests or gaudy Renaissance nobles to blend in with anymore.anymore.
** Most of the trailers and early gameplay show Connor in a snowy environment so he uses it as camouflage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why is Conner still walking around in a white robe? There aren't priests or gaudy Renaissance nobles to blend in with anymore.

Top