Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / Sherlock

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Doubles as a moment of heartwarming: when John first steps inside the front door of Baker Street after what's implied to be about two years of avoidance, he's immediately bombarded with memories: of Sherlock's "you invaded Afghanistan" joke and the piece of music he wrote while he was grieving for Irene Adler. John's instinctive memories of Sherlock had nothing to do with his intellect or any of the cases he solved. They were of the first time he heard Sherlock laugh, and of the first time he saw him grieving. They're of Sherlock at his most human.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* On the above scene: Sherlock begins by speaking to Mary using a phone and earpiece and ends up speaking to her face to face. The information given by earpiece is stuff that would hurt John to overhear (her name is an alias, her life is a façade, she's bored being "the doctor's wife") and the information Sherlock says aloud is exactly what he wants John to know about Mary (she could have killed him instantly but didn't; she is in trouble and needs help.) He even goads her into confessing her fear of losing John or breaking him before finally cutting the exchange short. In other words, he did everything possible to display Mary to John in as positive a light as possible.
** He also bends down to pick up the coin, breaking eye contact and showing his back to her while she is holding a loaded gun and had just used it. John, a trained soldier, would understand this as meaning Sherlock didn't see Mary as a threat to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**** Well, as we know from To Kill a Mockingbird, hands do matter in cases.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Though whether or not Mary adores or even ''likes'' him is debatable at this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Why not in ''that'' way? YMMV, but there's no indication that Moriarty wouldn't be interested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Mary, a [[spoiler: former intelligence agent,]] is able to shoot a hole through a coin, but fails to notice that [[spoiler: the figure she assumes first to be Sherlock and secondly to be a dummy is actually her own husband.]] This seems a bit of a clanger, except Sherlock had already observed in ''The Empty Hearse'' that Mary is short-sighted. He and John would have arranged the distance and shadows of the scene, knowing Mary's short-sightedness would also give her compromised vision in low light.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's played for laughs at the time, but Mary and Sherlock both tell an unimpressed John that he has to put his full name on his wedding invitations - Mary points out it's tradition, while Sherlock thinks it's just funny. Then in ''His Last Vow,'' we find out that [spoiler: Sherlock goes by ''his'' middle name and has never revealed his full name to John before, and Mary's using a false identity and alias. In the end, the only person who was honest about their name was John all along.]]

to:

* It's played for laughs at the time, but Mary and Sherlock both tell an unimpressed John that he has to put his full name on his wedding invitations - Mary points out it's tradition, while Sherlock thinks it's just funny. Then in ''His Last Vow,'' we find out that [spoiler: [[spoiler: Sherlock goes by ''his'' middle name and has never revealed his full name to John before, and Mary's using a false identity and alias. In the end, the only person who was honest about their name was John all along.]]

Added: 492

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's played for laughs at the time, but Mary and Sherlock both tell an unimpressed John that he has to put his full name on his wedding invitations - Mary points out it's tradition, while Sherlock thinks it's just funny. Then in ''His Last Vow,'' we find out that [spoiler: Sherlock goes by ''his'' middle name and has never revealed his full name to John before, and Mary's using a false identity and alias. In the end, the only person who was honest about their name was John all along.]]



** Also in "Game", people who abducted and placed victims in public areas of the city and then waited somewhere for hours aiming them with riffles should have been recorded on some camera in a city with so many ones.

to:

** Also in "Game", people who abducted and placed victims in public areas of the city and then waited somewhere for hours aiming them with riffles rifles should have been recorded on some camera in a city with so many ones.

Changed: 1370

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Sherlock's naïve assumption that the Watsons will just have a "domestic" about his shooting (and then get over it and reconcile quickly to again work together) isn't just wishful thinking. It's based on his observations of John. After all, it took John only a couple of days to freely forgive Sherlock for putting him through two years of hell, and he's aware now that he's John's best friend - the strongest relationship Sherlock has ever experienced. Since Sherlock doesn't really understand romantic relationships or marriages from an emotional perspective, he doesn't understand why Mary's lying to John (for a similar amount of time, about a pretty ''similar thing'') would affect him much more deeply.



* Sherlock's naïve assumption that the Watsons will just have a "domestic" about his shooting (and then get over it and reconcile quickly to again work together) is based on his experiences. After all, it took John only a couple of days to freely forgive him for faking his own death for ''two years,'' and he's aware now that he's John's best friend - the strongest relationship he has ever experienced. Since Sherlock doesn't really understand romantic relationships or marriages from an emotional perspective, he doesn't understand why Mary's lying to John (for a similar amount of time, about a pretty ''similar thing'') would affect him much more deeply.

to:

* Sherlock's naïve assumption that the Watsons will just have a "domestic" about his shooting (and then get over it and reconcile quickly to again work together) is based on his experiences. After all, it took John only a couple of days to freely forgive him for faking his own death for ''two years,'' and he's aware now that he's John's best friend - the strongest relationship he has ever experienced. Since Sherlock doesn't really understand romantic relationships or marriages from an emotional perspective, he doesn't understand why Mary's lying to John (for a similar amount of time, about a pretty ''similar thing'') would affect him much more deeply.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Sherlock's naïve assumption that the Watsons will just have a "domestic" about his shooting (and then get over it and reconcile quickly to again work together) is based on his experiences. After all, it took John only a couple of days to freely forgive him for faking his own death for ''two years,'' and he's aware now that he's John's best friend - the strongest relationship he has ever experienced. Since Sherlock doesn't really understand romantic relationships or marriages from an emotional perspective, he doesn't understand why Mary's lying to John (for a similar amount of time, about a pretty ''similar thing'') would affect him much more deeply.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Sherlock frequently refers to himself as a sociopath, including in this episode. But one of the earliest signs of sociopathy is sadism towards animals as a child. TSOT hints, and this episode reveals, that Sherlock loved animals when he was a kid.

Changed: 575

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I am replacing this because the reason for its removal was incorrect. The woman is not Anthea. It isn\'t the same actress, and doesn\'t even remotely look like her.



to:

* It may be that when John is approached by a strange, beautiful woman standing outside his door, he initially assumes that she's a prostitute. [[note]] And hey, she works for Irene, which means she may well be a sex worker of some description.[[/note]] She asks what he's up to on New Year, and he responds by asking what she had in mind, which all sounds very much like a PG rated proposition. If this was the case, it would show that John has been emotionally tense over Sherlock's moping around to a point where he's willing to abandon his friend for a random prostitute.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Something quite obvious, but the codename Sherlock and Mycroft utilized for the plan to fake the former's death, '''''Lazarus''''', apart from recalling [[ActorAllusion a role by]] MarkGatiss in a ''DoctorWho'' [[{{Recap/DoctorWhoNSS3E6TheLazarusExperiment}} episode]], was primarily also harkening the story of [[TheBible the resurrection of Jesus's friend Lazarus]]... and how, for that matter, the resurrection of Lazarus was well-questioned and speculated upon as a an elaborate hoax by Jesus's enemies.

to:

* Something quite obvious, but the codename Sherlock and Mycroft utilized for the plan to fake the former's death, '''''Lazarus''''', apart from recalling [[ActorAllusion a role by]] MarkGatiss in a ''DoctorWho'' [[{{Recap/DoctorWhoNSS3E6TheLazarusExperiment}} episode]], was primarily also harkening the story of [[TheBible [[Literature/TheBible the resurrection of Jesus's friend Lazarus]]... and how, for that matter, the resurrection of Lazarus was well-questioned and speculated upon as a an elaborate hoax by Jesus's enemies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Made a formatting mistake.


--> The difference between Moriarty and Magnussen.

Added: 456

Changed: 51

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

--> The difference between Moriarty and Magnussen.
* I was re watching the Season 2 and Season 3 finales and I noticed that when Moriarty visited 221B, he was courteous, having casual tea with Sherlock and a conversation which would not seem that threatening out of context. Magnussen on the other hand makes it a great point to piss Sherlock off as much as possible. Its ironic how Magnusson has morals (believing he's not a villain, only a businessman) but no honour but Moriarty has honour but no morals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I also can't imagine it'd be very easy arranging a sniper for Mycroft seeing as though he's hinted to be high up in MI6 and also to unofficially control the country I'd think there were protection measures in place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
John knows the woman is not a prostitute, because he knows she is Anthea, Mycroft\'s PA, and he\'s been making passes at her since episode one.


* It may be that when John is approached by a strange, beautiful woman standing outside his door, he initially assumes that she's a prostitute. [[note]] And hey, she works for Irene, which means she may well be a sex worker of some description.[[/note]] She asks what he's up to on New Year, and he responds by asking what she had in mind, which all sounds very much like a PG rated proposition. If this was the case, it would show that John has been emotionally tense over Sherlock's moping around to a point where he's willing to abandon his friend for a random prostitute.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Sherlock remarks that it was a stroke of luck meeting Magnussen's PA at John's wedding... and seems at that point to believe that it really was. In ''The Hounds of Baskerville'' he states his love for coincidences, and that those who don't believe in them must lead "dull lives." In ''The Sign of Three,'' Mycroft mentally scolds him that coincidences don't exist, because "the universe is rarely so lazy." If he'd taken Mycroft's advice on board a bit more, he would have realised that Mary's maid of honour being Magnussen's PA was a step too far, and Mary really was tangled with Magnussen somehow. His belief in coincidences (and failure to listen to Mycroft) ''nearly gets him killed.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* On the above reunion scene - in ''A Scandal in Belgravia,'' Irene deduced that John had been the one who hit Sherlock, because only someone who "loved him" would avoid his nose and teeth. When John hits Sherlock in ''The Empty Hearse'', he obviously went directly for both Sherlock's nose and teeth. (The incidents weren't shown in full, but Sherlock was left with a split lip and a bleeding nose.) The punch in ''Belgravia'' was provoked and looks a little vicious, but John was actually relatively careful and only really playing. In ''Hearse,'' he is genuinely pissed and hits Sherlock for real, in a way to cause maximum pain and facial damage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Two things: 1) Sherlock dismisses the injured man in Magnussen's office by telling John he's a white supremacist and for John not to bother helping him. Sherlock knows Janine is Magnussen's PA. Sherlock LOATHES Magnussen. Sherlock probably also knows *exactly* how much of Magnussen's "work" Janine is involved with. I doubt it bothers Sherlock much at all that he's manipulating Janine. (and I question whether she's actually in love with Sherlock, or if she's even capable of it -- YMMV) 2) when Magnussen is flicking John's eye, he says "Janine managed it once. She makes the funniest noises." Yes, and what *else* did Janine let Magnussen do to her, that she'd be making "funny noises"? The idea that Sherlock was willing to be *any* kind of intimate with a woman who may have been intimate with Magnussen is a Fridge Horror of an entire different kind ... and says worlds about his devotion to John and Mary.

to:

*** Two things: 1) Sherlock dismisses the injured man in Magnussen's office by telling John he's a white supremacist and for John not to bother helping him. Sherlock knows Janine is Magnussen's PA. Sherlock LOATHES Magnussen. Sherlock probably also knows *exactly* how much of Magnussen's "work" Janine is involved with. I doubt it bothers Sherlock much at all that he's manipulating Janine. (and I question whether she's actually in love with Sherlock, or if she's even capable of it -- YMMV) 2) when Magnussen is flicking John's eye, he says "Janine managed it once. She makes the funniest noises." Yes, and what *else* did Janine let Magnussen do to her, that she'd be making "funny noises"? The idea that Sherlock was willing to be *any* kind of intimate with a woman who is involved in Magnussen's loathesome schemes and may have been intimate with Magnussen him is a Fridge Horror of an entire different kind ... [[spoiler: "spread your legs and think of England," anyone?]]and says worlds about his devotion to John and Mary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Two things: 1) Sherlock dismisses the injured man in Magnussen's office by telling John he's a white supremacist and for John not to bother helping him. Sherlock knows Janine is Magnussen's PA. Sherlock LOATHES Magnussen. Sherlock probably also knows *exactly* how much of Magnussen's "work" Janine is involved with. I doubt it bothers Sherlock much at all that he's manipulating Janine. (and I question whether she's actually in love with Sherlock, or if she's even capable of it -- YMMV) 2) when Magnussen is flicking John's eye, he says "Janine managed it once. She makes the funniest noises." Yes, and what *else* did Janine let Magnussen do to her? The idea that Sherlock was willing to be *any* kind of intimate with a woman who may have been intimate with Magnussen is a Fridge Horror of an entire different kind ... and says worlds about his devotion to John and Mary.

to:

*** Two things: 1) Sherlock dismisses the injured man in Magnussen's office by telling John he's a white supremacist and for John not to bother helping him. Sherlock knows Janine is Magnussen's PA. Sherlock LOATHES Magnussen. Sherlock probably also knows *exactly* how much of Magnussen's "work" Janine is involved with. I doubt it bothers Sherlock much at all that he's manipulating Janine. (and I question whether she's actually in love with Sherlock, or if she's even capable of it -- YMMV) 2) when Magnussen is flicking John's eye, he says "Janine managed it once. She makes the funniest noises." Yes, and what *else* did Janine let Magnussen do to her? her, that she'd be making "funny noises"? The idea that Sherlock was willing to be *any* kind of intimate with a woman who may have been intimate with Magnussen is a Fridge Horror of an entire different kind ... and says worlds about his devotion to John and Mary.

Changed: 388

Removed: 386

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Two things: 1) Sherlock dismisses the injured man in Magnussen's office by telling John he's a white supremacist and for John not to bother helping him. Sherlock knows Janine is Magnussen's PA. Sherlock LOATHES Magnussen. Sherlock probably also knows *exactly* how much of Magnussen's "work" Janine is involved with. I doubt it bothers Sherlock much at all that he's manipulating Janine. (and I question whether she's actually in love with Sherlock, or if she's even capable of it -- YMMV)
2) when Magnussen is flicking John's eye, he says "Janine managed it once. She makes the funniest noises." Yes, and what *else* did Janine let Magnussen do to her? The idea that Sherlock was willing to be *any* kind of intimate with a woman who may have been intimate with Magnussen is a Fridge Horror of an entire different kind ... and says worlds about his devotion to John and Mary.

to:

*** Two things: 1) Sherlock dismisses the injured man in Magnussen's office by telling John he's a white supremacist and for John not to bother helping him. Sherlock knows Janine is Magnussen's PA. Sherlock LOATHES Magnussen. Sherlock probably also knows *exactly* how much of Magnussen's "work" Janine is involved with. I doubt it bothers Sherlock much at all that he's manipulating Janine. (and I question whether she's actually in love with Sherlock, or if she's even capable of it -- YMMV)
YMMV) 2) when Magnussen is flicking John's eye, he says "Janine managed it once. She makes the funniest noises." Yes, and what *else* did Janine let Magnussen do to her? The idea that Sherlock was willing to be *any* kind of intimate with a woman who may have been intimate with Magnussen is a Fridge Horror of an entire different kind ... and says worlds about his devotion to John and Mary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Two things: 1) Sherlock dismisses the injured man in Magnussen's office by telling John he's a white supremacist and for John not to bother helping him. Sherlock knows Janine is Magnussen's PA. Sherlock LOATHES Magnussen. Sherlock probably also knows *exactly* how much of Magnussen's "work" Janine is involved with. I doubt it bothers Sherlock much at all that he's manipulating Janine. (and I question whether she's actually in love with Sherlock, or if she's even capable of it -- YMMV)
2) when Magnussen is flicking John's eye, he says "Janine managed it once. She makes the funniest noises." Yes, and what *else* did Janine let Magnussen do to her? The idea that Sherlock was willing to be *any* kind of intimate with a woman who may have been intimate with Magnussen is a Fridge Horror of an entire different kind ... and says worlds about his devotion to John and Mary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* By his use of drugs in the episode's beginning, Sherlock inadvertently saved his own life. When Molly found drug residue in his urine sample, she was so outraged she slapped him -- ''hard'' and more than once. By this, she transformed his mind-palace image of her into someone who ''could'' slap him, hard enough to get his attention when he was busy dying.

Added: 796

Changed: 1476

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The word "liar" in fact appears as one of the observations, but it is easily missed. I only caught it because I, too, noticed the intensity of the scan and as a result decided to pause and go through it frame by frame. The brilliance kicked in later when Mary's skills as a master spy were revealed: The scan is intense because she is purposely overloading Sherlock with information in order to hide her true identity.




to:

* At first I was somewhat bothered, just as John was, by the fact that he, of all people, was kept out of the loop. With Sherlock's growing humanity and obvious care for John in particular, it actually seemed out of character. Sherlock's given reason, that he feared John would let the cat out of the bag, didn't seem to cut it for me. But then another scene popped into my head, one that had also seemed slightly odd to me at first, and suddenly it all clicked: The scene in which Mrs. Hudson is disappointed with John for not even calling and John explains how it was too hard and how it only became harder with time - that scene wasn't just about John calling Mrs. Hudson, ''it was also about Sherlock calling John''. Notice Sherlock's behaviour throughout his reveal - he tries to keep his cocky, everything-under-control attitude, probably also trying to convince himself that everything's fine, but he shows signs of nervousness and doubt that suggest he does realise at some level that he has wronged John. It also leads to Mary beginning to reveal her hand: Her laughing at Sherlock's joking attempts to diffuse the tension prompts John to ask why he's the only one reacting like a human being, and when Mary tells Sherlock she'll talk John around, Sherlock is puzzled and launches into a Sherlock Scan during which the amount of information apparently makes it difficult for him to get a read on her. The word "liar" appears at the end in between all the other info.


Added DiffLines:

** Alternatively it's because it was the one thing he originally did catch: When Sherlock first met Mary and scanned her, the word "liar" appeared exactly once, but it was easily missed amidst the flurry of other (some would say irrelevant) information. The overload of information suggests that Mary purposely overstimulated Sherlock's scan in order to hide her true nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When I first saw this episode, the big twist about Moriarty [[spoiler: living a second life as a television actor]] struck me as an AssPull, until I realized that it actually makes perfect sense as a strategy against Sherlock. It gives Moriarty a respectable cover identity to hide behind, yes, but it also leaves very little risk of Sherlock recognizing him and figuring out his scheme--since, as we know from the show ''and'' the blogs, [[spoiler: Sherlock is blissfully ignorant of pop culture, and he practically never watches TV]]. Considering how much research Moriarty did on Sherlock prior to this episode, it's likely that he knew this and decided to exploit it.

to:

* When I first saw this episode, the big twist about Moriarty [[spoiler: living a second life as a television actor]] struck me as an AssPull, until I realized that it actually makes perfect sense as a strategy against Sherlock. It gives Moriarty a respectable cover identity to hide behind, yes, but it also leaves very little risk of Sherlock recognizing him and figuring out his scheme--since, as we know from the show ''and'' the blogs, [[spoiler: Sherlock is blissfully ignorant of pop culture, and he practically never watches TV]]. Considering how much research Moriarty did on Sherlock prior to this episode, it's likely that he knew this and decided to exploit it.For Sherlock's nemesis, [[spoiler: becoming a television star]] is HidingInPlainSight.

Added: 669

Changed: 587

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This one hit me after a second-watch through. Back in The Empty Hearse, when John tells Mary that he doesn't shave for Sherlock Holmes, she tells him that he should 'put that on a t-shirt'. When confronting Magnussen at Appledore and telling him he doesn't understand how [[spoiler: Magnussen's Mind Palace]] works, he gives him ''the exact same line''. At first I thought it was coincidence, but then I realized that John was abducted not long after his conversation with Mary. How much would you like to bet that Magnussen or someone loyal to him was listening in on John and Mary's conversation? It is a small detail, but it is totally in-character for Magnussen.



* This one hit me incredibly hard. Back in The Empty Hearse, when John tells Mary that he doesn't shave for Sherlock Holmes, she tells him that he should 'put that on a t-shirt'. When confronting Magnussen at Appledore and telling him he doesn't understand how [[spoiler: Magnussen's Mind Palace]] works, he gives him the exact same line. At first I thought it was coincidence, but then I realized that John was abducted not long after his conversation with Mary. ''How much would you like to bet that Magnussen or someone loyal to him was listening in on John and Mary's conversation?''

to:

* This one hit me incredibly hard. Back in The Empty Hearse, when John tells Mary that he doesn't shave for Sherlock Holmes, she tells him that he should 'put that on a t-shirt'. When confronting Magnussen at Appledore and telling him he doesn't understand how [[spoiler: Magnussen's Mind Palace]] works, he gives him the exact same line. At first I thought it was coincidence, but then I realized that John was abducted not long after his conversation with Mary. ''How much would you like to bet that Magnussen or someone loyal to him was listening in on John and Mary's conversation?''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During a later scene in the episode, there is a very brief snippet of a newspaper heading that reads 'Lord Smallwood Suicide'. Evidently, Magnussen decided that the involvement of Sherlock Holmes [[spoiler: and later Mary Watson]] was enough grounds to use his leverage on Lady Smallwood's husband, which likely led directly to his death.

to:

* During a later scene in the episode, there is a very brief snippet of a newspaper heading that reads 'Lord Smallwood Suicide'. Evidently, Magnussen decided that the involvement of Sherlock Holmes [[spoiler: and later Mary Watson]] was enough grounds to use his leverage on Lady Smallwood's husband, which likely led directly to his death. A similar situation happens with John Garvie, the MP from the very first scene with Magnussen.




to:

* This one hit me incredibly hard. Back in The Empty Hearse, when John tells Mary that he doesn't shave for Sherlock Holmes, she tells him that he should 'put that on a t-shirt'. When confronting Magnussen at Appledore and telling him he doesn't understand how [[spoiler: Magnussen's Mind Palace]] works, he gives him the exact same line. At first I thought it was coincidence, but then I realized that John was abducted not long after his conversation with Mary. ''How much would you like to bet that Magnussen or someone loyal to him was listening in on John and Mary's conversation?''

Added: 879

Changed: 736

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Major Sholto tells Sherlock that he thinks they are alike. He doesn't explain ''why'' he thinks they are alike, and it seems an odd thing to say at first because he'd never met Sherlock before that day and hadn't spoken personally with him at all. But he's just listened to Sherlock's best man speech. The one where he describes himself as an "unpleasant, rude, and all-round obnoxious arsehole" who is redeemed only by the warmth and constancy of John's friendship. Sherlock described himself as the man John has "saved, so many times, and in so many ways." Sholto is even more emotionally closed off than Sherlock is, but he obviously identified with Sherlock because he also feels that it was only John's friendship that redeemed and saved him after his war trauma. And his love for John is the only reason he doesn't commit suicide on the spot... John has saved him again.



* Major Sholto tells Sherlock that he thinks they are alike. He doesn't explain ''why'' he thinks they are alike, but he's just listened to Sherlock's best man speech. The one where he describes himself as an "unpleasant, rude, and all-round obnoxious arsehole" who is redeemed only by the warmth and constancy of John's friendship. He describes himself as the man John has "saved, so many times, and in so many ways." Sholto is even more emotionally closed off than Sherlock is, but he obviously identified with Sherlock because he also feels that it was only John's friendship that redeemed and saved him after his war trauma. And his love for John is the only reason he doesn't commit suicide on the spot... John has saved him again.

to:

* Major Sholto tells Sherlock that he thinks they are alike. He doesn't explain ''why'' he thinks they are alike, but he's just listened to Sherlock's best man speech. The one where he describes himself as an "unpleasant, rude, and all-round obnoxious arsehole" who is redeemed only by the warmth and constancy of John's friendship. He describes himself as the man John has "saved, so many times, and in so many ways." Sholto is even more emotionally closed off than Sherlock is, but he obviously identified with Sherlock because he also feels that it was only John's friendship that redeemed and saved him after his war trauma. And his love for John is the only reason he doesn't commit suicide on the spot... John has saved him again.

Top