Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / DoctorWhoS35E2TheWitchsFamiliar

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's also possible that the Doctor had already decided that [[Recap/DoctorWho2017CSTwiceUponATime he would be the last Doctor]]; he wouldn't care about the loss of Regeneration energy if he never intended to regenerate again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Unlikely considering that Clara was forced by the voice encoder to say "Dalek" when she was using her concept of self. Daleks have been shown to be able to use the word "individual" or "person" before, Rusty really meant what he said.

Added: 78

Changed: 197

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The Doctor telling Missy to run at the end of this story. Partially, it's because he's absolutely furious with her, but also because he knows she's perfectly capable of getting out by herself.



** Doubtful; there's only so much regeneration energy per Dalek to go around.



* When Clara is hooked up to the Dalek travel machine, her more benign statements get dubbed into phrases like "I AM A DALEK" and "EXTERMINATE!" One wonders if the travel machines are meant to [[{{Gaslighting}} gaslight]] any [[TokenHeroicOrc "deviant"]] Daleks into compliance. If a Dalek starts to question the need for endless war, he'll feel all alone in the world, especially if his questions about how he feels are censored by his source of mobility and protection, leading them to questioning their own sanity and conforming as a coping mechanism. You got to wonder how many "good" Daleks The Doctor has killed because he had no way of knowing about these sentiments.

to:

* When Clara is hooked up to the Dalek travel machine, her more benign statements get dubbed into phrases like "I AM A DALEK" and "EXTERMINATE!" One wonders if the travel machines are meant to [[{{Gaslighting}} gaslight]] any [[TokenHeroicOrc "deviant"]] Daleks into compliance. If a Dalek starts to question the need for endless war, he'll feel all alone in the world, especially if his questions about how he feels are censored by his source of mobility and protection, leading them to questioning their own sanity and conforming as a coping mechanism. You got to wonder how many "good" Daleks The the Doctor has killed because he had no way of knowing about these sentiments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* This episode highlights just how clever and manipulative Davros is. He figured out that his childhood encounter with the Doctor was actually ''two'' encounters, and managed to spot the point in the Doctor's timeline when he had abandoned the younger Davros but had not yet gone back to save him after all. Davros made sure to contact the Doctor during that brief, critical gap when he would be feeling most guilty and be most vulnerable to manipulation. Who knows how long ago Davros figured out what happened? How long has he had this strategy in his back pocket, so to speak, waiting for the right moment to take advantage of it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The reveal in this episode that Daleks are unable to say certain things casts a new light on Rusty. Perhaps when he said, "you are a good Dalek," what he actually meant was, '''"you are a good person."'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All the way back in [[Recap/BigFinishDoctorWho048Davros "Davros"]], half a lifetime ago for both of them, Davros told the Sixth Doctor that he considered him, in a strange way, the only thing like a friend he had - his intellectual equal, the only person he's able to ''talk'' with. Ol' Sixie was ''not'' happy. ("We're ''not friends'', Davros.") But it does make you think that when Davros tells the Doctor he's happy he has his people back, and shares a joke with him, [[FriendshipMoment he's not lying.]] Sure, he's a sadistic megalomaniac who is trying to trick him into something, but that doesn't mean he's not telling the truth. And in a gesture of kindness to a dying enemy, Twelve quietly accepts it this time without argument.

to:

* All the way back in [[Recap/BigFinishDoctorWho048Davros "Davros"]], half a lifetime ago for both of them, Davros told the Sixth Doctor that he considered him, in a strange way, the only thing like a friend he had - his intellectual equal, the only person he's able to ''talk'' with. Ol' Sixie was ''not'' happy. ("We're ''not friends'', Davros.") But it does make you think that when Davros tells the Doctor he's happy he has his people back, and shares a joke with him, [[FriendshipMoment he's not lying.]] Sure, he's a sadistic megalomaniac who is ''is'' trying to trick him into something, but that doesn't mean he's not telling the truth.truth at that moment. And in a gesture of kindness to a dying enemy, Twelve quietly accepts it this time without argument.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When Clara is hooked up to the Dalek travel machine, her more benign statements get dubbed into phrases like "I AM A DALEK" and "EXTERMINATE!" One wonders if the travel machines are meant to [[{{Gaslighting}} gaslight]] any [[TokenHeroicOrc "deviant"]] Daleks into compliance. If a Dalek starts to question the need for endless war, he'll feel all alone in the world, especially if his questions about how he feels are censored by his source of mobility and protection, leading them to questioning their own sanity and conforming as a coping mechanism. You got to wonder how many "good" Daleks The Doctor has killed because he had no way of knowing about these sentiments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** He also said that he might just be shorter somewhere down the line. Since regenerating, she's definitely lost a lot of height.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All the way back in [[Recap/BigFinishDoctorWho048Davros "Davros"]], half a lifetime ago for both of them, Davros told the Sixth Doctor that he considered him, in a strange way, the only thing like a friend he had - his intellectual equal, the only person he's able to ''talk'' with. Ol' Sixie was ''not'' happy. ("We're ''not friends'', Davros.") But it does make you think that when Davros tells the Doctor he's happy he has his people back, and shares a joke with him, ''[[FriendshipMoment he's not lying.]] Sure, he's a sadistic megalomaniac who is trying to trick him into something, but that doesn't mean he's not telling the truth. And in a gesture of kindness to a dying enemy, Twelve quietly accepts it this time without argument.

to:

* All the way back in [[Recap/BigFinishDoctorWho048Davros "Davros"]], half a lifetime ago for both of them, Davros told the Sixth Doctor that he considered him, in a strange way, the only thing like a friend he had - his intellectual equal, the only person he's able to ''talk'' with. Ol' Sixie was ''not'' happy. ("We're ''not friends'', Davros.") But it does make you think that when Davros tells the Doctor he's happy he has his people back, and shares a joke with him, ''[[FriendshipMoment [[FriendshipMoment he's not lying.]] Sure, he's a sadistic megalomaniac who is trying to trick him into something, but that doesn't mean he's not telling the truth. And in a gesture of kindness to a dying enemy, Twelve quietly accepts it this time without argument.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All the way back in [[Recap/BigFinishDoctorWho048Davros "Davros"]], half a lifetime ago for both of them, Davros told the Sixth Doctor that he considered him, in a strange way, the only thing like a friend he had - his intellectual equal, the only person he's able to ''talk'' with. Ol' Sixie was ''not'' happy. ("We're ''not friends'', Davros.) But it does make you think that when Davros tells the Doctor he's happy he has his people back, and shares a joke with him, ''[[FriendshipMoment he's not lying.]] Sure, he's a sadistic megalomaniac who is trying to trick him into something, but that doesn't mean he's not telling the truth. And in a gesture of kindness to a dying enemy, Twelve quietly accepts it this time without argument.

to:

* All the way back in [[Recap/BigFinishDoctorWho048Davros "Davros"]], half a lifetime ago for both of them, Davros told the Sixth Doctor that he considered him, in a strange way, the only thing like a friend he had - his intellectual equal, the only person he's able to ''talk'' with. Ol' Sixie was ''not'' happy. ("We're ''not friends'', Davros.) ") But it does make you think that when Davros tells the Doctor he's happy he has his people back, and shares a joke with him, ''[[FriendshipMoment he's not lying.]] Sure, he's a sadistic megalomaniac who is trying to trick him into something, but that doesn't mean he's not telling the truth. And in a gesture of kindness to a dying enemy, Twelve quietly accepts it this time without argument.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* All the way back in [[Recap/BigFinishDoctorWho048Davros "Davros"]], half a lifetime ago for both of them, Davros told the Sixth Doctor that he considered him, in a strange way, the only thing like a friend he had - his intellectual equal, the only person he's able to ''talk'' with. Ol' Sixie was ''not'' happy. ("We're ''not friends'', Davros.) But it does make you think that when Davros tells the Doctor he's happy he has his people back, and shares a joke with him, ''[[FriendshipMoment he's not lying.]] Sure, he's a sadistic megalomaniac who is trying to trick him into something, but that doesn't mean he's not telling the truth. And in a gesture of kindness to a dying enemy, Twelve quietly accepts it this time without argument.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Granted, that's assuming the Master's child was still alive by the ''end'' of the Time War. If that wasn't the case, perhaps the Master'd ''already'' hated the War Doctor for not ''joining the war sooner'', in which case Missy's previous attempt to force the Doctor to become a Cyberman-commanding warmonger might've had more than a dash of embittered "See what I mean? This is how you ''should'' have done things!" to it. Which isn't that different from what ''Davros'' keeps trying to prove his own philosophy correct to the Doctor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheReveal that the Master had a daughter and the Doctor knew her may also help explain the noticeably increased contempt the JohnSimms Master incarnation showed towards the Doctor in previous series, to the point of refusing to regenerate and letting himself die rather than give the Doctor the comfort of knowing he wasn't the LastOfHisKind; if the Doctor knew the Master's daughter and she lived on Gallifrey at the end of the Last Time War, she would have presumably been among those the Doctor and the Master both ''thought'' he'd killed when he destroyed Gallifrey. This may be a factor in why the Tenth Doctor was so reluctant to harm the Master, as he would've been guilt-stricken at the thought of having murdered his oldest friend's child and having to face him after. Missy, the next Master, knew Gallifrey hadn't been destroyed as previously thought, and was more forgiving towards the Doctor.
* Following that, it also makes sense that Missy is the first Master shown to wear the brooch a previous Doctor had given a previous Master after something involving her/his daughter, and is even willing to mention her daughter, when previous Masters hadn't worn the brooch or mentioned their daughter at all; Missy has proven to be a more sentimental incarnation of the Master in trying to regain the Doctor's friendship, so she is both wearing the brooch to [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes remember her daughter and to remind the Doctor of their past together everytime he looks at her]].

to:

* TheReveal that the Master had a daughter and the Doctor knew her may also help explain the noticeably increased contempt the JohnSimms Creator/JohnSimm Master incarnation showed towards the Doctor in previous series, to the point of refusing to regenerate and letting himself die rather than give the Doctor the comfort of knowing he wasn't the LastOfHisKind; if the Doctor knew the Master's daughter and she lived on Gallifrey at the end of the Last Time War, she would have presumably been among those the Doctor and the Master both ''thought'' he'd killed when he destroyed Gallifrey. This may be a factor in why the Tenth Doctor was so reluctant to harm the Master, as he would've been guilt-stricken at the thought of having murdered his oldest friend's child and having to face him after. Missy, the next Master, knew Gallifrey hadn't been destroyed as previously thought, and was more forgiving towards the Doctor.
* Following that, it also makes sense that Missy is the first Master shown to wear the brooch a previous Doctor had given a previous Master after something involving her/his daughter, and is even willing to mention her daughter, when previous Masters hadn't worn the brooch or mentioned their daughter at all; Missy has proven to be a more sentimental incarnation of the Master in trying to regain the Doctor's friendship, so she is both wearing the brooch to [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes remember her daughter and as a visual reminder to remind the Doctor of their past together everytime he looks at her]].

Added: 581

Changed: 906

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* TheReveal that the Master had a daughter and the Doctor knew her may also help explain the noticeably increased contempt the JohnSimms Master incarnation showed towards the Doctor in previous series, to the point of refusing to regenerate and letting himself die rather than give the Doctor the comfort of knowing he wasn't the LastOfHisKind; if the Doctor knew the Master's daughter and she lived on Gallifrey at the end of the Last Time War, she would have presumably been among those the Doctor and the Master both ''thought'' he'd killed when he destroyed Gallifrey. This may be a factor in why the Tenth Doctor was so reluctant to harm the Master, as he would've been guilt-stricken at the thought of having murdered his oldest friend's child and having to face him after. Missy, the next Master, knew Gallifrey hadn't been destroyed as previously thought, and was more forgiving towards the Doctor.
* Following that, it also makes sense that Missy is the first Master shown to wear the brooch a previous Doctor had given a previous Master after something involving her/his daughter, and is even willing to mention her daughter, when previous Masters hadn't worn the brooch or mentioned their daughter at all; Missy has proven to be a more sentimental incarnation of the Master in trying to regain the Doctor's friendship, so she is both wearing the brooch to [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes remember her daughter and to remind the Doctor of their past together everytime he looks at her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The Doctor preference for the IndyPloy is justified after discovering (in Missy's story about his escape from the android assassins) that he can calculate much faster than a human can -- what seems like a last minute ploy to us is actually a long time for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rassilon asked, "How many regenerations did we give you?" implying that it was a finite number


** It's possible that he has infinite regenerations now, though, thanks to the events of "The Time of the Doctor".

to:

** It's possible that he has infinite regenerations now, though, thanks Thanks to the events of "The Time of the Doctor".
Doctor", the Doctor has an unknown number of regenerations and may have much more energy to spare than before.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This one is very subtle and is almost a YMMV case depending on how one considers the relationship between Clara and the Doctor. Missy makes a point out of getting Clara to say "I love you" while in the Dalek, which comes out as "EXTERMINATE!" Considering that she is well aware of the bond the Doctor and Clara share (whether platonic or non-platonic is irrelevant in this context), a fact later referenced in "Hell Bent," and that her ploy involves tricking the Doctor into killing Clara, what better way than to have Clara - as a Dalek - come out and say
"EXTERMINATE!" - a word the Doctor has been hard-wired to react to with force? If Clara had said "I love you" inside the Dalek, she would have been killed without thought by the Doctor. Instead, Clara [[TakeAThirdOption takes a third option]] and gets the Dalek to say "mercy" instead, which prevents this from happening - by expressing her feelings for the Doctor in another way. Recall that in "Death in Heaven," Clara promised Danny she'd never say "I love you" to anyone else (her utterance at Missy's request doesn't count as saying it ''to'' anyone). So of course she would have said something else in order to keep her promise to Danny.

to:

* This one is very subtle and is almost a YMMV case depending on how one considers the relationship between Clara and the Doctor. Missy makes a point out of getting Clara to say "I love you" while in the Dalek, which comes out as "EXTERMINATE!" Considering that she is well aware of the bond the Doctor and Clara share (whether platonic or non-platonic is irrelevant in this context), a fact later referenced in "Hell Bent," and that her ploy involves tricking the Doctor into killing Clara, what better way than to have Clara - as a Dalek - come out and say
say "EXTERMINATE!" - a word the Doctor has been hard-wired to react to with force? If Clara had said "I love you" inside the Dalek, she would have been killed without thought by the Doctor. Instead, Clara [[TakeAThirdOption takes a third option]] and gets the Dalek to say "mercy" instead, which prevents this from happening - by expressing her feelings for the Doctor in another way. Recall that in "Death in Heaven," Clara promised Danny she'd never say "I love you" to anyone else (her utterance at Missy's request doesn't count as saying it ''to'' anyone). So of course she would have said something else in order to keep her promise to Danny.

Added: 643

Changed: 559

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* This one is very subtle and is almost a YMMV case depending on how one considers the relationship between Clara and the Doctor. Missy makes a point out of getting Clara to say "I love you" while in the Dalek, which comes out as "EXTERMINATE!" Considering that she is well aware of the bond the Doctor and Clara share (whether platonic or non-platonic is irrelevant in this context), a fact later referenced in "Hell Bent," and that her ploy involves tricking the Doctor into killing Clara, what better way than to have Clara - as a Dalek - come out and say
"EXTERMINATE!" - a word the Doctor has been hard-wired to react to with force? If Clara had said "I love you" inside the Dalek, she would have been killed without thought by the Doctor. Instead, Clara [[TakeAThirdOption takes a third option]] and gets the Dalek to say "mercy" instead, which prevents this from happening - by expressing her feelings for the Doctor in another way. Recall that in "Death in Heaven," Clara promised Danny she'd never say "I love you" to anyone else (her utterance at Missy's request doesn't count as saying it ''to'' anyone). So of course she would have said something else in order to keep her promise to Danny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The willingness that common Dalek soldiers display to die for the cause - always a bit incongruously-selfless, given how deeply evil their kind otherwise are - makes a lot more sense, now that we know what sort of nightmarish "old age" they're fated to suffer if they ''don't'' get killed in battle.

Changed: 251

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Missy's using the Daleks' energy weapons to charge her vortex manipulator may also explain how she survived being seemingly disintegrated by the Brigadier in "Death in Heaven" (unless she simply was uploaded to the Nethersphere and then escaped it).

Changed: 115

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Doctor comments that the little spark of regeneration energy he's going to share with Davros may cost him a limb down the line. What will the ''much'' larger amount of energy Davros stole from him end up costing the Doctor? Perhaps being unsure of how much regeneration energy the Metcrisis had used up was a reason for Eleven checking on whether he had all his limbs after he regenerated.

to:

* The Doctor comments that the little spark of regeneration energy he's going to share with Davros may cost him a limb down the line. What will the ''much'' larger amount of energy Davros stole from him end up costing the Doctor? Perhaps being unsure of how much regeneration energy the Metcrisis Metacrisis had used up was a reason for Eleven checking on whether he had all his limbs after he regenerated.
** It's possible that he has infinite regenerations now, though, thanks to the events of "The Time of the Doctor".

Removed: 475

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
He wasn\'t talking about saving Davros at all. He was talking about saving Clara, his friend.


* The Doctor says, when he goes back to get Young Davros out of the hand minefield, "I'm saving my friend, the only way I know how." He's not just talking about physically saving the boy from getting killed. He's talking about saving him from becoming an irredeemable villain, about showing him that mercy can be a good thing, an important thing, something worth passing on to his "children."
** He wasn't talking about saving Davros at all. He was talking about saving Clara.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He wasn't talking about saving Davros at all. He was talking about saving Clara.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Colony Sarff spends much of this episode hanging from the wires in Davros' infirmary, including the scenes where Davros attempts to persuade the Doctor to use those same wires to commit genocide on the Daleks. We see later that Sarff is there mainly to restrain the Doctor, making these earlier scenes a bit of FridgeBrilliance for Davros for trying to dissuade the Doctor from his compassion for all life, toward Davros' own pragmatism, while having arranged everything in advance so that even if the Doctor did agree to destroy the Dalek race, there would be no danger at all of that actually happening. Davros would have made his point about the Doctor, and Sarff would have kept the Daleks alive anyway.

to:

* Colony Sarff spends much of this episode hanging from the wires in Davros' Davros's infirmary, including the scenes where Davros attempts to persuade the Doctor to use those same wires to commit genocide on the Daleks. We see later that Sarff is there mainly to restrain the Doctor, making these earlier scenes a bit of FridgeBrilliance for Davros for trying to dissuade the Doctor from his compassion for all life, toward Davros' Davros's own pragmatism, while having arranged everything in advance so that even if the Doctor did agree to destroy the Dalek race, there would be no danger at all of that actually happening. Davros would have made his point about the Doctor, and Sarff would have kept the Daleks alive anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* The reason why the Doctor sent his will to Missy: he knew he was going to be sacrificing regenerations to the Daleks, with no idea how many it would take, probably *all* of them, which left him with the desire to send a will. HE didn't do it at the end of 11's run because he had no idea another Gallifreyan was around (Missy) to do it.
** He didn't have to know the details of Davros's plans to want to send his will; he just had to figure he wasn't likely to get out of their meeting alive, remaining regenerations or no remaining regenerations. Daleks know how to make Time Lord deaths stick.

Top