Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / BeautyAndTheBeast2017

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The NotHisSled ending, where Belle's "I love you" comes too late to break the spell but then Agathe reverses the spell herself, resolves a possible PlotHole from the animated version have cited. Why in the animated version is the Prince restored to life and health when he becomes human again? Why isn't he just a dead human? Since in this version the spell is undone by Agathe rather than simply breaking, we can assume that Agathe uses her magic to bring the Prince back to life at the same time. In other words, [[AWizardDidIt An Enchantress Did It.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Looking at [[GeniusBonus Gaston and LeFou's uniforms]] one can guess the film is set in 1760... In the middle of the economic crisis caused by the War of Austrian Succession ''and'' during the Seven Years War. The Prince may not be taxing them much, but ''the King'' is doing just that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%!!FridgeLogic:
%% The remake makes the following changes from the original:
%% * In both movies, during the opening song, Belle is seen gushing about the book she just finished to someone who isn't interested. In the original, this is ''Literature/JackAndTheBeanstalk'', which can make her seem rather easily impressed for her age. The remake changes it to the more appropriate ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' - meaning she is reading a play's script, which is of course in book form, rather than a children's book.
%% * Many fans questioned how the bookseller in the animated film could maintain a business when Belle only borrows his books rather than buys them (and he even ends up giving her one for free) and it seemed very unlikely anyone else in the village had any interest in reading since it's for that very reason they all thought Belle to be so odd. In the movie he is replaced by Pere Robert, the town's pastor. He keeps a few books that serve as the town's library in the church and Belle is the only one who reads them. As a pastor, he wouldn't be reliant upon selling books for an income.
%% * It was never explained [[FridgeLogic how Belle got Beast on the horse]] after he passed out from his fight with the wolves. In the LiveActionFilm, Belle asks the Beast to stand up for her so she can help him onto it. Oddly enough, an audiobook of the original animated version stated that this was how it happened.
%% * The Beast is literate and well-read, which makes sense (he was a Prince and, as he says, he "had an expensive education"), and shows that he and Belle do share something important in common. And locked up with a huge library, naturally he would spend his time reading in order to give him some relief from his fate... [[Funny/BeautyAndTheBeast2017 Except the books in Greek.]]

to:

%%!!FridgeLogic:
%%
[[folder:FridgeLogic]]
The remake makes the following changes from the original:
%%
original:
* In both movies, during the opening song, Belle is seen gushing about the book she just finished to someone who isn't interested. In the original, this is ''Literature/JackAndTheBeanstalk'', which can make her seem rather easily impressed for her age. The remake changes it to the more appropriate ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet'' - meaning she is reading a play's script, which is of course in book form, rather than a children's book.
%% * Many fans questioned how the bookseller in the animated film could maintain a business when Belle only borrows his books rather than buys them (and he even ends up giving her one for free) and it seemed very unlikely anyone else in the village had any interest in reading since it's for that very reason they all thought Belle to be so odd. In the movie he is replaced by Pere Robert, the town's pastor. He keeps a few books that serve as the town's library in the church and Belle is the only one who reads them. As a pastor, he wouldn't be reliant upon selling books for an income.
%% * It was never explained [[FridgeLogic how Belle got Beast on the horse]] after he passed out from his fight with the wolves. In the LiveActionFilm, Live Action Film, Belle asks the Beast to stand up for her so she can help him onto it. Oddly enough, an audiobook of the original animated version stated that this was how it happened.
%% * The Beast is literate and well-read, which makes sense (he was a Prince and, as he says, he "had an expensive education"), and shows that he and Belle do share something important in common. And locked up with a huge library, naturally he would spend his time reading in order to give him some relief from his fate... [[Funny/BeautyAndTheBeast2017 Except the books in Greek.]]
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It may seem strange that the villagers are so quick to believe the Beast is an evil monster (the French version of the Mob Song outright calling him the devil). In pre-modern Europe, however, attacks from wolves and feral dogs (at times rabid) were a dire danger, with the notable case of [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beast_of_Gévaudan Beast of G%C3%A9vaudan]] claiming 500 lives before being put down (even escaping hunting parties assembled by ''the king'' with the best men available before a local hunter got lucky) and being so hard to kill many attributed it supernatural qualities. To the villagers it would have seemed like ''another'' man-eating monster had appeared but they got lucky and found out before it started attacking, and since the village's best hunter who is also a war veteran and former royal guard is asking for volunteers...

to:

* It may seem strange that the villagers are so quick to believe the Beast is an evil monster (the French version of the Mob Song outright calling him the devil). In pre-modern Europe, however, attacks from wolves and feral dogs (at times rabid) were a dire danger, with the notable case of [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beast_of_Gévaudan Beast of G%C3%A9vaudan]] Gévaudan]] claiming 500 lives before being put down (even escaping hunting parties assembled by ''the king'' with the best men available before a local hunter got lucky) and being so hard to kill many attributed it supernatural qualities. To the villagers it would have seemed like ''another'' man-eating monster had appeared but they got lucky and found out before it started attacking, and since the village's best hunter who is also a war veteran and former royal guard is asking for volunteers...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The War of Austrian Succession ended in 1748, so if it's twelve years after the war the film is set in 1760... During the Seven Years' War. While they wouldn't serve on the frontlines, as Louis XV did not go to the front this time, Gaston likely feels he's missing on the glory due not being in the army anymore, ''and'' may believe he could have prevented [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert-Fran%C3%A7ois_Damiens Robert-François Damiens]]' stabbing of the king. No wonder he's in such a worsening mood: if the king goes to the frontlines he won't be there to win glory, and while he's at Villeneuve his colleagues messed up so badly the king was nearly killed.

to:

** The War of Austrian Succession ended in 1748, so if it's twelve years after the war the film is set in 1760... During the Seven Years' War. While they wouldn't serve on the frontlines, as Louis XV did not go to the front this time, Gaston likely feels he's missing on the glory due not being in the army anymore, ''and'' may believe he could have prevented [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert-Fran%C3%A7ois_Damiens org/wiki/Robert-François_Damiens Robert-François Damiens]]' stabbing of the king. No wonder he's in such a worsening mood: if the king goes to the frontlines he won't be there to win glory, and while he's at Villeneuve his colleagues messed up so badly the king was nearly killed.



* It may seem strange that the villagers are so quick to believe the Beast is an evil monster (the French version of the Mob Song outright calling him the devil). In pre-modern Europe, however, attacks from wolves and feral dogs (at times rabid) were a dire danger, with the notable case of [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beast_of_G%C3%A9vaudan Beast of G%C3%A9vaudan]] claiming 500 lives before being put down (even escaping hunting parties assembled by ''the king'' with the best men available before a local hunter got lucky) and being so hard to kill many attributed it supernatural qualities. To the villagers it would have seemed like ''another'' man-eating monster had appeared but they got lucky and found out before it started attacking, and since the village's best hunter who is also a war veteran and former royal guard is asking for volunteers...

to:

* It may seem strange that the villagers are so quick to believe the Beast is an evil monster (the French version of the Mob Song outright calling him the devil). In pre-modern Europe, however, attacks from wolves and feral dogs (at times rabid) were a dire danger, with the notable case of [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beast_of_G%C3%A9vaudan org/wiki/Beast_of_Gévaudan Beast of G%C3%A9vaudan]] claiming 500 lives before being put down (even escaping hunting parties assembled by ''the king'' with the best men available before a local hunter got lucky) and being so hard to kill many attributed it supernatural qualities. To the villagers it would have seemed like ''another'' man-eating monster had appeared but they got lucky and found out before it started attacking, and since the village's best hunter who is also a war veteran and former royal guard is asking for volunteers...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Changing the source of Belle's borrowed books from a bookstore to the personal collection village priest makes perfect sense. Books of that type in the mid-1700s would have been very expensive and a town as small as theirs would have no real use for a bookstore. A priest, on the other hand, would be expected to be well read and would have connections to get books from the church or other clergy for free or cheap.

Added: 1404

Changed: 576

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the original film, Cogsworth was much bossier and seemed to (at least believe) that he held a degree of authority over the other servants. In this movie, his stuffiness seems more motivated by timidity and a desire to avoid conflict. It possibly has to do with how, in this movie, he has a shrewish, bitter wife whom he doesn't seem to like very much.

to:

** Gaston doesn't wear his old uniform in full the entire time, normally leaving his red coat at home. The one time he actually wears the full uniform is when he tries to get Maurice committed... That is when he needs everyone to remember he's a war hero as he does something questionable.
** [=LeFou=] instead wears the full uniform in almost every scene, as he's in a way a subordinate of Gaston. The only scene he doesn't is the final one, after he got out of Gaston's thumb.
* In the original film, Cogsworth was much bossier and seemed to (at least believe) that he held a degree of authority over the other servants. In this movie, his stuffiness seems more motivated by timidity and a desire to avoid conflict. It possibly has to do with how, in this movie, he has a shrewish, bitter wife whom he doesn't seem to like very much. much.
* It may seem strange that the villagers are so quick to believe the Beast is an evil monster (the French version of the Mob Song outright calling him the devil). In pre-modern Europe, however, attacks from wolves and feral dogs (at times rabid) were a dire danger, with the notable case of [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beast_of_G%C3%A9vaudan Beast of G%C3%A9vaudan]] claiming 500 lives before being put down (even escaping hunting parties assembled by ''the king'' with the best men available before a local hunter got lucky) and being so hard to kill many attributed it supernatural qualities. To the villagers it would have seemed like ''another'' man-eating monster had appeared but they got lucky and found out before it started attacking, and since the village's best hunter who is also a war veteran and former royal guard is asking for volunteers...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also at Fontenou the Gendarmes stopped the British by charging them on the side while they were busy with the Gardes Françaises. This adds to his preference for ambushing the Beast: it worked on the Black Watch on top of working on the largest game, why shouldn't it work on the Beast?

Top